What's Wrong with Slippery Slope Arguments?
暂无分享,去创建一个
Slippery slope arguments are commonly thought to be fallacious. But is there a single fallacy which they all commit? A study of applied logic texts reveals competing diagnoses of the supposed error, and several recent authors take slippery slope arguments seriously.1 Clearly, there is room for comment. I shall give evidence of divergence on the question of what sort of argument constitutes a slippery slope, distinguish four different types of argument which have all been deemed to be slippery slopes, and contend that two of these types need involve no logical error.
[1] Jonathan Glover,et al. Causing Death and Saving Lives , 1977 .
[2] M. Black. Reasoning with Loose Concepts , 1963, Dialogue.