From Muller to mechanism: How LNT became the default model for cancer risk assessment.

This paper summarizes the historical and scientific foundations of the Linear No-Threshold (LNT) cancer risk assessment model. The story of cancer risk assessment is an extraordinary one as it was based on an initial incorrect gene mutation interpretation of Muller, the application of this incorrect assumption in the derivation of the LNT single-hit model, and a series of actions by leading radiation geneticists during the 1946-1956 period, including a National Academy of Sciences (NAS) Biological Effects of Atomic Radiation (BEAR) I Genetics Panel (Anonymous, 1956), to sustain the LNT belief via a series of deliberate obfuscations, deceptions and misrepresentations that provided the basis of modern cancer risk assessment policy and practices. The reaffirming of the LNT model by a subsequent and highly influential NAS Biological Effects of Ionizing Radiation (BEIR) I Committee (NAS/NRC, 1972) using mouse data has now been found to be inappropriate based on the discovery of a significant documented error in the historical control group that led to incorrect estimations of risk in the low dose zone. Correction of this error by the original scientists and the application of the adjusted/corrected data back to the BEIR I (NAS/NRC, 1972) report indicates that the data would have supported a threshold rather than the LNT model. Thus, cancer risk assessment has a poorly appreciated, complex and seriously flawed history that has undermined policies and practices of regulatory agencies in the U.S. and worldwide to the present time.

[1]  F. Serres.  X-ray-induced specific-locus mutation in the ad-3 region of two-component heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa , 1990 .

[2]  D. Krewski,et al.  Carcinogenic risk assessment: a guide to the literature. , 1981, Biometrics.

[3]  C. Auerbach.  Mutation research: Problems, results, and perspectives , 1976 .

[4]  P. Lohman,et al.  Low dose-rate X-irradiation induces larger deletions at the human HPRT locus than high dose-rate X-irradiation. , 1997, International journal of radiation biology.

[5]  D G Hoel,et al.  Estimation of risks of irreversible, delayed toxicity. , 1975, Journal of toxicology and environmental health.

[6]  L. Stadler,et al.  Genetic Effects of X-Rays in Maize. , 1928, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[7]  R. Owen.  Anecdotal, historical and critical commentaries on genetics. , 1989, Genetics.

[8]  I. M. Jones,et al.  Mapping the end points of large deletions affecting the hprt locus in human peripheral blood cells and cell lines. , 1995, Radiation research.

[9]  D. J. Chen,et al.  Molecular analysis of gamma-ray-induced mutations at the hprt locus in primary human skin fibroblasts by multiplex polymerase chain reaction. , 1995, Radiation research.

[10]  J Van Ryzin,et al.  A generalized multihit dose-response model for low-dose extrapolation. , 1981, Biometrics.

[11]  O. Ueda,et al.  Spi− selection: An efficient method to detect γ‐ray‐induced deletions in transgenic mice , 1999, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[12]  W. Russell,et al.  Spontaneous mutations recovered as mosaics in the mouse specific-locus test. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[13]  W. Russell,et al.  Radiation Dose Rate and Mutation Frequency , 1958, Science.

[14]  G. Taubes.  Epidemiology faces its limits. , 1995, Science.

[15]  J. Crow.  Quarreling geneticists and a diplomat. , 1995, Genetics.

[16]  B. Mcclintock.  Induction of Instability at Selected Loci in Maize. , 1953, Genetics.

[17]  F. D. de Serres.  X-ray-induced specific-locus mutations in the ad-3 region of two-component heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa. VIII. Dose-dependence of the overall spectrum. , 1991, Mutation research.

[18]  T. Ono,et al.  Radiation Dose-Rate Effect on Mutation Induction in Spleen and Liver of gpt delta Mice , 2010, Radiation research.

[19]  L. Stadler.  On the genetic nature of induced mutation in plants , 1933 .

[20]  C. Stern,et al.  Experiments to Test the Validity of the Linear R-Dose/Mutation Frequency Relation in Drosophila at Low Dosage. , 1948, Genetics.

[21]  Edward J. Calabrese,et al.  Model Uncertainty via the Integration of Hormesis and LNT as the Default in Cancer Risk Assessment , 2015, Dose-response : a publication of International Hormesis Society.

[22]  G. Lefevre.  X-Ray Induced Genetic Effects in Germinal and Somatic Tissue of Drosophila melanogaster , 1950, The American Naturalist.

[23]  L. Dillon.  The Gene , 1987, Springer US.

[24]  Edward J. Calabrese.  The Genetics Panel of the NAS BEAR I Committee (1956): epistolary evidence suggests self-interest may have prompted an exaggeration of radiation risks that led to the adoption of the LNT cancer risk assessment model , 2014, Archives of Toxicology.

[25]  C. Stern.  An Effect of Temperature and Age on Crossing-Over in the First Chromosome of Drosophila Melanogaster. , 1926, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[26]  W. Dewey,et al.  Historical and Current Highlights in Radiation Biology: Has Anything Important Been Learned by Irradiating Cells? , 2002, Radiation research.

[27]  B. Mcclintock.  The origin and behavior of mutable loci in maize , 1950, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[28]  Hermann J. Muller,et al.  Radiation and Genetics , 1930, The American Naturalist.

[29]  J. Thacker.  Radiation-Induced Mutation in Mammalian Cells at Low Doses and Dose Rates , 1992 .

[30]  E. Calabrese.  Key studies used to support cancer risk assessment questioned , 2011, Environmental and molecular mutagenesis.

[31]  Edward J Calabrese,et al.  LNTgate: How scientific misconduct by the U.S. NAS led to governments adopting LNT for cancer risk assessment. , 2016, Environmental research.

[32]  J. Schwartz,et al.  Dose-Dependent Changes in the Spectrum of Mutations Induced by Ionizing Radiation , 2000, Radiation research.

[33]  E. Calabrese.  The threshold vs LNT showdown: Dose rate findings exposed flaws in the LNT model part 2. How a mistake led BEIR I to adopt LNT , 2017, Environmental research.

[34]  Serge Haroche,et al.  Nobel Prize Lecture , 2013 .

[35]  A. Grosovsky,et al.  Spectrum of X-ray-induced mutations in the human hprt gene. , 1994, Carcinogenesis.

[36]  E. Caspari,et al.  The Influence of Chronic Irradiation with Gamma-Rays at Low Dosages on the Mutation Rate in DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER. , 1948, Genetics.

[37]  J. Crow,et al.  Seventy years ago: mutation becomes experimental. , 1997, Genetics.

[38]  J. Cornfield,et al.  Carcinogenic risk assessment. , 1977, Science.

[39]  T. S. Painter,et al.  SALIVARY CHROMOSOMES AND THE ATTACK ON THE GENE , 1934 .

[40]  Yong Liu,et al.  Analysis of spontaneous, gamma ray- and ethylnitrosourea-induced hprt mutants in HL-60 cells with multiplex PCR. , 2003, World journal of gastroenterology.

[41]  V. Ratner,et al.  Prolongation of MGE 412 Transposition Induction after γ-Irradiation in an Isogenic Line of Drosophila melanogaster , 2001, Russian Journal of Genetics.

[42]  N Mantel,et al.  Fundamental carcinogenic processes and their implications for low-dose risk assessment. , 1978, Cancer research.

[43]  H J Muller,et al.  ARTIFICIAL TRANSMUTATION OF THE GENE. , 1927, Science.

[44]  H. Muller,et al.  The Cytological Expression of Changes in Gene Alignment Produced by X-Rays in Drosophila , 1929, The American Naturalist.

[45]  R. Voss,et al.  The nature of reverse mutations in Drosophila melanogaster. , 1973, Mutation research.

[46]  H. Muller.  Thomas Hunt Morgan 1866-1945. , 1946, Science.

[47]  K. Ishizaki,et al.  Cytotoxic and Mutagenic Effects of Chronic Low-Dose-Rate Irradiation on TERT-Immortalized Human Cells , 2005, Radiation research.

[48]  P. Selby.  Major impacts of gonadal mosaicism on hereditary risk estimation, origin of hereditary diseases, and evolution , 2004, Genetica.

[49]  B. Mcclintock.  CHROMOSOME MORPHOLOGY IN ZEA MAYS. , 1929, Science.

[50]  H. Muller.  The production of mutations. , 1947, Journal of Heredity.

[51]  K Yamagiwa,et al.  Experimental study of the pathogenesis of carcinoma , 1977, CA: a cancer journal for clinicians.

[52]  H. Muller,et al.  Are "Progressive" Mutations Produced by X-Rays? , 1930, Genetics.

[53]  J. Thacker.  The nature of mutants induced by ionising radiation in cultured hamster cells. III. Molecular characterization of HPRT-deficient mutants induced by gamma-rays or alpha-particles showing that the majority have deletions of all or part of the hprt gene. , 1986, Mutation research.

[54]  E. Calabrese.  LNTgate: The ideological history of cancer risk assessment , 2017 .

[55]  P. Lohman,et al.  Similar mutational spectra in the HPRT gene of human and hamster cell lines after exposure to either low dose rate or high dose rate X-rays. , 1998, Mutation research.

[56]  S. P. Ray-Chaudhuri.  IX.—The Validity of the Bunsen-Roscoe Law in the Production of Mutations by Radiation of Extremely Low Intensity , 1944 .

[57]  H. Muller.  The First Cytological Demonstration of a Translocation in Drosophila , 1929, American Naturalist.

[58]  H J Muller,et al.  The Production of Mutations by X-Rays. , 1928, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[59]  L. DiPietro.  A Silent Spring? , 2017, Journal of physical activity & health.

[60]  M. Busch,et al.  Molecular analysis of the , 1996 .

[61]  D. Uphoff,et al.  The Genetic Effects of Low Intensity Irradiation. , 1948, Science.

[62]  H. Cullings,et al.  The Genetic Risk in Mice from Radiation: An Estimate of the Mutation Induction Rate per Genome , 2013, Radiation research.

[63]  H. Muller,et al.  Some present problems in the genetic effects of radiation. , 1950, Journal of cellular physiology. Supplement.

[64]  J. Thacker,et al.  Localization of deletion breakpoints in radiation-induced mutants of the hprt gene in hamster cells. , 1990, Mutation research.

[65]  Hiroshi Suzuki,et al.  Effect of Atm Disruption on Spontaneously Arising and Radiation-Induced Deletion Mutations in Mouse Liver , 2003, Radiation research.

[66]  M. Mognato,et al.  Analysis of mutational effects at the HPRT locus in human G0 phase lymphocytes irradiated in vitro with γ rays , 2001 .

[67]  R. Albert,et al.  Rationale developed by the Environmental Protection Agency for the assessment of carcinogenic risks. , 1977, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[68]  Edward J. Calabrese,et al.  Origin of the linearity no threshold (LNT) dose–response concept , 2013, Archives of Toxicology.

[69]  C. Auerbach.  A Pilgrim's Progress through Mutation Research , 2015, Perspectives in biology and medicine.

[70]  B. Webber,et al.  INDUCTION KINETICS AND GENETIC ANALYSIS OF X-RAY-INDUCED MUTATIONS IN THE AD-3 REGION OF NEUROSPORA CRASSA. , 1965, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[71]  R. D. Evans.  Quantitative Inferences concerning the Genetic Effects of Radiation on Human Beings. , 1949, Science.

[72]  E. Carlson,et al.  Genes, radiation, and society: The life and work of H.J. Muller , 1981 .

[73]  Edward J. Calabrese,et al.  Flaws in the LNT single‐hit model for cancer risk: An historical assessment , 2017, Environmental research.

[74]  F. Serres.  X-ray-induced specific-locus mutations in the ad-3 region of two-component heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa. VIII. Dose-dependence of the overall spectrum. , 1991 .

[75]  E. Calabrese.  On the origins of the linear no-threshold (LNT) dogma by means of untruths, artful dodges and blind faith. , 2015, Environmental research.

[76]  J. Robson,et al.  Chemical Production of Mutations , 1946, Nature.

[77]  E. Calabrese.  An abuse of risk assessment: how regulatory agencies improperly adopted LNT for cancer risk assessment , 2015, Archives of Toxicology.

[78]  Luis Campos.  Radium and the Secret of Life , 2015 .

[79]  Keiji Suzuki,et al.  The Contribution of Radiation-Induced Large Deletion of the Genome to Chromosomal Instability , 2009, Radiation research.

[80]  D. J. Chen,et al.  Molecular analysis and comparison of radiation-induced large deletions of the HPRT locus in primary human skin fibroblasts. , 1996, Radiation research.

[81]  M. Ruchirawat,et al.  Effects of low-dose gamma radiation on DNA damage, chromosomal aberration and expression of repair genes in human blood cells. , 2006, International journal of hygiene and environmental health.

[82]  J F Berliner.  A NEGLECTED NOTE BY A NEGLECTED MAN. , 1927, Science.

[83]  P. Selby.  Discovery of numerous clusters of spontaneous mutations in the specific-locus test in mice necessitates major increases in estimates of doubling doses , 2004, Genetica.

[84]  P. Hunsicker,et al.  The Effect of Dose Rate on the Frequency of Specific-Locus Mutations Induced in Mouse Spermatogonia is Restricted to Larger Lesions; a Retrospective Analysis of Historical Data , 2012, Radiation research.

[85]  Was Muller’s 1946 Nobel Prize research for radiation-induced gene mutations peer-reviewed? , 2018, Philosophy, ethics, and humanities in medicine : PEHM.

[86]  C. S. Gager,et al.  Chromosome and Gene Mutations in Datura Following Exposure to Radium Rays. , 1927, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[87]  Edward J Calabrese,et al.  The threshold vs LNT showdown: Dose rate findings exposed flaws in the LNT model part 1. The Russell-Muller debate. , 2017, Environmental research.

[88]  N. Comfort,et al.  Book reviews-the tangled field. Barbara McClintock's search for the patterns of genetic control , 2001 .

[89]  Quantitative Inferences concerning the Genetic Effects of Radiation on Human Beings. , 1949 .

[90]  E. Calabrese.  Cancer risk assessment foundation unraveling: New historical evidence reveals that the US National Academy of Sciences (US NAS), Biological Effects of Atomic Radiation (BEAR) Committee Genetics Panel falsified the research record to promote acceptance of the LNT , 2015, Archives of Toxicology.

[91]  J. Crow.  Genes, radiation, and society: The life and work of H. J. Muller. , 1982 .

[92]  B. Mcclintock,et al.  Chromosome organization and genic expression. , 1951, Cold Spring Harbor symposia on quantitative biology.

[93]  W. R. Lee,et al.  The influence of large deletions on the mutation frequency induced by tritiated water and X-radiation in male Drosophila melanogaster post-meiotic germ cells. , 1994, Mutation research.