Extending an order on a Set to the power set: Some remarks on Kannai and Peleg's approach

Abstract Kannai and Peleg have shown that given an ordering over a set, it is impossible to induce an ordering over the power set satisfying certain plausible axioms. We prove an impossibility and also a possibility result in this context with closely related sets of axioms, and argue that the dividing line between impossibility and possibility here is rather thin. Also, we distinguish three possible intuitive interpretations for the formal framework of Kannai and Peleg, and argue that the acceptability of specific formal axioms may crucialy depend on the particular interpretation that one chooses to adopt.