Sensitivity to Change and Responsiveness of Four Balance Measures for Community-Dwelling Older Adults

Background Impaired balance has a significant negative impact on mobility, functional independence, and fall risk in older adults. Although several, well-respected balance measures are currently in use, there is limited evidence regarding the most appropriate measure to assess change in community-dwelling older adults. Objective The aim of this study was to compare floor and ceiling effects, sensitivity to change, and responsiveness across the following balance measures in community-dwelling elderly people with functional limitations: Berg Balance Scale (BBS), Performance-Oriented Mobility Assessment total scale (POMA-T), POMA balance subscale (POMA-B), and Dynamic Gait Index (DGI). Design Retrospective data from a 16-week exercise trial were used. Secondary analyses were conducted on the total sample and by subgroups of baseline functional limitation or baseline balance scores. Methods Participants were 111 community-dwelling older adults 65 years of age or older, with functional limitations. Sensitivity to change was assessed using effect size, standardized response mean, and paired t tests. Responsiveness was assessed using minimally important difference (MID) estimates. Results No floor effects were noted. Ceiling effects were observed on all measures, including in people with moderate to severe functional limitations. The POMA-T, POMA-B, and DGI showed significantly larger ceiling effects compared with the BBS. All measures had low sensitivity to change in total sample analyses. Subgroup analyses revealed significantly better sensitivity to change in people with lower compared with higher baseline balance scores. Although both the total sample and lower baseline balance subgroups showed statistically significant improvement from baseline to 16 weeks on all measures, only the lower balance subgroup showed change scores that consistently exceeded corresponding MID estimates. Limitations This study was limited to comparing 4 measures of balance, and anchor-based methods for assessing MID could not be reported. Conclusions Important limitations, including ceiling effects and relatively low sensitivity to change and responsiveness, were noted across all balance measures, highlighting their limited utility across the full spectrum of the community-dwelling elderly population. New, more challenging measures are needed for better discrimination of balance ability in community-dwelling elderly people at higher functional levels.

[1]  Jacob Cohen.  Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences , 1969, The SAGE Encyclopedia of Research Design.

[2]  M. Tinetti.  Performance‐Oriented Assessment of Mobility Problems in Elderly Patients , 1986, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[3]  Lewis E. Kazis,et al.  Effect Sizes for Interpreting Changes in Health Status , 1989, Medical care.

[4]  K. Berg.  Measuring balance in the elderly: preliminary development of an instrument , 1989 .

[5]  M. Liang,et al.  Comparisons of Five Health Status Instruments for Orthopedic Evaluation , 1990, Medical care.

[6]  B. E. Maki,et al.  Measuring balance in the elderly: validation of an instrument. , 1992, Canadian journal of public health = Revue canadienne de sante publique.

[7]  L. Ferrucci,et al.  A short physical performance battery assessing lower extremity function: association with self-reported disability and prediction of mortality and nursing home admission. , 1994, Journal of gerontology.

[8]  Reducing the Likelihood for Falls in the Elderly: The Effects of Exercise , 1994 .

[9]  R W Bohannon,et al.  Standing balance and function over the course of acute rehabilitation. , 1995, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[10]  D B Reuben,et al.  Screening for balance and mobility impairment in elderly individuals living in residential care facilities. , 1995, Physical therapy.

[11]  K. Norman,et al.  Functional assessment of balance and gait. , 1996, Clinics in geriatric medicine.

[12]  A. Shumway-cook,et al.  Predicting the probability for falls in community-dwelling older adults. , 1997, Physical therapy.

[13]  T. Ivanova,et al.  Postural responses to unilateral arm perturbation in young, elderly, and hemiplegic subjects. , 1997, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[14]  A. Shumway-cook,et al.  The effect of multidimensional exercises on balance, mobility, and fall risk in community-dwelling older adults. , 1997, Physical therapy.

[15]  P. Stratford,et al.  Sensitivity to change of the Roland-Morris Back Pain Questionnaire: part 2. , 1998, Physical therapy.

[16]  G H Guyatt,et al.  Sensitivity to change of the Roland-Morris Back Pain Questionnaire: part 1. , 1998, Physical therapy.

[17]  M. Liang.  Longitudinal Construct Validity: Establishment of Clinical Meaning in Patient Evaluative Instruments , 2000, Medical care.

[18]  C. Mecagni,et al.  Balance and ankle range of motion in community-dwelling women aged 64 to 87 years: a correlational study. , 2000, Physical therapy.

[19]  Suzanne G. Leveille,et al.  Lower extremity function and subsequent disability: consistency across studies, predictive models, and value of gait speed alone compared with the short physical performance battery. , 2000, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[20]  J. VanSwearingen,et al.  Making geriatric assessment work: selecting useful measures. , 2001, Physical therapy.

[21]  S L Luther,et al.  Fall risk assessment measures: an analytic review. , 2001, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[22]  Ack,et al.  LOWER-EXTREMITY FUNCTION IN PERSONS OVER THE AGE OF 70 YEARS AS A PREDICTOR OF SUBSEQUENT DISABILITY , 2001 .

[23]  L. Mollinger,et al.  Age- and gender-related test performance in community-dwelling elderly people: Six-Minute Walk Test, Berg Balance Scale, Timed Up & Go Test, and gait speeds. , 2002, Physical therapy.

[24]  Gordon H Guyatt,et al.  Methods to explain the clinical significance of health status measures. , 2002, Mayo Clinic proceedings.

[25]  M. Liang,et al.  Measuring Clinically Important Changes With Patient-Oriented Questionnaires , 2002, Medical care.

[26]  Ching-Fan Sheu,et al.  Analysis and Comparison of the Psychometric Properties of Three Balance Measures for Stroke Patients , 2002, Stroke.

[27]  D. Cella,et al.  What is a clinically meaningful change on the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Lung (FACT-L) Questionnaire? Results from Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) Study 5592. , 2002, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[28]  K. Gill-Body,et al.  Determinants of balance confidence in community-dwelling elderly people. , 2003, Physical therapy.

[29]  Scott D. Bennie,et al.  Measurements of Balance: Comparison of the Timed "Up and Go" Test and Functional Reach Test with the Berg Balance Scale , 2003 .

[30]  G. Norman,et al.  Interpretation of Changes in Health-related Quality of Life: The Remarkable Universality of Half a Standard Deviation , 2003, Medical care.

[31]  Karen W. Hayes,et al.  Measures of adult general performance tests: The Berg Balance Scale, Dynamic Gait Index (DGI), Gait Velocity, Physical Performance Test (PPT), Timed Chair Stand Test, Timed Up and Go, and Tinetti Performance‐Oriented Mobility Assessment (POMA) , 2003 .

[32]  L. K. Boulgarides,et al.  Use of clinical and impairment-based tests to predict falls by community-dwelling older adults. , 2003, Physical therapy.

[33]  D. Neuberg,et al.  A combination of distribution- and anchor-based approaches determined minimally important differences (MIDs) for four endpoints in a breast cancer scale. , 2004, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[34]  P. Stratford,et al.  The evaluation of change in pain intensity: a comparison of the P4 and single-item numeric pain rating scales. , 2004, The Journal of orthopaedic and sports physical therapy.

[35]  S. Fritz,et al.  Rating scale analysis of the Berg Balance Scale. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[36]  R. Eastell,et al.  Clinical performance of immunoreactive tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase isoform 5b as a marker of bone resorption. , 2004, Bone.

[37]  Daniel L Riddle,et al.  Assessing sensitivity to change: choosing the appropriate change coefficient , 2005, Health and quality of life outcomes.

[38]  L. Mollinger,et al.  Age‐ and Gender‐related Test Performance in Community‐dwelling Adults , 2005, Journal of neurologic physical therapy : JNPT.

[39]  Yi-Po Chiu,et al.  Use of item response analysis to investigate measurement properties and clinical validity of data for the dynamic gait index. , 2006, Physical therapy.

[40]  S. Haley,et al.  Interpreting change scores of tests and measures used in physical therapy. , 2006, Physical therapy.

[41]  Marjan J Faber,et al.  Clinimetric properties of the performance-oriented mobility assessment. , 2006, Physical therapy.

[42]  L. Rubenstein.  Falls in older people: epidemiology, risk factors and strategies for prevention. , 2006, Age and ageing.

[43]  R. Francis,et al.  Low bone mineral density measurements in care home residents--a treatable cause of fractures. , 2006, Age and ageing.

[44]  Lenny D. Wiersma,et al.  Development of a multidimensional balance scale for use with functionally independent older adults. , 2006, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[45]  M. Woollacott,et al.  Motor Control: Translating Research into Clinical Practice , 2006 .

[46]  T E Howe,et al.  Exercise for improving balance in older people. , 2007, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[47]  Kristine Votova,et al.  Multifactorial and functional mobility assessment tools for fall risk among older adults in community, home-support, long-term and acute care settings. , 2007, Age and ageing.

[48]  Diane D Allen,et al.  Responsiveness of the Movement Ability Measure: A Self-Report Instrument Proposed for Assessing the Effectiveness of Physical Therapy Intervention , 2007, Physical Therapy.

[49]  R. Hays,et al.  Recommended methods for determining responsiveness and minimally important differences for patient-reported outcomes. , 2008, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[50]  S. Alibhai,et al.  Development, Implementation, and Evaluation of an Interprofessional Falls Prevention Program for Older Adults , 2008, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[51]  Sarah E Lamb,et al.  Systematic review of accuracy of screening instruments for predicting fall risk among independently living older adults. , 2008, Journal of rehabilitation research and development.

[52]  M. Roller,et al.  Multifactorial Intervention with Balance Training as a Core Component Among Fall‐prone Older Adults , 2009, Journal of geriatric physical therapy.

[53]  W. Frontera,et al.  Increased velocity exercise specific to task training versus the National Institute on Aging's strength training program: changes in limb power and mobility. , 2009, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[54]  Jeffrey M. Hausdorff,et al.  The Dynamic Gait Index in healthy older adults: the role of stair climbing, fear of falling and gender. , 2009, Gait & posture.

[55]  S. Bandinelli,et al.  Use of the Short Physical Performance Battery Score to predict loss of ability to walk 400 meters: analysis from the InCHIANTI study. , 2009, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[56]  E. Stokes,et al.  How much change is true change? The minimum detectable change of the Berg Balance Scale in elderly people. , 2009, Journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[57]  Imre Cikajlo,et al.  Development of an objective balance assessment method for purposes of telemonitoring and telerehabilitation in elderly population , 2010, Disability and rehabilitation.

[58]  Mark Speechley,et al.  Quantifying the magnitude of risk for balance impairment on falls in community-dwelling older adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2010, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[59]  Wen-Chung Wang,et al.  Development of a Computerized Adaptive Test for Assessing Balance Function in Patients With Stroke , 2010, Physical Therapy.

[60]  Community-dwelling older adults with balance impairment show a moderate increase in fall risk, although further research is required to refine how balance measurement can be used in clinical practice , 2010, Evidence Based Nursing.

[61]  P. Stratford,et al.  Baseline Dependency of Minimal Clinically Important Improvement , 2011, Physical Therapy.