Early and multiple origins of metastatic lineages within primary tumors

Significance The knowledge that cancer is an evolutionary process is old, but only recently can sequencing technology provide data for clinically relevant evolutionary analyses of cancer. Approaches developed for evolutionary biology can reveal the relationship among clonal lineages, the ancestral states of gene sequences, and the timing of evolutionary events. We performed whole exome sequencing of cancer tissues from multiple sites of dozens of subjects, demonstrating nonlinear patterns of tumor progression and early origins of metastatic lineages and quantifying the times of occurrence of driver mutations. These findings direct research attention away from the search for genes that induce metastasis toward genes that are mutated early in tumorigenesis, providing therapeutic targets effective against both primary tumors and metastases. Many aspects of the evolutionary process of tumorigenesis that are fundamental to cancer biology and targeted treatment have been challenging to reveal, such as the divergence times and genetic clonality of metastatic lineages. To address these challenges, we performed tumor phylogenetics using molecular evolutionary models, reconstructed ancestral states of somatic mutations, and inferred cancer chronograms to yield three conclusions. First, in contrast to a linear model of cancer progression, metastases can originate from divergent lineages within primary tumors. Evolved genetic changes in cancer lineages likely affect only the proclivity toward metastasis. Single genetic changes are unlikely to be necessary or sufficient for metastasis. Second, metastatic lineages can arise early in tumor development, sometimes long before diagnosis. The early genetic divergence of some metastatic lineages directs attention toward research on driver genes that are mutated early in cancer evolution. Last, the temporal order of occurrence of driver mutations can be inferred from phylogenetic analysis of cancer chronograms, guiding development of targeted therapeutics effective against primary tumors and metastases.