Blood from a stone: Performance of catch-only methods in estimating stock biomass status

Abstract Demand for data-limited stock assessment methods is increasing, and new methods are being developed rapidly. One class of these methods requires only catch time series and, in some cases, information about life history or fishery characteristics, to estimate stock status. These catch-only methods (COMs) range from statistical models trained on data-rich stocks to mechanistic population models that make assumptions about changes in fishing effort. We review 11 COMs, comparing performance through application to data-rich stocks and simulated fisheries. The catch-only methods evaluated here produce imprecise and biased estimates of B/BMSY, especially for stocks that are lightly exploited. They were also generally poor classifiers of stock status. While no method performed best across all stocks, ensembles of multiple COMs generally performed better than individual COMs. We advocate for testing new COMs using this common platform. We also caution that performance in estimating stock status is not sufficient for gauging the usefulness of COMs in managing fisheries. Greater use of management strategy evaluation is needed before COMs can be considered a reliable tool for management.

[1]  André E. Punt,et al.  Management strategy evaluation: best practices , 2016 .

[2]  André E. Punt,et al.  Estimating stock depletion level from patterns of catch history , 2017 .

[3]  Daniel Pauly,et al.  Global fisheries: a brief review , 2008 .

[4]  André E. Punt,et al.  An optimized catch-only assessment method for data poor fisheries , 2018 .

[5]  S. Martell,et al.  A simple method for estimating MSY from catch and resilience , 2013 .

[6]  Ray Hilborn,et al.  Standing on the Shoulders of Giants: Learning from Experience in Fisheries , 1998, Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries.

[7]  Sean C. Anderson,et al.  Assessing global marine fishery status with a revised dynamic catch-based method and stock-assessment reference points , 2012 .

[8]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Rebuilding Global Fisheries , 2009, Science.

[9]  Murdoch K. McAllister,et al.  Evaluating methods that classify fisheries stock status using only fisheries catch data , 2012 .

[10]  T. N. Krishnamurti,et al.  Improved Weather and Seasonal Climate Forecasts from Multimodel Superensemble. , 1999, Science.

[11]  Rainer Froese,et al.  Impact of fishing on the abundance of marine species , 2002 .

[12]  Elizabeth A. Fulton,et al.  Strong fisheries management and governance positively impact ecosystem status , 2017 .

[13]  Richard D. Methot,et al.  Stock synthesis: A biological and statistical framework for fish stock assessment and fishery management , 2013 .

[14]  Jun Zhang,et al.  Application of a catch-based method for stock assessment of three important fisheries in the East China Sea , 2018, Acta Oceanologica Sinica.

[15]  Osio Giacomo Chato,et al.  DEVELOPING NEW APPROACHES TO GLOBAL STOCK STATUS ASSESSMENT AND FISHERY PRODUCTION POTENTIAL OF THE SEAS , 2014 .

[16]  E. Barbier,et al.  Response to Comments on "Impacts of Biodiversity Loss on Ocean Ecosystem Services" , 2007, Science.

[17]  André E. Punt,et al.  Evaluating methods for setting catch limits in data-limited fisheries , 2014 .

[18]  Catherine M. Dichmont,et al.  Guidelines for developing formal harvest strategies for data-poor species and fisheries , 2015 .

[19]  K. Kleisner,et al.  Estimating Fisheries Reference Points from Catch and Resilience , 2017 .

[20]  Milner B. Schaefer.  Some aspects of the dynamics of populations important to the management of the commercial marine fisheries , 1991 .

[21]  D. Rubin,et al.  The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects , 1983 .

[22]  Jacob Cohen,et al.  Weighted kappa: Nominal scale agreement provision for scaled disagreement or partial credit. , 1968 .

[23]  James T. Thorson,et al.  Using model-based inference to evaluate global fisheries status from landings, location, and life history data , 2012 .

[24]  Christopher M. Free,et al.  Evaluating the performance of data-limited methods for setting catch targets through application to data-rich stocks: A case study using Northeast U.S. fish stocks , 2019, Fisheries Research.

[25]  J. Thorson,et al.  A new role for effort dynamics in the theory of harvested populations and data-poor stock assessment , 2013 .

[26]  Rainer Froese,et al.  Using global catch data for inferences on the world's marine fisheries , 2013 .

[27]  Alec D. MacCall,et al.  Depletion-corrected average catch: a simple formula for estimating sustainable yields in data-poor situations , 2009 .

[28]  K. Cochrane,et al.  Overview of World Status of Data-Limited Fisheries: Inferences from Landings Statistics , 2005 .

[29]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Contrasting Global Trends in Marine Fishery Status Obtained from Catches and from Stock Assessments , 2011, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[30]  Malin L. Pinsky,et al.  Unexpected patterns of fisheries collapse in the world's oceans , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[31]  Philippe Grosjean,et al.  FLR: an open-source framework for the evaluation and development of management strategies , 2007 .

[32]  Ana M. Parma,et al.  Primary fisheries management: a minimum requirement for provision of sustainable human benefits in small-scale fisheries , 2011 .

[33]  Alec D. MacCall,et al.  Depletion-Based Stock Reduction Analysis: A catch-based method for determining sustainable yields for data-poor fish stocks , 2011 .

[34]  André E. Punt,et al.  The importance of length and age composition data in statistical age-structured models for marine species , 2015 .

[35]  Cóilín Minto,et al.  Examining the knowledge base and status of commercially exploited marine species with the RAM Legacy Stock Assessment Database , 2012 .

[36]  D. Pauly.  The Sea Around Us Project: Documenting and Communicating Global Fisheries Impacts on Marine Ecosystems , 2007, Ambio.

[37]  James T. Thorson,et al.  Catch curve stock-reduction analysis: An alternative solution to the catch equations , 2015 .

[38]  Daniel Pauly,et al.  Fisheries: Does catch reflect abundance? , 2013, Nature.

[39]  Gianpaolo Coro,et al.  Status and rebuilding of European fisheries , 2018, Marine Policy.

[40]  Villy Christensen,et al.  The state of biodiversity and fisheries in Regional Seas , 2011 .

[41]  Elizabeth A. Fulton,et al.  Applying a New Ensemble Approach to Estimating Stock Status of Marine Fisheries around the World , 2018 .

[42]  Luiz Barbieri,et al.  Calculating Acceptable Biological Catch for Stocks That Have Reliable Catch Data Only: Only Reliable Catch Stocks - Orcs , 2013 .

[43]  C. Walters,et al.  Quantitative fisheries stock assessment: Choice, dynamics and uncertainty , 2004, Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries.

[44]  Moritz Stäbler,et al.  Performance evaluation of data-limited, length-based stock assessment methods , 2019, ICES Journal of Marine Science.

[45]  Jonathan J. Deroba,et al.  The refined ORCS approach: A catch-based method for estimating stock status and catch limits for data-poor fish stocks , 2017 .

[46]  Steven J. D. Martell,et al.  A stochastic approach to stock reduction analysis , 2006 .

[47]  Sean C. Anderson,et al.  Trade-offs for data-limited fisheries when using harvest strategies based on catch-only models , 2018, Fish and Fisheries.

[48]  Ray Hilborn,et al.  Global fishery prospects under contrasting management regimes , 2016, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[49]  Jim Berkson,et al.  Current methods for setting catch limits for data-limited fish stocks in the United States , 2015 .

[50]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Status and Solutions for the World’s Unassessed Fisheries , 2012, Science.

[51]  Sean C. Anderson,et al.  Improving estimates of population status and trend with superensemble models , 2017 .

[52]  James T Thorson,et al.  Drivers and rates of stock assessments in the United States , 2018, PloS one.

[53]  Cóilín Minto,et al.  Trends in the abundance of marine fishes , 2010 .

[54]  J. R. Landis,et al.  The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. , 1977, Biometrics.