Development of the error-monitoring system from ages 9–35: Unique insight provided by MRI-constrained source localization of EEG

&NA; The ability to self‐detect errors and dynamically adapt behavior is a cornerstone of higher‐level cognition, requiring coordinated activity from a network of neural regions. However, disagreement exists over how the error‐monitoring system develops throughout adolescence and early adulthood. The present report leveraged MRI‐constrained EEG source localization to detail typical development of the error‐monitoring system in a sample of 9–35 year‐olds (n = 43). Participants performed a flanker task while high‐density EEG was recorded; structural MRIs were also acquired for all participants. Analysis of the scalp‐recorded EEG data revealed a frontocentral negativity (error‐related negativity; ERN) immediately following errors for all participants, although the topography of the ERN varied with age. Source localization of the ERN time range revealed maximal activity within the posterior cingulate cortex (PCC) for all ages, consistent with recent evidence that the PCC provides a substantial contribution to the scalp‐recorded ERN. Activity within a network of brain regions, including dorsal anterior cingulate, PCC, and parietal cortex, was predictive of improved performance following errors, regardless of age. However, additional activity within insula, orbitofrontal cortex and inferior frontal gyrus linearly increased with age. Together, these data suggest that the core error‐monitoring system is online by early adolescence and remains relatively stable into adulthood. However, additional brain regions become embedded within this core network with age. These results serve as a model of typical development of the error‐monitoring system from early adolescence into adulthood. HighlightsERN topography and source activity changed as a function of age (9–35 years).Two primary clusters of neural activity found to give rise to the ERN.Dorsal cluster stable across age, ventral‐frontal cluster increased with age.Dorsal cluster (including posterior cingulate) predicted control after errors.Data serve as model of typical error‐monitoring development.

[1]  Steven G. Luke,et al.  Co-registration of eye movements and event-related potentials in connected-text paragraph reading , 2013, Front. Syst. Neurosci..

[2]  T. B. Üstün,et al.  Age of onset of mental disorders: a review of recent literature , 2007, Current opinion in psychiatry.

[3]  W. Gehring,et al.  Action-Monitoring Dysfunction in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder , 2000, Psychological science.

[4]  S. Petersen,et al.  Development of distinct control networks through segregation and integration , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[5]  Tim P. Moran,et al.  On the relationship between anxiety and error monitoring: a meta-analysis and conceptual framework , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[6]  S. Blakemore,et al.  Development of the adolescent brain: implications for executive function and social cognition. , 2006 .

[7]  Joshua W. Brown,et al.  Performance Monitoring by the Anterior Cingulate Cortex During Saccade Countermanding , 2003, Science.

[8]  Thomas R. Knösche,et al.  A guideline for head volume conductor modeling in EEG and MEG , 2014, NeuroImage.

[9]  D. Pine,et al.  The risk for early-adulthood anxiety and depressive disorders in adolescents with anxiety and depressive disorders. , 1998, Archives of general psychiatry.

[10]  Alexander Hammers,et al.  Three‐dimensional maximum probability atlas of the human brain, with particular reference to the temporal lobe , 2003, Human brain mapping.

[11]  M. Botvinick,et al.  Conflict monitoring and cognitive control. , 2001, Psychological review.

[12]  Robert Oostenveld,et al.  FieldTrip: Open Source Software for Advanced Analysis of MEG, EEG, and Invasive Electrophysiological Data , 2010, Comput. Intell. Neurosci..

[13]  Moritz Grosse-Wentrup,et al.  Multisubject Learning for Common Spatial Patterns in Motor-Imagery BCI , 2011, Comput. Intell. Neurosci..

[14]  M. Kringelbach.  The human orbitofrontal cortex: linking reward to hedonic experience , 2005, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[15]  John E. Richards,et al.  Evaluating Methods for Constructing Average High-Density Electrode Positions , 2014, Brain Topography.

[16]  Tom Eichele,et al.  Posterior Medial Frontal Cortex Activity Predicts Post-Error Adaptations in Task-Related Visual and Motor Areas , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[17]  Roberto D. Pascual-Marqui,et al.  Discrete, 3D distributed, linear imaging methods of electric neuronal activity. Part 1: exact, zero error localization , 2007, 0710.3341.

[18]  N. Ryan,et al.  Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Age Children-Present and Lifetime Version (K-SADS-PL): initial reliability and validity data. , 1997, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[19]  Sidney J Segalowitz,et al.  Development of Response-Monitoring ERPs in 7- to 25-Year-Olds , 2004, Developmental neuropsychology.

[20]  D. Meyer,et al.  A Neural System for Error Detection and Compensation , 1993 .

[21]  W. Gehring,et al.  Altered relationship between electrophysiological response to errors and gray matter volumes in an extended network for error‐processing in pediatric obsessive‐compulsive disorder , 2014, Human brain mapping.

[22]  N. Yeung,et al.  On the ERN and the significance of errors. , 2005, Psychophysiology.

[23]  Marco Steinhauser,et al.  Error-related brain activity and adjustments of selective attention following errors , 2011, NeuroImage.

[24]  M. Schoenfeld,et al.  Temporal dynamics of reward processing revealed by magnetoencephalography , 2011, Human brain mapping.

[25]  Vince D. Calhoun,et al.  Neuroimaging measures of error-processing: Extracting reliable signals from event-related potentials and functional magnetic resonance imaging , 2016, NeuroImage.

[26]  A. Mognon,et al.  ADJUST: An automatic EEG artifact detector based on the joint use of spatial and temporal features. , 2011, Psychophysiology.

[27]  Daniel M. Roberts,et al.  Uncertainty-dependent activity within the ventral striatum predicts task-related changes in response strategy , 2016, Cognitive, affective & behavioral neuroscience.

[28]  Miguel Á. Carreira-Perpiñán,et al.  Non-rigid point set registration: Coherent Point Drift , 2006, NIPS.

[29]  R. Kotov,et al.  Error-related negativity (ERN) and sustained threat: Conceptual framework and empirical evaluation in an adolescent sample. , 2016, Psychophysiology.

[30]  N. Makris,et al.  Multimodal neuroimaging dissociates hemodynamic and electrophysiological correlates of error processing , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[31]  Y. Benjamini,et al.  Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing , 1995 .

[32]  T. Robbins,et al.  Inhibition and the right inferior frontal cortex , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[33]  Kyungmin Su,et al.  The PREP pipeline: standardized preprocessing for large-scale EEG analysis , 2015, Front. Neuroinform..

[34]  A. Damasio,et al.  Emotion, decision making and the orbitofrontal cortex. , 2000, Cerebral cortex.

[35]  E. Procyk,et al.  Anterior cingulate error‐related activity is modulated by predicted reward , 2005, The European journal of neuroscience.

[36]  Thomas R. Knösche,et al.  Influence of the head model on EEG and MEG source connectivity analyses , 2015, NeuroImage.

[37]  C. Eriksen,et al.  Effects of noise letters upon the identification of a target letter in a nonsearch task , 1974 .

[38]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Dorsal anterior cingulate cortex shows fMRI response to internal and external error signals , 2004, Nature Neuroscience.

[39]  W. Gehring,et al.  Neural Systems for Error Monitoring , 2007, The Neuroscientist : a review journal bringing neurobiology, neurology and psychiatry.

[40]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  Anterior Cingulate Conflict Monitoring and Adjustments in Control , 2004, Science.

[41]  Joshua W. Brown,et al.  Medial prefrontal cortex as an action-outcome predictor , 2011, Nature Neuroscience.

[42]  Katherine R. Luking,et al.  Orbitofrontal cortex activity and connectivity predict future depression symptoms in adolescence. , 2017, Biological psychiatry. Cognitive neuroscience and neuroimaging.

[43]  A. Toga,et al.  Localizing Age-Related Changes in Brain Structure between Childhood and Adolescence Using Statistical Parametric Mapping , 1999, NeuroImage.

[44]  M. Murray,et al.  EEG source imaging , 2004, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[45]  Cameron S Carter,et al.  Development of action monitoring through adolescence into adulthood: ERP and source localization. , 2007, Developmental science.

[46]  Marina Schmid,et al.  An Introduction To The Event Related Potential Technique , 2016 .

[47]  John E. Richards,et al.  A database of age-appropriate average MRI templates , 2016, NeuroImage.

[48]  B. Luna,et al.  What has fMRI told us about the Development of Cognitive Control through Adolescence? , 2010, Brain and Cognition.

[49]  K. Merikangas,et al.  Lifetime prevalence of mental disorders in U.S. adolescents: results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication--Adolescent Supplement (NCS-A). , 2010, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.

[50]  L. Somerville,et al.  Developmental neurobiology of cognitive control and motivational systems , 2010, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[51]  V. Menon,et al.  Saliency, switching, attention and control: a network model of insula function , 2010, Brain Structure and Function.

[52]  Jonathan D. Power,et al.  Functional Brain Networks Develop from a “Local to Distributed” Organization , 2009, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[53]  Thomas F. Nugent,et al.  Dynamic mapping of human cortical development during childhood through early adulthood. , 2004, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[54]  Eveline A. Crone,et al.  Neuroimaging in Developmental Clinical Neuroscience: Neural correlates of the development of cognitive control , 2009 .

[55]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. , 2002, Psychological review.

[56]  N. Fox,et al.  A History of Childhood Behavioral Inhibition and Enhanced Response Monitoring in Adolescence Are Linked to Clinical Anxiety , 2009, Biological Psychiatry.

[57]  Franziska M. Korb,et al.  Post-Error Behavioral Adjustments Are Facilitated by Activation and Suppression of Task-Relevant and Task-Irrelevant Information Processing , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[58]  Arthur W. Toga,et al.  Construction of a 3D probabilistic atlas of human cortical structures , 2008, NeuroImage.

[59]  M. Ullsperger,et al.  Neurophysiology of performance monitoring and adaptive behavior. , 2014, Physiological reviews.

[60]  C. Patrick,et al.  Externalizing Psychopathology and the Error-Related Negativity , 2007, Psychological science.

[61]  Atle Bjørnerud,et al.  Error-related negativity is mediated by fractional anisotropy in the posterior cingulate gyrus--a study combining diffusion tensor imaging and electrophysiology in healthy adults. , 2009, Cerebral cortex.

[62]  William J. Gehring,et al.  The Error-Related Negativity (ERN/Ne) , 2011 .

[63]  C. Carter,et al.  Error Detection, Correction, and Prevention in the Brain: A Brief Review of Data and Theories , 2006, Clinical EEG and neuroscience.

[64]  H. Critchley,et al.  Neural systems supporting interoceptive awareness , 2004, Nature Neuroscience.

[65]  John E Richards,et al.  Cortical Source Localization of Infant Cognition , 2009, Developmental neuropsychology.

[66]  J. Richards,et al.  Stereotaxic Magnetic Resonance Imaging Brain Atlases for Infants from 3 to 12 Months , 2015, Developmental Neuroscience.

[67]  A. Toga,et al.  In vivo evidence for post-adolescent brain maturation in frontal and striatal regions , 1999, Nature Neuroscience.

[68]  Charles H Hillman,et al.  On the number of trials necessary for stabilization of error-related brain activity across the life span. , 2010, Psychophysiology.

[69]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  Conflict monitoring and anterior cingulate cortex: an update , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[70]  Arnaud Delorme,et al.  EEGLAB: an open source toolbox for analysis of single-trial EEG dynamics including independent component analysis , 2004, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[71]  G. Hajcak,et al.  The error-related negativity (ERN) and psychopathology: toward an endophenotype. , 2008, Clinical psychology review.

[72]  R. Knight,et al.  Prefrontal–cingulate interactions in action monitoring , 2000, Nature Neuroscience.

[73]  Karen J. Mathewson,et al.  Brain bases of error-related ERPs as influenced by age and task , 2005, Biological Psychology.

[74]  M. Botvinick,et al.  Anterior cingulate cortex, error detection, and the online monitoring of performance. , 1998, Science.

[75]  Daniel Rueckert,et al.  Automatic anatomical brain MRI segmentation combining label propagation and decision fusion , 2006, NeuroImage.

[76]  John E. Richards,et al.  Cortical sources of ERP in prosaccade and antisaccade eye movements using realistic source models , 2013, Front. Syst. Neurosci..

[77]  K. Walhovd,et al.  Performance monitoring in children and adolescents: A review of developmental changes in the error-related negativity and brain maturation , 2013, Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.

[78]  J. Stockman.  Lifetime Prevalence of Mental Disorders in U.S. Adolescents: Results from the National Comorbidity Survey Replication–Adolescent Supplement (NCS-A) , 2012 .

[79]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  The Expected Value of Control: An Integrative Theory of Anterior Cingulate Cortex Function , 2013, Neuron.

[80]  Andriy Myronenko,et al.  Point Set Registration: Coherent Point Drift , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence.

[81]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Motivation of extended behaviors by anterior cingulate cortex , 2012, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[82]  F. Vargha-Khadem,et al.  Maturation of action monitoring from adolescence to adulthood: an ERP study. , 2005, Developmental science.

[83]  L. Westlye,et al.  Brain maturation in adolescence and young adulthood: regional age-related changes in cortical thickness and white matter volume and microstructure. , 2010, Cerebral cortex.

[84]  S. Segalowitz,et al.  Developmental differences in error-related ERPs in middle- to late-adolescent males. , 2008, Developmental psychology.

[85]  Rolando J. Biscay-Lirio,et al.  Assessing interactions in the brain with exact low-resolution electromagnetic tomography , 2011, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

[86]  G. Glover,et al.  Dissociable Intrinsic Connectivity Networks for Salience Processing and Executive Control , 2007, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[87]  A. Turken,et al.  Left inferior frontal gyrus is critical for response inhibition , 2008, BMC Neuroscience.

[88]  Wanze Xie,et al.  Brains for all the ages: structural neurodevelopment in infants and children from a life-span perspective. , 2015, Advances in child development and behavior.