Lean healthcare: review, classification and analysis of literature

Abstract This study presents a literature review of 107 papers on lean healthcare to evaluate its evolution by updating previous literature reviews and to propose a classification and analysis of the papers reviewed. The literature classification was performed based on six parameters: research method, country, healthcare area, implementation, lean tools and methods and results. From the analysis performed, this paper presents a quantitative analysis of the state of the art concerning lean healthcare and indicates current research trends, based on the stage of evolution of the area, that may guide further studies on the subject. An example is lean healthcare expansion to other countries, such as Brazil and the Netherlands. Another aspect is the application of lean healthcare in hospital as a whole, not limited to a specific setting. Finally, a few studies detail the lean implementation process and use infrequently applied tools, present the barriers and main critical factors found in the lean implementation.

[1]  Pamela Mazzocato,et al.  How does lean work in emergency care? A case study of a lean-inspired intervention at the Astrid Lindgren Children's hospital, Stockholm, Sweden , 2012, BMC Health Services Research.

[2]  Joyce E Johnson,et al.  From Toyota to the bedside: nurses can lead the lean way in health care reform. , 2012, Nursing administration quarterly.

[3]  Leanne Hayward.  How applicable is lean in mental health? A critical appraisal , 2012 .

[4]  José Crespo de Carvalho,et al.  Lean Healthcare across Cultures: State-Of-The-Art , 2012 .

[5]  Antonio Freitas Rentes,et al.  A new value stream mapping approach for healthcare environments , 2016 .

[6]  A. Chiarini.  Risk management and cost reduction of cancer drugs using Lean Six Sigma tools , 2012 .

[7]  Paul M Ness,et al.  Blood wastage reduction using Lean Sigma methodology , 2010, Transfusion.

[8]  P. V. Marsden,et al.  Handbook of Survey Research , 1985 .

[9]  Shahriar Zehtabchi,et al.  A Structured Approach to Transforming a Large Public Hospital Emergency Department via Lean Methodologies , 2012, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[10]  Yichuan Wang,et al.  Deploying Lean in Healthcare: Evaluating Information Technology Effectiveness in U.S. Hospital Pharmacies , 2014, Int. J. Inf. Manag..

[11]  Walter Sermeus,et al.  Exploring the relation between process design and efficiency in high-volume cataract pathways from a lean thinking perspective. , 2011, International journal for quality in health care : journal of the International Society for Quality in Health Care.

[12]  Greg D Randolph,et al.  Applying Lean principles and Kaizen rapid improvement events in public health practice. , 2012, Journal of public health management and practice : JPHMP.

[13]  Linda R. LaGanga.  Lean service operations: Reflections and new directions for capacity expansion in outpatient clinics , 2011 .

[14]  M. Holweg,et al.  Lean in healthcare: the unfilled promise? , 2012, Social science & medicine.

[15]  Airica Steed,et al.  An Exploration of the Leadership Attributes and Methods Associated With Successful Lean System Deployments in Acute Care Hospitals , 2012, Quality management in health care.

[16]  Karl Kappeler,et al.  Lean methodology in i.v. medication processes in a children's hospital. , 2010, American journal of health-system pharmacy : AJHP : official journal of the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.

[17]  Selena Hariharan,et al.  Patients are Not Cars and Staff are Not Robots: Impact of Differences between Manufacturing and Clinical Operations on Process Improvement , 2012 .

[18]  Davi Noboru Nakano,et al.  A produção científica nos anais do encontro nacional de engenharia de produção: um levantamento de métodos e tipos de pesquisa , 1999 .

[19]  John K. Gershenson,et al.  Classification scheme for lean manufacturing tools , 2003 .

[20]  Shreeranga Bhat,et al.  Enhancing performance of the health information department of a hospital using lean Six Sigma methodology , 2013 .

[21]  T. Ingebrigtsen,et al.  Lean thinking in hospitals: is there a cure for the absence of evidence? A systematic review of reviews , 2014, BMJ Open.

[22]  Kurt Stuenkel,et al.  A community hospital's journey into Lean Six Sigma. , 2009, Frontiers of health services management.

[23]  Rambabu Kodali,et al.  Lean production: literature review and trends , 2015 .

[24]  Nurul Fadly Habidin,et al.  Exploring lean healthcare practice and supply chain innovation for Malaysian healthcare industry , 2014 .

[25]  Jack R. Meredith,et al.  Building operations management theory through case and field research , 1998 .

[26]  K. Haller.  Conducting A Literature Review , 1988, MCN. The American journal of maternal child nursing.

[27]  P. Kaboli,et al.  Guiding inpatient quality improvement: a systematic review of Lean and Six Sigma. , 2010, Joint Commission journal on quality and patient safety.

[28]  John Nicholas,et al.  An Integrated Lean-Methods Approach to Hospital Facilities Redesign , 2012, Hospital topics.

[29]  J. Casey,et al.  Utilization of lean management principles in the ambulatory clinic setting , 2009, Nature Clinical Practice Urology.

[30]  Ronald J. M. M. Does,et al.  Quality Quandaries: Efficiency Improvement in a Nursing Department , 2009 .

[31]  J. Paauwe,et al.  Toward a conceptual framework for exploring multilevel relationships between Lean Management and Six Sigma, enabling HRM, strategic climate and outcomes in healthcare , 2014 .

[32]  E. Dickson,et al.  Use of lean in the emergency department: a case series of 4 hospitals. , 2009, Annals of emergency medicine.

[33]  Su Mi Dahlgaard-Park,et al.  Lean Service: A literature analysis and classification , 2012 .

[34]  Erik Drotz,et al.  Lean in healthcare from employees' perspectives. , 2014, Journal of health organization and management.

[35]  Giuliano Almeida Marodin,et al.  Implementing lean production systems: research areas and opportunities for future studies , 2013 .

[36]  Robin Moore,et al.  Use of lean and six sigma methodology to improve operating room efficiency in a high-volume tertiary-care academic medical center. , 2011, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[37]  Robert E. Hody,et al.  Reduction of regulated medical waste using lean sigma results in financial gains for hospital. , 2011, Anesthesiology clinics.

[38]  Richard Janssen,et al.  Application of lean thinking to health care: issues and observations , 2009, International journal for quality in health care : journal of the International Society for Quality in Health Care.

[39]  Jiju Antony,et al.  Reducing Patient Waiting Time in Outpatient Department Using Lean Six Sigma Methodology , 2014, Qual. Reliab. Eng. Int..

[40]  Kim Hua Tan,et al.  Managing lean capabilities through flexible workforce development: a process and framework , 2013 .

[41]  James D. Wright,et al.  Handbook of Survey Research. , 1985 .

[42]  Peter Jacobsen,et al.  Implementing lean in surgery - lessons and implications , 2012, Int. J. Technol. Manag..

[43]  Ronald J. M. M. Does,et al.  Quality Quandaries: Shortening the Throughput Time of a Hospital's Billing Process , 2013 .

[44]  Elena G Canacari,et al.  Lean Principles to Optimize Instrument Utilization for Spine Surgery in an Academic Medical Center: An Opportunity to Standardize, Cut Costs, and Build a Culture of Improvement , 2014, Spine.

[45]  P. Kostense,et al.  How to save costs by reducing unnecessary testing: lean thinking in clinical practice. , 2012, European journal of internal medicine.

[46]  Aditi Saxena,et al.  The Emergency Department , 2010 .

[47]  John W. Creswell,et al.  Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches , 2010 .

[48]  Benjamin P. H. Kemper,et al.  Quality Quandaries: Streamlining the Path to Optimal Care for Cardiovascular Patients , 2011 .

[49]  Pauline M Johnson,et al.  Lean methodology: an evidence-based practice approach for healthcare improvement. , 2013, The Nurse practitioner.

[50]  Peter Hogg,et al.  A mixed model study evaluating lean in the transformation of an orthopaedic radiology service , 2013 .

[51]  Bimal Nepal,et al.  On the adoption of lean manufacturing principles in process industries , 2015 .

[52]  Bozena Poksinska,et al.  The Current State of Lean Implementation in Health Care: Literature Review , 2010, Quality management in health care.

[53]  Ross W Simon,et al.  A practical guide to applying lean tools and management principles to health care improvement projects. , 2012, AORN journal.

[54]  Patrick R Axon,et al.  The use of Lean Thinking techniques in implementing the Department of Health, UK, 18-week waiting time directive for cochlear implantation. , 2009, Cochlear implants international.

[55]  Iris D. Tommelein,et al.  Lean hospitals: a new challenge for facility designers , 2012 .

[56]  Simon Bishop,et al.  Lean healthcare: rhetoric, ritual and resistance. , 2010, Social science & medicine.

[57]  Rita D'Angelo,et al.  The Henry ford production system: effective reduction of process defects and waste in surgical pathology. , 2007, American journal of clinical pathology.

[58]  Håkan Aronsson,et al.  Developing lean and agile health care supply chains , 2011 .

[59]  Samir Lamouri,et al.  A critical analysis of Lean approach structuring in hospitals , 2014, Bus. Process. Manag. J..

[60]  T. Bortolotti,et al.  Successful lean implementation: Organizational culture and soft lean practices , 2015 .

[61]  Andrew C. Lyons,et al.  Developing an understanding of lean thinking in process industries , 2013 .

[62]  T A Yousri,et al.  Lean thinking: can it improve the outcome of fracture neck of femur patients in a district general hospital? , 2011, Injury.

[63]  Kimberlee D. Snyder,et al.  A Rural Hospital Takes on Lean , 2009, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[64]  R W Edmonds.  Health service in UK. , 1992, Australian family physician.

[65]  Luciano Brandão de Souza,et al.  Trends and approaches in lean healthcare , 2009 .

[66]  Natalie Prystajecky,et al.  Use of Lean Response to Improve Pandemic Influenza Surge in Public Health Laboratories , 2012, Emerging infectious diseases.

[67]  Daniel Roos,et al.  The machine that changed the world : the story of lean production , 1991 .

[68]  James P. Womack,et al.  Lean Thinking: Banish Waste and Create Wealth in Your Corporation , 1996 .

[69]  Rachel Deans,et al.  Finding a balance between "value added" and feeling valued: revising models of care. The human factor of implementing a quality improvement initiative using Lean methodology within the healthcare sector. , 2011, Healthcare quarterly.

[70]  Andrea Chiarini,et al.  Waste savings in patient transportation inside large hospitals using lean thinking tools and logistic solutions , 2013 .

[71]  Jens J. Dahlgaard,et al.  Quality and lean health care: A system for assessing and improving the health of healthcare organisations , 2011 .

[72]  Sachin Sahni,et al.  Contextualizing Ethics: Ventilators, H1N1 and Marginalized Populations , 2016 .

[73]  Nick Rich,et al.  Losing patients: a systems view on healthcare improvement , 2013 .

[74]  Syed Aljunid,et al.  Using alternative programming algorithms and techniques for optimizing performance of the Casemix software , 2012, BMC Health Services Research.

[75]  F Tejedor-Panchón,et al.  Mejora del proceso de un servicio de urgencias de hospital mediante la metodología Lean , 2014 .

[76]  Ronald D. Snee,et al.  Lean Six Sigma – getting better all the time , 2010 .

[77]  Terry Platchek,et al.  Lean Health Care for the Hospitalist , 2012 .

[78]  Clark Carboneau,et al.  A Lean Six Sigma Team Increases Hand Hygiene Compliance and Reduces Hospital‐Acquired MRSA Infections by 51% , 2010, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[79]  Ron Brown,et al.  The Henry Ford production system: LEAN process redesign improves service in the molecular diagnostic laboratory: a paper from the 2008 William Beaumont hospital symposium on molecular pathology. , 2009, The Journal of molecular diagnostics : JMD.

[80]  A. Sohal,et al.  Readiness factors for lean implementation in healthcare settings--a literature review. , 2014, Journal of health organization and management.

[81]  Kevin Neailey,et al.  UK health visiting: challenges faced during lean implementation , 2010 .

[82]  Thanos Papadopoulos.  Continuous innovation through lean thinking in healthcare: the role of dynamic actor associations , 2012, Int. J. Technol. Manag..

[83]  Keng Lin Soh,et al.  What is the leanness level of your organisation in lean transformation implementation? An integrated lean index using ANP approach , 2014 .

[84]  Lori Rothenberg,et al.  Facilitating Lean Learning and Behaviors in Hospitals During the Early Stages of Lean Implementation , 2012 .

[85]  Christine Pocha.  Lean Six Sigma in Health Care and the Challenge of Implementation of Six Sigma Methodologies at a Veterans Affairs Medical Center , 2010, Quality management in health care.

[86]  John E Billi,et al.  Lean management in academic surgery. , 2012, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[87]  Ellen M. Goonan,et al.  Applying Lean/Toyota production system principles to improve phlebotomy patient satisfaction and workflow. , 2009, American journal of clinical pathology.

[88]  Jason Black,et al.  Transforming the Patient Care Environment with Lean Six Sigma and Realistic Evaluation , 2009, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[89]  José Crespo de Carvalho,et al.  Vendor managed inventory (VMI): evidences from lean deployment in healthcare , 2013 .

[90]  Kjeld Harald Aij,et al.  Experiences of leaders in the implementation of Lean in a teaching hospital—barriers and facilitators in clinical practices: a qualitative study , 2013, BMJ Open.

[91]  Seyed Mohammad,et al.  A proposed dynamic model for a lean roadmap , 2011 .

[92]  Jiju Antony,et al.  Applications of Lean Six Sigma in an Irish hospital , 2013 .

[93]  Kim Barnas,et al.  ThedaCare's business performance system: sustaining continuous daily improvement through hospital management in a lean environment. , 2011, Joint Commission journal on quality and patient safety.

[94]  Norzima Zulkifli,et al.  Application of a modified VIKOR method for decision-making problems in lean tool selection , 2014 .

[95]  Gordon T. Vail,et al.  Applying the Lean principles of the Toyota Production System to reduce wait times in the emergency department. , 2010, CJEM.

[96]  Helen Boulton.  Action research: a methodology , 2011 .

[97]  Shreeranga Bhat,et al.  Application of Lean Six Sigma methodology to reduce the cycle time of out-patient department service in a rural hospital , 2014 .

[98]  J. Pelage,et al.  [Interventional radiology]. , 2006, Journal de radiologie.

[99]  Shahryar Sorooshian,et al.  An integrated design methodology based on the use of group AHP-DEA approach for measuring lean tools efficiency with undesirable output , 2014 .

[100]  Lisiane Priscila Roldão Selau,et al.  PRODUÇÃO ENXUTA NO SETOR DE SERVIÇOS: CASO DO HOSPITAL DE CLÍNICAS DE PORTO ALEGRE - HCPA , 2009 .

[101]  Ronald J. M. M. Does,et al.  Quality Quandaries: Lean Nursing , 2010 .

[102]  P. Garengo,et al.  Lean manufacturing in developing countries: evidence from Indian SMEs , 2012 .

[103]  L. Berry,et al.  The promise of Lean in health care. , 2013, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[104]  P. Atkinson,et al.  Nurse-led liaison mental health service for older adults: service development using lean thinking methodology. , 2012, Journal of psychosomatic research.

[105]  Jrjung Lyu,et al.  A Lean Six-Sigma approach to touch panel quality improvement , 2009 .

[106]  Omar Al-Araidah,et al.  Lead‐Time Reduction Utilizing Lean Tools Applied to Healthcare: The Inpatient Pharmacy at a Local Hospital , 2010, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[107]  A. Cunha,et al.  Aplicabilidade da metodologia Lean em uma lavanderia hospitalar , 2011 .

[108]  Moacir Godinho Filho,et al.  From time-based competition (TBC) to quick response manufacturing (QRM): the evolution of research aimed at lead time reduction , 2013 .

[109]  E. Wojtys,et al.  Applying Lean Techniques to Improve the Patient Scheduling Process , 2009, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[110]  Jennifer Rowley,et al.  Conducting a literature review , 2004 .

[111]  Anuj Saraogi,et al.  Assessing the evidence of Six Sigma and Lean in the health care industry. , 2011, Quality management in health care.

[112]  Tony W. York,et al.  The Healthcare Environment , 2015 .

[113]  Zoe Radnor,et al.  The role of actor associations in understanding the implementation of Lean thinking in healthcare , 2011 .

[114]  Michael Pidd,et al.  Exploring the barriers to lean health care implementation , 2011 .

[115]  Thanos Papadopoulos,et al.  Continuous improvement and dynamic actor associations: A study of lean thinking implementation in the UK National Health Service , 2011 .

[116]  John W. Creswell,et al.  Research Design: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches , 1997 .

[117]  James R. Langabeer,et al.  Implementation of Lean and Six Sigma quality initiatives in hospitals: A goal theoretic perspective , 2009 .

[118]  Zoe Radnor,et al.  Evaluating Lean in healthcare. , 2013, International journal of health care quality assurance.

[119]  Shreeranga Bhat,et al.  Application of Lean Six Sigma methodology in the registration process of a hospital , 2014 .

[120]  D. Tranfield,et al.  Towards a Methodology for Developing Evidence-Informed Management Knowledge by Means of Systematic Review , 2003 .

[121]  C. Su,et al.  Applying lean six sigma to improve healthcare: An empirical study , 2011 .

[122]  Andrew Eller,et al.  Rapid Assessment and Disposition: Applying LEAN in the Emergency Department , 2009, Journal for healthcare quality : official publication of the National Association for Healthcare Quality.

[123]  Soudabeh Khodambashi,et al.  Evaluation of the clinical process in a critical care information system using the Lean method: a case study , 2012, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[124]  José Crespo de Carvalho,et al.  A lean case study in an oncological hospital: implementation of a telephone triage system in the emergency service , 2013, Risk management and healthcare policy.

[125]  Amita Singh,et al.  Lean and queuing integration for the transformation of health care processes , 2012 .

[126]  Norzima Zulkifli,et al.  A dynamic modeling to measure lean performance within lean attributes , 2013 .

[127]  Dante Morra,et al.  Leading Lean: a Canadian healthcare leader's guide. , 2009, Healthcare quarterly.

[128]  Greg J. Bamber,et al.  Implementing lean management/Six Sigma in hospitals: beyond empowerment or work intensification? , 2014 .

[129]  Martyn Hammersley,et al.  Ethnography : Principles in Practice , 1983 .

[130]  Christopher S Kim,et al.  Creating value in health care: The case for Lean Thinking , 2009 .

[131]  Pranav Phadtare.  Lean Production: Literature Review , 2014 .

[132]  R. A. Rico,et al.  Application of lean methods to compounding services in hospital pharmacy , 2013 .

[133]  J. S. Desmond,et al.  Optimizing clinical operations as part of a global emergency medicine initiative in Kumasi, Ghana: application of Lean manufacturing principals to low-resource health systems. , 2012, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[134]  Martin D. Merry,et al.  On the Mend: Revolutionizing Healthcare to Save Lives and Transform the Industry , 2011 .

[135]  Liliane Pintelon,et al.  Lean Thinking and Six Sigma: proven techniques in industry. Can they help health care? , 2013 .

[136]  John Toussaint,et al.  Mistake-proofing healthcare: Why stopping processes may be a good start , 2010 .

[137]  Lin Ma,et al.  Integrated Lean Six Sigma Approach for Patient Flow Improvement in Hospital Emergency Department , 2013 .

[138]  V. Cruz Machado,et al.  Lean tools and lean transformation process in health care , 2010 .

[139]  Sabi Singh,et al.  Application of lean manufacturing techniques in the Emergency Department. , 2009, The Journal of emergency medicine.

[140]  Diane B Kimsey.  Lean methodology in health care. , 2010, AORN journal.

[141]  Rachel Harvey,et al.  Lean information management: the use of observational data in health care , 2009 .

[142]  Andrea Chiarini,et al.  Implementing Lean Six Sigma in healthcare: issues from Italy , 2013 .

[143]  Pamela Mazzocato,et al.  Lean thinking in healthcare: a realist review of the literature , 2010, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[144]  Christopher S Kim,et al.  Implementation of lean thinking: one health system's journey. , 2009, Joint Commission journal on quality and patient safety.

[145]  Peter Henriksson,et al.  Antecedents and Characteristics of Lean Thinking Implementation in a Swedish Hospital: A Case Study , 2013, Quality management in health care.

[146]  S. J. Knoer,et al.  Effect of lean process improvement techniques on a university hospital inpatient pharmacy. , 2009, American journal of health-system pharmacy : AJHP : official journal of the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.

[147]  Melissa L Dougherty,et al.  Redesigning care at the Flinders Medical Centre: clinical process redesign using “lean thinking” , 2008, The Medical journal of Australia.

[148]  Dale Schattenkirk.  Building sustainable internal capacity for quality within a healthcare environment , 2012 .

[149]  J. Daggy,et al.  Redesigning a joint replacement program using Lean Six Sigma in a Veterans Affairs hospital. , 2013, JAMA surgery.

[150]  Arlene Libby,et al.  Application of lean methods improves surgical clinic experience. , 2010, Journal of pediatric surgery.

[151]  K. Neailey,et al.  Lean implementation in primary care health visiting services in National Health Service UK , 2010, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[152]  Bernd Hamm,et al.  Lean manufacturing and Toyota Production System terminology applied to the procurement of vascular stents in interventional radiology , 2011, Insights into imaging.