Fish embryo tests and acute fish toxicity tests are interchangeable in the application of the threshold approach

A database was compiled for algal Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) test guideline 201, for Daphnia magna OECD test guideline 202, for the acute fish toxicity (AFT) OECD test guideline 203, and for the fish embryo toxicity (FET) OECD test guideline 236 to assess the suitability and applicability of the FET test in a threshold approach context. In the threshold approach, algal and Daphnia toxicity are assessed first, after which a limit test is conducted at the lower of the 2 toxicity values using fish. If potential fish toxicity is indicated, a full median lethal concentration assay is performed. This tiered testing strategy can significantly reduce the number of fish used in toxicity testing because algae or Daphnia are typically more sensitive than fish. A total of 165 compounds had AFT and FET data available, and of these, 82 had algal and Daphnia acute toxicity data available. Algae and Daphnia were more sensitive 75 to 80% of the time. Fish or FET tests were most sensitive 20 and 16% of the time, respectively, when considered as the sole fish toxicity indicator and 27% of the time when both were considered simultaneously. When fish were the most sensitive trophic level, different compounds were identified as the most toxic in FET and to AFT tests; however, the differences were not so large that they resulted in substantially different outcomes when potencies were binned using the United Nations categories of aquatic toxicity under the Globally Harmonized System for classification and labeling. It is recommended that the FET test could be used to directly replace the AFT test in the threshold approach or could be used as the definitive test if an AFT limit test indicated toxicity potential for a chemical. Environ Toxicol Chem 2019;38:671-681. © 2019 SETAC.

[1]  S. Glaberman,et al.  Evaluating the zebrafish embryo toxicity test for pesticide hazard screening , 2017, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[2]  Marianne Thomsen,et al.  Comparative analysis of pharmaceuticals versus industrial chemicals acute aquatic toxicity classification according to the United Nations classification system for chemicals. Assessment of the (Q)SAR predictability of pharmaceuticals acute aquatic toxicity and their predominant acute toxic mode-of-a , 2009, Toxicology letters.

[3]  Mark A Lampi,et al.  Alternative approaches to vertebrate ecotoxicity tests in the 21st century: A review of developments over the last 2 decades and current status , 2016, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[4]  James R Wheeler,et al.  Application of the threshold approach for acute fish toxicity testing to plant protection products: a proposed framework. , 2014, Chemosphere.

[5]  Juliette Legler,et al.  OECD validation study to assess intra- and inter-laboratory reproducibility of the zebrafish embryo toxicity test for acute aquatic toxicity testing. , 2014, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[6]  S. Raimondo,et al.  Influence of taxonomic relatedness and chemical mode of action in acute interspecies estimation models for aquatic species. , 2010, Environmental science & technology.

[7]  E. E. Kenaga,et al.  Fish and Daphnia toxicity as surrogates for aquatic vascular plants and algae , 1979 .

[8]  T. Braunbeck,et al.  Is the fish embryo toxicity test (FET) with the zebrafish (Danio rerio) a potential alternative for the fish acute toxicity test? , 2009, Comparative biochemistry and physiology. Toxicology & pharmacology : CBP.

[9]  ZhiChao Dang,et al.  Fish embryo toxicity test, threshold approach, and moribund as approaches to implement 3R principles to the acute fish toxicity test. , 2017, Chemosphere.

[10]  John F Carriger,et al.  A Bayesian network model for predicting aquatic toxicity mode of action using two dimensional theoretical molecular descriptors. , 2016, Aquatic toxicology.

[11]  David M. Reif,et al.  Zebrafish developmental screening of the ToxCast™ Phase I chemical library. , 2012, Reproductive toxicology.

[12]  Scott E Belanger,et al.  Use of fish embryo toxicity tests for the prediction of acute fish toxicity to chemicals , 2013, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[13]  Stefan Scholz,et al.  Predicting adult fish acute lethality with the zebrafish embryo: relevance of test duration, endpoints, compound properties, and exposure concentration analysis. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[14]  Jr. John Cairns,et al.  The Myth of the Most Sensitive SpeciesMultispecies testing can provide valuable evidence for protecting the environment , 1986 .

[15]  Dick de Zwart,et al.  Creation of a Curated Aquatic Toxicology Database: EnviroTox , 2019, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[16]  S. Scholz,et al.  Applicability of the fish embryo acute toxicity (FET) test (OECD 236) in the regulatory context of Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation, and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) , 2018, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[17]  J. Hermens,et al.  Classifying environmental pollutants , 1992 .

[18]  Birgit Sokull-Klüttgen,et al.  Acute toxicity data: A comprehensive comparison of results of fish, daphnia, and algae tests with new substances notified in the European Union , 2000 .

[19]  Alexander Kukush,et al.  Measurement Error Models , 2011, International Encyclopedia of Statistical Science.

[20]  J. Edward Jackson,et al.  A User's Guide to Principal Components: Jackson/User's Guide to Principal Components , 2004 .

[21]  S E Belanger,et al.  Mode of Action (MOA) Assignment Classifications for Ecotoxicology: An Evaluation of Approaches. , 2017, Environmental science & technology.

[22]  T. Hutchinson,et al.  A strategy to reduce the use of fish in acute ecotoxicity testing of new chemical substances notified in the European Union. , 2005, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[23]  Steve Gutsell,et al.  It is time to develop ecological thresholds of toxicological concern to assist environmental hazard assessment , 2015, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[24]  Jürg Oliver Straub,et al.  A strategy to reduce the numbers of fish used in acute ecotoxicity testing of pharmaceuticals , 2003, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[25]  Albertinka J Murk,et al.  Alternative approaches can greatly reduce the number of fish used for acute toxicity testing , 2006, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[26]  W. V. van Wieringen,et al.  Dithiocarbamates induce craniofacial abnormalities and downregulate sox9a during zebrafish development. , 2010, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[27]  C. Russom,et al.  Predicting modes of toxic action from chemical structure: Acute toxicity in the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) , 1997 .