Telehealth services in rural and remote Australia: a systematic review of models of care and factors influencing success and sustainability.

INTRODUCTION With the escalating costs of health care, issues with recruitment and retention of health practitioners in rural areas, and poor economies of scale, the question of delivering people to services or services to people is a dilemma for health authorities around the world. People living in rural areas have poorer health outcomes compared to their urban counterparts, and the problem of how to provide health care and deliver services in rural locations is an ongoing challenge. Telehealth services can efficiently and effectively improve access to healthcare for people living in rural and remote areas of Australia. However, telehealth services are not mainstream or routinely available in many rural and remote locations. The barriers to integration of telehealth into mainstream practice have been well described, but not the factors that may influence the success and sustainability of a service. Our aim was to collate, review and synthesise the available literature regarding telehealth services in rural and remote locations of Australia, and to identify the factors associated with their sustained success. METHODS A systematic literature review of peer-reviewed and grey literature was undertaken. Electronic databases were searched for potentially relevant articles. Reference lists of retrieved articles and the grey literature were also searched. Searches identified 970 potentially eligible articles published between 1988 and 2015. Studies and manuscripts of any type were included if they described telehealth services (store-and-forward or real-time videoconferencing) to provide clinical service or education and training related to health care in rural or remote locations of Australia. Data were extracted according to pre-defined criteria and checked for completeness and accuracy by a second reviewer. Any disagreements were resolved with discussion with a third researcher. All articles were appraised for quality and levels of evidence. Data were collated and grouped into categories including clinical speciality, disciplines involved, geographical location and the role of the service. Data relating to the success or sustainability of services were grouped thematically. RESULTS Inclusion criteria were met by 116 articles that described 72 discrete telehealth services. Telehealth services in rural and remote Australia are described and we have identified six key factors associated with the success and sustainability of services: vision, ownership, adaptability, economics, efficiency and equipment. CONCLUSIONS Telehealth has the potential to address many of the key challenges to providing health in Australia, with its substantial land area and widely dispersed population. This review collates information regarding the telehealth services in Australia and describes models of care and characteristics of successful and sustainable services. We identified a wide variety of telehealth services being provided in rural and remote areas of Australia. There is great potential to increase this number by scaling up and replicating successful services. This review provides information for policy makers, governments and public and private health services that wish to integrate telehealth into routine practice and for telehealth providers to enhance the sustainability of their service.

[1]  H. Gelber The experience of the Royal Children's Hospital mental health service videoconferencing project , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[2]  N Blackwell,et al.  The use of telemedicine to treat ophthalmological emergencies in rural Australia , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[3]  C. Chamberlain,et al.  Evaluation of a rural telepsychiatry service. , 2004, Australasian psychiatry : bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.

[4]  J. Soar,et al.  Uptake of telehealth services funded by Medicare in Australia. , 2014, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[5]  S. Davis,et al.  Evaluation of an ear health pathway in remote communities: improvements in ear health access. , 2014, The Australian journal of rural health.

[6]  Richard Wootton,et al.  A review of three years experience using email and videoconferencing for the delivery of post-acute burns care to children in Queensland. , 2004, Burns : journal of the International Society for Burn Injuries.

[7]  Joseph P. Wherton,et al.  The organising vision for telehealth and telecare: discourse analysis , 2012, BMJ Open.

[8]  J. Mant Process versus outcome indicators in the assessment of quality of health care. , 2001, International journal for quality in health care : journal of the International Society for Quality in Health Care.

[9]  P Yellowlees,et al.  A community-based approach to evaluation of health outcomes and costs for telepsychiatry in a rural population: Preliminary results , 2000, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[10]  A. Kornberg,et al.  The introduction of web-based video-consultation in a paediatric acute care setting , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[11]  K. Nunn,et al.  Evaluating satisfaction with a child and adolescent psychological telemedicine outreach service , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[12]  Nigel R Armfield,et al.  Changes in paediatric hospital ENT service utilisation following the implementation of a mobile, indigenous health screening service , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[13]  Jozef Loermans,et al.  Evaluation of the Western Australian Department of Health telehealth project , 2005, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[14]  Richard Wootton,et al.  Paediatric telecardiology services in Queensland: A review of three years’ experience , 2004, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[15]  B. Biggs,et al.  Telehealth: experience of the first 120 consultations delivered from a new Refugee Telehealth clinic , 2014, Internal medicine journal.

[16]  R. Di Pietro Population density. , 1973, Science.

[17]  M. Bowater The experience of a rural general practitioner using videoconferencing for telemedicine , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[18]  S. Larkins,et al.  A tele-oncology model replacing face-to-face specialist cancer care: perspectives of patients in North Queensland , 2014, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[19]  Farhad Fatehi,et al.  Telemedicine for clinical management of diabetes – a process analysis of video consultations , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[20]  C. Rees,et al.  Education in cognitive-behavioural therapy for mental health professionals , 2009, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[21]  J. Wood,et al.  E-CYMHS: an expansion of a child and youth telepsychiatry model in Queensland , 2012, Australasian psychiatry : bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists.

[22]  Marg McGill,et al.  Integrating Telemedicine into a National Diabetes Footcare Network , 2000 .

[23]  P. Valery,et al.  Teleoncology for indigenous patients: the responses of patients and health workers. , 2012, The Australian journal of rural health.

[24]  P H Clarke,et al.  A referrer and patient evaluation of a telepsychiatry consultation–liaison service in South Australia , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[25]  Anthony Herbert,et al.  Home telehealth and paediatric palliative care: clinician perceptions of what is stopping us? , 2014, BMC Palliative Care.

[26]  N. Santamaria,et al.  Cleaning up. The development of the Alfred/Medseed Wound Imaging System. , 2000, Collegian.

[27]  J. Muir,et al.  Telehealth: the specialist perspective. , 2014, Australian family physician.

[28]  Geoff A. W. West,et al.  Evaluation of TELEDERM for dermatological services in rural and remote areas , 2008, Artif. Intell. Medicine.

[29]  The use of telemedicine to aid in assessing patients prior to aeromedical retrieval to a tertiary referral centre , 2008, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[30]  Nigel R Armfield,et al.  Clinical services and professional support: a review of mobile telepaediatric services in Queensland. , 2010, Studies in health technology and informatics.

[31]  Anthony Herbert,et al.  Home telemedicine for paediatric palliative care. , 2010, Studies in health technology and informatics.

[32]  P. Yellowlees,et al.  Telemedicine as a means of delivering cognitive-behavioural therapy to rural and remote mental health clients , 2006, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[33]  Richard Wootton,et al.  The use of online health techniques to assist with the delivery of specialist paediatric diabetes services in Queensland , 2003, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[34]  D. Dossetor,et al.  A child and adolescent psychiatric outreach service for rural New South Wales: A telemedicine pilot study , 1999, Journal of paediatrics and child health.

[35]  J. North,et al.  Teleconference fracture clinics: a trial for rural hospitals , 2012, ANZ journal of surgery.

[36]  S. Larkins,et al.  Telemedicine for rural cancer care in North Queensland: bringing cancer care home. , 2012, The Australian journal of rural health.

[37]  Gabriella Constantinescu Satisfaction with telemedicine for teaching listening and spoken language to children with hearing loss , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[38]  P. Trott,et al.  Cost evaluation of a telepsychiatry service in northern Queensland , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[39]  J. Gaglia,et al.  Considerations for Successful Encapsulated β-Cell Therapy , 2017 .

[40]  Richard Wootton,et al.  Telemedicine for rural and remote child and youth mental health services , 2005, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[41]  D. Cadilhac,et al.  Experience with scaling up the Victorian Stroke Telemedicine programme , 2014, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[42]  W. Cheng,et al.  Successful treatment of patients with hepatitis C in rural and remote Western Australia via telehealth , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[43]  Garth Herrington,et al.  A pilot trial of emergency telemedicine in regional Western Australia , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[44]  P. Yellowlees,et al.  The effectiveness of telepsychiatry measured using the Health of the Nation Outcome Scale and the Mental Health Inventory , 2003, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[45]  L. Flicker,et al.  The clinical achievements of a geriatric telehealth project in its first year. , 2002, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[46]  P. McGrath Technology-Based Patient Consultations: Research Findings from Haematology Patients in Regional, Rural and Remote Queensland , 2015, The Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research.

[47]  D. Eley,et al.  Barriers to the up-take of telemedicine in Australia--a view from providers. , 2011, Rural and remote health.

[48]  I. Olver,et al.  The use of videophones to enhance palliative care outreach nursing in remote areas , 2005 .

[49]  Leonard C Gray,et al.  Telemedicine across the ages , 2009, The Medical journal of Australia.

[50]  D. Lyle,et al.  Successful provision of emergency mental health care to rural and remote New South Wales: an evaluation of the Mental Health Emergency Care-Rural Access Program. , 2014, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[51]  Adrian G. Barnett,et al.  Using videotelephony to support paediatric oncology-related palliative care in the home: from abandoned RCT to acceptability study , 2009, Palliative medicine.

[52]  I. Olver,et al.  Evaluation of a telemedicine link between Darwin and Adelaide to facilitate cancer management. , 2000, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[53]  D. Eley,et al.  The reported benefits of telehealth for rural Australians. , 2010, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[54]  K. Leder,et al.  Improvements in patient care: videoconferencing to improve access to interpreters during clinical consultations for refugee and immigrant patients. , 2015, Australian health review : a publication of the Australian Hospital Association.

[55]  Telemedicine in neonatology: lessons from North Queensland. , 1998, The Australian journal of rural health.

[56]  P. Manuel A pilot study: A prospective, interventional study of the effectiveness of digital wound imaging, remote consultation and podiatry offloading devices on the healing rates of chronic lower extremity wounds in remote regions of Western Australia , 2012 .

[57]  D. Lyle,et al.  Assessing Program Efficiency: A Time and Motion Study of the Mental Health Emergency Care — Rural Access Program in NSW Australia , 2014, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[58]  Jozef Loermans,et al.  Telehealth in Western Australia: The challenge of evaluation , 2003, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[59]  Richard Monypenny,et al.  Cost savings from a telemedicine model of care in northern Queensland, Australia , 2013, The Medical journal of Australia.

[60]  H. Gelber The experience in Victoria with telepsychiatry for the child and adolescent mental health service , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[61]  F. Chan,et al.  Clinical value of real-time tertiary fetal ultrasound consultation by telemedicine: preliminary evaluation. , 2000, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[62]  P. Scuffham,et al.  Geriatric ward rounds by video conference: a solution for rural hospitals , 2009, The Medical journal of Australia.

[63]  J. Humphreys,et al.  Sustainable primary health care services in rural and remote areas: innovation and evidence. , 2011, The Australian journal of rural health.

[64]  Nigel R Armfield,et al.  Telemedicine ‐ is the cart being put before the horse? , 2014, The Medical journal of Australia.

[65]  Victoria Wade,et al.  The role of the champion in telehealth service development: a qualitative analysis , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[66]  R. Wootton Twenty years of telemedicine in chronic disease management – an evidence synthesis , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[67]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement , 2009, BMJ.

[68]  N A Blackwell,et al.  Telemedicine ophthalmology consultation in remote Queensland , 1997, The Medical journal of Australia.

[69]  Richard Wootton,et al.  The family costs of attending hospital outpatient appointments via videoconference and in person , 2003, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[70]  P. Scuffham,et al.  A break-even analysis of delivering a memory clinic by videoconferencing , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[71]  Natalie K. Bradford,et al.  Development of a state-wide pediatric palliative care service in Australia: referral and outcomes over two years. , 2014, Journal of palliative medicine.

[72]  M. Bensink,et al.  Telemedicine and rural health care applications. , 2005, Journal of postgraduate medicine.

[73]  Anthony Herbert,et al.  A pilot study of the effectiveness of home teleconsultations in paediatric palliative care , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[74]  N. Santamaria,et al.  The effectiveness of digital imaging and remote expert wound consultation on healing rates in chronic lower leg ulcers in the Kimberley region of Western Australia , 2004 .

[75]  F. Chan,et al.  Realtime fetal ultrasound by telemedicine in Queensland. A successful venture? , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[76]  J. Muir,et al.  Tele-dermatology in Australia. , 2008, Studies in health technology and informatics.

[77]  G. Leigh,et al.  Telepractice: The Australian Experience in an International Context. , 2012 .

[78]  Anthony C. Smith,et al.  Telehealth in paediatric orthopaedic surgery in Queensland: a 10‐year review , 2014, ANZ journal of surgery.

[79]  K Yogesan,et al.  Emergency eye care in rural Australia: role of internet , 2006, Eye.

[80]  I. Constable,et al.  Remote ophthalmology services: cost comparison of telemedicine and alternative service delivery options , 2006 .

[81]  D. Lyle,et al.  Responding to mental health emergencies: implementation of an innovative telehealth service in rural and remote new South Wales, Australia. , 2011, Journal of emergency nursing: JEN : official publication of the Emergency Department Nurses Association.

[82]  Richard Wootton,et al.  The costs and potential savings of a novel telepaediatric service in Queensland , 2007, BMC Health Services Research.

[83]  H. Soyer,et al.  Audit of a State-wide store and forward teledermatology service in Australia , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[84]  S. Jackson,et al.  Integrating telehealth services into a remote allied health service: A pilot study , 2017, The Australian journal of rural health.

[85]  B. Meiser,et al.  The virtual consultation: practitioners' experiences of genetic counseling by videoconferencing in Australia. , 2010, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[86]  Seyhan Yazar,et al.  Real-time teleophthalmology in rural Western Australia. , 2015, The Australian journal of rural health.

[87]  E. Ward,et al.  A pilot trial of a speech pathology telehealth service for head and neck cancer patients , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[88]  D. Lyle,et al.  Use of a mental health emergency care-rural access programme in emergency departments , 2014, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[89]  M. Buckman,et al.  Evaluation of Satisfaction of Parents With the Use of Videoconferencing for a Pediatric Genetic Consultation , 2011, Twin Research and Human Genetics.

[90]  K. Lessing,et al.  Mental health telemedicine programmes in Australia , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[91]  J. North,et al.  An analysis of an ongoing trial of rural videoconference fracture clinics , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[92]  Operational teledermatology in Broken Hill, rural Australia , 2005, The Australasian journal of dermatology.

[93]  D. Lyle,et al.  A transferable telepsychiatry model for improving access to emergency mental health care , 2014, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[94]  Justin Keen,et al.  Key challenges in the development and implementation of telehealth projects , 2011, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[95]  P. Yellowlees,et al.  Telemedicine--clinical applications in mental health. , 1995, Australian family physician.

[96]  H. Cook Historical keywords: health. , 2004, Lancet.

[97]  Penny Van Ast Supporting community carers via videoconferencing , 2005 .

[98]  J. Mitchell,et al.  Clinical applications of renal telemedicine , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[99]  Victoria Brazil,et al.  Education links between the Australian rural and tertiary emergency departments: Videoconference can support a virtual learning community , 2007, Emergency medicine Australasia : EMA.

[100]  R. D'Souza Telemedicine for intensive support of psychiatric inpatients admitted to local hospitals , 2000, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[101]  R. Wootton,et al.  Trial of low-cost teledermatology in primary care , 2004, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[102]  Richard Wootton,et al.  Wireless telemedicine for the delivery of specialist paediatric services to the bedside , 2005, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[103]  G. Burrows,et al.  An evaluation of the telepsychiatry programme in Victoria, Australia , 2000, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[104]  Bridgette Wessels,et al.  Examining the use of telehealth in community nursing: identifying the factors affecting frontline staff acceptance and telehealth adoption. , 2015, Journal of advanced nursing.

[105]  P. Scuffham,et al.  Queensland Parliament - Health and Community Services Committee Submission to the Inquiry into Telehealth Services in Queensland , 2014 .

[106]  H. Haines,et al.  Rural Victorian Telestroke project , 2012, Internal medicine journal.

[107]  Judy Williams,et al.  Realtime telemedicine for paediatric otolaryngology pre-admission screening , 2005, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[108]  S. Sabesan,et al.  Medical oncology clinics through videoconferencing: an acceptable telehealth model for rural patients and health workers , 2012, Internal medicine journal.

[109]  S. Weisser,et al.  Videoconferencing could reduce the number of mental health patients transferred from outlying facilities to a regional mental health unit , 2012, Australian and New Zealand journal of public health.

[110]  Natalie K. Bradford,et al.  Paediatric palliative care by video consultation at home: a cost minimisation analysis , 2014, BMC Health Services Research.

[111]  Julia Adler-Milstein,et al.  Telehealth among US hospitals: several factors, including state reimbursement and licensure policies, influence adoption. , 2014, Health affairs.

[112]  Richard Wootton,et al.  Adoption of telemedicine: from pilot stage to routine delivery , 2012, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[113]  S. Quilty,et al.  Telehealth in remote NT: bridging the gap , 2015, Medical Journal of Australia.

[114]  A. Prawira,et al.  Rural oncology: overcoming the tyranny of distance for improved cancer care. , 2014, Journal of oncology practice.

[115]  A. Springs NATIONAL STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK FOR RURAL AND REMOTE HEALTH: CONSULTATION WORKSHOP SCHEDULE AND ATTENDANCE , 2010 .

[116]  J. Jones,et al.  A systematic review of primary health care delivery models in rural and remote Australia 1993 - 2006 , 2006 .

[117]  S. Kavanagh,et al.  The fall and rise of the South Australian telepsychiatry network , 2001, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[118]  Anthony C. Smith,et al.  Teleconsultation from a secondary hospital for paediatric emergencies occurring at rural hospitals in Queensland , 2013, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[119]  P. Aitken,et al.  The use of telehealth to assist remote hospital resuscitation and aeromedical retrieval tasking: a 12-month case review , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[120]  J. Hiller,et al.  A qualitative study of ethical, medico-legal and clinical governance matters in Australian telehealth services , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[121]  P. Yellowlees,et al.  Telepsychiatry in South Australia , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[122]  P M Yellowlees,et al.  Evaluation of a pilot second-opinion child telepsychiatry service , 2004, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[123]  R. Ray,et al.  Palliative care professional education via video conference builds confidence to deliver palliative care in rural and remote locations , 2014, BMC Health Services Research.