Relative Effectiveness of Conditional and Unconditional Cash Transfers for Schooling Outcomes in Developing Countries: A Systematic Review

Increasing educational attainment around the world is one of the key aims of the Millennium Development Goals. Cash transfer programs, both conditional and unconditional, are a popular social protection tool in developing countries that aim, among other things, to improve education outcomes in developing countries. The debate over whether these programs should include conditions has been at the forefront of recent global policy discussions. This systematic review aims to complement the existing evidence on the effectiveness of these programs in improving schooling outcomes and help inform the debate surrounding the design of cash transfer programs. Our main objective was to assess the relative effectiveness of conditional and unconditional cash transfers in improving enrollment, attendance and test scores in developing countries. Our secondary objective was to understand the role of different dimensions of the cash transfer programs, particularly the role of the intensity of conditions and the effects of priming (with respect to the importance of children’s schooling) in cash transfer programs.

[1]  E. Edmonds,et al.  Poverty Alleviation and Child Labor , 2008 .

[2]  Fernando Borraz,et al.  Impact of the Uruguayan conditional cash transfer program , 2009 .

[3]  M. Asadullah,et al.  Reverse Gender Gap in Schooling in Bangladesh: Insights from Urban and Rural Households , 2009 .

[4]  D. Filmer,et al.  School Enrollment, Selection and Test Scores , 2009 .

[5]  M. Sanfilippo,et al.  INNOVATIVE FEATURES IN CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS: AN IMPACT EVALUATION OF CHILE SOLIDARIO ON HOUSEHOLDS AND CHILDREN , 2012 .

[6]  E. Duflo.  Grandmothers and Graddaughters: Old Age Pension and Intra-Household Allocation in South Africa , 2000 .

[7]  D. Coady,et al.  From Social Assistance to Social Development: Targeted Education Subsidies in Developing Countries , 2003 .

[8]  Emmanuel Skoufias,et al.  Conditional Cash Transfers and Their Impact on Child Work and Schooling: Evidence from the PROGRESA Program in Mexico , 2001 .

[9]  John Hoddinott,et al.  Must Conditional Cash Transfer Programs be Conditioned to be Effective? The Impact of Conditioning Transfers on School Enrollment in Mexico , 2009 .

[10]  J. Ohls,et al.  Evaluation of Jamaica's PATH conditional cash transfer programme , 2010 .

[11]  Mónica Yáñez-Pagans.  Culture and Human Capital Investments: Evidence of an Unconditional Cash Transfer Program in Bolivia , 2008, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[12]  J. Mohanty.  Education for All (EFA) , 1994 .

[13]  A. Janvry,et al.  Can conditional cash transfer programs serve as safety nets in keeping children at school and from working when exposed to shocks , 2006 .

[14]  S. PabloVillatoro.  Conditional cash transfer programmes: experiences from Latin America , 2005 .

[15]  M. Adato.  Combining survey and ethnographic methods to improve evaluation of conditional cash transfer programs , 2008 .

[16]  M. Gaarder.  Conditional versus unconditional cash: a commentary , 2012 .

[17]  E. Perova.  Three Essays on Intended and not Intended Impacts of Conditional Cash Transfers , 2010 .

[18]  A. Glassman,et al.  Conditional cash transfers and health: unpacking the causal chain , 2010 .

[19]  S. Rozelle,et al.  School Dropouts and Conditional Cash Transfers: Evidence from a Randomised Controlled Trial in Rural China's Junior High Schools , 2011 .

[20]  L. Hedges,et al.  Introduction to Meta‐Analysis , 2009, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[21]  H. Patrinos,et al.  Empowering Parents to Improve Education : Evidence from Rural Mexico , 2006 .

[22]  G. Teruel,et al.  EVALUATING CONDITIONAL SCHOOLING AND HEALTH PROGRAMS , 2007 .

[23]  J. Maluccio.  Education and Child Labor: Experimental Evidence from a Nicaraguan Conditional Cash Transfer Program , 2009 .

[24]  A. Bedi,et al.  The Impact of a Cash Transfer Program on Cognitive Achievement : The Bono de Desarrollo Humano of Ecuador , 2008 .

[25]  B. Barham,et al.  Women's Power, Conditional Cash Transfers, and Schooling in Nicaragua , 2007 .

[26]  C. Alviar,et al.  Cash Transfers for Vulnerable Children in Kenya: From Political Choice to Scale Up , 2009 .

[27]  Andrés Ham.  The Effect of Conditional Cash Transfers on Educational Opportunities - Experimental Evidence from Latin America , 2010 .

[28]  Jeffrey A. Smith,et al.  Heterogeneous Impacts in PROGRESA , 2008, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[29]  Carolyn J. Heinrich.  Demand and Supply-Side Determinants of Conditional Cash Transfer Program Effectiveness , 2007 .

[30]  S. Bradshaw,et al.  Women Beneficiaries or Women Bearing the Cost? A Gendered Analysis of the Red de Protección Social in Nicaragua , 2008 .

[31]  M. Coetzee.  Finding the Benefits: Estimating the Impact of the South African Child Support Grant , 2013 .

[32]  A. Dammert.  Heterogeneous impacts of conditional cash transfers : evidence from Nicaragua , 2008 .

[33]  O. Attanasio,et al.  Re-evaluating conditional cash transfers : is the Oportunidades primary school stipend necessary? , 2009 .

[34]  F. Bertranou,et al.  Semi‐Conditional Cash Transfers in the Form of Family Allowances for Children and Adolescents in the Informal Economy in Argentina , 2012 .

[35]  D. Filmer,et al.  Getting Girls into School: Evidence from a Scholarship Program in Cambodia , 2006, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[36]  P. Glewwe,et al.  Schools, Teachers, and Education Outcomes in Developing Countries Second Draft of Chapter for Handbook on the Economics of Education , 2005 .

[37]  A. Mccord,et al.  Systematic Review of the Impact of Employment Guarantee Schemes and Cash Transfers on the Poor , 2011 .

[38]  F. Bertranou,et al.  Semi-Conditional Cash Transfers in the Form of Family Allowances for Children and Adolescents in the Informal Economy in Argentina , 2011 .

[39]  Laura B. Rawlings,et al.  Evaluating the Impact of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Lessons from Latin America , 2003 .

[40]  Hai-Anh H. Dang,et al.  School Access, Resources, and Learning Outcomes: Evidence from a Non-Formal School Program in Bangladesh , 2011, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[41]  H. Patrinos.  Quality of Schooling, Returns to Schooling and the 1981 Vouchers Reform in Chile , 2008 .

[42]  Leigh L. Linden,et al.  Improving the Design of Conditional Transfer Programs: Evidence from a Randomized Education Experiment in Colombia † , 2011 .

[43]  A. Janvry,et al.  Making Conditional Cash Transfer Programs More Efficient , 2012 .

[44]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Schooling Impacts of Conditional Cash Transfers on Young Children: Evidence from Mexico , 2009, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[45]  N. Fuwa.  The Net Impact of the Female Secondary Stipend Program in Bangladesh , 2006 .

[46]  A. Janvry,et al.  Making Conditional Cash Transfer Programs More Efficient: Designing for Maximum Effect of the Conditionality , 2006 .

[47]  Jennifer Hill,et al.  The Impact of Conditional Cash Transfers on Children’s School Achievement: Evidence from Colombia , 2010 .

[48]  Eliana A. Cardoso,et al.  The Impact of Cash Transfers on Child Labor and School Enrollment in Brazil , 2009 .

[49]  L. H. Braido,et al.  AN IMPACT EVALUATION OF THE CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS TO EDUCATION UNDER PRAF: AN EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH , 2005 .

[50]  The Heterogeneous Impact of Conditional Cash Transfers , 2013 .

[51]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Are conditional cash transfers effective in urban areas? Evidence from Mexico , 2011, Education economics.

[52]  P. Glewwe,et al.  The impact of the Bolsa Escola/Familia conditional cash transfer program on enrollment, dropout rates and grade promotion in Brazil , 2012 .

[53]  F. Soares,et al.  Externality and Behavioural Change Effects of a Non-Randomised CCT Programme: Heterogeneous Impact on the Demand for Health and Education , 2011 .

[54]  R. Sparrow.  Protecting Education for the Poor in Times of Crisis: An Evaluation of a Scholarship Programme in Indonesia , 2004 .

[55]  S. Duryea,et al.  The Effect of Conditional Transfers on School Performance and Child Labor: Evidence from an Ex-Post Impact Evaluation in Costa Rica , 2004 .

[56]  Marta Rubio-Codina.  Intra-household time allocation in rural Mexico: Evidence from a randomized experiment , 2010 .

[57]  D. Gilligan,et al.  Using the regression discontinuity design with implicit partitions: The impacts of comunidades solidarias rurales on schooling in El Salvador , 2011 .

[58]  Carlos Lamarche.  Measuring the incentives to learn in Colombia using new quantile regression approaches , 2011 .

[59]  F. Devoto,et al.  Why do Beneficiaries Leave the Safety Net in Mexico? A Study of the Effects of Conditionality on Dropouts , 2008 .

[60]  J. Eaton,et al.  Effects of unconditional and conditional cash transfers on child health and development in Zimbabwe: a cluster-randomised trial , 2013, The Lancet.

[61]  Fernando M. Reimers,et al.  WHERE IS THE "EDUCATION" IN CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFERS IN EDUCATION? , 2006 .

[62]  Lant Pritchett,et al.  It's All About MeE: Using Structured Experiential Learning ('e') to Crawl the Design Space , 2013 .

[63]  J. Maluccio,et al.  Impact evaluation of a conditional cash transfer program: the Nicaraguan Red de Protección Social , 2004 .

[64]  D. Filmer,et al.  Own and Sibling Effects of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs : Theory and Evidence from Cambodia , 2009 .

[65]  R. Slavin.  Can Financial Incentives Enhance Educational Outcomes? Evidence from International Experiments. , 2009 .

[66]  V. Ponczek.  Income and bargaining effects on education and health in Brazil , 2010 .

[67]  E. Chirwa,et al.  The Short-Term Impacts of a Schooling Conditional Cash Transfer Program on the Sexual Behavior of Young Women , 2009, Health Economics.

[68]  Amer Hasan.  Gender-Targeted Conditional Cash Transfers: Enrollment, Spillover Effects and Instructional Quality , 2010 .

[69]  J. Hoddinott,et al.  Conditional Cash Transfers in Latin America , 2010 .

[70]  Laura Juárez,et al.  Grandfathers and Grandsons: SHould Transfers be Targeted to Women? , 2011 .

[71]  Christina H. Paxson,et al.  Does Money Matter? The Effects of Cash Transfers on Child Development in Rural Ecuador , 2010, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[72]  J. Maluccio,et al.  Does supply matter? Initial schooling conditions and the effectiveness of conditional cash transfers for grade progression in Nicaragua , 2010 .

[73]  S. Soares.  Bolsa Família, its design, its impacts and possibilities for the future , 2012 .

[74]  N. Chaudhury,et al.  Conditional Cash Transfers and Female Schooling: The Impact of the Female School Stipend Program on Public School Enrollments in Punjab, Pakistan , 2006 .

[75]  M. Adato,et al.  Social protection to support vulnerable children and families: the potential of cash transfers to protect education, health and nutrition , 2009, AIDS care.

[76]  E. Costello,et al.  Parents' Incomes and Children's Outcomes: A Quasi-Experiment , 2008, American economic journal. Applied economics.

[77]  Pierre Dubois,et al.  Effects on School Enrollment and Performance of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program in Mexico , 2012, Journal of Labor Economics.

[78]  B. Schubert,et al.  The impact of social cash transfers on children affected by HIV and AIDS -- Evidence from Zambia Malawi and South Africa. , 2007 .

[79]  F. Lund.  A step in the wrong direction: linking the South Africa Child Support Grant to school attendance , 2011 .

[80]  J. Behrman.  The International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and the Mexican PROGRESA anti-poverty and human resource investment conditional cash. , 2010 .

[81]  Raul Melo,et al.  Impacto do Programa Bolsa Família sobre a frequência escolar: o caso da agricultura familiar no Nordeste do Brasil , 2010 .

[82]  P. Winters,et al.  Conditionality and the Impact of Programme Design on Household welfare: Comparing two diverse cash transfer programmes in rural Mexico , 2002 .

[83]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Within-Family Program Effect Estimators: The Impact of Oportunidades on Schooling in Mexico , 2006 .

[84]  S. Khandker,et al.  Subsidy to Promote Girls' Secondary Education: The Female Stipend Program in Bangladesh , 2013 .

[85]  P. Winters,et al.  From protection to production: productive impacts of the Malawi Social Cash Transfer scheme , 2012 .

[86]  S. Baird,et al.  Examining the reliability of self-reported data on school participation , 2012 .

[87]  R. Vakis,et al.  Cash Transfers, Behavioral Changes, and Cognitive Development in Early Childhood: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment , 2008 .

[88]  C. Meghir,et al.  Education choices in Mexico: using a structural model and a randomized experiment to evaluate Progresa , 2010 .

[89]  E. Edmonds.  Child labor and schooling responses to anticipated income in South Africa , 2006 .

[90]  D. Filmer,et al.  Does more cash in conditional cash transfer programs always lead to larger impacts on school attendance , 2011 .

[91]  Anne Case,et al.  The reach and impact of Child Support Grants: evidence from KwaZulu-Natal , 2005 .

[92]  Niall Keleher,et al.  Conditional Cash Transfers: Reducing Present and Future Poverty , 2009 .

[93]  David Hulme,et al.  Just Give Money to the Poor: The Development Revolution from the Global South , 2010 .

[94]  F. Soares,et al.  Evaluating the Impact of Brazil's Bolsa Família: Cash Transfer Programs in Comparative Perspective , 2010, Latin American Research Review.

[95]  E. Fitzsimons,et al.  How effective are conditional cash transfers? Evidence from Colombia , 2005 .

[96]  D. de Walque,et al.  Cash Transfers and Child Schooling : Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation of the Role of Conditionality ∗ , 2013 .

[97]  Fabio Veras Soares,et al.  Achievements and Shortfalls of Conditional Cash Transfers: Impact Evaluation of Paraguay?s Tekoporã Programme , 2008 .

[98]  B. Barham,et al.  Conditional Cash Transfers, Shocks, and School Enrolment in Nicaragua , 2009 .

[99]  D. Carpio,et al.  ESSAYS ON CHILD LABOR AND POVERTY IN THE CONTEXT OF A CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFER PROGRAM IN NICARAGUA , 2010 .

[100]  I. Arráiz,et al.  Same Bureaucracy, Different Outcomes in Human Capital? How Indigenous and Rural Non-Indigenous Areas in Panama Responded to the CCT , 2011 .

[101]  Imran Rasul,et al.  Family Networks and School Enrolment: Evidence from a Randomized Social Experiment , 2009, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[102]  Diego A. Vera Cossio.  Enrollment and child labor in Bolivia , 2011 .

[103]  M. J. Williams,et al.  The Social and Economic Impacts of South Africa's Child Support Grant , 2010 .

[104]  B. Barham,et al.  The Coffee Crisis, Early Childhood Development, and Conditional Cash Transfers , 2011 .

[105]  L. Cameron.  Can a Public Scholarship Program Successfully Reduce School Drop-Outs in a Time of Economic Crisis? Evidence from Indonesia. , 2009 .

[106]  F. Bourguignon,et al.  Conditional cash transfers, schooling, and child labor : micro-simulating Brazil's bolsa escola program , 2003 .

[107]  E. Duflo.  Grandmothers and Granddaughters: Old-Age Pensions and Intrahousehold Allocation in South Africa , 2003 .

[108]  J. Baez,et al.  Does Cash for School Influence Young Women's Behavior in the Longer Term? Evidence from Pakistan , 2011, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[109]  J. Baez,et al.  Assessing the Long-Term Effects of Conditional Cash Transfers on Human Capital: Evidence from Colombia , 2011, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[110]  Norbert Schady,et al.  Cash Transfers, Conditions, and School Enrollment in Ecuador , 2008 .

[111]  Sarah Baird,et al.  Cash or Condition? Evidence from a Cash Transfer Experiment , 2010 .

[112]  H. Patrinos,et al.  Child Labor, School Attendance, and Indigenous Households: Evidence from Mexico , 2005 .

[113]  R. Slater.  Cash transfers, social protection and poverty reduction , 2011 .

[114]  M. Grosh,et al.  Assessing safety net readiness in response to food price volatility , 2011 .

[115]  P. Winters,et al.  The Effect of Early Interventions in Health and Nutrition on On-Time School Enrollment: Evidence from the Oportunidades Program in Rural Mexico , 2011, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[116]  Frederico Finan,et al.  Local Electoral Incentives and Decentralized Program Performance , 2010, Review of Economics and Statistics.

[117]  T. Tamasane,et al.  The quality of material care provided by grandparents for their orphaned grandchildren in the context of HIV/AIDS and poverty: a study of Kopanong municipality, Free State , 2010, SAHARA J : journal of Social Aspects of HIV/AIDS Research Alliance.

[118]  Jeremy G. Weber,et al.  Fair Trade-Organic Coffee Cooperatives, Migration, and Secondary Schooling in Southern Mexico , 2012 .

[119]  Luis Tejerina,et al.  Do We Know What Works? A Systematic Review of Impact Evaluations of Social Programs in Latin America and the Caribbean , 2007 .

[120]  Barb Bruns,et al.  Achieving Universal Primary Education by 2015: A Chance for Every Child , 2003 .

[121]  A. Janvry,et al.  Protecting Vulnerable Children from Uninsured Risks: Adapting Conditional Cash Transfer Programs to Provide Broader Safety Nets , 2008 .

[122]  T. Schultz.  SCHOOL SUBSIDIES FOR THE POOR: EVALUATING THE MEXICAN PROGRESA POVERTY PROGRAM , 2012 .

[123]  Niall Keleher,et al.  Conditional cash transfers : reducing present and future poverty - overview , 2009 .

[124]  T. Guthrie.  Assessing the impact of the Child Support Grant on the well-being of children in South Africa: a summary of available evidence , 2002 .

[125]  J. Raynor,et al.  The girls stipend program in Bangladesh. , 2006 .

[126]  A. Haines,et al.  Conditional cash transfers for improving uptake of health interventions in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review. , 2007, JAMA.

[127]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Assessing the Impact of a School Subsidy Program in Mexico: Using a Social Experiment to Validate a Dynamic Behavioral Model of Child Schooling and Fertility. , 2006, The American economic review.

[128]  H. Oosterbeek,et al.  The Impact of Cash Transfers on School Enrollment: Evidence from Ecuador , 2008 .

[129]  C. Ninno,et al.  SOCIAL ASSISTANCE SCHEMES ACROSS THE WORLD ELIGIBILITY CONDITIONS AND BENEFITS 1 , 2008 .

[130]  M. C. Cacciamali,et al.  Impactos do Programa Bolsa Família federal sobre o trabalho infantil e a frequência escolar , 2010 .

[131]  Rafael Lalive,et al.  Social Interactions and Schooling Decisions , 2006, The Review of Economics and Statistics.

[132]  E. Sadoulet,et al.  Educational Grants Closing the Gap in Schooling Attainment between Poor and Non-Poor , 2003 .

[133]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Long-term impacts of the oportunidades conditional cash transfer program on rural youth in Mexico , 2005 .

[134]  Petra E. Todd,et al.  Do Conditional Cash Transfers for Schooling Generate Lasting Benefits?: A Five-Year Followup of PROGRESA/Oportunidades , 2012 .

[135]  J. Streak.  Child poverty and the performance of the child support grant in South Africa , 2011 .

[136]  J. Saavedra,et al.  Impacts of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs on Educational Outcomes in Developing Countries , 2012 .

[137]  K. Macours,et al.  More Schooling and More Learning?: Effects of a Three-Year Conditional Cash Transfer Program in Nicaragua after 10 Years , 2013 .

[138]  E. Fitzsimons,et al.  Children’s Schooling and Work in the Presence of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program in Rural Colombia , 2010, Economic Development and Cultural Change.

[139]  A. Kassouf,et al.  The impact of conditional cash transfer programs on household work decisions in Brazil , 2010 .