Environmental Risk Assessment: Comparison of Receptor and Air Quality Models for Source Apportionment

ABSTRACT Source apportionment of particulate matter has been commonly performed using receptor models, but studies suggest that the assumptions in receptor models limit the accuracy of results. An alternative approach is the use of three-dimensional source-oriented air quality models. Here, a comparison is conducted between the PM2.5 apportioned from the Chemical Mass Balance (CMB) receptor model using organic tracers as molecular markers with those from the source-based Community Multiscale Air Quality (CMAQ) model. Source apportionment was conducted at sites in the southeastern United States for July 2001 and January 2002. PM2.5 source apportionment results had moderate discrepancies, which originate from different spatial scales, fundamental limitations, and uncertainties of the two models. Results from CMB fluctuated temporally more than real variation due to measurement and source profile errors and uncertainties, whereas those from CMAQ could not capture daily variation well. In addition, results from CMB are mass contributions for the monitoring location, whereas those from CMAQ represent the average mass contributions of the model's grid. It is difficult to assess which approach is “better.” Indeed, both models have strengths and limitations, and each model's strengths can be utilized to help overcome the other model's limitations.

[1]  Alper Unal,et al.  Airport related emissions and impacts on air quality: Application to the Atlanta International Airport , 2005 .

[2]  F. Slemr,et al.  Evaluation of an emission inventory by comparisons of modelled and measured emission ratios of individual HCs, CO and NOx , 2002 .

[3]  A. Russell,et al.  Accounting for high-order correlations in probabilistic characterization of environmental variables, and evaluation , 2008 .

[4]  Glen R. Cass,et al.  SOURCES OF FINE ORGANIC AEROSOL. 3. ROAD DUST, TIRE DEBRIS, AND ORGANOMETALLIC BRAKE LINING DUST: ROADS AS SOURCES AND SINKS , 1993 .

[5]  R. O. Gilbert,et al.  Emissions of ozone precursors from stationary sources:: a critical review , 2000 .

[6]  A. Russell,et al.  Estimation of emission adjustments from the application of four-dimensional data assimilation to photochemical air quality modeling , 2001 .

[7]  Michael J Kleeman,et al.  Measurement of emissions from air pollution sources. 5. C1-C32 organic compounds from gasoline-powered motor vehicles. , 2002, Environmental science & technology.

[8]  Rohit Mathur,et al.  Ensemble and bias-correction techniques for air quality model forecasts of surface O3 and PM2.5 during the TEXAQS-II experiment of 2006 , 2010 .

[9]  Qi Ying,et al.  A comparison of the UCD/CIT air quality model and the CMB source-receptor model for primary airborne particulate matter , 2005 .

[10]  Desheng Dash Wu,et al.  Enterprise risk management: a DEA VaR approach in vendor selection , 2010 .

[11]  Howard Frumkin,et al.  Ambient Air Pollution and Cardiovascular Emergency Department Visits , 2004, Epidemiology.

[12]  G. Cass,et al.  Sources of fine organic aerosol. 5. Natural gas home appliances , 1993 .

[13]  G. Cass,et al.  Sources of Fine Organic Aerosol. 7. Hot Asphalt Roofing Tar Pot Fumes , 1997 .

[14]  Philippe Thunis,et al.  Skill and uncertainty of a regional air quality model ensemble , 2009 .

[15]  Wei Liu,et al.  Comparison of PM2.5 source apportionment using positive matrix factorization and molecular marker-based chemical mass balance. , 2008, The Science of the total environment.

[16]  J. Schauer,et al.  Source apportionment of PM2.5 in the Southeastern United States using solvent-extractable organic compounds as tracers. , 2002, Environmental science & technology.

[17]  L. Waller,et al.  ANALYSES OF AIR QUALITY DATA FOR AN EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT STUDY, 1993-2002 , 2004 .

[18]  G. Cass,et al.  Chemical Characterization of Fine Particle Emissions from the Wood Stove Combustion of Prevalent United States Tree Species , 2004 .

[19]  Yongtao Hu,et al.  Evaluation of Fine Particle Number Concentrations in CMAQ , 2006 .

[20]  Desheng Dash Wu,et al.  Introduction to the Special Section on “Optimizing Risk Management: Methods and Tools” , 2009 .

[21]  William F. Christensen,et al.  Chemical mass balance analysis of air quality data when unknown pollution sources are present , 2004 .

[22]  Allen L. Robinson,et al.  Contribution of motor vehicle emissions to organic carbon and fine particle mass in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: Effects of varying source profiles and seasonal trends in ambient marker concentrations , 2006 .

[23]  James G. Wilkinson,et al.  Fast, Direct Sensitivity Analysis of Multidimensional Photochemical Models , 1997 .

[24]  J. Chow,et al.  Simulating Changes in Source Profiles from Coal-Fired Power Stations: Use in Chemical Mass Balance of PM2.5 in the Mount Zirkel Wilderness , 2002 .

[25]  J. Schauer,et al.  Sensitivity of molecular marker-based CMB models to biomass burning source profiles , 2007 .

[26]  G. Cass,et al.  Sources of Fine Organic Aerosol. 8. Boilers Burning No. 2 Distillate Fuel Oil , 1997 .

[27]  Michael J. Kleeman,et al.  MEASUREMENT OF EMISSIONS FROM AIR POLLUTION SOURCES. 2. C1 THROUGH C30 ORGANIC COMPOUNDS FROM MEDIUM DUTY DIESEL TRUCKS , 1999 .

[28]  A. M. Dunker,et al.  Efficient calculation of sensitivity coefficients for complex atmospheric models , 1981 .

[29]  Sylvie Cautenet,et al.  Impact of a highly detailed emission inventory on modeling accuracy , 2005 .

[30]  Hampden Kuhns,et al.  Source profiles for industrial, mobile, and area sources in the Big Bend Regional Aerosol Visibility and Observational study. , 2004, Chemosphere.

[31]  G R Cass,et al.  Sources of fine organic aerosol. 6. Cigaret smoke in the urban atmosphere. , 1994, Environmental science & technology.

[32]  Robin L. Dennis,et al.  Seasonal NH3 emission estimates for the eastern United States , 2003 .

[33]  Glen R. Cass,et al.  Sources of fine organic aerosol. 1. Charbroilers and meat cooking operations , 1991 .

[34]  Michael J. Kleeman,et al.  Measurement of Emissions from Air Pollution Sources. 1. C1 through C29 Organic Compounds from Meat Charbroiling , 1999 .

[35]  H. Javitz,et al.  Performance of the chemical mass balance model with simulated local-scale aerosols , 1988 .

[36]  John E. Core,et al.  Particulate Dispersion Model Evaluation: A New Approach Using Receptor Models , 1982 .

[37]  James A. Mulholland,et al.  Source apportionment of PM2.5 in the southeastern United States using receptor and emissions-based models : Conceptual differences and implications for time-series health studies , 2006 .

[38]  G. Cass,et al.  Sources of Fine Organic Aerosol. 9. Pine, Oak, and Synthetic Log Combustion in Residential Fireplaces , 1998 .

[39]  Tan Zhu,et al.  Receptor modeling application framework for particle source apportionment. , 2002, Chemosphere.

[40]  Desheng Dash Wu,et al.  Enterprise risk management: coping with model risk in a large bank , 2010, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[41]  Seoung Bum Kim,et al.  Spatial prediction of ozone concentration profiles , 2009, Comput. Stat. Data Anal..

[42]  D. Dockery,et al.  Acute respiratory effects of particulate air pollution. , 1994, Annual review of public health.

[43]  G R Cass,et al.  Measurement of emissions from air pollution sources. 3. C1-C29 organic compounds from fireplace combustion of wood. , 2001, Environmental science & technology.

[44]  M. Viana,et al.  Inter-comparison of receptor models for PM source apportionment: Case study in an industrial area , 2008 .

[45]  Bert Brunekreef,et al.  Estimating Long-Term Average Particulate Air Pollution Concentrations: Application of Traffic Indicators and Geographic Information Systems , 2003, Epidemiology.

[46]  Glen R. Cass,et al.  Sources of fine organic aerosol. 4. Particulate abrasion products from leaf surfaces of urban plants , 1993 .

[47]  Christian Hogrefe,et al.  An Assessment of the Emissions Inventory Processing Systems EMS-2001 and SMOKE in Grid-Based Air Quality Models , 2003, Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

[48]  Yongtao Hu,et al.  Uncertainty in air quality model evaluation for particulate matter due to spatial variations in pollutant concentrations , 2006 .

[49]  James J. Schauer,et al.  Source apportionment of airborne particulate matter using organic compounds as tracers , 1996 .

[50]  Armistead G Russell,et al.  Source Apportionment of Daily Fine Particulate Matter at Jefferson Street, Atlanta, GA, during Summer and Winter , 2007, Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

[51]  Robin L. Dennis,et al.  NARSTO critical review of photochemical models and modeling , 2000 .

[52]  Rohit Mathur,et al.  An evaluation of real‐time air quality forecasts and their urban emissions over eastern Texas during the summer of 2006 Second Texas Air Quality Study field study , 2009 .

[53]  Zhiliang Yao,et al.  High-resolution vehicular emission inventory using a link-based method: a case study of light-duty vehicles in Beijing. , 2009, Environmental science & technology.

[54]  H Christopher Frey,et al.  Propagation of uncertainty in hourly utility NOx emissions through a photochemical grid air quality model: a case study for the Charlotte, NC, modeling domain. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[55]  Rainer Friedrich,et al.  Paris emission inventory diagnostics from ESQUIF airborne measurements and a chemistry transport model , 2003 .

[56]  David L. Olson,et al.  Supply chain risk, simulation, and vendor selection , 2008 .

[57]  Glen R. Cass,et al.  Chemical composition of emissions from urban sources of fine organic aerosol , 1991 .

[58]  J. Chow,et al.  PM2.5 chemical source profiles for vehicle exhaust, vegetative burning, geological material, and coal burning in Northwestern Colorado during 1995. , 2001, Chemosphere.

[59]  J. Schauer,et al.  Measurement of emissions from air pollution sources. 4. C1-C27 organic compounds from cooking with seed oils. , 2002, Environmental science & technology.

[60]  Armistead G Russell,et al.  Characterization of Spatially Homogeneous Regions Based on Temporal Patterns of Fine Particulate Matter in the Continental United States , 2008, Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

[61]  Glen R. Cass,et al.  Sources of fine organic aerosol. 2. Noncatalyst and catalyst-equipped automobiles and heavy-duty diesel trucks , 1993 .