Integrating Novel Data Streams to Support Biosurveillance in Commercial Livestock Production Systems in Developed Countries: Challenges and Opportunities

Reducing the burden of emerging and endemic infectious diseases on commercial livestock production systems will require the development of innovative technology platforms that enable information from diverse animal health resources to be collected, analyzed, and communicated in near real-time. In this paper, we review recent initiatives to leverage data routinely observed by farmers, production managers, veterinary practitioners, diagnostic laboratories, regulatory officials, and slaughterhouse inspectors for disease surveillance purposes. The most commonly identified challenges were (1) the lack of standardized systems for recording essential data elements within and between surveillance data streams, (2) the additional time required to collect data elements that are not routinely recorded by participants, (3) the concern over the sharing and use of business sensitive information with regulatory authorities and other data analysts, (4) the difficulty in developing sustainable incentives to maintain long-term program participation, and (5) the limitations in current methods for analyzing and reporting animal health information in a manner that facilitates actionable response. With the significant recent advances in information science, there are many opportunities to develop more sophisticated systems that meet national disease surveillance objectives, while still providing participants with valuable tools and feedback to manage routine animal health concerns.

[1]  M. Nielen,et al.  The British pig health schemes: integrated systems for large-scale pig abattoir lesion monitoring , 2011, Veterinary Record.

[2]  M. Vernon,et al.  Demographics of cattle movements in the United Kingdom , 2011, BMC veterinary research.

[3]  D. Pearl,et al.  Patterns of condemnation rates in swine from a federally inspected abattoir in relation to disease outbreak information in Ontario (2005-2007). , 2011, The Canadian veterinary journal = La revue veterinaire canadienne.

[4]  Daniel A. Grear,et al.  A national-scale picture of U.S. cattle movements obtained from Interstate Certificate of Veterinary Inspection data. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[5]  Paul H. Garthwaite,et al.  Statistical methods for the prospective detection of infectious disease outbreaks: a review , 2012 .

[6]  F. Natale,et al.  Network analysis of Italian cattle trade patterns and evaluation of risks for potential disease spread. , 2009, Preventive Veterinary Medicine.

[7]  L. Audigé,et al.  Monitoring and surveillance for rare health-related events: a review from the veterinary perspective. , 2001, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[8]  F. Conraths,et al.  ‘Schmallenberg virus’ – a novel orthobunyavirus emerging in Europe , 2012, Epidemiology and Infection.

[9]  R. Dias,et al.  Time series evaluation of traumatic lesions and airsacculitis at one poultry abattoir in the state of São Paulo, Brazil (1996-2005). , 2010, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[11]  K. Zurbrigg,et al.  Factors associated with good compliance and long-term sustainability in a practitioner-based livestock disease surveillance system. , 2013, The Canadian veterinary journal = La revue veterinaire canadienne.

[12]  Bart Sonck,et al.  Range measurements of a High Frequency Radio Frequency Identification (HF RFID) system for registering feeding patterns of growing-finishing pigs , 2014 .

[13]  J. A. Lines,et al.  A review of livestock monitoring and the need for integrated systems , 1997 .

[14]  K. P. Waller,et al.  Risk factors associated with the incidence of veterinary-treated clinical mastitis in Swedish dairy herds with a high milk yield and a low prevalence of subclinical mastitis. , 2007, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[15]  D. Pearl,et al.  Comparison of disease trends in the Ontario swine population using active practitioner-based surveillance and passive laboratory-based surveillance (2007-2009). , 2013, The Canadian veterinary journal = La revue veterinaire canadienne.

[16]  W. Epperson,et al.  Farm animal practitioners' views on their use and expectations of veterinary diagnostic laboratories , 2013, Veterinary Record.

[17]  O. Østerås,et al.  Completeness of metabolic disease recordings in Nordic national databases for dairy cows. , 2012, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[18]  Ynte H Schukken,et al.  Management factors associated with veterinary usage by organic and conventional dairy farms. , 2013, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.

[19]  R. Christley,et al.  Exploring the role of auction markets in cattle movements within Great Britain. , 2007, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[20]  A. Vollman,et al.  A Focused Ethnographic Study of Sri Lankan Government Field Veterinarians’ Decision Making about Diagnostic Laboratory Submissions and Perceptions of Surveillance , 2012, PloS one.

[21]  A. Vollman,et al.  A Focused Ethnographic Study of Alberta Cattle Veterinarians’ Decision Making about Diagnostic Laboratory Submissions and Perceptions of Surveillance Programs , 2013, PloS one.

[22]  D. Calavas,et al.  Why do farmers and veterinarians not report all bovine abortions, as requested by the clinical brucellosis surveillance system in France? , 2014, BMC Veterinary Research.

[23]  A. Lindberg,et al.  Nordic dairy farmers' threshold for contacting a veterinarian and consequences for disease recording: mild clinical mastitis as an example. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[24]  T. Carpenter,et al.  A flock-tailored early warning system for low pathogenic avian influenza (LPAI) in commercial egg laying flocks. , 2009, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[25]  P R Tozer,et al.  Using activity and milk yield as predictors of fresh cow disorders. , 2004, Journal of dairy science.

[26]  Ryan S Miller,et al.  Assessment of paper interstate certificates of veterinary inspection used to support disease tracing in cattle. , 2013, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.

[27]  J. W. Wilesmith,et al.  Descriptive epidemiology of the 2001 foot-and-mouth disease epidemic in Great Britain: the first five months , 2001, Veterinary Record.

[28]  W. Mcnab,et al.  Factors associated with whole carcass condemnation rates in provincially-inspected abattoirs in Ontario 2001-2007: implications for food animal syndromic surveillance , 2010, BMC veterinary research.

[29]  D. Pearl,et al.  Suitability and limitations of portion-specific abattoir data as part of an early warning system for emerging diseases of swine in Ontario , 2012, BMC Veterinary Research.

[30]  Gertraud Regula,et al.  Concepts for risk-based surveillance in the field of veterinary medicine and veterinary public health: Review of current approaches , 2006, BMC Health Services Research.

[31]  D. Pearl,et al.  Describing antimicrobial use and reported treatment efficacy in Ontario swine using the Ontario swine veterinary-based Surveillance program , 2013, BMC Veterinary Research.

[32]  P. Paarlberg UPDATED ESTIMATED ECONOMIC WELFARE IMPACTS OF PORCINE EPIDEMIC DIARRHEA VIRUS (PEDV) , 2014 .

[33]  M. Vaarst,et al.  Farmers' choice of medical treatment of mastitis in Danish dairy herds based on qualitative research interviews. , 2002, Journal of dairy science.

[34]  M. Nöremark,et al.  Network analysis of cattle and pig movements in Sweden: measures relevant for disease control and risk based surveillance. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[35]  Ryan Hafen,et al.  Generating Synthetic Syndromic-Surveillance Data for Evaluating Visual-Analytics Techniques , 2009, IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications.

[36]  Kensuke Kawamura,et al.  Development of an automatic classification system for eating, ruminating and resting behavior of cattle using an accelerometer , 2008 .

[37]  T. Halasa,et al.  Temporal characterisation of the network of Danish cattle movements and its implication for disease control: 2000-2009. , 2013, Preventive Veterinary Medicine.

[38]  A Steiner,et al.  Data quality of animal health records on Swiss dairy farms , 2008, Veterinary Record.

[39]  Kenneth D Mandl,et al.  Privacy protection versus cluster detection in spatial epidemiology. , 2006, American journal of public health.

[40]  D. Pearl,et al.  Identifying an outbreak of a novel swine disease using test requests for porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome as a syndromic surveillance tool , 2012, BMC Veterinary Research.

[41]  J. Berezowski,et al.  A minimum data set of animal health laboratory data to allow for collation and analysis across jurisdictions for the purpose of surveillance. , 2012, Transboundary and emerging diseases.

[42]  Crawford W. Revie,et al.  Syndromic Surveillance Using Veterinary Laboratory Data: Algorithm Combination and Customization of Alerts , 2013, PloS one.

[43]  David L. Buckeridge,et al.  Outbreak detection through automated surveillance: A review of the determinants of detection , 2007, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[44]  G. Regula,et al.  Using a Herd Health Monitoring System in the Assessment of Welfare , 2001 .

[45]  H Hogeveen,et al.  Detection of clinical mastitis with sensor data from automatic milking systems is improved by using decision-tree induction. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[46]  Christl A. Donnelly,et al.  The Foot-and-Mouth Epidemic in Great Britain: Pattern of Spread and Impact of Interventions , 2001, Science.

[47]  E. Watson,et al.  Review of diagnostic laboratory submissions of adult cattle ‘found dead’ in England and Wales in 2004 , 2008, Veterinary Record.

[48]  Y. Gröhn,et al.  Partial condemnations of swine carcasses — a descriptive study of meat inspection findings at Southwestern Finland's Cooperative Slaughterhouse , 1994 .

[49]  A. Reingold,et al.  If syndromic surveillance is the answer, what is the question? , 2003, Biosecurity and bioterrorism : biodefense strategy, practice, and science.

[50]  C. Saegerman,et al.  Field veterinary survey on clinical and economic impact of Schmallenberg virus in Belgium. , 2014, Transboundary and emerging diseases.

[51]  J. B. Andersen,et al.  The Danish pig health scheme: Nation-wide computer-based abattoir surveillance and follow-up at the herd level , 1984 .

[52]  Peter L. Nuthall,et al.  Adoption of computer based information systems , 2006 .

[53]  Veterinary decision making in relation to metritis - a qualitative approach to understand the background for variation and bias in veterinary medical records , 2009, Acta veterinaria Scandinavica.

[54]  Anders Ringgaard Kristensen,et al.  A model for monitoring the condition of young pigs by their drinking behaviour , 2005 .

[55]  Andrew W. Moore,et al.  Algorithms for rapid outbreak detection: a research synthesis , 2005, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[56]  P. J. Kettlewell,et al.  An implantable radio-telemetry system for remote monitoring of heart rate and deep body temperature in poultry , 1997 .

[57]  T. Carpenter,et al.  An epidemiologic study of late-term abortions in dairy cattle in Denmark, July 2000-August 2003. , 2006, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[58]  Javier Sanchez,et al.  Veterinary syndromic surveillance: Current initiatives and potential for development. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[59]  M. Konschake,et al.  Trade communities and their spatial patterns in the German pork production network. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[60]  C Lupo,et al.  Feasibility of screening broiler chicken flocks for risk markers as an aid for meat inspection , 2009, Epidemiology and Infection.

[61]  M. Amaku,et al.  Detecting livestock production zones. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[62]  R Piccinini,et al.  Cough sound description in relation to respiratory diseases in dairy calves. , 2010, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[63]  M. Kulldorff,et al.  A Space–Time Permutation Scan Statistic for Disease Outbreak Detection , 2005, PLoS medicine.

[64]  M. Stevenson,et al.  Analysis of cattle movements in Argentina, 2005. , 2011, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[65]  J. Christensen,et al.  Pig health and production surveillance in Denmark: sampling design, data recording, and measures of disease frequency , 1994 .

[66]  Jean-Marie Aerts,et al.  Original papers: Real-time recognition of sick pig cough sounds , 2008 .

[67]  Charalampos Z. Patrikakis,et al.  A complete farm management system based on animal identification using RFID technology , 2010 .

[68]  Robert M Meyer,et al.  Abattoir surveillance: the U.S. experience. , 2006, Veterinary microbiology.

[69]  D M Weary,et al.  Prepartum behavior and dry matter intake identify dairy cows at risk for metritis. , 2007, Journal of dairy science.

[70]  P. V. van Rijn,et al.  Performance of clinical signs to detect bluetongue virus serotype 8 outbreaks in cattle and sheep during the 2006-epidemic in The Netherlands. , 2008, Veterinary microbiology.

[71]  R. W. Humphry,et al.  Associations between bovine viral diarrhoea virus (BVDV) seropositivity and performance indicators in beef suckler and dairy herds. , 2013, Veterinary journal.

[72]  M D Salman,et al.  Development of a syndromic surveillance system for detection of disease among livestock entering an auction market. , 2009, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association.

[73]  E. Morignat,et al.  Assessing the Mandatory Bovine Abortion Notification System in France Using Unilist Capture-Recapture Approach , 2013, PloS one.

[74]  Crawford W. Revie,et al.  Exploratory Analysis of Methods for Automated Classification of Laboratory Test Orders into Syndromic Groups in Veterinary Medicine , 2013, PloS one.

[75]  P. Dunlop,et al.  Early dissemination of foot-and-mouth disease virus through sheep marketing in February 2001 , 2003, Veterinary Record.

[77]  Elmer V. Bernstam,et al.  Toward a veterinary informatics research agenda: An analysis of the PubMed-indexed literature , 2007, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[78]  Validation of Nordic dairy cattle disease recording databases--completeness for locomotor disorders. , 2012, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[79]  A. Lindberg,et al.  Validation of a national disease recording system for dairy cattle against veterinary practice records. , 2010, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[80]  A. Cosby,et al.  Factors influencing diagnostic sample submission by food animal veterinarians in Mississippi. , 2012, Veterinaria italiana.

[81]  A. Lindberg,et al.  Herd and cow characteristics affecting the odds of veterinary treatment for disease – a multilevel analysis , 2009, Acta veterinaria Scandinavica.

[82]  Roger Poland,et al.  Detecting Emerging Diseases in Farm Animals through Clinical Observations , 2006, Emerging infectious diseases.

[83]  M. Coffey,et al.  Changes in feeding behavior as possible indicators for the automatic monitoring of health disorders in dairy cows. , 2008, Journal of dairy science.

[84]  C W Revie,et al.  Syndromic surveillance using laboratory test requests: a practical guide informed by experience with two systems. , 2014, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[85]  C. Dupuy,et al.  Inventory of veterinary syndromic surveillance initiatives in Europe (Triple-S project): current situation and perspectives. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[86]  J. Aerts,et al.  Cough sound analysis to identify respiratory infection in pigs , 2008 .

[87]  K A Weigel,et al.  Genetic selection for health traits using producer-recorded data. I. Incidence rates, heritability estimates, and sire breeding values. , 2004, Journal of dairy science.

[88]  Ruud B.M. Huirne,et al.  Quantifying Economic Benefits of Sow-Herd Management Information Systems Using Panel Data , 1995 .

[89]  M. Woolhouse,et al.  Impact of changes in cattle movement regulations on the risks of bovine tuberculosis for Scottish farms. , 2013, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[90]  Linda Hoinville,et al.  Use of spatiotemporal analysis of laboratory submission data to identify potential outbreaks of new or emerging diseases in cattle in Great Britain , 2011, BMC veterinary research.

[91]  Gregory F Cooper,et al.  Issues in applied statistics for public health bioterrorism surveillance using multiple data streams: research needs , 2007, Statistics in medicine.

[92]  Richard William Shephard,et al.  The development of a syndromic surveillance system for the extensive beef cattle producing regions of Australia , 2006 .

[93]  S. Viazzi,et al.  A novel method to automatically measure the feed intake of broiler chickens by sound technology , 2014 .

[94]  G. Koch,et al.  Within-Flock Mortality During the High-Pathogenicity Avian Influenza (H7N7) Epidemic in the Netherlands in 2003: Implications for an Early Detection System , 2007, Avian diseases.

[95]  W. Mcnab,et al.  Evaluation of a veterinary-based syndromic surveillance system implemented for swine. , 2010, Canadian journal of veterinary research = Revue canadienne de recherche veterinaire.

[96]  D. Pearl,et al.  The association between submission counts to a veterinary diagnostic laboratory and the economic and disease challenges of the Ontario swine industry from 1998 to 2009. , 2012, Preventive veterinary medicine.

[97]  C R Webb,et al.  Investigating the potential spread of infectious diseases of sheep via agricultural shows in Great Britain , 2005, Epidemiology and Infection.

[98]  D. Pearl,et al.  Exploring relationships between whole carcass condemnation abattoir data, non-disease factors and disease outbreaks in swine herds in Ontario (2001–2007) , 2014, BMC Research Notes.

[99]  Farrokh Alemi,et al.  Enhancing spatial detection accuracy for syndromic surveillance with street level incidence data , 2010, International journal of health geographics.

[100]  K. Schwartz,et al.  Emergence of Porcine epidemic diarrhea virus in the United States: clinical signs, lesions, and viral genomic sequences , 2013, Journal of veterinary diagnostic investigation : official publication of the American Association of Veterinary Laboratory Diagnosticians, Inc.

[101]  Christian Ducrot,et al.  Defining syndromes using cattle meat inspection data for syndromic surveillance purposes: a statistical approach with the 2005–2010 data from ten French slaughterhouses , 2013, BMC Veterinary Research.

[102]  A J C Cook,et al.  Use of laboratory data to reduce the time taken to detect new diseases: vida to FarmFile , 2008, Veterinary Record.

[103]  William B. Lober,et al.  Review Paper: Implementing Syndromic Surveillance: A Practical Guide Informed by the Early Experience , 2003, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[104]  Marcello Pagano,et al.  Effect of spatial resolution on cluster detection: a simulation study , 2007, International journal of health geographics.

[105]  B. Dufour,et al.  Vulnerability of animal trade networks to the spread of infectious diseases: a methodological approach applied to evaluation and emergency control strategies in cattle, France, 2005. , 2011, Transboundary and emerging diseases.

[106]  A. Lindberg,et al.  Completeness of the disease recording systems for dairy cows in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden with special reference to clinical mastitis , 2012, BMC Veterinary Research.

[107]  T. Nunes,et al.  Spatial analysis of cattle movement patterns in Portugal. , 2007, Veterinaria italiana.