Percutaneous or surgical tracheostomy: a meta-analysis.

OBJECTIVE To compare percutaneous with surgical tracheostomy using a meta-analysis of studies published from 1960 to 1996. DATA SOURCES Publications obtained through a MEDLINE database search with a Boolean combination (tracheostomy or tracheotomy) and complications, with constraints for human studies and English language. STUDY SELECTION Publications addressing all peri- and postoperative complications. Studies limited to specific tracheostomy complications or containing insufficient details were excluded. Two authors independently selected the publications. DATA EXTRACTION A list of relevant surgical variables and complications was compiled. Complications were divided into peri- and postoperative groups and further subclassified into severe, intermediate, and minor groups. Because most studies of percutaneous tracheostomy were published after 1985, surgical tracheostomy studies were divided into two periods: 1960 to 1984 and 1985 to 1996. The articles were analyzed independently by three investigators, and rare discrepancies were resolved through discussion and data reexamination. DATA SYNTHESIS Earlier surgical tracheostomy studies (n = 17; patients, 4185) have the highest rates of both peri- (8.5%) and postoperative (33%) complications. Comparison of recent surgical (n = 21; patients, 3512) and percutaneous (n = 27; patients, 1817) tracheostomy trials shows that perioperative complications are more frequent with the percutaneous technique (10% vs. 3%), whereas postoperative complications occur more often with surgical tracheotomy (10% vs. 7%). The bulk of the differences is in minor complications, except perioperative death (0.44% vs. 0.03%) and serious cardiorespiratory events (0.33% vs. 0.06%), which were higher with the percutaneous technique. Heterogeneity analysis of complication rates shows higher heterogeneity in older and surgical trials. CONCLUSIONS Percutaneous tracheostomy is associated with a higher prevalence of perioperative complications and, especially, perioperative deaths and cardiorespiratory arrests. Postoperative complication rates are higher with surgical tracheostomy.

[1]  Jackson.  High Tracheotomy and Other Errors—The Chief Causes of Chronic Laryngeal Stenosis , 1921 .

[2]  T. C. Galloway.  TRACHEOTOMY IN BULBAR POLIOMYELITIS , 1943 .

[3]  M. Pijoan,et al.  THE TREATMENT OF IMPETIGO CONTAGIOSA WITH SULFATHIAZOLE IN AN ALCOHOLIC PLASTIC VEHICLE , 1945 .

[4]  H. Lassen..  A preliminary report on the 1952 epidemic of poliomyelitis in Copenhagen with special reference to the treatment of acute respiratory insufficiency. , 1953, Lancet.

[5]  J. Kodicek.  The Place and Management of Tracheostomy in Respiratory Insufficiency , 1960, The Journal of Laryngology & Otology.

[6]  J. Head.  TRACHEOSTOMY IN THE MANAGEMENT OF RESPIRATORY PROBLEMS , 1962, The New England journal of medicine.

[7]  J. Meade.  Tracheotomy--its complications and their management. A study of 212 cases. , 1961, The New England journal of medicine.

[8]  B. B. Roe.  Bedside tracheostomy. , 1962, Surgery, gynecology & obstetrics.

[9]  J. Watts,et al.  Tracheostomy in modern practice , 1963, The British journal of surgery.

[10]  J. Davidson,et al.  A history of tracheostomy: si spiritum ducit vivit (Cicero). , 1963, British journal of anaesthesia.

[11]  P. Samson,et al.  TRACHEOSTOMY: PRESENT DAY INDICATIONS AND TECHNICS. , 1963, American journal of surgery.

[12]  Tracheotomy: Complications and Late Sequelae , 1965 .

[13]  J. Richardson,et al.  TRACHEOTOMY IN CHILDREN , 1962, The New England journal of medicine.

[14]  R. B. Lynn,et al.  OBSERVATIONS UPON ELECTIVE AND EMERGENCY TRACHEOSTOMY. , 1965, Surgery, gynecology & obstetrics.

[15]  C. T. Yarington,et al.  Complications of tracheotomy. , 1965, Archives of surgery.

[16]  W. Austen,et al.  The role of elective tracheostomy after open-heart surgery. , 1966, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[17]  R. Lord.  Review of 280 tracheostomies. , 1967, The Australian and New Zealand journal of surgery.

[18]  Tracheal stenosis from the cuffed tracheotomy tube. , 1968, Archives of otolaryngology.

[19]  J. Nicholls.  The use of tracheostomy following major open cardiac surgery: a review of 64 cases , 1968, Thorax.

[20]  J. Weinstein,et al.  A percutaneous tracheostomy device. , 1969, Surgery.

[21]  D. Mulder,et al.  COMPLICATIONS OF TRACHEOSTOMY: RELATIONSHIP TO LONG TERM VENTILATORY ASSISTANCE , 1970 .

[22]  R. Marshall.  A review of the management of 140 elective tracheostomies following open-heart surgery , 1969, Thorax.

[23]  Mulder Ds,et al.  Complications of tracheostomy: relationshipp to long term ventilatory assistance. , 1969, The Journal of trauma.

[24]  L. A. Rogers.  Complications of Tracheostomy , 1969, Southern medical journal.

[25]  C. L. Cogbill,et al.  Tracheostomy: management, mortality, complications. , 1969, The American surgeon.

[26]  Complications of tracheostomy. , 1970, The American surgeon.

[27]  R. Austin.  Tracheostomy and prolonged intubation in the management of trauma. , 1971, Injury.

[28]  J. Kamen,et al.  A new low-pressure cuff for endotracheal tubes. , 1971, Anesthesiology.

[29]  R. Cantrell,et al.  Tracheostomy: Complications and Their Management , 1972 .

[30]  A. Aass.  Complications to Tracheostomy and Long‐Term Intubation: A Follow‐Up Study , 1975, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica.

[31]  G. Waddell.  Movement of criticall ill patients within hospital. , 1975, British medical journal.

[32]  E. G. King,et al.  A prospective study of complications after tracheostomy for assisted ventilation. , 1975, Chest.

[33]  E. Frost.  Tracing the Tracheostomy , 1976, The Annals of otology, rhinology, and laryngology.

[34]  C. Lindholm.  [Complications of tracheostomy]. , 1978, Lakartidningen.

[35]  C. Sasaki,et al.  Pediatric tracheostomy and associated complications , 1978, The Laryngoscope.

[36]  W. Cleveland.  Robust Locally Weighted Regression and Smoothing Scatterplots , 1979 .

[37]  P. Moore,et al.  Tracheostomy in the management of chest injuries: its use and complications. , 1981, The Australian and New Zealand journal of surgery.

[38]  M. Arola.  Tracheostomy and its complications. A retrospective study of 794 tracheostomized patients. , 1981, Annales chirurgiae et gynaecologiae.

[39]  J. Stauffer,et al.  Complications and consequences of endotracheal intubation and tracheotomy. A prospective study of 150 critically ill adult patients. , 1981, The American journal of medicine.

[40]  Local complications and mortality of adult tracheostomy. , 1983, The Journal of the Kentucky Medical Association.

[41]  J. Miller,et al.  Complications of tracheostomies in neurosurgical patients. , 1984, Surgical neurology.

[42]  R. Firsching,et al.  Elective percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy. A new simple bedside procedure; preliminary report. , 1985, Chest.

[43]  R. Cane,et al.  Perioperative complications of elective tracheostomy in critically ill patients. , 1986 .

[44]  B. Shapiro,et al.  Perioperative complications of elective tracheostomy in critically ill patients , 1986, Critical care medicine.

[45]  J. Weinstein,et al.  Clinical experience with percutaneous tracheostomy and cricothyroidotomy in 100 patients. , 1986, The Journal of trauma.

[46]  V. S. Dayal,et al.  Tracheostomy in intensive care setting , 1986, The Laryngoscope.

[47]  Haack Dg,et al.  Comparing the means of several groups. , 1986 .

[48]  S. Breda,et al.  Surgical complications of bedside tracheotomy in an otolaryngology residency program , 1987, The Laryngoscope.

[49]  P. Hazard,et al.  Bedside percutaneous tracheostomy: experience with 55 elective procedures. , 1988, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[50]  W. Goodwin,et al.  Prolonged intubation vs. tracheotomy: Complications, practical and psychological considerations , 1988, The Laryngoscope.

[51]  Tracheostomies in burn patients. , 1989 .

[52]  R. Treat,et al.  Tracheostomy in the Intensive Care Unit: A Safe Alternative to the Operating Room , 1989, Southern medical journal.

[53]  D. Mulder,et al.  Percutaneous endoscopic tracheostomy. , 1989, The Annals of thoracic surgery.

[54]  Y. Heilbronn,et al.  Percutaneous tracheostomy--a new method. , 1989, Critical care medicine.

[55]  Cook Pd,et al.  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy technique and experience. , 1989 .

[56]  R. B. Holtzman.  Percutaneous approach to tracheostomy. , 1989, Critical care medicine.

[57]  A. Cernaianu,et al.  Mishaps during transport from the intensive care unit. , 1990 .

[58]  N. Padgham,et al.  Complications of emergency and elective tracheostomy: a retrospective study of 150 consecutive cases. , 1990, Annals of the Royal College of Surgeons of England.

[59]  K J Rothman,et al.  No Adjustments Are Needed for Multiple Comparisons , 1990, Epidemiology.

[60]  W. Knaus,et al.  PREDICTING TOMORROW'S THERAPY USING TODAY'S APACHE H SCORE: , 1990 .

[61]  A. Cernaianu,et al.  Mishaps during transport from the intensive care unit , 1990, Critical care medicine.

[62]  T. Burdon,et al.  Endoscopic guided percutaneous tracheostomy: early results of a consecutive trial. , 1990, The Journal of trauma.

[63]  D. Wood,et al.  Late complications of tracheotomy. , 1991, Clinics in chest medicine.

[64]  P. Hazard,et al.  Comparative clinical trial of standard operative tracheostomy with percutaneous tracheostomy , 1991, Critical Care Medicine.

[65]  A. Bodenham,et al.  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy , 1991 .

[66]  R. Hutchinson,et al.  Life-threatening complications from percutaneous dilational tracheostomy. , 1991, Critical care medicine.

[67]  E. Myers,et al.  Early complications of tracheotomy. Incidence and management. , 1991, Clinics in chest medicine.

[68]  Percutaneous tracheostomy. , 1991, Chest.

[69]  S. Delany,et al.  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy: one years experience. , 1991, The New Zealand medical journal.

[70]  J. Siegel,et al.  Percutaneous tracheostomy after trauma and critical illness. , 1992, The Journal of trauma.

[71]  The role of early tracheotomy in the management of the neurosurgical patient , 1992, The Laryngoscope.

[72]  R. Gunawardana.  Experience with tracheostomy in medical intensive care patients. , 1992, Postgraduate medical journal.

[73]  J. Macbeath,et al.  Appraisal of percutaneous tracheostomy , 1992, The British journal of surgery.

[74]  P. Ciaglia,et al.  Percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy. Results and long-term follow-up. , 1992, Chest.

[75]  Tracheostomy in spinal cord injured: frequency and follow up , 1992, Paraplegia.

[76]  D. Howard,et al.  Percutaneous tracheostomy in a head and neck unit , 1992, The Journal of Laryngology & Otology.

[77]  W. Rappaport,et al.  The role of early tracheostomy in blunt, multiple organ trauma. , 1992, The American surgeon.

[78]  P. Ciaglia,et al.  Life-threatening complications from percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy. , 1992, Critical care medicine.

[79]  G. Berke,et al.  Early experience with percutaneous tracheotomy , 1992, The Laryngoscope.

[80]  Y. Friedman,et al.  Bedside percutaneous tracheostomy in critically ill patients. , 1993, Chest.

[81]  J. Heffner.  Timing of tracheotomy in mechanically ventilated patients. , 1993, The American review of respiratory disease.

[82]  N. Futran,et al.  The Safety and Efficacy of Bedside Tracheotomy , 1993, Otolaryngology--head and neck surgery : official journal of American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery.

[83]  R. J. Sanderson,et al.  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy , 1993, Anaesthesia.

[84]  B. Avery,et al.  Complications of tracheostomy in major head and neck cancer surgery; a retrospective study of 60 consecutive cases. , 1994, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery.

[85]  Inn-Chul Nam,et al.  Percutaneous Dilatational Tracheostomy , 2022, Korean Journal of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery.

[86]  B. Toursarkissian,et al.  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy in children and teenagers. , 1994, Journal of pediatric surgery.

[87]  J. Lowry,et al.  The percutaneous dilatational subcricoid tracheostomy. , 1994, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery.

[88]  A. Manara.  Experience with percutaneous tracheostomy in intensive care: the technique of choice? , 1994, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery.

[89]  D. Spain,et al.  Tracheostomy and percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy in the management of the head-injured trauma patient. , 1994, The American surgeon.

[90]  A. Zeitouni,et al.  Tracheostomy: a retrospective review of 281 cases. , 1994, The Journal of otolaryngology.

[91]  I. Cole.  Elective percutaneous (rapitrac) tracheotomy: Results of a prospective trial , 1994, The Laryngoscope.

[92]  G. Mcguire,et al.  A comparison of percutaneous and operative tracheostomies in intensive care patients , 1995, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[93]  A. Olshan,et al.  Multiple comparisons and related issues in the interpretation of epidemiologic data. , 1995, American journal of epidemiology.

[94]  A. Chendrasekhar,et al.  Percutaneous Dilatational Tracheostomy: An Alternative Approach to Surgical Tracheostomy , 1995, Southern medical journal.

[95]  B. Pecaro,et al.  Safety and efficiency of elective tracheostomy performed in the intensive care unit. , 1995, Journal of oral and maxillofacial surgery : official journal of the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons.

[96]  A. Bodenham,et al.  An evaluation of a new percutaneous tracheostomy kit , 1995, Anaesthesia.

[97]  M. Rotondo,et al.  Bronchoscopic guidance makes percutaneous tracheostomy a safe, cost-effective, and easy-to-teach procedure. , 1995, Surgery.

[98]  C. Bredenberg,et al.  Percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy. A safe, cost-effective bedside procedure. , 1996, Archives of surgery.

[99]  J. Glover,et al.  Bedside tracheostomy in the intensive care unit. , 1996, Archives of surgery.

[100]  K. E. Outzen,et al.  Percutaneous dilatational tracheostomy , 1996, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica.

[101]  Bedside percutaneous tracheostomy with bronchoscopic guidance in critically ill patients. , 1996 .

[102]  Percutaneous dilational tracheostomy--a clinical study evaluating two systems. , 1996, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[103]  A. Batchelor,et al.  An audit of Björk flap tracheostomies in head and neck plastic surgery. , 1996, The British journal of oral & maxillofacial surgery.

[104]  B. Hill,et al.  Percutaneous Dilational Tracheostomy , 1996 .

[105]  T. Rosengart,et al.  Elective bedside tracheostomy in the intensive care unit. , 1996, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[106]  J. Fildes,et al.  Comparison of percutaneous and surgical tracheostomies. , 1996, Chest.

[107]  B. Hill,et al.  Percutaneous Dilational Tracheostomy , 1996 .

[108]  J. Graham,et al.  Percutaneous versus open tracheostomy: a retrospective cohort outcome study. , 1996, The Journal of trauma.

[109]  S. Bredbacka.  Percutaneous tracheostomy , 1997, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica. Supplementum.

[110]  Marc S. Rovner.  Percutaneous Dilatational Tracheotomy , 2001 .