Black-Scholes-Merton Option Pricing Revisited: Did we Find a Fatal Flaw?

The option pricing formula of Black and Scholes (1973) hinges on the continuous-time self-financing condition, which is a special case of the continuous-time budget equation of Merton (1971). The self-financing condition is believed to formalize the economic concept of portfolio rebalancing without inflows or outflows of external funds, but was never formally derived in continuous time. As a much bigger issue, however, we discover a timing mistake in the model of Merton (1971) and show that his self-financing condition is misspecified both in discrete and continuous time. Our results invalidate seminal contributions to the literature, including the budget equation of Merton (1971), the option pricing formula of Black and Scholes (1973), the continuous trading model of Harrison and Pliska (1981), and the binomial option pricing model of Cox, Ross and Rubinstein (1979). We also show that Black and Scholes (1973) and Harrison and Pliska (1981) implicitly assumed their replication result.

[1]  P. Guasoni.  Portfolio Theory and Arbitrage: A Course in Mathematical Finance , 2022, Quantitative Finance.

[2]  I. Karatzas,et al.  Portfolio Theory and Arbitrage , 2021, Graduate Studies in Mathematics.

[3]  R. C. Merton,et al.  Theory of Rational Option Pricing , 2015, World Scientific Reference on Contingent Claims Analysis in Corporate Finance.

[4]  S. P. Mason,et al.  Contingent Claims Analysis of Corporate Capital Structures: An Empirical Investigation , 1984, World Scientific Reference on Contingent Claims Analysis in Corporate Finance.

[5]  R. C. Merton,et al.  On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates , 1974, World Scientific Reference on Contingent Claims Analysis in Corporate Finance.

[6]  S. Shreve.  Stochastic Calculus for Finance II: Continuous-Time Models , 2010 .

[7]  Bernard Lapeyre,et al.  Introduction to Stochastic Calculus Applied to Finance , 2007 .

[8]  P. Carr.  FAQ’s in Option Pricing Theory , 2007 .

[9]  Walter Schachermayer,et al.  The Mathematics of Arbitrage , 2006 .

[10]  Tomas Björk,et al.  A note on Wick products and the fractional Black-Scholes model , 2005, Finance Stochastics.

[11]  Hansong Chen.  THE HYPOTHESES UNDERLYING THE PRICING OF OPTIONS , 2002 .

[12]  Robert Buff.  Continuous Time Finance , 2002 .

[13]  Gurdip Bakshi,et al.  Delta-Hedged Gains and the Negative Market Volatility Risk Premium , 2001 .

[14]  Hans Föllmer,et al.  Probabilistic aspects of financial risk , 2000 .

[15]  T. Björk.  Arbitrage Theory in Continuous Time , 2019 .

[16]  Gurdip Bakshi,et al.  Do Call Prices and the Underlying Stock Always Move in the Same Direction , 1999 .

[17]  A. MacDonald.  The hypotheses underlying the pricing of options: a note on a paper by Bartels , 1997 .

[18]  Walter Willinger,et al.  Dynamic spanning without probabilities , 1994 .

[19]  Thomas Beck.  Black-Scholes Revisited: Some Important Details , 1993 .

[20]  D. Duffie.  Dynamic Asset Pricing Theory , 1992 .

[21]  C. A. Roberts,et al.  Discussion * , 1970, Proceedings of the ASIL Annual Meeting.

[22]  J. Harrison,et al.  A stochastic calculus model of continuous trading: Complete markets , 1983 .

[23]  Yaacov Z. Bergman.  A Characterization of Self-Financing Portfolio Strategies , 1981 .

[24]  J. Harrison,et al.  Martingales and stochastic integrals in the theory of continuous trading , 1981 .

[25]  Larry J. Merville,et al.  An Empirical Examination of the Black‐Scholes Call Option Pricing Model , 1979 .

[26]  N. H. Hakansson..  The Fantastic World of Finance: Progress and the Free Lunch , 1979, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis.

[27]  S. Ross,et al.  Option pricing: A simplified approach☆ , 1979 .

[28]  David M. Kreps,et al.  Martingales and arbitrage in multiperiod securities markets , 1979 .

[29]  Robert C. Merton,et al.  On the pricing of contingent claims and the Modigliani-Miller theorem , 1977 .

[30]  R. C. Merton,et al.  AN INTERTEMPORAL CAPITAL ASSET PRICING MODEL , 1973 .

[31]  F. Black,et al.  The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities , 1973, Journal of Political Economy.

[32]  R. C. Merton,et al.  Optimum consumption and portfolio rules in a continuous - time model Journal of Economic Theory 3 , 1971 .