Effect of Environmental and Feedback Interventions on Pacing Profiles in Cycling: A Meta-Analysis

In search of their optimal performance athletes will alter their pacing strategy according to intrinsic and extrinsic physiological, psychological and environmental factors. However, the effect of some of these variables on pacing and exercise performance remains somewhat unclear. Therefore, the aim of this meta-analysis was to provide an overview as to how manipulation of different extrinsic factors affects pacing strategy and exercise performance. Only self-paced exercise studies that provided control and intervention group(s), reported trial variance for power output, disclosed the type of feedback received or withheld, and where time-trial power output data could be segmented into start, middle and end sections; were included in the meta-analysis. Studies with similar themes were grouped together to determine the mean difference (MD) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) between control and intervention trials for: hypoxia, hyperoxia, heat-stress, pre-cooling, and various forms of feedback. A total of 26 studies with cycling as the exercise modality were included in the meta-analysis. Of these, four studies manipulated oxygen availability, eleven manipulated heat-stress, four implemented pre-cooling interventions and seven studies manipulated various forms of feedback. Mean power output (MPO) was significantly reduced in the middle and end sections (p < 0.05), but not the start section of hypoxia and heat-stress trials compared to the control trials. In contrast, there was no significant change in trial or section MPO for hyperoxic or pre-cooling conditions compared to the control condition (p > 0.05). Negative feedback improved overall trial MPO and MPO in the middle section of trials (p < 0.05), while informed feedback improved overall trial MPO (p < 0.05). However, positive, neutral and no feedback had no significant effect on overall trial or section MPO (p > 0.05). The available data suggests exercise regulation in hypoxia and heat-stress is delayed in the start section of trials, before significant reductions in MPO occur in the middle and end of the trial. Additionally, negative feedback involving performance deception may afford an upward shift in MPO in the middle section of the trial improving overall performance. Finally, performance improvements can be retained when participants are informed of the deception.

[1]  J. R. Landis,et al.  The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. , 1977, Biometrics.

[2]  R. Polman,et al.  Pacing and Awareness: Brain Regulation of Physical Activity , 2013, Sports Medicine.

[3]  Jukka T. Viitasalo,et al.  Effects of oxygen fraction in inspired air on force production and electromyogram activity during ergometer rowing , 1997, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[4]  A. St. Clair Gibson,et al.  Application of Decision-Making Theory to the Regulation of Muscular Work Rate during Self-Paced Competitive Endurance Activity , 2014, Sports Medicine.

[5]  Gert-Jan Pepping,et al.  Cycling in the Absence of Task-Related Feedback: Effects on Pacing and Performance , 2016, Front. Physiol..

[6]  R. Shephard.  Effects of Environmental Heat Stress (35°C) with Simulated Air Movement on the Thermoregulatory Responses during a 4-km Cycling Time Trial , 2010 .

[7]  B. Pageaux.  The Psychobiological Model of Endurance Performance: An Effort-Based Decision-Making Theory to Explain Self-Paced Endurance Performance , 2014, Sports Medicine.

[8]  A. St. Clair Gibson,et al.  Risk perception influences athletic pacing strategy. , 2015, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[9]  The effect of skin temperature on performance during a 7.5-km cycling time trial , 2012, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[10]  H. Ulmer,et al.  Concept of an extracellular regulation of muscular metabolic rate during heavy exercise in humans by psychophysiological feedback , 1996, Experientia.

[11]  C. Byrne,et al.  Self-paced exercise performance in the heat after pre-exercise cold-fluid ingestion. , 2011, Journal of athletic training.

[12]  A. Ferrauti,et al.  Effects of training-induced fatigue on pacing patterns in 40-km cycling time trials. , 2015, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[13]  David Lester Neumann,et al.  The effects of the presence of others during a rowing exercise in a virtual reality environment , 2016 .

[14]  Lars Nybo,et al.  Hyperthermia and fatigue. , 2008, Journal of applied physiology.

[15]  H. Kundel,et al.  Measurement of observer agreement. , 2003, Radiology.

[16]  T. Noakes,et al.  From catastrophe to complexity: a novel model of integrative central neural regulation of effort and fatigue during exercise in humans: summary and conclusions , 2005, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[17]  J. Brisswalter,et al.  Relationships between triathlon performance and pacing strategy during the run in an international competition. , 2011, International journal of sports physiology and performance.

[18]  T. Noakes,et al.  Rates of fluid ingestion alter pacing but not thermoregulatory responses during prolonged exercise in hot and humid conditions with appropriate convective cooling , 2008, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[19]  C. Caillaud,et al.  Cardiovascular strain impairs prolonged self‐paced exercise in the heat , 2011, Experimental physiology.

[20]  T D Noakes,et al.  Experimental evaluation of the power balance model of speed skating. , 2005, Journal of applied physiology.

[21]  David T. Martin,et al.  Effect of carbohydrate ingestion and ambient temperature on muscle fatigue development in endurance-trained male cyclists. , 2008, Journal of applied physiology.

[22]  Ross Tucker,et al.  The Role of Information Processing Between the Brain and Peripheral Physiological Systems in Pacing and Perception of Effort , 2006, Sports medicine.

[23]  T D Noakes,et al.  Evidence for complex system integration and dynamic neural regulation of skeletal muscle recruitment during exercise in humans , 2004, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[24]  Fatigue sensation and gene expression in trained cyclists following a 40 km time trial in the heat , 2016, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[25]  G. Atkinson,et al.  Effects of environmental heat stress (35 degrees C) with simulated air movement on the thermoregulatory responses during a 4-km cycling time trial. , 2009, International journal of sports medicine.

[26]  C. Willíams,et al.  External exercise information provides no immediate additional performance benefit to untrained individuals in time trial cycling , 2011, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[27]  T D Noakes,et al.  Evidence that a central governor regulates exercise performance during acute hypoxia and hyperoxia. , 2001, The Journal of experimental biology.

[28]  Influence of age and sex on pacing during Sprint, Olympic, Half-Ironman and Ironman triathlons: Part B , 2014 .

[29]  T. Noakes,et al.  The rate of increase in rating of perceived exertion predicts the duration of exercise to fatigue at a fixed power output in different environmental conditions , 2008, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[30]  David Marchant,et al.  Improvements in Cycling Time Trial Performance Are Not Sustained Following the Acute Provision of Challenging and Deceptive Feedback , 2016, Front. Physiol..

[31]  T. Mickleborough,et al.  Using Deception to Establish a Reproducible Improvement in 4-Km Cycling Time Trial Performance , 2016, International Journal of Sports Medicine.

[32]  Sally Hopewell,et al.  PRISMA for Abstracts: Reporting Systematic Reviews in Journal and Conference Abstracts , 2013, PLoS medicine.

[33]  I. Swaine,et al.  The effects of caffeine ingestion on performance time, speed and power during a laboratory-based 1 km cycling time-trial , 2006, Journal of sports sciences.

[34]  Markus Amann,et al.  Arterial oxygenation influences central motor output and exercise performance via effects on peripheral locomotor muscle fatigue in humans , 2006, The Journal of physiology.

[35]  Z. Schlader,et al.  Is peak oxygen uptake a determinant of moderate-duration self-paced exercise performance in the heat? , 2011, Applied physiology, nutrition, and metabolism = Physiologie appliquee, nutrition et metabolisme.

[36]  Florentina J. Hettinga,et al.  The effect of ambient temperature on gross-efficiency in cycling , 2007, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[37]  N. Secher,et al.  COUNTERPOINT: AFFERENT FEEDBACK FROM FATIGUED LOCOMOTOR MUSCLES IS NOT AN IMPORTANT DETERMINANT OF ENDURANCE EXERCISE PERFORMANCE , 2010 .

[38]  R. Thelwell,et al.  Influence of competition on performance and pacing during cycling exercise. , 2012, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[39]  Greg Atkinson,et al.  The effects of changing pace on metabolism and stroke characteristics during high-speed breaststroke swimming , 2004, Journal of sports sciences.

[40]  P. Ferreira,et al.  Can Water Temperature and Immersion Time Influence the Effect of Cold Water Immersion on Muscle Soreness? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis , 2015, Sports Medicine.

[41]  E. Hartley,et al.  I. Psychological Determinants , 1961 .

[42]  A. St. Clair Gibson,et al.  Effects of deception on exercise performance: implications for determinants of fatigue in humans. , 2012, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[43]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[44]  Toby Mündel,et al.  Skin temperature as a thermal controller of exercise intensity , 2010, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[45]  S. Racinais,et al.  Performance and Pacing during Cycle Exercise in Hyperthermic and Hypoxic Conditions. , 2016, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[46]  V. Placet,et al.  Self-paced cycling performance and recovery under a hot and highly humid environment after cooling. , 2014, The Journal of sports medicine and physical fitness.

[47]  J. Corbett,et al.  Early change in thermal perception is not a driver of anticipatory exercise pacing in the heat , 2011, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[48]  Effects of wind application on thermal perception and self-paced performance , 2013, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[49]  Blair D. Johnson,et al.  Rapidity of responding to a hypoxic challenge during exercise , 2009, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[50]  N. Maxwell,et al.  Deception of ambient and body core temperature improves self paced cycling in hot, humid conditions , 2011, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[51]  A. Murphy,et al.  Augmenting performance feedback does not affect 4 km cycling time-trials in the heat , 2015, Journal of sports sciences.

[52]  John P. Porcari,et al.  Regulation of Pacing Strategy during Athletic Competition , 2011, PloS one.

[53]  B. Nielsen.  Heat stress and acclimation. , 1994, Ergonomics.

[54]  R. Meeusen,et al.  Neurophysiological Determinants of Theoretical Concepts and Mechanisms Involved in Pacing , 2013, Sports Medicine.

[55]  H. Rusko,et al.  Oxygen uptake response during maximal cycling in hyperoxia, normoxia and hypoxia. , 2001, Aviation, space, and environmental medicine.

[56]  L. Mcnaughton,et al.  Deception studies manipulating centrally acting performance modifiers: a review. , 2014, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[57]  R. Duffield,et al.  Precooling can prevent the reduction of self-paced exercise intensity in the heat. , 2010, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[58]  S. Cheung,et al.  Separate and combined effects of dehydration and thirst sensation on exercise performance in the heat , 2015, Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports.

[59]  Adrian W Midgley,et al.  Physiological and Psychological Effects of Deception on Pacing Strategy and Performance: A Review , 2013, Sports Medicine.

[60]  A. Lees,et al.  The effect of even, positive and negative pacing on metabolic, kinematic and temporal variables during breaststroke swimming , 2002, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[61]  T D Noakes,et al.  Exercising with reserve: exercise regulation by perceived exertion in relation to duration of exercise and knowledge of endpoint , 2009, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[62]  Jos J de Koning,et al.  Rapidity of response to hypoxic conditions during exercise. , 2013, International journal of sports physiology and performance.

[63]  Ross Tucker,et al.  Psychobiology and Behavioral Strategies Effect of Distance Feedback on Pacing Strategy and Perceived Exertion during Cycling , 2005 .

[64]  R. Aughey,et al.  The effect of acute simulated moderate altitude on power, performance and pacing strategies in well-trained cyclists , 2007, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[65]  R. Duffield,et al.  Volume-dependent response of precooling for intermittent-sprint exercise in the heat. , 2011, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[66]  H. Rusko,et al.  Cardiorespiratory responses to exercise in acute hypoxia, hyperoxia and normoxia , 2001, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[67]  Denise Baden,et al.  Am I Nearly There? The Effect of Anticipated Running Distance on Perceived Exertion and Attentional Focus , 2004 .

[68]  Ross Tucker,et al.  Impaired exercise performance in the heat is associated with an anticipatory reduction in skeletal muscle recruitment , 2004, Pflügers Archiv.

[69]  Ross Tucker,et al.  Hyperoxia improves 20 km cycling time trial performance by increasing muscle activation levels while perceived exertion stays the same , 2007, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[70]  G Atkinson,et al.  Effects of music on work-rate distribution during a cycling time trial. , 2004, International journal of sports medicine.

[71]  Samuele M. Marcora,et al.  Psychological Determinants of Whole-Body Endurance Performance , 2015, Sports Medicine.

[72]  H B Nielsen,et al.  Cerebral desaturation during exercise reversed by O2 supplementation. , 1999, American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology.

[73]  Chris R Abbiss,et al.  Describing and Understanding Pacing Strategies during Athletic Competition , 2008, Sports medicine.

[74]  R. Tucker,et al.  The anticipatory regulation of performance: the physiological basis for pacing strategies and the development of a perception-based model for exercise performance , 2009, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[75]  Samuel N Cheuvront,et al.  Evidence against a 40 degrees C core temperature threshold for fatigue in humans. , 2009, Journal of applied physiology.

[76]  Adrian W Midgley,et al.  Deception has no acute or residual effect on cycling time trial performance but negatively effects perceptual responses. , 2016, Journal of science and medicine in sport.

[77]  Precooling Does Not Improve 2,000-m Rowing Performance of Females in Hot, Humid Conditions , 2014, Journal of strength and conditioning research.

[78]  M. Febbraio,et al.  Effects of heat stress on physiological responses and exercise performance in elite cyclists. , 2000, Journal of science and medicine in sport.

[79]  Andrew M. Jones,et al.  Influence of feedback and prior experience on pacing during a 4-km cycle time trial. , 2009, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[80]  J. Peiffer,et al.  Influence of environmental temperature on 40 km cycling time-trial performance. , 2011, International journal of sports physiology and performance.

[81]  A. Coutts,et al.  Pacing Adjustments Associated With Familiarization: Heat Versus Temperate Environments. , 2016, International journal of sports physiology and performance.

[82]  D. Casa.  Exercise in the heat. I. Fundamentals of thermal physiology, performance implications, and dehydration. , 1999, Journal of athletic training.

[83]  Benjamin L. M. Smits,et al.  Pacing and Decision Making in Sport and Exercise: The Roles of Perception and Action in the Regulation of Exercise Intensity , 2014, Sports Medicine.

[84]  S. Racinais,et al.  Heat stress exacerbates the reduction in middle cerebral artery blood velocity during prolonged self‐paced exercise , 2015, Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports.

[85]  Toby Mündel,et al.  Human thermoregulatory behavior during rest and exercise — A prospective review , 2010, Physiology & Behavior.

[86]  Wolfgang Viechtbauer,et al.  Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package , 2010 .

[87]  G. Kenny,et al.  Current evidence does not support an anticipatory regulation of exercise intensity mediated by rate of body heat storage. , 2009, Journal of applied physiology.

[88]  J T Viitasalo,et al.  Effects of oxygen fraction in inspired air on rowing performance. , 1995, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[89]  Samuele M. Marcora,et al.  Effects of isolated locomotor muscle fatigue on pacing and time trial performance , 2013, European Journal of Applied Physiology.