How tasks change whole-brain functional organization to reveal brain-phenotype relationships

Functional connectivity (FC) calculated from task fMRI data better reveals brain-phenotype relationships than rest-based FC, but how tasks have this effect is unknown. In over 700 individuals performing 7 tasks, we use psychophysiological interaction (PPI) and predictive modeling analyses to demonstrate that task-induced changes in FC successfully predict phenotype, and these changes are not simply driven by task activation. Activation, however, is useful for prediction only if the in-scanner task is related to the predicted phenotype. Given this evidence that tasks change patterns of FC independent of activation to amplify brain-phenotype relationships, we develop and apply an inter-subject PPI analysis to further characterize these predictive FC changes. We find that task-induced consistency of FC patterns across individuals is useful for prediction—to a point; these results suggest that tasks improve FC-based prediction performance by de-noising the BOLD signal, revealing meaningful individual differences in brain functional organization. Together, these findings demonstrate that, when it comes to the effects of in-scanner tasks on the brain, focal activation is only the tip of the iceberg, and they offer a framework to best leverage both task activation and FC to reveal the neural bases of complex human traits, symptoms, and behaviors.