Public Goods, Private Goods: The American Struggle Over Educational Goals

This article explores three alternative goals for American education that have been at the root of educational conflicts over the years: democratic equality (schools should focus on preparing citizens), social efficiency (they should focus on training workers), and social mobility (they should prepare individuals to compete for social positions). These goals represent, respectively, the educational perspective of the citizen, the taxpayer, and the consumer. Whereas the first two look on education as a public good, the third sees it as a private good. Historical conflict over these competing visions of education has resulted in a contradictory structure for the educational system that has sharply impaired its effectiveness. More important still has been the growing domination of the social mobility goal, which has reshaped education into a commodity for the purposes of status attainment and has elevated the pursuit of credentials over the acquisition of knowledge.

[1]  Gerald W. Bracey.  The Eighth Bracey Report on the Condition of Public Education , 1998 .

[2]  Ivar E. Berg,et al.  Degrees of control : a sociology of educational expansion and occupational credentialism , 1997 .

[3]  B. B. Brown,et al.  Beyond the Classroom: Why School Reform Has Failed and What Parents Need to Do , 1996 .

[4]  Barbara K. Townsend.  The Contradictory College: The Conflicting Origins, Impacts, and Futures of the Community College , 1996 .

[5]  A. Wells,et al.  The Politics of Culture: Understanding Local Political Resistance to Detracking in Racially Mixed Schools. , 1996 .

[6]  D. Berliner,et al.  The Manufactured Crisis: Myths, Fraud, and the Attack on America's Public Schools , 1996 .

[7]  David C. Paris.  Ideology And Educational Reform: Themes And Theories In Public Education , 1995 .

[8]  Kevin J. Dougherty.  The Contradictory College: The Conflicting Origins, Impacts, and Futures of the Community College. SUNY Series, Frontiers in Education. , 1994 .

[9]  J. Goodlad.  Teachers for Our Nation's Schools , 1994 .

[10]  M. Fox.  Is it a good investment to attend an elite private college , 1993 .

[11]  W. Grubb.  Further tests of screening on education and observed ability , 1993 .

[12]  J. Kozol.  Savage Inequalities: Children in America's Schools , 1992 .

[13]  Benjamin R. Barber,et al.  An Aristocracy of Everyone: The Politics of Education and the Future of America , 1992 .

[14]  K. Shelley.  The Future of Jobs for College Graduates. , 1992 .

[15]  D. Hogan.  "... the silent compulsions of economic relations": Markets and the Demand for Education , 1992 .

[16]  H. Sharp.  The Predictable Failure of Educational Reform: Can We Change Course Before It's Too Late? , 1991 .

[17]  Allan A. Glatthorn.  Teachers for Our Nation's Schools , 1991 .

[18]  L. Lewis,et al.  The High-status track : studies of elite schools and stratification , 1991 .

[19]  Jerome Karabel,et al.  The Diverted Dream: Community Colleges and the Promise of Educational Opportunity in America, 1900-1985 , 1991 .

[20]  D. Hogan.  Modes of Discipline: Affective Individualism and Pedagogical Reform in New England, 1820-1850 , 1990, American Journal of Education.

[21]  David Labaree.  The Making of an American High School: The Credentials Market and the Central High School of Philadelphia, 1838-1939 , 1990 .

[22]  Gene V. Glass,et al.  Politics, Markets, and America's Schools , 1990 .

[23]  D. Hogan.  The Market Revolution and Disciplinary Power: Joseph Lancaster and the Psychology of the Early Classroom System , 1989, History of Education Quarterly.

[24]  J. Wrigley,et al.  Reconstructing American Education. , 1988 .

[25]  Peter W. Cookson,et al.  Preparing For Power: America's Elite Boarding Schools , 1987 .

[26]  S. Berrol.  The American College and the Culture of Aspiration, 1915–1940 , 1987 .

[27]  William J. Reese,et al.  Power and the Promise of School Reform: Grass Roots Movements during the Progressive Era , 1987 .

[28]  Robert L. Hampel,et al.  Selling Students Short: Classroom Bargains and Academic Reform in the American High School , 1986, History of Education Quarterly.

[29]  H. C. Lee.  Schooling for All: Class, Race and the Decline of the Democratic Ideal , 1986 .

[30]  N. Burbules.  Education under Siege , 1986 .

[31]  John S. Rigden,et al.  Editorial: The Carnegie report, ‘‘A Nation Prepared: Teachers for the 21st Century’’ , 1986 .

[32]  D. Levine,et al.  The American College and the Culture of Aspiration, 1915–1940 , 1986 .

[33]  R. Reid.  Class and Reform: School and Society in Chicago, 1880–1930 by David John Hogan , 1986 .

[34]  H. Levin,et al.  Schooling and Work in the Democratic State. , 1986 .

[35]  J. Richardson.  Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education , 1986 .

[36]  Charlie Coffman,et al.  Developing Career Ladders in Teaching , 1985 .

[37]  Arthur G. Powell,et al.  The Shopping Mall High School: Winners and Losers in the Educational Marketplace. , 1985 .

[38]  A. Giddens,et al.  The Constitution Of Society , 1985 .

[39]  Robert B. Everhart.  The Egalitarian Ideal and the American High School: Studies of Three Schools: Philip A. Cusick , 1985 .

[40]  D. Hogan,et al.  Class and Reform: School and Society in Chicago, 1880-1930. , 1985 .

[41]  R. Klitgaard,et al.  Choosing Elites: Selecting the "Best and the Brightest" at Top Universities and Elsewhere , 1985 .

[42]  W. Grubb,et al.  Broken Promises: How Americans Fail Their Children , 1985 .

[43]  D. Cohen.  The American Common School , 1984 .

[44]  R. Goldman,et al.  Status Attainment and the Commodity Form: Stratification in Historical Perspective , 1984 .

[45]  David Labaree.  Setting the Standard: Alternative Policies for Student Promotion. , 1984 .

[46]  Jean Campbell.  A Place Called School: Prospects for the Future. By John I. Goodlad. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co., 1984. 396 pp. $18.95 , 1984 .

[47]  John W. Meyer,et al.  Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality , 1984 .

[48]  M. Apple.  Education and power , 1983 .

[49]  David P. Gardner,et al.  A Nation at Risk: The Imperative for Educational Reform , 1983, The Elementary School Journal.

[50]  R. Connell.  Making the difference: Schools, families, and social division , 1982 .

[51]  R. Rumberger,et al.  Overeducation in the U.S. Labor Market , 1982 .

[52]  Thomas F. Green,et al.  Predicting the Behavior of the Educational System , 1981 .

[53]  John W. Meyer,et al.  Public Education as Nation-Building in America: Enrollments and Bureaucratization in the American States, 1870-1930 , 1979, American Journal of Sociology.

[54]  R. H. D. Lone.  Small Futures: Children, Inequality, and the Limits of Liberal Reform , 1979 .

[55]  R. Collins.  The Credential Society: An Historical Sociology of Education and Stratification , 1979 .

[56]  L. Griffin,et al.  Schooling and Socioeconomic Attainments: High School and College Influences , 1978, American Journal of Sociology.

[57]  Jerome Karabel,et al.  Power and ideology in education , 1978 .

[58]  M. Foucault,et al.  Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. , 1978 .

[59]  R. Freeman,et al.  The Over-Educated American , 1977 .

[60]  Ronald Dore,et al.  The Diploma Disease: Education, Qualification, and Development , 1977 .

[61]  Joann Vanek,et al.  Worlds of Pain: Life in the Working-Class Family by Lillian Breslow Rubin (review) , 1976 .

[62]  A. Zuckerman.  Education, Opportunity, and Social Inequality: Changing Prospects in Western Society . By Raymond Boudon. (New York: Wiley-Interscience, 1974. Pp. xxvii, 220. $12.50.) , 1976 .

[63]  H. Gintis,et al.  Schooling in Capitalist America , 1976 .

[64]  J. H. McGrath.  Busing and Backlash: White Against White in an Urban School District , 1974 .

[65]  W. Grubb,et al.  American Education and Vocationalism: a Documentary History, 1870-1970 , 1974 .

[66]  M. Olson,et al.  The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups. , 1973 .

[67]  M. Spence.  Job Market Signaling , 1973 .

[68]  D. Halberstam,et al.  The Best and the Brightest. , 1973 .

[69]  E. Campbell,et al.  Busing and Backlash; White Against White in an Urban School District , 1973 .

[70]  G. Psacharopoulos,et al.  Investment in Human Capital. , 1972 .

[71]  A. Hirschman.  Exit, Voice, and Loyalty , 1970 .

[72]  E. Wegner,et al.  Making the Grade: The Academic Side of College Life. , 1969 .

[73]  M. Olson,et al.  The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups , 1969 .

[74]  Sidney C. Sufrin.  Book Review: Organizational Behavior: The Logic of Collective Action: Public Goods and the Theory of Groups , 1966 .

[75]  T. Parsons.  Social Structure and Personality , 1964 .

[76]  Currin V. Shields.  The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke . By C. B. MacPherson. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1962. Pp. xi, 310. 42 s.) , 1964 .

[77]  C. B. Macpherson,et al.  The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: Hobbes to Locke , 1963 .

[78]  R. Turner.  Sponsored and Contest Mobility and the School System , 1960 .

[79]  L. Cremin,et al.  The republic and the school : Horace Mann on the education of free men. , 1957 .

[80]  Paul A. Varg,et al.  Popular Education and Democratic Thought in America , 1956 .

[81]  W. W. Charters,et al.  The School as a Social System , 1952 .

[82]  A. Shanker.  Tomorrow's Teachers , 1950 .

[83]  John Dale Russell,et al.  An Historical Study of Examinations and Grading Systems in Early American Universities: A Critical Study of the Original Records of Harvard, William and Mary, Yale, Mount Holyoke, and Michigan from Their Founding to 1900. Mary Lovett Smallwood , 1936 .

[84]  R. Church.  Education in the United States , 1900, Science.

[85]  Stewart W. Ehly,et al.  Educational Renewal: Better Teachers, Better Schools. , 1995 .

[86]  Gary B. Nash,et al.  National Standards for United States History: Exploring the American Experience. Grades 5-12. Expanded Edition. Including Examples of Student Achievement. , 1994 .

[87]  A. C. Kerckhoff.  Diverging Pathways: Social Structure and Career Deflections , 1993 .

[88]  M. Fullan.  Change Forces: Probing the Depths of Educational Reform. School Development and the Management of Change Series: 10. , 1993 .

[89]  M. Fullan.  The New Meaning of Educational Change , 1990 .

[90]  S. Sarason.  The predictable failure of educational reform : can we change course before it's too late? , 1990 .

[91]  Penelope Eckert,et al.  Jocks and Burnouts: Social Categories and Identity in the High School , 1989 .

[92]  Martin Trow,et al.  American higher education—Past, present and future , 1989 .

[93]  M. Weir,et al.  Schooling for All : Class, Race, and the Decline of the Democratic Ideal , 1988 .

[94]  P. J. Krueger.  Schooling For All - Class, Race, And The Decline Of The Democratic Ideal - Katznelson,i, Weir,m , 1988 .

[95]  J. Macleod,et al.  Ain't no makin' it: Leveled aspirations in a low-income neighborhood , 1987 .

[96]  J. Kett,et al.  Cultural Literacy: What Every American Needs to Know , 1987 .

[97]  J. Rosenbaum.  Institutional career structures and the social construction of ability , 1986 .

[98]  M. Woodhall.  Education versus qualifications?: Edited by John Oxenham. London: George Allen and Unwin, 1984. pp. 246. $25.00 (cloth), $9.95 (paper) , 1986 .

[99]  W. Bennett.  What works : research about teaching and learning , 1986 .

[100]  William J. Reese.  Power and the Promise of School Reform: Grass-Roots Movements During the Progressive Era , 1986 .

[101]  E. Boyer.  High school: A Report on Secondary Education in America , 1983 .

[102]  Philip A. Cusick.  The egalitarian ideal and the American high school : studies of three schools , 1983 .

[103]  R. Richardson.  Literacy in the open-access college , 1983 .

[104]  E. Shils.  The Constitution Of Society , 1982 .

[105]  D. Cohen,et al.  The Failure of High Schools and the Progress of Education. , 1981 .

[106]  L. Cremin.  American Education: The National Experience, 1783–1876 , 1980 .

[107]  J. Goodlad.  What Schools Are for , 1979 .

[108]  S. Parmaji.  Education and jobs , 1979 .

[109]  Christopher J. Hurn.  The limits and possibilities of schooling: An introduction to the sociology of education , 1978 .

[110]  M. Curti.  The Social Ideas of American Educators , 1978 .

[111]  David K. Cohen,et al.  Schooling in Capitalist America. , 1977 .

[112]  J. Rosenbaum.  Making inequality: The hidden curriculum of high school tracking , 1976 .

[113]  Gary S. Becker.  Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education , 1975 .

[114]  R. Boudon,et al.  Education, Opportunity, and Social Inequality: Changing Prospects in Western Society. , 1974 .

[115]  David B. Tyack.  The One Best System: A History of American Urban Education , 1974 .

[116]  David E. Kaun,et al.  Marketing Signaling: Informational Transfer in Hiring and Related Screening Processes. , 1974 .

[117]  I. C. Candoli.  Busing and Backlash: White Against White in an Urban School. , 1973 .

[118]  L. Thurow.  Education and Economic Equality. , 1972 .

[119]  B. Kiker.  Investment in human capital , 1971 .

[120]  Ivar E. Berg,et al.  Education and Jobs: The Great Training Robbery , 1971 .

[121]  Mancur Olson.  The logic of collective action :public goods and the theory ofgroups , 1971 .

[122]  James B. Mowry,et al.  Education in the United States , 1941, Nature.

[123]  Mary Lovett Smallwood,et al.  An historical study of examinations and grading systems in early American Universities : a critical study of the original records of Harvard, William and Mary, Yale, Mount Holyoke, and Michigan from their founding to 1900 , 1935 .