Can We Explain Heterogeneity Among Randomized Clinical Trials of Exercise for Chronic Back Pain? A Meta-Regression Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials

Background Exercise programs may vary in terms of duration, frequency, and dosage; whether they are supervised; and whether they include a home-based program. Uncritical pooling of heterogeneous exercise trials may result in misleading conclusions regarding the effects of exercise on chronic low back pain (CLBP). Purpose The purpose of this study was to establish the effect of exercise on pain and disability in patients with CLBP, with a major aim of explaining between-trial heterogeneity. Data Sources Six databases were searched up to August 2008 using a computerized search strategy. Study Selection Eligible studies needed to be randomized clinical trials evaluating the effects of exercise for nonspecific CLBP. Outcomes of interest were pain and disability measured on a continuous scale. Data Extraction Baseline demographic data, exercise features, and outcome data were extracted from all included trials. Data Synthesis Univariate meta-regressions were conducted to assess the associations between exercise effect sizes and 8 study-level variables: baseline severity of symptoms, number of exercise hours and sessions, supervision, individual tailoring, cognitive-behavioral component, intention-to-treat analysis, and concealment of allocation. Limitations Only study-level characteristics were included in the meta-regression analyses. Therefore, the implications of the findings should not be used to differentiate the likelihood of the effect of exercise based on patient characteristics. Conclusions The results show that, in general, when all types of exercise are analyzed, small but significant reductions in pain and disability are observed compared with minimal care or no treatment. Despite many possible sources of heterogeneity in exercise trials, only dosage was found to be significantly associated with effect sizes.

[1]  J. Higgins,et al.  Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions , 2010, International Coaching Psychology Review.

[2]  J. Freburger,et al.  Exercise prescription for chronic back or neck pain: who prescribes it? who gets it? What is prescribed? , 2009, Arthritis and rheumatism.

[3]  Y. Matsuyama,et al.  The Effect of Muscle Relaxant on the Paraspinal Muscle Blood Flow: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain , 2008, Spine.

[4]  D. Stott,et al.  A prospective study of patients with chronic back pain randomised to group exercise, physiotherapy or osteopathy , 2008 .

[5]  J. Knottnerus,et al.  Chronic low back pain: Physical training, graded activity with problem solving training, or both? The one-year post-treatment results of a randomized controlled trial , 2008, PAIN.

[6]  K. Refshauge,et al.  Comparison of general exercise, motor control exercise and spinal manipulative therapy for chronic low back pain: A randomized trial , 2007, Pain.

[7]  David J Torgerson,et al.  Active Exercise, Education, and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Persistent Disabling Low Back Pain: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2007, Spine.

[8]  V. Vad,et al.  The role of the Back Rx exercise program in diskogenic low back pain: a prospective randomized trial. , 2007, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[9]  L. A. Machado,et al.  Client-centered therapy vs exercise therapy for chronic low back pain: a pilot randomized controlled trial in Brazil. , 2007, Pain medicine.

[10]  P. Malliou,et al.  A Pilot Study of the Effects of High-Intensity Aerobic Exercise Versus Passive Interventions on Pain, Disability, Psychological Strain, and Serum Cortisol Concentrations in People With Chronic Low Back Pain , 2007, Physical Therapy.

[11]  K. Mohammad,et al.  Low back pain education and short term quality of life: a randomized trial , 2007, BMC musculoskeletal disorders.

[12]  V. Gladwell,et al.  Does a program of pilates improve chronic non-specific low back pain? , 2006 .

[13]  N. Foster,et al.  Re: Goldby LJ, Moore AP, Doust J, Trew ME. A randomised controlled trial investigating the efficiency of musculoskeletal physiotherapy on chronic low back disorder. Spine 2006;31:1083-93. , 2006, Spine.

[14]  N. Foster,et al.  Randomized Controlled Trial of Specific Spinal Stabilization Exercises and Conventional Physiotherapy for Recurrent Low Back Pain , 2006, Spine.

[15]  E. Kellis,et al.  Effects of two 4-week proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation programs on muscle endurance, flexibility, and functional performance in women with chronic low back pain. , 2006, Physical therapy.

[16]  A. Patwardhan,et al.  A randomized clinical trial and subgroup analysis to compare flexion–distraction with active exercise for chronic low back pain , 2006, European Spine Journal.

[17]  A. Moore,et al.  A Randomized Controlled Trial Investigating the Efficiency of Musculoskeletal Physiotherapy on Chronic Low Back Disorder , 2006, Spine.

[18]  H. Ursin,et al.  Chapter 4 European guidelines for the management of chronic nonspecific low back pain , 2006, European Spine Journal.

[19]  J. Twisk,et al.  The Effects of a Graded Activity Intervention for Low Back Pain in Occupational Health on Sick Leave, Functional Status and Pain: 12-Month Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial , 2005, Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation.

[20]  R. Collins,et al.  Randomised controlled trial to compare surgical stabilisation of the lumbar spine with an intensive rehabilitation programme for patients with chronic low back pain: the MRC spine stabilisation trial , 2005, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[21]  George Tomlinson,et al.  Systematic Review: Strategies for Using Exercise Therapy To Improve Outcomes in Chronic Low Back Pain , 2005, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[22]  Jeremy S. Lewis,et al.  A Randomized Clinical Trial Comparing Two Physiotherapy Interventions for Chronic Low Back Pain , 2005, Spine.

[23]  M. Shaughnessy,et al.  A pilot study to investigate the effect of lumbar stabilisation exercise training on functional ability and quality of life in patients with chronic low back pain , 2004, International journal of rehabilitation research. Internationale Zeitschrift fur Rehabilitationsforschung. Revue internationale de recherches de readaptation.

[24]  O. Hägg,et al.  Re: Brox JI, Sörensen R, Friis A, et al. Randomized clinical trial of lumbar instrumented fusion and cognitive intervention and exercises in patients with chronic low back pain and disc degeneration. Spine. 2003; 28:1913-1921. , 2004, Spine.

[25]  Maarten J. IJzerman,et al.  Differences in outcome of a multidisciplinary treatment between subgroups of chronic low back pain patients defined using two multiaxial assessment instruments: the Multidimensional Pain Inventory and lumbar dynamometry , 2004, Clinical rehabilitation.

[26]  Malcolm H Parker.  Homocysteine and vitamin status in older people in Perth , 2004, The Medical journal of Australia.

[27]  J. Farrar,et al.  The impact of modified Hatha yoga on chronic low back pain: a pilot study. , 2004, Alternative therapies in health and medicine.

[28]  P. Glasziou,et al.  Prolotherapy Injections, Saline Injections, and Exercises for Chronic Low-Back Pain: A Randomized Trial , 2004, Spine.

[29]  D. Altman,et al.  Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[30]  Inger Holm,et al.  Randomized Clinical Trial of Lumbar Instrumented Fusion and Cognitive Intervention and Exercises in Patients with Chronic Low Back Pain and Disc Degeneration , 2003, Spine.

[31]  K. Refshauge,et al.  Acute low back pain: systematic review of its prognosis , 2003, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[32]  Catherine Sherrington,et al.  Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials. , 2003, Physical therapy.

[33]  Andrea Furlan,et al.  Updated Method Guidelines for Systematic Reviews in the Cochrane Collaboration Back Review Group , 2003, Spine.

[34]  K. Nas,et al.  Efficacy of low power laser therapy and exercise on pain and functions in chronic low back pain , 2003, Lasers in surgery and medicine.

[35]  L. Vismara,et al.  Controlled study on the efficacy of two different treatments in obese patients affected by chronic low back pain, assessed by an isokinetic device: Analysis of muscle strength and spine mobility , 2002 .

[36]  D. Felsenberg,et al.  Treatment of Chronic Lower Back Pain with Lumbar Extension and Whole-Body Vibration Exercise: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2002, Spine.

[37]  Theo Stijnen,et al.  Advanced methods in meta‐analysis: multivariate approach and meta‐regression , 2002, Statistics in medicine.

[38]  H. Möller,et al.  Surgery versus conservative management in adult isthmic spondylolisthesis--a prospective randomized study: part 1. , 2000, Spine.

[39]  B. Koes,et al.  Exercise therapy for low back pain. , 2000, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[40]  Anne-Marie Hassenkamp,et al.  Active Rehabilitation for Chronic Low Back Pain , 2000 .

[41]  O. Airaksinen,et al.  The efficacy of active rehabilitation in chronic low back pain. Effect on pain intensity, self-experienced disability, and lumbar fatigability. , 1999, Spine.

[42]  R. Gatchel,et al.  Percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation for low back pain: a randomized crossover study. , 1999, JAMA.

[43]  Gordon Waddell,et al.  The Back Pain Revolution , 1998 .

[44]  Garry T. Allison,et al.  Evaluation of Specific Stabilizing Exercise in the Treatment of Chronic Low Back Pain With Radiologic Diagnosis of Spondylolysis or Spondylolisthesis , 1997, Spine.

[45]  J. Fairbank,et al.  Randomised controlled trial for evaluation of fitness programme for patients with chronic low back pain , 1995, BMJ.

[46]  M. Pollock,et al.  Lumbar Strengthening in Chronic Low Back Pain Patients|Physiologic and Psychological Benefits , 1993, Spine.

[47]  J. Turner,et al.  Effectiveness of behavioral therapy for chronic low back pain: a component analysis. , 1990, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[48]  R A Deyo,et al.  A controlled trial of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) and exercise for chronic low back pain. , 1990, The New England journal of medicine.

[49]  H. Hurri,et al.  The Swedish back school in chronic low back pain. Part I. Benefits. , 1989, Scandinavian journal of rehabilitation medicine.

[50]  N. D. de Morton.  The PEDro scale is a valid measure of the methodological quality of clinical trials: a demographic study. , 2009, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[51]  F. Jennings,et al.  Effectiveness of a back school program in low back pain. , 2008, Clinical and experimental rheumatology.

[52]  R. D. de Bie,et al.  A high-intensity lumbar extensor strengthening program is little better than a low-intensity program or a waiting list control group for chronic low back pain: a randomised clinical trial. , 2008, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[53]  G. E. Djavid,et al.  In chronic low back pain, low level laser therapy combined with exercise is more beneficial than exercise alone in the long term: a randomised trial. , 2007, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[54]  Ville Leinonen,et al.  Dynamic surface electromyographic responses in chronic low back pain treated by traditional bone setting and conventional physical therapy. , 2007, Journal of manipulative and physiological therapeutics.

[55]  Rob J. E. M. Smeets.  Active rehabilitation for chronic low back pain: cognitive-behavioral, physical, or both? , 2006 .

[56]  A. Bakhtiary,et al.  Lumbar stabilizing exercises improve activities of daily living in patients with lumbar disc herniation , 2005 .

[57]  R. Herbert.  How to estimate treatment effects from reports of clinical trials. II: Dichotomous outcomes. , 2000, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[58]  R. Herbert.  How to estimate treatment effects from reports of clinical trials. I: Continuous outcomes. , 2000, The Australian journal of physiotherapy.

[59]  V. Robertson,et al.  A Randomised Controlled Study of the Outcome of Hydrotherapy for Subjects with Low Back or Back and Leg Pain , 1998 .