Palliative sedation: ethics in clinical practice guidelines – systematic review

Objectives The objective of our study was to determine whether, and to what degree, the ethical dimension was present in clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) on palliative sedation, and to identify the ethical issues with respect to the different forms of this practice. The purpose was purely to be descriptive; our aim was not to make any kind of normative judgements on these ethical issues or to develop our own ethical recommendations. Methods We performed a systematic review of CPGs on the palliative sedation of adults, focusing our analysis on the ethical dimension of these texts and the ethical issues of this practice. The study protocol is registered on PROSPERO. Results In total, 36 current CPGs from four continents (and 14 countries) were included in our analysis. Generally, ethics was rarely referred to or absent from the CPGs. Only six texts contained a specific section explicitly related to ethics. Ethical issues were named, conceptualised and presented in heterogeneous, often confusing ways. It was impossible to identify the ethical issues of each form of palliative sedation. Ethics expertise was not involved in the development of most of the CPGs and, if it was, this did not always correlate with the ethical dimension of the document. Conclusions Effective cooperation between palliative care clinicians and ethicists should be encouraged, in order to integrate in particular the crucial ethical issues of continuous deep sedation until death when developing or updating CPGs on palliative sedation.

[1]  R. Jox,et al.  Clinical Practice Guidelines on Palliative Sedation Around the World: A Systematic Review. , 2022, Journal of palliative care.

[2]  J. Menten,et al.  Review of European Guidelines on Palliative Sedation: A Foundation for the Updating of the European Association for Palliative Care Framework. , 2022, Journal of palliative medicine.

[3]  R. Jox,et al.  Ethical challenges in palliative sedation of adults: protocol for a systematic review of current clinical practice guidelines , 2021, BMJ Open.

[4]  Martyna Tomczyk,et al.  [Current status of clinical practice guidelines on palliative sedation for adults in French-speaking countries]. , 2021, Bulletin du cancer.

[5]  R. Huxtable,et al.  Real-world ethics in palliative care: A systematic review of the ethical challenges reported by specialist palliative care practitioners in their clinical practice , 2020, Palliative medicine.

[6]  E. Mayo-Wilson,et al.  The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews , 2020, BMJ.

[7]  T. Morita,et al.  The Principles of Revised Clinical Guidelines about Palliative Sedation Therapy of the Japanese Society for Palliative Medicine. , 2020, Journal of palliative medicine.

[8]  R. Mirza,et al.  The Use of Palliative Sedation to Treat Existential Suffering: A Scoping Review on Practices, Ethical Considerations, and Guidelines , 2020, Journal of palliative care.

[9]  J. Menten,et al.  Physicians’ perceptions of palliative sedation for existential suffering: a systematic review , 2019, BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care.

[10]  R. Twycross Reflections on palliative sedation , 2019, Palliative care.

[11]  M. Tomczyk,et al.  Informer sur la sédation continue maintenue jusqu’au décès, en France et en Pologne : quel impact des contextes nationaux sur le contenu de l’information médicale destinée au patient ? , 2018, Ethics, Medicine and Public Health.

[12]  C. Gastmans,et al.  Palliative Sedation for Existential Suffering: A Systematic Review of Argument-Based Ethics Literature. , 2018, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[13]  D. Strech,et al.  Ethical issues in obesity prevention for school children: a systematic qualitative review , 2017, International Journal of Public Health.

[14]  R. Twycross Regarding Palliative Sedation. , 2017, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[15]  L. Deliens,et al.  International variations in clinical practice guidelines for palliative sedation: a systematic review , 2017, BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care.

[16]  R. Likar,et al.  [Austrian guideline for palliative sedation therapy (long version) : Results of a Delphi process of the Austrian Palliative Society (OPG)]. , 2017, Wiener medizinische Wochenschrift.

[17]  B. Henry A systematic literature review on the ethics of palliative sedation: an update (2016) , 2016, Current opinion in supportive and palliative care.

[18]  J. Jacobs,et al.  Palliative Sedation at the End of Life , 2016, The American journal of hospice & palliative care.

[19]  J. V. van Delden,et al.  What do international ethics guidelines say in terms of the scope of medical research ethics? , 2016, BMC medical ethics.

[20]  C. Seale,et al.  The language of sedation in end-of-life care: The ethical reasoning of care providers in three countries , 2015, Health.

[21]  D. Strech,et al.  Systematic and transparent inclusion of ethical issues and recommendations in clinical practice guidelines: a six-step approach , 2014, Implementation Science.

[22]  L. Morin,et al.  Sédation pour détresse en phase terminale : guide d’aide à la décision , 2014 .

[23]  S. Brearley,et al.  Current debates on end-of-life sedation: an international expert elicitation study , 2014, Supportive Care in Cancer.

[24]  S. Brearley,et al.  From sedation to continuous sedation until death: how has the conceptual basis of sedation in end-of-life care changed over time? , 2013, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[25]  L. Deliens,et al.  Similarities and differences between continuous sedation until death and euthanasia – professional caregivers’ attitudes and experiences: A focus group study , 2013, Palliative medicine.

[26]  B. Henry,et al.  Framework for continuous palliative sedation therapy in Canada. , 2012, Journal of palliative medicine.

[27]  J. V. van Delden,et al.  Continuous palliative sedation for cancer and noncancer patients. , 2012, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[28]  L. Deliens,et al.  The labelling and reporting of euthanasia by Belgian physicians: a study of hypothetical cases. , 2012, European journal of public health.

[29]  A. Kon Palliative Sedation: It's Not a Panacea , 2011, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[30]  B. Broeckaert Palliative Sedation, Physician-Assisted Suicide, and Euthanasia: “Same, Same but Different”? , 2011, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[31]  J. Verheijde,et al.  Continuous Deep Sedation Until Death: Palliation or Physician-Assisted Death? , 2010, The American journal of hospice & palliative care.

[32]  M. Viallard,et al.  Sédation en médecine palliative : recommandations chez l’adulte et spécificités au domicile et en gériatrie , 2010 .

[33]  M. Viallard,et al.  La sédation pour détresse chez l’adulte dans des situations spécifiques et complexes , 2010 .

[34]  L. Radbruch,et al.  Sedierung in der Palliativmedizin – Leitlinie1 für den Einsatz sedierender Maßnahmen in der Palliativversorgung , 2010 .

[35]  C. Campbell,et al.  Palliative sedation therapy. , 2009, British journal of hospital medicine.

[36]  E. Sloan,et al.  North , 2006, Canadian Medical Association Journal.

[37]  F. De Conno,et al.  Symptom Prevalence and Control during Cancer Patients’ Last Days of Life , 1990, Journal of palliative care.

[38]  R. Rawbone,et al.  Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 7th Edition , 2015 .

[39]  E. Schildmann,et al.  Palliative sedation therapy: a systematic literature review and critical appraisal of available guidance on indication and decision making. , 2014, Journal of palliative medicine.

[40]  H. Ten Have,et al.  Palliative sedation versus euthanasia: an ethical assessment. , 2014, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[41]  P. K. Aspaas Safe care. , 2007, South Dakota medicine : the journal of the South Dakota State Medical Association.

[42]  R. Hartenstein Deutsche Gesellschaft für Palliativmedizin , 1995 .