Design optimization of multi-energy systems using mixed-integer linear programming: Which model complexity and level of detail is sufficient?

Abstract Designing sustainable, cross-sectoral energy supply systems is a challenging task. A widespread and proven planning approach is mathematical optimization and in particular mixed-integer linear programming (MILP). While numerous MILP models have been presented in literature, there is no convention which level of detail is necessary to obtain reliable energy system designs. In this paper, a systematic performance comparison of 24 MILP models for designing multi-energy systems is conducted. The models include different combinations of five widely used model features: Piece-wise linear investment curves, multiple component resolution, minimum part-load limitations, part-load efficiencies, and start-up costs. The operational performances of the optimal system designs are compared by using a unit commitment optimization with high level of detail. In a district heating case study, the total annualized costs of the unit commitment optimizations differ substantially from 391 to 481 kEUR and the computation times of the design optimizations range from 10 s to more than 10 h. Models that consider part-load efficiencies lead to the lowest system costs but the highest computation times. In addition, simple design heuristics are identified which lead in combination with fast-solving linear models to energy systems with low total annualized costs (410 kEUR, 5% cost increase).

[1]  D. Müller,et al.  A comparison of thermal energy storage models for building energy system optimization , 2015 .

[2]  Jose Manuel Cejudo-Lopez,et al.  Selection of typical demand days for CHP optimization , 2011 .

[3]  Behnam Mohammadi-Ivatloo,et al.  Stochastic risk-constrained scheduling of smart energy hub in the presence of wind power and demand response , 2017 .

[4]  François Maréchal,et al.  Methods for multi-objective investment and operating optimization of complex energy systems , 2012 .

[5]  Fariborz Haghighat,et al.  Optimization approaches in district heating and cooling thermal network , 2017 .

[6]  Neven Duić,et al.  Future district heating systems and technologies: On the role of smart energy systems and 4th generation district heating , 2018, Energy.

[7]  F. Jolai,et al.  Optimal design of distributed energy system in a neighborhood under uncertainty , 2016 .

[8]  George Mavrotas,et al.  Multi-objective optimization and comparison framework for the design of Distributed Energy Systems , 2019, Energy Conversion and Management.

[9]  Thomas Huld,et al.  Impact of different levels of geographical disaggregation of wind and PV electricity generation in large energy system models: A case study for Austria , 2017 .

[10]  Detlef Stolten,et al.  Impact of different time series aggregation methods on optimal energy system design , 2017, ArXiv.

[11]  B. Penz,et al.  Techno‐economic planning of local energy systems through optimization models: a survey of current methods , 2020, International Journal of Energy Research.

[12]  Massimiliano Zappa,et al.  Does model performance improve with complexity? : A case study with three hydrological models , 2015 .

[13]  Daniel Schwabeneder,et al.  A comparison between mixed-integer linear programming and dynamic programming with state prediction as novelty for solving unit commitment , 2021 .

[14]  William D'haeseleer,et al.  Impact of the level of temporal and operational detail in energy-system planning models , 2016 .

[15]  Marco Mazzotti,et al.  Electrochemical conversion technologies for optimal design of decentralized multi-energy systems: Modeling framework and technology assessment , 2018, Applied Energy.

[16]  André Bardow,et al.  Automated optimization based synthesis of distributed energy supply systems , 2014 .

[17]  Pierluigi Mancarella,et al.  Multi-energy systems : An overview of concepts and evaluation models , 2015 .

[18]  Lars Nolting,et al.  Complexity profiles: A large-scale review of energy system models in terms of complexity , 2020, Energy Strategy Reviews.

[19]  Jan Carmeliet,et al.  New formulations of the ‘energy hub’ model to address operational constraints , 2014 .

[20]  F. W. Yu,et al.  Part load performance of air-cooled centrifugal chillers with variable speed condenser fan control , 2007 .

[21]  Ryohei Yokoyama,et al.  Multiobjective Optimal Design of Energy Supply Systems Based on Relative Robustness Criterion , 2002 .

[22]  Andreas Rieder,et al.  Multi criteria dynamic design optimization of a small scale distributed energy system , 2014 .

[23]  Edoardo Amaldi,et al.  A detailed MILP optimization model for combined cooling, heat and power system operation planning , 2014 .

[24]  Lars Nolting,et al.  Are complex energy system models more accurate? An intra-model comparison of power system optimization models , 2019, Applied Energy.

[25]  Michael Stadler,et al.  Modeling of non-linear CHP efficiency curves in distributed energy systems , 2015 .

[26]  André Bardow,et al.  Robust multi-objective optimization for sustainable design of distributed energy supply systems , 2017, Comput. Chem. Eng..

[27]  Nilay Shah,et al.  Optimisation based design of a district energy system for an eco-town in the United Kingdom , 2011 .

[28]  Yun Yang,et al.  Optimal design of distributed energy resource systems coupled with energy distribution networks , 2015 .

[29]  Nilay Shah,et al.  A multi-objective optimization and multi-criteria evaluation integrated framework for distributed energy system optimal planning , 2018, Energy Conversion and Management.

[30]  Tetsuya Wakui,et al.  Optimization of energy supply systems by MILP branch and bound method in consideration of hierarchical relationship between design and operation , 2015 .

[31]  Jan Carmeliet,et al.  Design of distributed energy systems under uncertainty: A two-stage stochastic programming approach , 2018, Applied Energy.

[32]  André Bardow,et al.  An adaptive discretization MINLP algorithm for optimal synthesis of decentralized energy supply systems , 2016, Comput. Chem. Eng..

[33]  Martin Greiner,et al.  Cost optimal scenarios of a future highly renewable European electricity system: Exploring the influence of weather data, cost parameters and policy constraints , 2018, Energy.

[34]  Brian Elmegaard,et al.  Comparison of linear, mixed integer and non-linear programming methods in energy system dispatch modelling , 2014 .

[35]  Jan Carmeliet,et al.  Optimising urban energy systems: Simultaneous system sizing, operation and district heating network layout , 2016 .

[36]  D. Stolten,et al.  Time series aggregation for energy system design: Modeling seasonal storage , 2017, 1710.07593.

[37]  Bryan Palmintier,et al.  Impact of unit commitment constraints on generation expansion planning with renewables , 2011, 2011 IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting.

[38]  Thomas Pregger,et al.  Comparison of spatially and temporally resolved energy system models with a focus on Germany's future power supply , 2019 .

[39]  Priyanko Guha Thakurta,et al.  Flexible unit commitment of a network-constrained combined heat and power system , 2018, 1809.09508.

[40]  Jan Carmeliet,et al.  Ten questions concerning modeling of distributed multi-energy systems , 2019, Building and Environment.

[41]  Larry R. Dysert.  Sharpen your cost estimating skills , 2003 .

[42]  Feng Wei,et al.  Optimal Capacity Configuration for Energy Hubs Considering Part-Load Characteristics of Generation Units , 2017 .

[43]  J. Kiviluoma,et al.  Impact of operational details and temporal representations on investment planning in energy systems dominated by wind and solar , 2021 .

[44]  A. Boies,et al.  Distributed energy resource system optimisation using mixed integer linear programming , 2013 .

[45]  Marco Mazzotti,et al.  Optimal design of multi-energy systems with seasonal storage , 2017, Applied Energy.

[46]  Dirk Müller,et al.  5th Generation District Heating: A novel design approach based on mathematical optimization , 2020 .

[47]  Ryohei Yokoyama,et al.  Optimal structural design of residential cogeneration systems in consideration of their operating restrictions , 2014 .

[48]  Alexandra M. Newman,et al.  Evaluating shortfalls in mixed-integer programming approaches for the optimal design and dispatch of distributed generation systems , 2013 .

[49]  André Bardow,et al.  Synthesis and Optimization of Distributed Energy Supply Systems using Automated Superstructure and Model Generation , 2012 .

[50]  Jan Carmeliet,et al.  Comparing different temporal dimension representations in distributed energy system design models , 2017 .

[51]  Nan Li,et al.  Optimal design and operation strategy for integrated evaluation of CCHP (combined cooling heating and power) system , 2016 .

[52]  Patrick Jochem,et al.  Reducing computing time of energy system models by a myopic approach , 2014 .

[53]  André Bardow,et al.  Optimal (n-1)-reliable design of distributed energy supply systems , 2019, Comput. Chem. Eng..

[54]  Efstratios N. Pistikopoulos,et al.  An energy systems engineering approach for the design and operation of microgrids in residential applications , 2013 .

[55]  H. Rogner,et al.  Incorporating flexibility requirements into long-term energy system models – A case study on high levels of renewable electricity penetration in Ireland , 2014 .

[56]  André Bardow,et al.  The optimum is not enough: A near-optimal solution paradigm for energy systems synthesis , 2015 .

[57]  Efstratios N. Pistikopoulos,et al.  Impacts of equipment off-design characteristics on the optimal design and operation of combined cooling, heating and power systems , 2013, Comput. Chem. Eng..

[58]  Thomas Schütz,et al.  Comparison of clustering algorithms for the selection of typical demand days for energy system synthesis , 2018, Renewable Energy.

[59]  Daniel Bender,et al.  Using multi-objective optimization to balance system-level model complexity , 2014, EOOLT '14.

[60]  Thomas Schütz,et al.  Optimal design of energy conversion units for residential buildings considering German market conditions , 2017 .