Real and hypothetical monetary rewards modulate risk taking in the brain

Both real and hypothetical monetary rewards are widely used as reinforcers in risk taking and decision making studies. However, whether real and hypothetical monetary rewards modulate risk taking and decision making in the same manner remains controversial. In this study, we used event-related potentials (ERP) with a balloon analogue risk task (BART) paradigm to examine the effects of real and hypothetical monetary rewards on risk taking in the brain. Behavioral data showed reduced risk taking after negative feedback (money loss) during the BART with real rewards compared to those with hypothetical rewards, suggesting increased loss aversion with real monetary rewards. The ERP data demonstrated a larger feedback-related negativity (FRN) in response to money loss during risk taking with real rewards compared to those with hypothetical rewards, which may reflect greater prediction error or regret emotion after real monetary losses. These findings demonstrate differential effects of real versus hypothetical monetary rewards on risk taking behavior and brain activity, suggesting a caution when drawing conclusions about real choices from hypothetical studies of intended behavior, especially when large rewards are used. The results have implications for future utility of real and hypothetical monetary rewards in studies of risk taking and decision making.

[1]  Warren K Bickel,et al.  Within-subject comparison of real and hypothetical money rewards in delay discounting. , 2002, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[2]  S. Lane,et al.  Measurement of delay discounting using trial-by-trial consequences , 2003, Behavioural Processes.

[3]  R. Yi,et al.  Statistical equivalence and test–retest reliability of delay and probability discounting using real and hypothetical rewards , 2013, Behavioural Processes.

[4]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Sensitivity of electrophysiological activity from medial frontal cortex to utilitarian and performance feedback. , 2004, Cerebral cortex.

[5]  Carla H. Lagorio,et al.  Delay discounting of real and hypothetical rewards III: Steady-state assessments, forced-choice trials, and all real rewards , 2005, Behavioural Processes.

[6]  Anna Weinberg,et al.  Event‐related potential activity in the basal ganglia differentiates rewards from nonrewards: Temporospatial principal components analysis and source localization of the feedback negativity , 2011, Human brain mapping.

[7]  Sihua Xu,et al.  Assessment of risk-taking and impulsive behaviors: A comparison between three tasks. , 2013, Social behavior and personality.

[8]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Reward prediction error signals associated with a modified time estimation task. , 2007, Psychophysiology.

[9]  H. Rachlin,et al.  Real and hypothetical rewards. , 2011, Judgment and decision making.

[10]  G. Fein,et al.  Drug and Alcohol Dependence , 2007 .

[11]  Edmund Fantino,et al.  How reinforcer type affects choice in economic games , 2007, Behavioural Processes.

[12]  Xiaolin Zhou,et al.  The P300 and reward valence, magnitude, and expectancy in outcome evaluation , 2009, Brain Research.

[13]  Thomas Li-Ping Tang,et al.  Does attitude toward money moderate the relationship between intrinsic job satisfaction and voluntary turnover? , 2000 .

[14]  Michael X. Cohen,et al.  Behavioral / Systems / Cognitive Reinforcement Learning Signals Predict Future Decisions , 2007 .

[15]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  Dissociated roles of the anterior cingulate cortex in reward and conflict processing as revealed by the feedback error-related negativity and N200 , 2011, Biological Psychology.

[16]  John A. Detre,et al.  Neural correlates of voluntary and involuntary risk taking in the human brain: An fMRI Study of the Balloon Analog Risk Task (BART) , 2008, NeuroImage.

[17]  Adrian G. Fischer,et al.  Neural mechanisms and temporal dynamics of performance monitoring , 2014, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[18]  Adrian R. Willoughby,et al.  The Medial Frontal Cortex and the Rapid Processing of Monetary Gains and Losses , 2002, Science.

[19]  Gregory L. Stuart,et al.  Evaluation of a behavioral measure of risk taking: the Balloon Analogue Risk Task (BART). , 2002, Journal of experimental psychology. Applied.

[20]  Zhiheng Zhou,et al.  To do or not to do? Action enlarges the FRN and P300 effects in outcome evaluation , 2010, Neuropsychologia.

[21]  V. Csépe,et al.  Different strategies underlying uncertain decision making: higher executive performance is associated with enhanced feedback-related negativity. , 2015, Psychophysiology.

[22]  R. G. Cummings,et al.  Homegrown Values and Hypothetical Surveys: Is the Dichotomous Choice Approach Incentive-Compatible? , 1995 .

[23]  Warren K Bickel,et al.  Congruence of BOLD Response across Intertemporal Choice Conditions: Fictive and Real Money Gains and Losses , 2009, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[24]  O. Turnbull,et al.  Real versus facsimile reinforcers on the Iowa Gambling Task , 2003, Brain and Cognition.

[25]  Kurt A. Carlson,et al.  Unrealistically Optimistic Consumers: A Selective Hypothesis Testing Account for Optimism in Predictions of Future Behavior , 2009 .

[26]  Howard Rachlin,et al.  Real and hypothetical rewards in self-control and social discounting , 2011, Judgment and Decision Making.

[27]  D. Fernandez-Duque,et al.  “Feeling more regret than I would have imagined”: Self-report and behavioral evidence , 2008, Judgment and Decision Making.

[28]  Magnus Johannesson,et al.  Eliciting Willingness to Pay Without Bias: Evidence from a Field Experiment , 2008 .

[29]  I. Franken,et al.  Acute effects of alcohol on feedback processing and outcome evaluation during risky decision-making: an ERP study , 2011, Psychopharmacology.

[30]  Xu Sihua,et al.  Real or Hypothetical Monetary Rewards Modulates Risk Taking Behavior , 2013 .

[31]  S. Hillyard,et al.  Event-related brain potentials in the study of visual selective attention. , 1998, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[32]  I. Anderson,et al.  The effects of real versus hypothetical reward on delay and probability discounting , 2010, Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[33]  Per-Olov Johansson,et al.  An experimental comparison of dichotomous choice contingent valuation questions and real purchase decisions , 1998 .

[34]  Antonio Rangel,et al.  Hypothetical and Real Choice Differentially Activate Common Valuation Areas , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[35]  H. Okouchi,et al.  [Real and hypothetical rewards in probability discounting]. , 2007, Shinrigaku kenkyu : The Japanese journal of psychology.

[36]  Qiang Liu,et al.  The influence of the diffusion of responsibility effect on outcome evaluations: Electrophysiological evidence from an ERP study , 2010, NeuroImage.

[37]  Alexander M. Nitsch,et al.  A Single-Trial Estimation of the Feedback-Related Negativity and Its Relation to BOLD Responses in a Time-Estimation Task , 2014, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[38]  Hiroaki Masaki,et al.  Affective-motivational influences on feedback-related ERPs in a gambling task , 2006, Brain Research.

[39]  Xiaolin Zhou,et al.  Modulation of the brain activity in outcome evaluation by interpersonal relationship: An ERP study , 2010, Neuropsychologia.

[40]  A. Tversky,et al.  The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. , 1981, Science.

[41]  J. Schwarzbach,et al.  Regret now, take it now: On the role of experienced regret on intertemporal choice , 2010 .

[42]  Bethany R Raiff,et al.  Delay discounting of potentially real and hypothetical rewards: II. Between- and within-subject comparisons. , 2004, Experimental and clinical psychopharmacology.

[43]  Clay B. Holroyd,et al.  The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. , 2002, Psychological review.

[44]  G. Madden,et al.  Delay discounting of real and hypothetical rewards. , 2003, Experimental and clinical psychopharmacology.

[45]  Ted O’Donoghue,et al.  Procrastination on Long-Term Projects , 2002 .