Empathy and Callous–Unemotional Traits in Different Bullying Roles: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Bullying is an extremely damaging type of violence that is present in schools all over the world, but there are still many gaps in knowledge regarding different variables that might influence the phenomenon. Two promising research lines focus on empathy and callous–unemotional traits but findings from individual studies seem to be contradictory. This article reports the results of a systematic review and a meta-analysis on empathy and callous–unemotional traits in relation to school bullying based on 53 empirical reports that met the inclusion criteria. Bullying perpetration is negatively associated with cognitive (odds ratio [OR] = 0.60) and affective (OR = 0.51) empathy. Perpetration is also positively associated with callous–unemotional traits (OR = 2.55). Bully-victims scored low in empathy (OR = 0.57). There is a nonsignificant association between victimization and empathy (OR = 0.96), while the relationship between callous–unemotional traits and victimization is significant but small (OR = 1.66). Defenders scored high on cognitive (OR = 2.09) and affective (OR = 2.62) empathy. These findings should be taken into account in explaining and preventing bullying.

[1]  Andreas König,et al.  Cyber bullying: The role of traditional bullying and empathy , 2009 .

[2]  J. Strayer,et al.  Empathy, Anger, Guilt: Emotions and Prosocial Behaviour , 2014 .

[3]  Stelios N. Georgiou,et al.  Linking Callous-Unemotional Traits to Instrumental and Non-Instrumental Forms of Aggression , 2009 .

[4]  K. Fanti,et al.  Dimensions of juvenile psychopathy distinguish “bullies,” “bully-victims,” and “victims”. , 2013 .

[5]  G. Schwartz,et al.  Distress and restraint as superordinate dimensions of self-reported adjustment: a typological perspective. , 1990, Journal of personality.

[6]  C. O'Brien,et al.  Examining the association between callous-unemotional traits, bullying and victimization in preschoolers , 2012 .

[7]  Sarah N. Woods,et al.  Emotion recognition abilities and empathy of victims of bullying. , 2009, Child abuse & neglect.

[8]  C. Salmivalli,et al.  Bullying as a group process: Participant roles and their relations to social status within the group , 1998 .

[9]  Amanda B. Nickerson,et al.  Empathetic responsiveness, group norms, and prosocial affiliations in bullying roles. , 2014, School psychology quarterly : the official journal of the Division of School Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[10]  Elisa Poskiparta,et al.  A large-scale evaluation of the KiVa antibullying program: grades 4-6. , 2011, Child development.

[11]  D. Pepler,et al.  Individual Motivations and Characteristics Associated With Bystander Intervention During Bullying Episodes Among Children and Youth , 2012 .

[12]  K. Fanti,et al.  Bullying and Victimization: The Role of Conduct Problems and Psychopathic Traits , 2012 .

[13]  W. Craig,et al.  Evaluation of An Ecological Program to Reduce Bullying in Schools , 2002 .

[14]  C. Salmivalli,et al.  Classroom norms of bullying alter the degree to which children defend in response to their affective empathy and power. , 2015, Developmental psychology.

[15]  The Social, Behavioral, and Emotional Correlates of Bullying and Victimization in a School-Based Sample , 2016, Journal of abnormal child psychology.

[16]  F. Alsaker,et al.  Early diagnosis and prevention of victimization in kindergarten. , 2001 .

[17]  D. Farrington,et al.  Are within-individual causes of delinquency the same as between-individual causes? , 2002, Criminal behaviour and mental health : CBMH.

[18]  M. Dadds,et al.  Stability and Malleability of Callous-Unemotional Traits During Treatment for Childhood Conduct Problems , 2007, Journal of clinical child and adolescent psychology : the official journal for the Society of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, American Psychological Association, Division 53.

[19]  Çiğdem Topcu,et al.  Affective and cognitive empathy as mediators of gender differences in cyber and traditional bullying , 2012 .

[20]  C. Salmivalli,et al.  What Does It Take to Stand Up for the Victim of Bullying?: The Interplay Between Personal and Social Factors , 2010 .

[21]  D. Farrington,et al.  Empathy and offending: a systematic review and meta-analysis , 2004 .

[22]  P. Frick,et al.  Research review: the importance of callous-unemotional traits for developmental models of aggressive and antisocial behavior. , 2008, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[23]  Christina Salmivalli,et al.  Unique and Interactive Effects of Empathy and Social Status on Involvement in Bullying , 2009 .

[24]  David Warden,et al.  Prosocial children, bullies and victims: An investigation of their sociometric status, empathy and social problem-solving strategies , 2003 .

[25]  W. Dieterich,et al.  Effects of a Skills-based Prevention Program on Bullying and Bully Victimization among Elementary School Children , 2007, Prevention Science.

[26]  J. Jenson,et al.  Transitions between subclasses of bullying and victimization when entering middle school. , 2014, Aggressive behavior.

[27]  Isabel Correia,et al.  School Bullying : Belief in a Personal Just World of Bullies, Victims, and Defenders , 2008 .

[28]  Peter K. Smith,et al.  Bullying in schools: Lessons from two decades of research , 2000 .

[29]  Rosario Del Rey,et al.  Systematic review of theoretical studies on bullying and cyberbullying: Facts, knowledge, prevention, and intervention , 2015 .

[30]  A. Garton,et al.  The development of a scale to measure empathy in 8- and 9-year old children , 2005 .

[31]  D. Farrington,et al.  Drawing conclusions about causes from systematic reviews of risk factors: The Cambridge Quality Checklists , 2009 .

[32]  Craig D DiGiovanni,et al.  Predicting Homophobic Behavior Among Heterosexual Youth: Domain General and Sexual Orientation-Specific Factors at the Individual and Contextual Level , 2013, Journal of youth and adolescence.

[33]  Theodoros Giovazolias,et al.  Personality traits, empathy and bullying behavior: A meta-analytic approach , 2015 .

[34]  M. H. Hussein.  The social and emotional skills of bullies, victims, and bully–victims of Egyptian primary school children , 2013 .

[35]  George Davey Smith,et al.  Principles of and Procedures for Systematic Reviews , 2008 .

[36]  Antonius H. N. Cillessen,et al.  Empathy and Involvement in Bullying in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review , 2015, Journal of youth and adolescence.

[37]  Joaquín A. Mora-Merchán,et al.  Bullying in Schools: SAVE model: an anti-bullying intervention in Spain , 2004 .

[38]  Constantinos M. Kokkinos,et al.  The relationship between bullying, victimization, trait emotional intelligence, self-efficacy and empathy among preadolescents , 2011, Social Psychology of Education.

[39]  A. Baroncelli,et al.  The Association between Callous-Unemotional Traits and Behavioral and Academic Adjustment in Children: Further Validation of the Inventory of Callous-Unemotional Traits , 2014 .

[40]  Christopher H. K. Cheng,et al.  Cyberbullying perpetration and victimization among adolescents in Hong Kong , 2014 .

[41]  Juliana Raskauskas,et al.  Bullying among primary school children in New Zealand: relationships with prosocial behaviour and classroom climate , 2010 .

[42]  D. Espelage,et al.  Empathy, Caring, and Bullying: Toward an Understanding of Complex Associations , 2003 .

[43]  David P. Farrington,et al.  School bullying as a predictor of violence later in life: A systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective longitudinal studies , 2012 .

[44]  D. Espelage,et al.  Willingness to Intervene in Bullying Episodes Among Middle School Students , 2012 .

[45]  J. Hubbard,et al.  Children's physiological and emotional reactions to witnessing bullying predict bystander intervention. , 2013, Child development.

[46]  S. Perren,et al.  Children’s Peer Victimization, Empathy, and Emotional Symptoms , 2010, Child psychiatry and human development.

[47]  D. Olweus,et al.  Self-reported empathy in Norwegian adolescents: Sex differences, age trends, and relationship to bullying. , 2001 .

[48]  C. Salmivalli.  Bullying and the peer group: A review , 2010 .

[49]  Mark H. Davis.  Measuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach. , 1983 .

[50]  P. Scheidt,et al.  Bullying and symptoms among school-aged children: international comparative cross sectional study in 28 countries. , 2005, European journal of public health.

[51]  Benjamin B. Lahey,et al.  Atypical empathic responses in adolescents with aggressive conduct disorder: A functional MRI investigation , 2009, Biological Psychology.

[52]  L. Downey,et al.  Brief report: Emotional intelligence, victimisation and bullying in adolescents. , 2012, Journal of adolescence.

[53]  D. Olweus,et al.  The Importance of Sex‐of‐Stimulus Object: Age Trends and Sex Differences in Empathic Responsiveness , 2001 .

[54]  L. Downey,et al.  The development of an adolescent measure of EI , 2007 .

[55]  Ramani S. Pilla,et al.  Bullying Behaviors Among US Youth: Prevalence and Association With Psychosocial Adjustment , 2001 .

[56]  E. Viding,et al.  The contribution of callous-unemotional traits and conduct problems to bullying in early adolescence. , 2009, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[57]  José A. Casas,et al.  Bullying and cyberbullying: Convergent and divergent predictor variables , 2013, Comput. Hum. Behav..

[58]  A. Baroncelli,et al.  Unique effects of different components of trait emotional intelligence in traditional bullying and cyberbullying. , 2014, Journal of adolescence.

[59]  David P. Farrington,et al.  School-Based Programs to Reduce Bullying and Victimization , 2012 .

[60]  C. Belacchi,et al.  Feeling and thinking of others: affective and cognitive empathy and emotion comprehension in prosocial/hostile preschoolers. , 2012, Aggressive behavior.

[61]  Enrique Chaux,et al.  Money and age in schools: Bullying and power imbalances. , 2015, Aggressive behavior.

[62]  C. Hunt.  The Effect of an Education Program on Attitudes and Beliefs about Bullying and Bullying Behaviour in Junior Secondary School Students. , 2007, Child and adolescent mental health.

[63]  Claus Lamm,et al.  Meta-analytic evidence for common and distinct neural networks associated with directly experienced pain and empathy for pain , 2011, NeuroImage.

[64]  R. Ortega-Ruiz,et al.  Scientific research on bullying and cyberbullying: where have we been and where are we going , 2015 .

[65]  T. Pigott,et al.  A Meta-Analysis of School-Based Bullying Prevention Programs' Effects on Bystander Intervention Behavior , 2012 .

[66]  D. Farrington,et al.  Examining the relationship between low empathy and bullying , 2006 .

[67]  R. Loeber,et al.  The clinical utility of the proposed DSM-5 callous-unemotional subtype of conduct disorder in young girls. , 2012, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[68]  N. Crick,et al.  Children's treatment by peers: Victims of relational and overt aggression , 1996, Development and Psychopathology.

[69]  Maria Hughes,et al.  A two-method investigation of early adolescents' responses upon witnessing peer victimization in school. , 2012, Journal of adolescence.

[70]  David B. Wilson.  Missing a critical piece of the pie: simple document search strategies inadequate for systematic reviews , 2009 .

[71]  Amanda B. Nickerson,et al.  Attachment and empathy as predictors of roles as defenders or outsiders in bullying interactions. , 2008, Journal of school psychology.

[72]  P. Frick,et al.  Gender differences in the assessment, stability, and correlates to bullying roles in middle school children. , 2011, Behavioral sciences & the law.

[73]  Chantal Gagnon.  Bullying in schools: The role of empathy, temperament, and emotion regulation , 2012 .

[74]  C. Salmivalli,et al.  Early Adolescents’ Participation in Bullying: Is ToM Involved? , 2010 .

[75]  Clayton R. Cook,et al.  Predictors of Bullying and Victimization in Childhood and Adolescence: A Meta-analytic Investigation , 2010 .

[76]  M. M. Ttofi,et al.  Adolescent bullying linked to depression in early adulthood , 2015, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[77]  G. Pugliese.  Social-Emotional Processing and Bullying Behaviour , 2014 .

[78]  Darrick Jolliffe,et al.  Is low empathy related to bullying after controlling for individual and social background variables? , 2011, Journal of adolescence.

[79]  R. Hare,et al.  Psychopathy as a clinical and empirical construct. , 2008, Annual review of clinical psychology.

[80]  Enrica Ciucci,et al.  The emotional core of bullying: Further evidences of the role of callous–unemotional traits and empathy , 2014 .

[81]  P. Frick,et al.  The incremental utility of callous-unemotional traits and conduct problems in predicting aggression and bullying in a community sample of boys and girls. , 2013, Psychological assessment.

[82]  D. Farrington,et al.  Effectiveness of school-based programs to reduce bullying: a systematic and meta-analytic review , 2011 .

[83]  Amy Zelidman.  Empathy As A Moderator Of Adolescent Bullying Behavior And Moral Disengagement After Controlling For Social Desirability , 2014 .

[84]  Gianmarco Altoè,et al.  Does empathy predict adolescents' bullying and defending behavior? , 2007, Aggressive behavior.

[85]  S. Georgiou,et al.  Bullying and empathy: a short‐term longitudinal investigation , 2010 .

[86]  D. Farrington,et al.  Development and validation of the Basic Empathy Scale. , 2006, Journal of adolescence.

[87]  Brenda K. Bryant,et al.  An Index of Empathy for Children and Adolescents. , 1982 .

[88]  M. Terwogt,et al.  IN PRESS: PERSONALITY AND INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES TITLE: Psychometric properties of the Emotion Awareness Questionnaire for children AUTHORS: , 2009 .

[89]  P. Qualter,et al.  Empathy and Bullying: Exploring the Influence of Callous-Unemotional Traits , 2011, Child psychiatry and human development.

[90]  Con Stough,et al.  Emotional intelligence, victimisation, bullying behaviours and attitudes , 2014 .

[91]  D. Espelage,et al.  Exploring the Relation Between Bullying and Homophobic Verbal Content: The Homophobic Content Agent Target (HCAT) Scale , 2005, Violence and Victims.

[92]  Gianluca Gini,et al.  Bullied Children and Psychosomatic Problems: A Meta-analysis , 2013, Pediatrics.

[93]  K. Bussey,et al.  Predictors of student defenders of peer aggression victims: Empathy and social cognitive factors , 2011 .

[94]  L. Gano-Overway.  Exploring the Connections Between Caring and Social Behaviors in Physical Education , 2013, Research quarterly for exercise and sport.

[95]  Nancy Eisenberg,et al.  Empathy and its measurement. , 2003 .