A frequent assumption of proficiency tests for nonnative speakers of a language is that they measure something that native speakers are able to do uniformly well. The cloze procedure is increasingly used to construct proficiency tests for administration to nonnative speakers of English. However, little evidence is available on the question of whether cloze tests are capable of making fine distinctions between native and nonnative speakers. The paper reports on a study comparing the performances of native speakers of English with those of nonnative speakers, on a number of cloze tests constructed by manipulating variables in cloze test design. It is shown that native and nonnative speakers perform similarly on cloze tests with respect to these variables. The results are related to the claim that cloze tests (as distinct from cloze items) measure essentially lower-order language skills, and it is suggested that the notion of language proficiency needs to be revised. This has major implications for the construction and validation of language tests.
[1]
John W. Oller,et al.
CLOZE, DICTATION, AND THE TEST OF ENGLISH AS A FOREIGN LANGUAGE
,
1974
.
[2]
John W. Oller,et al.
A Cloze Test of English Prepositions.
,
1971
.
[3]
D. Oller.
SIMPLIFICATION AS THE GOAL OF PHONOLOGICAL PROCESSES IN CHILD SPEECH1
,
1974
.
[4]
G. Richard Tucker,et al.
The Cloze Test as a Measure of English Proficiency
,
1974
.
[5]
John W. Oller,et al.
CLOZE TESTS IN ENGLISH, THAI, AND VIETNAMESE: NATIVE AND NON‐NATIVE PERFORMANCE
,
1972
.
[6]
J. Alderson.
THE CLOZE PROCEDURE AND PROFICIENCY IN ENGLISH AS A FOREIGN LANGUAGE
,
1979
.
[7]
A Comparison of Scores Earned on the Test of English as a Foreign Language by Native American College Students and Foreign Applicants to U.S. Colleges.
,
1971
.
[8]
J. Oller,et al.
WHEN ARE CLOZE ITEMS SENSITIVE TO CONSTRAINTS ACROSS SENTENCES
,
1977
.
[9]
John W. Oller,et al.
The Cloze Technique and ESL Proficiency.
,
1971
.
[10]
A Look at Cloze Testing across Languages and Levels.
,
1978
.
[11]
J. Charles Alderson,et al.
The effect on the doze test of changes in deletion frequency
,
1979
.