Enhancing optimization planning models for health human resources management with foresight

Abstract Achieving a balanced healthcare workforce requires health planners to adjust the supply of health human resources (HHR). Mathematical programming models have been widely used to assist such planning, but the way uncertainty is usually considered in these models entails methodological and practical issues and often disregards radical yet plausible changes to the future. This study proposes a new socio-technical methodology to factor in uncertainty over the future within mathematical programming modelling. The methodological approach makes use of foresight and scenario planning concepts to build tailor-made scenarios and scenario fit input parameters, which are then used within mathematical programming models. Health stakeholders and experts are engaged in the scenario building process. Causal map modelling and morphological analysis are adopted to digest stakeholders and experts’ information about the future and give origin to contrasting and meaningful scenarios describing plausible future. These scenarios are then adjusted and validated by stakeholders and experts, who then elicit their best quantitative estimates for coherent combinations of input parameters for the mathematical programming model under each scenario. These sets of parameters for each scenario are then fed to the mathematical programming model to obtain optimal solutions that can be interpreted in light of the meaning of the scenario. The proposed methodology has been applied to a case study involving HHR planning in Portugal, but its scope far extends HHR planning, being especially suited for addressing strategic and policy planning problems that are sensitive to input parameters.

[1]  Paul Goodwin,et al.  Decision Analysis for Management Judgment , 1998 .

[2]  Mário Amorim-Lopes,et al.  Advancing the science of unfinished nursing care AS PER PDF: Exploring the benefits of cross‐disciplinary knowledge exchange, knowledge integration and transdisciplinarity AS PER PDF , 2019, Journal of advanced nursing.

[3]  João Gregório,et al.  A scenario-planning approach to human resources for health: the case of community pharmacists in Portugal , 2014, Human Resources for Health.

[4]  Thomas A. Birkland,et al.  An Introduction to the Policy Process: Theories, Concepts and Models of Public Policy Making , 2001 .

[5]  Martin Kunc,et al.  Exploring the development of a methodology for scenario use: Combining scenario and resource mapping approaches , 2017 .

[6]  Teresa Ribeiro,et al.  Technological Forecasting & Social Change Scenario planning in public policy : Understanding use , impacts and the role of institutional context factors ☆ , 2009 .

[7]  Mónica Duarte Oliveira,et al.  Organizing hospitals into networks: a hierarchical and multiservice model to define location, supply and referrals in planned hospital systems , 2012, OR Spectr..

[8]  Daiki Min,et al.  A simulation study of appointment scheduling in outpatient clinics: Open access and overbooking , 2013, Simul..

[9]  Andrew Page,et al.  Applications of system dynamics modelling to support health policy. , 2015, Public health research & practice.

[10]  Andrea Lodi,et al.  Forecasting future needs and optimal allocation of medical residency positions: the Emilia-Romagna Region case study , 2015, Human Resources for Health.

[11]  Nick Hughes,et al.  Towards improving the relevance of scenarios for public policy questions: A proposed methodological framework for policy relevant low carbon scenarios , 2013 .

[12]  Ron S. Dembo,et al.  Scenario optimization , 1991, Ann. Oper. Res..

[13]  Lauge Baungaard Rasmussen.  The narrative aspect of scenario building - How story telling may give people a memory of the future , 2008, Cognition, Communication and Interaction.

[14]  Emre Kirac,et al.  Evaluating alternative resource allocation in an emergency department using discrete event simulation , 2016, Simul..

[15]  Sally C. Brailsford,et al.  Emergency and on-demand health care: modelling a large complex system , 2004, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[16]  Carlos A. Bana e Costa,et al.  Transparent prioritisation, budgeting and resource allocation with multi-criteria decision analysis and decision conferencing , 2007, Ann. Oper. Res..

[17]  B. Martin.  Foresight in science and technology , 1995 .

[18]  Nutrition Board,et al.  Assessing the Current Situation , 2012 .

[19]  Patrícia Fortes,et al.  Long-term energy scenarios: : Bridging the gap between socio-economic storylines and energy modeling , 2015 .

[20]  Stephen Lawrence,et al.  Emergency Department Staff Planning to Improve Patient Care and Reduce Costs , 2014, Decis. Sci..

[21]  Bernardo Almada-Lobo,et al.  Forecasting the medical workforce: a stochastic agent-based simulation approach , 2018, Health care management science.

[22]  Jack P. C. Kleijnen,et al.  Sensitivity analysis versus uncertainty analysis: when to use what? in predictability and nonlinear , 1994 .

[23]  Harri Raisio,et al.  Health care reform planners and wicked problems: Is the wickedness of the problems taken seriously or is it even noticed at all? , 2009, Journal of health organization and management.

[24]  Taesu Cheong,et al.  Accounting for Fairness in a Two-Stage Stochastic Programming Model for Kidney Exchange Programs , 2018, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[25]  Olivier Da Costa,et al.  The impact of foresight on policy-making: insights from the FORLEARN mutual learning process , 2008, Technol. Anal. Strateg. Manag..

[26]  R. Popper.  How are foresight methods selected , 2008 .

[27]  Xiuli Qu,et al.  A two-stage stochastic programming model for phlebotomist scheduling in hospital laboratories , 2018, Health systems.

[28]  Joyce J. P. A. Bierbooms,et al.  A scenario analysis of the future residential requirements for people with mental health problems in Eindhoven , 2011, BMC Medical Informatics Decis. Mak..

[29]  Bernard Roy,et al.  Decision science or decision-aid science? , 1993 .

[30]  Martin Pitt,et al.  An analysis of the academic literature on simulation and modelling in health care , 2009, J. Simulation.

[31]  Ki-Hwan G. Bae,et al.  Simulation modelling of patient flow and capacity planning for regional long-term care needs: a case study , 2019, Health systems.

[32]  Marc K. Peter,et al.  The practice of foresight in long-term planning , 2015 .

[33]  Alan Maynard,et al.  Trust and performance management in the medical marketplace. , 2003, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[34]  Peter M. Verderame,et al.  Planning and Scheduling under Uncertainty: A Review Across Multiple Sectors , 2010 .

[35]  Bernardo Almada-Lobo,et al.  Handling healthcare workforce planning with care: where do we stand? , 2015, Human Resources for Health.

[36]  Dick den Hertog,et al.  A practical guide to robust optimization , 2015, 1501.02634.

[37]  Ying Chen,et al.  Process optimization with consideration of uncertainties—An overview , 2017, Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering.

[38]  Michel Godet,et al.  The Art of Scenarios and Strategic Planning - Tools and Pitfalls , 2000 .

[39]  George Cairns,et al.  Scenario analysis to support decision making in addressing wicked problems: Pitfalls and potential , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[40]  Paula Santana,et al.  Indicators for evaluating European population health: a Delphi selection process , 2018, BMC Public Health.

[41]  David C. Lane,et al.  Looking in the wrong place for healthcare improvements: A system dynamics study of an accident and emergency department , 2000, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[42]  Meryem Masmoudi,et al.  A multiobjective stochastic program for hospital bed planning , 2012, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[43]  S. Stordeur,et al.  Physician supply forecast: better than peering in a crystal ball? , 2009, Human resources for health.

[44]  Stefan Nickel,et al.  Modeling the demand for long-term care services under uncertain information , 2012, Health Care Management Science.

[45]  Brian T. Denton,et al.  A stochastic programming approach to reduce patient wait times and overtime in an outpatient infusion center , 2016 .

[46]  Muhammad Amer,et al.  A review of scenario planning , 2013 .

[47]  Warren B. Powell,et al.  A unified framework for stochastic optimization , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[48]  Liam Fahey,et al.  Learning from the Future: Competitive Foresight Scenarios: Editors Liam Fahey and Robert M. Randall, John Wiley (1998), 446 pp., £27.50 , 1998 .

[49]  Mónica Duarte Oliveira,et al.  From problem structuring to optimization: A multi-methodological framework to assist the planning of medical training , 2019, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[50]  Hercules Vladimirou,et al.  Stochastic Programming and Robust Optimization , 1997 .

[51]  Brigitte Werners,et al.  A fuzzy multi-criteria approach for robust operating room schedules , 2015, Annals of Operations Research.

[52]  Ana Paula Barbosa-Póvoa,et al.  Introducing health gains in location-allocation models: A stochastic model for planning the delivery of long-term care , 2015 .

[53]  Patrick Hirsch,et al.  Home health care routing and scheduling: A review , 2017, Comput. Oper. Res..

[54]  Martin Kunc,et al.  Strategic workforce planning in healthcare: A multi-methodology approach , 2017, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[55]  Warren E. Walker,et al.  Improving the link between the futures field and policymaking , 2018, Futures.

[56]  Yu Wang,et al.  An adjustable robust optimisation method for elective and emergency surgery capacity allocation with demand uncertainty , 2015 .

[57]  Bernd Carsten Stahl,et al.  Policy scenarios as an instrument for policymakers , 2020 .

[58]  Tomoko Ono,et al.  Health Workforce Planning in OECD Countries: A Review of 26 Projection Models from 18 Countries , 2013 .

[59]  George Cairns,et al.  Does the intuitive logics method – and its recent enhancements – produce “effective” scenarios? , 2013 .

[60]  António Alvarenga,et al.  Scenarios for population health inequalities in 2030 in Europe: the EURO-HEALTHY project experience , 2019, International Journal for Equity in Health.

[61]  Mariel S. Lavieri,et al.  Optimizing nursing human resource planning in British Columbia , 2009, Health care management science.

[62]  Peter J. H. Hulshof,et al.  Taxonomic classification of planning decisions in health care: a structured review of the state of the art in OR/MS , 2012 .

[63]  Bernardo Almada-Lobo,et al.  Physician Emigration: Should they Stay or Should they Go? A Policy Analysis , 2018, Computational Economics.

[64]  John Mingers,et al.  Multimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies , 1997 .

[65]  Xiaolan Xie,et al.  Addressing healthcare operational deficiencies using stochastic and dynamic programming , 2019, Int. J. Prod. Res..

[66]  Carlos A. Bana e Costa,et al.  Thoughts on the Future of the Multicriteria Field: Basic Convictions and Outline for a General Methodology , 1997 .

[67]  A. Vieira,et al.  Enhancing knowledge construction processes within multicriteria decision analysis: The Collaborative Value Modelling framework , 2020 .

[68]  M. Rhisiart,et al.  From foresight to impact? The 2030 Future of Work scenarios , 2017 .