The Equivalence Myth of Quantum Mechanics-Part I

The author endeavours to show two things: first, that Schrodingers (and Eckarts) demonstration in March (September) 1926 of the equivalence of matrix mechanics, as created by Heisenberg, Born, Jordan and Dirac in 1925, and wave mechanics, as created by Schrodinger in 1926, is not foolproof; and second, that it could not have been foolproof, because at the time matrix mechanics and wave mechanics were neither mathematically nor empirically equivalent. That they were is the Equivalence Myth. In order to make the theories equivalent and to prove this, one has to leave the historical scene of 1926 and wait until 1932, when von Neumann finished his magisterial edifice. During the period 1926–1932 the original families of mathematical structures of matrix mechanics and of wave mechanics were stretched, parts were chopped off and novel structures were added. To Procrustean places we go, where we can demonstrate the mathematical, empirical and ontological equivalence of ‘the final versions of’ matrix mechanics and wave mechanics. The present paper claims to be a comprehensive analysis of one of the pivotal papers in the history of quantum mechanics: Schrodingers equivalence paper. Since the analysis is performed from the perspective of Suppes structural view (‘semantic view’) of physical theories, the present paper can be regarded not only as a morsel of the internal history of quantum mechanics, but also as a morsel of applied philosophy of science. The paper is self-contained and presupposes only basic knowledge of quantum mechanics. For reasons of length, the paper is published in two parts; Part I appeared in the previous issue of this journal. Section 1 contains, besides an introduction, also the papers five claims and a preview of the arguments supporting these claims; so Part I, Section 1 may serve as a summary of the paper for those readers who are not interested in the detailed arguments.

[1]  N. Balazs,et al.  Schr̈odinger: Life and Thought , 1989 .

[2]  Gérard G. Emch,et al.  Mathematical and conceptual foundations of 20th-century physics , 1984 .

[3]  Linus Pauling,et al.  Introduction to Quantum Mechanics with Applications to Chemistry , 1935 .

[4]  Roland Omnès The Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics , 1987 .

[5]  S.J.L. van Eijndhoven,et al.  A mathematical introduction to Dirac's formalism , 1986 .

[6]  Paul Teller,et al.  Quantum Mechanics: An Empiricist View , 1991 .

[7]  Max Jammer,et al.  The conceptual development of quantum mechanics , 1966 .

[8]  W. PauliJr. Über das Wasserstoffspektrum vom Standpunkt der neuen Quantenmechanik , 1926 .

[9]  J. Mehra The physicist's conception of nature , 1973 .

[10]  J. Neumann Die Eindeutigkeit der Schrödingerschen Operatoren , 1931 .

[11]  P. Dirac Principles of Quantum Mechanics , 1982 .

[12]  L. Crone A characterization of matrix operators onl2 , 1971 .

[13]  Max Born,et al.  Eine neue Formulierung der Quantengesetze für periodische und nicht periodische Vorgänge , 1926 .

[14]  Jesudason C.G.,et al.  COLLECTED WORKS II. , 1988 .

[15]  E. Prugovec̆ki,et al.  Quantum Mechanics In Hilbert Space , 1971 .

[16]  H. Casimir,et al.  Haphazard Reality: Half a Century of Science , 1983 .

[17]  W. Heisenberg,et al.  Zur Quantenmechanik. II. , 1926 .

[18]  P. Pascual,et al.  Quantum Mechanics II , 1991 .

[19]  D. Griffiths,et al.  Introduction to Quantum Mechanics , 1960 .

[20]  Carl Eckart,et al.  Operator Calculus and the Solution of the Equations of Quantum Dynamics , 1926 .

[21]  H. Kramers Quantum Mechanics , 1957 .

[22]  Erwin Schrödinger,et al.  Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem , 1925 .

[23]  M. Born Zur Quantenmechanik der Stoßvorgänge , 1926 .

[24]  Paul Adrien Maurice Dirac,et al.  Quantum Mechanics and a Preliminary Investigation of the Hydrogen Atom , 1926 .

[25]  L. Lichtenstein,et al.  Spektraltheorie der unendlichen Matrizen : Einführung in den analytischen Apparat der Quantenmechanik , 1929 .

[26]  A. Galindo,et al.  Quantum Mechanics I , 1990 .

[27]  J. Neumann Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics , 1955 .

[28]  H. Weyl The Theory Of Groups And Quantum Mechanics , 1931 .

[29]  F. Hund,et al.  Geschichte der Quantentheorie , 1984 .

[30]  Erwin Schrödinger,et al.  Über das Verhältnis der Heisenberg‐Born‐Jordanschen Quantenmechanik zu der meinem , 1926 .

[31]  P. Hoch,et al.  Life and Thought , 1992, A Medieval Muslim Scholar at Work.

[32]  M. Beller Born's probabilistic interpretation: A case study of ‘concepts in flux’ , 1990 .

[33]  J. Neumann Mathematische Begründung der Quantenmechanik , 2022 .

[34]  Anders Martin-Löf,et al.  Collected Works I , 1994 .

[35]  J. Neumann Zur Theorie der unbeschränkten Matrizen. , 1929 .

[36]  M. Born,et al.  Zur Quantenmechanik , 1925 .

[37]  L. Wessels What Was Born's Statistical Interpretation? , 1980, PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association.

[38]  N. R. Hanson Are wave mechanics and matrix mechanics equivalent theories? , 1961 .

[39]  W. Heisenberg Development of Concepts in the History of Quantum Theory , 1975 .

[40]  J. Neumann Wahrscheinlichkeitstheoretischer Aufbau der Quantenmechanik , 1927 .

[41]  Patrick Suppes,et al.  Studies in the foundations of quantum mechanics , 1980 .

[42]  I. N. Sneddon,et al.  Wave Mechanics and Its Applications , 1963 .

[43]  N. Akhiezer,et al.  The Classical Moment Problem. , 1968 .

[44]  A. Messiah Quantum Mechanics , 1961 .

[45]  M. Born Quantenmechanik der Stoßvorgänge , 1926 .

[46]  R. Hughes,et al.  The Structure and Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics , 1989 .

[47]  Walter Greiner,et al.  Quantum Mechanics: An Introduction , 1989 .

[48]  Erwin Schrödinger,et al.  Collected Papers on Wave Mechanics , 1928 .

[49]  P. Jordan Anschauliche Quantentheorie: Eine Einführung in die Moderne Auffassung der Quantenerscheinungen , 1936 .

[50]  D. Wick,et al.  The Infamous Boundary: Seven Decades of Controversy in Quantum Physics , 1994 .

[51]  The Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics , 1974 .

[52]  G. Gamow BOOKS: Thirty Years That Shook Physics: The Story of Quantum Theory , 1967 .

[53]  M. Beller Matrix Theory before Schrodinger: Philosophy, Problems, Consequences , 1983, Isis.

[54]  J. L. Powell Quantum Mechanics , 1961 .

[55]  H. Maxwell,et al.  Current Issues in the Philosophy of Science , 1961 .

[56]  L. Broglie,et al.  Wave mechanics : the first fifty years , 1973 .

[57]  R. G. Cooke,et al.  Infinite Matrices and Sequence Spaces , 1966 .

[58]  J. Linnett,et al.  Quantum mechanics , 1975, Nature.

[59]  Helge Kragh,et al.  Dirac: A Scientific Biography , 1991 .

[60]  M. Beller The conceptual and the anecdotal history of quantum mechanics , 1996 .

[61]  Patrick Suppes,et al.  Introduction To Logic , 1958 .

[62]  Patrick Suppes,et al.  Introduction To Logic , 1958 .

[63]  Thirty Years That Shook Physics , 1972 .

[64]  Olivier Darrigol,et al.  Erwin Schrödinger : philosophy and the birth of quantum mechanics , 1992 .

[65]  Werner Heisenberg The Physicist's Conception of Nature , 1959 .

[66]  Book-Review - Uncertainty - the Life and Science of Werner Heisenberg , 1991 .

[67]  Paul Adrien Maurice Dirac,et al.  The fundamental equations of quantum mechanics , 1925 .

[68]  V. Gordon Childe,et al.  Society and knowledge , 1973 .

[69]  W. Heisenberg Über quantentheoretische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen. , 1925 .

[70]  Linda Wessels,et al.  Schrödinger's route to wave mechanics , 1979 .

[71]  Roberto Torretti,et al.  Creative understanding : philosophical reflections on physics , 1992 .

[72]  P. Karlson Half a century of science , 1976 .

[73]  E. MacKinnon Heisenberg, Models, and the Rise of Matrix Mechanics , 1977 .

[74]  B. L. van der Waerden From Matrix Mechanics and Wave Mechanics to Unified Quantum Mechanics , 1998 .

[75]  Robert L. Weber,et al.  Sources of Quantum Mechanics , 1968 .