Validation of analytical methods for the detection of beeswax adulteration with a focus on paraffin

Abstract Beeswax adulteration in the apiculture sector represents a growing problem worldwide due to the lack of clearly defined purity criteria, the absence of official quality (authenticity) controls, and the inconsistency of the analytical methods used for adulteration detection. Although beeswax authentication is implemented in other regulatory sectors (pharmaceutical and food industry), the classical physico-chemical analytical methods used for determination of beeswax purity exhibit inconsistencies for the detection of adulterants. In this study, an inventory was made on a comprehensive set of analytical methods and the corresponding purity criteria used for the detection of the most common beeswax adulterants (paraffin, stearin and/or stearic acid) from existing legislations and scientific literature. The selected analytical methods (classical physico-chemical, and advanced instrumental, i.e. chromatographic and spectroscopic analytical techniques) were weighted by three independent experts against two criteria: feasibility and analytical performance in detecting targeted adulterants. Classical methods for which measurement data were available (melting point and acid/saponification/ester values for paraffin-adulterated vs. non-adulterated beeswax samples) were retained and further validated by a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. These methods were also validated by generating the corresponding calibration curves for paraffin detection using paraffin-beeswax mixtures containing different proportions of paraffin (ranging from 5 to 95%, w/w). The results of the ROC analysis revealed that a tentative detection of paraffin in beeswax can be achieved by a combination of at least two physico-chemical methods. However, for a reliable detection of the most common adulterants in beeswax, physico-chemical methods should be complemented with advanced analytical tools. i.e. GC-MS, HTGC-FID (MS) and/or FTIR-ATR spectroscopy, depending on the expected adulterant.

[1]  I. Jerković,et al.  Influence of beeswax adulteration with paraffin on the composition and quality of honey determined by physico-chemical analyses, 1H NMR, FTIR-ATR and HS-SPME/GC-MS. , 2019, Food chemistry.

[2]  T. Szczęsna,et al.  Efficiency of GC-MS method in detection of beeswax adulterated with paraffin , 2016 .

[3]  S. Bogdanov.  Beeswax: quality issues today , 2004 .

[4]  A. P. Tulloch.  Beeswax: Composition and Analysis , 1980 .

[5]  A. Barros,et al.  A novel, direct, reagent-free method for the detection of beeswax adulteration by single-reflection attenuated total reflectance mid-infrared spectroscopy. , 2013, Talanta.

[6]  Jens P. Linge,et al.  A topic model approach to identify and track emerging risks from beeswax adulteration in the media , 2021 .

[7]  Tautz.  Honeybee waggle dance: recruitment success depends on the dance floor , 1996, The Journal of experimental biology.

[8]  J. S. Bonvehí,et al.  Detection of adulterated commercial Spanish beeswax , 2012 .

[9]  C. Kast,et al.  Distribution of coumaphos in beeswax after treatment of honeybee colonies with CheckMite® against the parasitical mite Varroa destructor , 2019, Apidologie.

[10]  R. Colombo,et al.  A 10 year survey of acaricide residues in beeswax analysed in Italy. , 2016, Pest management science.

[11]  F. J. Orantes-Bermejo,et al.  Pesticide residues in beeswax and beebread samples collected from honey bee colonies (Apis mellifera L.) in Spain. Possible implications for bee losses , 2010 .

[12]  H. Hepburn.  Reciprocal interactions between honeybees and combs in the integration of some colony functions in Apis mellifera L. , 1998 .

[13]  S. Zeggane,et al.  An assessment of honeybee colony matrices, Apis mellifera (Hymenoptera: Apidae) to monitor pesticide presence in continental France , 2011, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[14]  Sandeman,et al.  Transmission of vibration across honeycombs and its detection by bee leg receptors , 1996, The Journal of experimental biology.

[15]  Risk assessment of beeswax adulterated with paraffin and/or stearin/stearic acid when used in apiculture and as food (honeycomb) , 2020, EFSA Supporting Publications.

[16]  T. Szczęsna,et al.  Application of Gas Chromatography with the Mass Detector (GC-MS) Technique for Detection of Beeswax Adulteration with Paraffin , 2015 .

[17]  W. Kirchner.  Vibrational signals in the tremble dance of the honeybee, Apis mellifera , 1993, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology.

[18]  J. S. Bonvehí,et al.  Discoloration and Adsorption of Acaricides from Beeswax , 2017 .

[19]  J. Humphrey,et al.  Thermal energy conduction in a honey bee comb due to cell-heating bees. , 2008, Journal of theoretical biology.

[20]  A. P. Tulloch,et al.  Canadian beeswax: Analytical values and composition of hydrocarbons, free acids and long chain esters , 1972 .

[21]  A. P. Tulloch.  Factors affecting analytical values of beeswax and detection of adulteration , 1973 .

[22]  J. Bernal,et al.  Identification of adulterants added to beeswax: Estimation of detectable minimum percentages , 2009 .

[23]  J. Faucon,et al.  Pesticide residues in beeswax samples collected from honey bee colonies (Apis mellifera L.) in France. , 2007, Pest management science.

[24]  J. Quiles,et al.  Industrial-Scale Decontamination Procedure Effects on the Content of Acaricides, Heavy Metals and Antioxidant Capacity of Beeswax , 2019, Molecules.

[25]  D. Titěra,et al.  Analysis of beeswax adulteration with paraffin using GC/MS, FTIR-ATR and Raman spectroscopy , 2021 .

[26]  K. Voorhees,et al.  Principal component analysis of the pyrolysis-mass spectra from African, Africanized hybrid, and European beeswax , 1995 .

[27]  Jürgen Tautz,et al.  Honeybees establish specific sites on the comb for their waggle dances , 1997, Journal of Comparative Physiology A.

[28]  R. Krell,et al.  Value-added products from beekeeping , 1996 .

[29]  F. Saucy,et al.  Standard methods for Apis mellifera beeswax research , 2019, Journal of Apicultural Research.

[30]  M. Breed,et al.  Interfamily variation in comb wax hydrocarbons produced by honey bees , 1995, Journal of Chemical Ecology.

[31]  T. Wenseleers,et al.  Wax combs mediate nestmate recognition by guard honeybees , 2006, Animal Behaviour.

[32]  I. Tlak Gajger,et al.  An Approach for Routine Analytical Detection of Beeswax Adulteration Using FTIR-ATR Spectroscopy , 2015 .

[33]  D. D. de Graaf,et al.  Pesticides for Apicultural and/or Agricultural Application Found in Belgian Honey Bee Wax Combs , 2015, Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology.

[34]  T. Szczęsna,et al.  Hydrocarbon Composition of Beeswax (Apis Mellifera) Collected from Light and Dark Coloured Combs , 2014 .

[35]  M. Maia,et al.  Authentication of beeswax (Apis mellifera) by high-temperature gas chromatography and chemometric analysis. , 2013, Food chemistry.

[36]  E. Crane.  Bees and Beekeeping: Science Practice and World Resources , 1990 .

[37]  J. Tautz,et al.  Comb-wax discrimination by honeybees tested with the proboscis extension reflex. , 2000, The Journal of experimental biology.

[38]  K. Wallner.  Varroacides and their residues in bee products , 1999 .

[39]  C. Saegerman,et al.  Residues in Beeswax: A Health Risk for the Consumer of Honey and Beeswax? , 2016, Journal of agricultural and food chemistry.

[40]  Marco Lodesani,et al.  The Status of Honey Bee Health in Italy: Results from the Nationwide Bee Monitoring Network , 2016, PloS one.

[41]  M. Breed,et al.  The role of wax comb in honey bee nestmate recognition , 1995, Animal Behaviour.

[42]  B. Lichtenberg-Kraag,et al.  Identification and Quantification of Single and Multi‐Adulteration of Beeswax by FTIR‐ATR Spectroscopy , 2019 .

[43]  J. Bernal,et al.  Physico‐chemical parameters for the characterization of pure beeswax and detection of adulterations , 2005 .

[44]  S. Nicolson,et al.  Brood comb as a humidity buffer in honeybee nests , 2010, Naturwissenschaften.