Objective:The purpose of the study was to identify a group of operations which general surgery residency program directors believed residents should be competent to perform by the end of 5 years of training and then ascertain actual resident experience with these procedures during their training. Summary Background Data:There is concern about the adequacy of training of general surgeons in the United States. The American Board of Surgery and the Association of Program Directors in Surgery undertook a study to determine what operative procedures residency program directors consider to be essential to the practice of general surgery and then we measured the actual operative experience of graduating residents in those procedures, as reported to the Residency Review Committee for Surgery (RRC). Methods:An electronic survey was sent to residency program directors at the 254 general surgery programs in the US accredited by the RRC as of spring 2006. The program directors were presented with a list of 300 types of operations. Program directors graded the 300 procedures “A,” “B,” or “C” using the following criteria: A—graduating general surgery residents should be competent to perform the procedure independently; B—graduating residents should be familiar with the procedure, but not necessarily competent to perform it; and C—graduating residents neither need to be familiar with nor competent to perform the procedure. After ballots were tallied, the actual resident operative experience reported to the RRC by all residents finishing general surgery training in June 2005 was reviewed. Results:One hundred twenty-one of the 300 operations were considered A level procedures by a majority of program directors (PDs). Graduating 2005 US residents (n = 1022) performed only 18 of the 121 A procedures, an average of more than 10 times during residency; 83 of 121 procedures were performed on an average less than 5 times and 31 procedures less than once. For 63 of the 121 procedures, the mode (most commonly reported) experience was 0. In addition, there was significant variation between residents in operative experience for specific procedures. In virtually all cases, the mean reported experience exceeded the mode, suggesting that the mean is a poor measure of typical experience. Conclusions:These data pose important problems for surgical educators. Methods will have to be developed to allow surgeons to reach a basic level of competence in procedures which they are likely to experience only rarely during residency. Even for more commonly performed procedures, the numbers of repetitions are not very robust, stressing the need to determine objectively whether residents are actually achieving basic competency in these operations. Finally, the large variations in experience between individuals in our residency system need to be explored, understood, and remedied.
[1]
D A Asch,et al.
Response rates to mail surveys published in medical journals.
,
1997,
Journal of clinical epidemiology.
[2]
C. Daniel Smith,et al.
Bile Duct Injury During Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy: Results of a National Survey
,
2001,
Annals of surgery.
[3]
L. Tafra,et al.
The learning curve and sentinel node biopsy.
,
2001,
American journal of surgery.
[4]
R. Satava,et al.
Virtual Reality Training Improves Operating Room Performance: Results of a Randomized, Double-Blinded Study
,
2002,
Annals of surgery.
[5]
C. Delaney,et al.
Evaluation of the Learning Curve in Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery: Comparison of Right-Sided and Left-Sided Resections
,
2005,
Annals of surgery.
[6]
F. Giuliante,et al.
Bile duct injury during laparoscopic cholecystectomy: results of an Italian national survey on 56 591 cholecystectomies.
,
2005,
Archives of surgery.
[7]
A. K. Sachdeva,et al.
American Surgical Association Blue Ribbon Committee Report on Surgical Education: 2004.
,
2005,
Annals of surgery.
[8]
K. A. Ericsson,et al.
An expert‐performance perspective of research on medical expertise: the study of clinical performance
,
2007,
Medical education.
[9]
R. Bell,et al.
Surgical council on resident education: a new organization devoted to graduate surgical education.
,
2007,
Journal of the American College of Surgeons.
[10]
A. Park,et al.
Minimally invasive surgery: the evolution of fellowship.
,
2007,
Surgery.
[11]
A. K. Sachdeva,et al.
National efforts to reform residency education in surgery.
,
2007,
Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.
[12]
Richard M Satava,et al.
The future of sugical simulation and surgical robotics.
,
2007,
Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons.
[13]
Program for Accreditation of Education Institutes continues to grow.
,
2007,
Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons.
[14]
Marc E Mitchell,et al.
Changing demographics of residents choosing fellowships: longterm data from the American Board of Surgery.
,
2008,
Journal of the American College of Surgeons.
[15]
F. Gobet,et al.
The Cambridge handbook of expertise and expert performance
,
2006
.