Resolving future fire management conflicts using multicriteria decision making

Management strategies to reduce the risks to human life and property from wildfire commonly involve burning native vegetation. However, planned burning can conflict with other societal objectives such as human health and biodiversity conservation. These conflicts are likely to intensify as fire regimes change under future climates and as growing human populations encroach farther into fire-prone ecosystems. Decisions about managing fire risks are therefore complex and warrant more sophisticated approaches than are typically used. We applied a multicriteria decision making approach (MCDA) with the potential to improve fire management outcomes to the case of a highly populated, biodiverse, and flammable wildland-urban interface. We considered the effects of 22 planned burning options on 8 objectives: house protection, maximizing water quality, minimizing carbon emissions and impacts on human health, and minimizing declines of 5 distinct species types. The MCDA identified a small number of management options (burning forest adjacent to houses) that performed well for most objectives, but not for one species type (arboreal mammal) or for water quality. Although MCDA made the conflict between objectives explicit, resolution of the problem depended on the weighting assigned to each objective. Additive weighting of criteria traded off the arboreal mammal and water quality objectives for other objectives. Multiplicative weighting identified scenarios that avoided poor outcomes for any objective, which is important for avoiding potentially irreversible biodiversity losses. To distinguish reliably among management options, future work should focus on reducing uncertainty in outcomes across a range of objectives. Considering management actions that have more predictable outcomes than landscape fuel management will be important. We found that, where data were adequate, an MCDA can support decision making in the complex and often conflicted area of fire management.

[1]  Jerry F. Franklin,et al.  Beyond Smoke and Mirrors: a Synthesis of Fire Policy and Science , 2004 .

[2]  J. Randerson,et al.  El Niño and health risks from landscape fire emissions in Southeast Asia , 2012, Nature climate change.

[3]  Mark W. Brunson,et al.  Badly Burned? Effects of an Escaped Prescribed Burn on Social Acceptability of Wildland Fuels Treatments , 2005 .

[4]  Keith M. Reynolds,et al.  Decision support for integrated landscape evaluation and restoration planning , 2005 .

[5]  A. Gill,et al.  Survival of serotinous seedbanks during bushfires: Comparative studies of Hakea species from southeastern Australia , 1994 .

[6]  S. Roxburgh,et al.  Modelling the potential for prescribed burning to mitigate carbon emissions from wildfires in fire-prone forests of Australia , 2012 .

[7]  James D. Nichols,et al.  Integrating Land Cover Modeling and Adaptive Management to Conserve Endangered Species and Reduce Catastrophic Fire Risk , 2014 .

[8]  J. Olson,et al.  Energy Storage and the Balance of Producers and Decomposers in Ecological Systems , 1963 .

[9]  Patricia H. Gude,et al.  Potential for Future Development on Fire-Prone Lands , 2008, Journal of Forestry.

[10]  Hugh P. Possingham,et al.  OPTIMAL FIRE MANAGEMENT FOR MAINTAINING COMMUNITY DIVERSITY , 1999 .

[11]  A. Gill,et al.  Using stochastic dynamic programming to determine optimal fire management for Banksia ornata , 2001 .

[12]  H. Houthakker,et al.  The Pareto Distribution and the Cobb-Douglas Production Function in Activity Analysis , 1955 .

[13]  D. Driscoll,et al.  Land Management Practices Associated with House Loss in Wildfires , 2012, PloS one.

[14]  D. Lindenmayer,et al.  The conservation of arboreal marsupials in the montane ash forests of the central highlands of Victoria, south-eastern Australia. VIII. Landscape analysis of the occurrence of arboreal marsupials , 1999 .

[15]  Denis Gromb,et al.  Cultural Inertia and Uniformity in Organizations , 2002 .

[16]  J. Handmer,et al.  Community safety during the 2009 Australian 'Black Saturday' bushfires : an analysis of household preparedness and response , 2013 .

[17]  R. Bradstock,et al.  Contrasting fire responses to climate and management: insights from two Australian ecosystems , 2013, Global change biology.

[18]  O. F. Price,et al.  Reducing wildfire risk to urban developments: Simulation of cost-effective fuel treatment solutions in south eastern Australia , 2014, Environ. Model. Softw..

[19]  T. Penman,et al.  Spatial ecology of the giant burrowing frog (Heleioporus australiacus): implications for conservation prescriptions , 2008 .

[20]  P. Kennedy,et al.  Meta‐analysis of avian and small‐mammal response to fire severity and fire surrogate treatments in U.S. fire‐prone forests , 2012, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[21]  D. Calkin,et al.  Guiding preventative wildland fire mitigation policy and decisions with an economic modeling system , 2010 .

[22]  Izak P J Smit,et al.  The ongoing development of a pragmatic and adaptive fire management policy in a large African savanna protected area. , 2014, Journal of environmental management.

[23]  Ross A. Bradstock,et al.  Relative importance of fuel management, ignition management and weather for area burned: evidence from five landscape–fire–succession models , 2009 .

[24]  R. Bradstock,et al.  The efficacy of fuel treatment in mitigating property loss during wildfires: Insights from analysis of the severity of the catastrophic fires in 2009 in Victoria, Australia. , 2012, Journal of environmental management.

[25]  E. David Ford,et al.  Informed multi-objective decision-making in environmental management using Pareto optimality , 2007 .

[26]  Faith R. Kearns,et al.  Urban–wildland fires: how California and other regions of the US can learn from Australia , 2009 .

[27]  T. Swetnam,et al.  Managing Forests and Fire in Changing Climates , 2013, Science.

[28]  Brad Hawkes,et al.  Multi-attribute evaluation of landscape-level fuel management to reduce wildfire risk , 2006 .

[29]  Ross A. Bradstock,et al.  Prescribed burning: how can it work to conserve the things we value? , 2011 .

[30]  Stuart James,et al.  Resolving conflicts in fire management using decision theory: asset‐protection versus biodiversity conservation , 2010 .

[31]  R J Conroy.  To burn or not to burnq A description of the historyc nature and management of bushfires within Ku-Ring- Gai Chase National Park , 1996 .

[32]  R. Bradstock,et al.  Landscape Scale Influences of Forest Area and Housing Density on House Loss in the 2009 Victorian Bushfires , 2013, PloS one.

[33]  B. Strahm,et al.  Potential Erosion from Bladed Firelines in the Appalachian Region Estimated with USLE-Forest and WEPP Models , 2013 .

[34]  E. David Ford,et al.  Using Multicriteria Analysis of Simulation Models to Understand Complex Biological Systems , 2011 .

[35]  T. Vilén,et al.  Forest Fires in Mediterranean Countries: CO2 Emissions and Mitigation Possibilities Through Prescribed Burning , 2011, Environmental management.

[36]  Helen M. Regan,et al.  Fire management to combat disease: turning interactions between threats into conservation management , 2011, Oecologia.

[37]  Susan I. Stewart,et al.  Demographic Trends, the Wildland–Urban Interface, and Wildfire Management , 2009 .

[38]  Adel Guitouni,et al.  Tentative guidelines to help choosing an appropriate MCDA method , 1998, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[39]  Nicole M. Vaillant,et al.  A comparison of landscape fuel treatment strategies to mitigate wildland fire risk in the urban interface and preserve old forest structure , 2010 .

[40]  Peter Wallbrink,et al.  Effects of differing wildfire severities on soil wettability and implications for hydrological response , 2006 .

[41]  Hugh P. Possingham,et al.  Reliability of Relative Predictions in Population Viability Analysis , 2003 .

[42]  R. Bradstock,et al.  Effects of weather, fuel and terrain on fire severity in topographically diverse landscapes of south-eastern Australia , 2010, Landscape Ecology.

[43]  Hong S. He,et al.  Integrating LANDIS model and a multi-criteria decision-making approach to evaluate cumulative effects of forest management in the Missouri Ozarks, USA , 2012 .

[44]  D. Ward,et al.  Smoke emissions from wildland fires , 1991 .

[45]  A. Syphard,et al.  The role of defensible space for residential structure protection during wildfires , 2014 .

[46]  M. Turetsky,et al.  Impacts of climate change on fire activity and fire management in the circumboreal forest , 2009 .

[47]  Kurt E Anderson,et al.  Fire Management, Managed Relocation, and Land Conservation Options for Long‐Lived Obligate Seeding Plants under Global Changes in Climate, Urbanization, and Fire Regime , 2014, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[48]  Igor Linkov,et al.  Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: ten years of applications and trends. , 2011, The Science of the total environment.

[49]  Wilfried Thuiller,et al.  Predicting extinction risks under climate change: coupling stochastic population models with dynamic bioclimatic habitat models , 2008, Biology Letters.

[50]  F. Moreira,et al.  Prescribed burning in southern Europe: developing fire management in a dynamic landscape , 2013 .

[51]  T. M. Quigley,et al.  Evolution of USDA Forest Service organizational culture and adaptation issues in embracing an ecosystem management paradigm , 1998 .

[52]  J. Davies,et al.  Spatially explicit benefit–cost analysis of fire management for greenhouse gas abatement , 2012 .

[53]  S. Freitas,et al.  Estimating trace gas and aerosol emissions over South America: Relationship between fire radiative energy released and aerosol optical depth observations , 2009 .

[54]  Brendan A. Wintle,et al.  Plant extinction risk under climate change: are forecast range shifts alone a good indicator of species vulnerability to global warming? , 2012 .

[55]  T. Penman,et al.  Applied conservation management of a threatened forest dependent frog, Heleioporus australiacus , 2008 .

[56]  James D. Nichols,et al.  A Markov decision process for managing habitat for Florida scrub-jays , 2011 .

[57]  Sally A. Kenny,et al.  Habitat or fuel? Implications of long‐term, post‐fire dynamics for the development of key resources for fauna and fire , 2011 .

[58]  M. Ehsan Shafiee,et al.  An evolutionary algorithm approach to generate distinct sets of non-dominated solutions for wicked problems , 2013, Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell..

[59]  R. Bradstock,et al.  Wildfires, fuel treatment and risk mitigation in Australian eucalypt forests: insights from landscape-scale simulation. , 2012, Journal of environmental management.

[60]  Ross A. Bradstock,et al.  Bayes Nets as a method for analysing the influence of management actions in fire planning , 2011 .

[61]  P. Nyman,et al.  Wildfire effects on water quality in forest catchments: A review with implications for water supply , 2011 .

[62]  Raphaele Blanchi,et al.  Meteorological conditions and wildfire-related houseloss in Australia , 2010 .

[63]  Matthew P. Thompson,et al.  How risk management can prevent future wildfire disasters in the wildland-urban interface , 2013, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[64]  Michael Brauer,et al.  Estimated Global Mortality Attributable to Smoke from Landscape Fires , 2012, Environmental health perspectives.

[65]  T. Penman,et al.  Heleioporus australiacus predation , 2007 .

[66]  A. Gill,et al.  Bushfire incidence, fire hazard and fuel reduction burning , 1987 .

[67]  Jeremy Russell-Smith,et al.  Frequent fires reduce tree growth in northern Australian savannas: implications for tree demography and carbon sequestration , 2010 .

[68]  Alexandra D. Syphard,et al.  Land Use Planning and Wildfire: Development Policies Influence Future Probability of Housing Loss , 2013, PloS one.

[69]  MICHAELA. MCCARTF.  INCORPORATING METAPOPULATION DYNAMICS OF GREATER GLIDERS INTO RESERVE DESIGN IN DISTURBED LANDSCAPES , 2007 .

[70]  S. Rambal,et al.  Simulating climate change impacts on fire frequency and vegetation dynamics in a Mediterranean‐type ecosystem , 2002 .

[71]  R. Shakesby,et al.  Distinctiveness of wildfire effects on soil erosion in south-east Australian eucalypt forests assessed in a global context , 2007 .