Agent-Based Social Simulation of the Covid-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review

When planning interventions to limit the spread of Covid-19, the current state of knowledge about the disease and specific characteristics of the population need to be considered. Simulations can facilitate policy making as they take prevailing circumstances into account. Moreover, they allow for the investigation of the potential effects of different interventions using an artificial population. Agent-based Social Simulation (ABSS) is argued to be particularly useful as it can capture the behavior of and interactions between individuals. We performed a systematic literature reviewand identified 126 articles that describe ABSS of Covid-19 transmission processes. Our reviewshowed that ABSS is widely used for investigating the spread of Covid-19. Existing models are very heterogeneous with respect to their purpose, the number of simulated individuals, and the modeled geographical region, as well as how they model transmission dynamics, disease states, human behavior, and interventions. To this end, a discrepancy can be identified between the needs of policy makers and what is implemented by the simulation models. This also includes how thoroughly the models consider and represent the real world, e.g. in terms of factors that affect the transmission probability or how humans make decisions. Shortcomingswere also identified in the transparency of the presented models, e.g. in terms of documentation or availability, as well as in their validation, which might limit their suitability for supporting decision-making processes. We discuss how these issues can be mitigated to further establish ABSS as a powerful tool for crisis management.

[1]  M. Lurgi,et al.  COVID-19 containment policies through time may cost more lives at metapopulation level , 2020, medRxiv.

[2]  Ganna Rozhnova,et al.  Impact of delays on effectiveness of contact tracing strategies for COVID-19: a modelling study , 2020, The Lancet Public Health.

[3]  C. Bauch,et al.  Local lockdowns outperform global lockdown on the far side of the COVID-19 epidemic curve , 2020, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[4]  Julie S. Ivy,et al.  High-Quality Masks Reduce COVID-19 Infections and Deaths in the US , 2020, 2021 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC).

[5]  Aditya Gopalan,et al.  How Reliable are Test Numbers for Revealing the COVID-19 Ground Truth and Applying Interventions? , 2020, Journal of the Indian Institute of Science.

[6]  P. Klepac,et al.  Feasibility of controlling COVID-19 outbreaks by isolation of cases and contacts , 2020, The Lancet Global Health.

[7]  M. C. Torres,et al.  Transmission of Respiratory Infectious Diseases between Neighboring Cities using Agent-based Model and Compartmental Model , 2020, medRxiv.

[8]  Jean-Marc Schwartz,et al.  Why COVID-19 models should incorporate the network of social interactions , 2020, Physical biology.

[9]  Mofeng Yang,et al.  Modeling indoor-level non-pharmaceutical interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic: A pedestrian dynamics-based microscopic simulation approach , 2020, Transport Policy.

[10]  Alberto Bisin,et al.  Spatial-SIR with Network Structure and Behavior: Lockdown Rules and the Lucas Critique , 2021, 2103.13789.

[11]  G. Milne,et al.  The Effectiveness of Social Distancing in Mitigating COVID-19 Spread: a modelling analysis , 2020, medRxiv.

[12]  Mikko Kolehmainen,et al.  An agent-based epidemic model REINA for COVID-19 to identify destructive policies , 2020, medRxiv.

[13]  Moritz Wagner,et al.  Using contact data to model the impact of contact tracing and physical distancing to control the SARS-CoV-2 outbreak in Kenya , 2020, Wellcome Open Research.

[14]  Francesco Ciari,et al.  Modeling the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Sensitivity Analysis on Input Data Using Agent-Based Transportation Simulation , 2020 .

[15]  J. Lewnard,et al.  The effect of school closures and reopening strategies on COVID-19 infection dynamics in the San Francisco Bay Area: a cross-sectional survey and modeling analysis , 2020, medRxiv.

[16]  K. Sneppen,et al.  Cost–benefit of limited isolation and testing in COVID-19 mitigation , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[17]  M. Tertilt,et al.  An Economic Model of the Covid-19 Epidemic: The Importance of Testing and Age-Specific Policies , 2020, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[18]  Navid Hooshangi,et al.  Spatio-temporal simulation of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak using the agent-based modeling approach (case study: Urmia, Iran) , 2020, Informatics in Medicine Unlocked.

[19]  Woo-Sik Son,et al.  Intervention effects in the transmission of COVID-19 depending on the detection rate and extent of isolation , 2020, Epidemiology and health.

[20]  A. Karaivanov A social network model of COVID-19 , 2020, PloS one.

[21]  Panos Louvieris,et al.  FACS: A geospatial agent-based simulator for analysing COVID-19 spread and public health measures on local regions , 2020, J. Simulation.

[22]  Robert L. Axtell,et al.  Aligning simulation models: A case study and results , 1996, Comput. Math. Organ. Theory.

[23]  Basim Mahmood,et al.  The Pandemic COVID-19 Infection Spreading Spatial Aspects: A Network-Based Software Approach , 2020 .

[24]  S. Moghadas,et al.  Simulating the effect of school closure during COVID-19 outbreaks in Ontario, Canada , 2020, BMC Medicine.

[25]  Nicole Eikmeier,et al.  Modeling COVID-19 spread in small colleges , 2020, PloS one.

[26]  Co-Pierre Georg,et al.  SABCoM: A Spatial Agent-Based Covid-19 Model , 2020, medRxiv.

[27]  Alexander V. Mantzaris,et al.  Investigating dynamics of COVID-19 spread and containment with agent-based modeling , 2020, medRxiv.

[28]  Benoit Gaudou,et al.  COMOKIT: A Modeling Kit to Understand, Analyze, and Compare the Impacts of Mitigation Policies Against the COVID-19 Epidemic at the Scale of a City , 2020, Frontiers in Public Health.

[29]  M. Racko,et al.  A stochastic, individual-based model for the evaluation of the impact of non-pharmacological interventions on COVID-19 transmission in Slovakia , 2020, medRxiv.

[30]  M. Olfson,et al.  Facing the COVID-19 epidemic in NYC: a stochastic agent-based model of various intervention strategies , 2020, medRxiv.

[31]  S. Maslov,et al.  Entry screening and multi-layer mitigation of COVID-19 cases for a safe university reopening , 2020, medRxiv.

[32]  Peter Norvig,et al.  Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach , 1995 .

[33]  Jeisson Prieto,et al.  INFEKTA: A General Agent-based Model for Transmission of Infectious Diseases: Studying the COVID-19 Propagation in Bogotá - Colombia , 2020, medRxiv.

[34]  A. Ansari,et al.  Mechanistic modelling of coronavirus infections and the impact of confined neighbourhoods on a short time scale , 2020, medRxiv.

[35]  Paul Davidsson,et al.  Agent Based Social Simulation: A Computer Science View , 2002, J. Artif. Soc. Soc. Simul..

[36]  H. Pathan,et al.  Simulation Study on Effect of Lockdown and Recovery Time on Spread of COVID-19 in High and Low-Density Areas , 2020 .

[37]  Thanh Thi Nguyen,et al.  Artificial Intelligence in the Battle against Coronavirus (COVID-19): A Survey and Future Research Directions , 2020, ArXiv.

[38]  Timothy Churches,et al.  Flexible, Freely Available Stochastic Individual Contact Model for Exploring COVID-19 Intervention and Control Strategies: Development and Simulation , 2020, JMIR public health and surveillance.

[39]  M. Weinstein,et al.  Clinical Impact, Costs, and Cost-Effectiveness of Expanded SARS-CoV-2 Testing in Massachusetts , 2020, medRxiv.

[40]  Claes Wohlin,et al.  Guidelines for snowballing in systematic literature studies and a replication in software engineering , 2014, EASE '14.

[41]  Nigel Gilbert,et al.  Simulation: A New Way of Doing Social Science , 1999 .

[42]  Attayeb Mohsen,et al.  The impact of community containment implementation timing on the spread of COVID-19: A simulation study , 2020, F1000Research.

[43]  Claus Beisbart,et al.  What is Validation of Computer Simulations? Toward a Clarification of the Concept of Validation and of Related Notions , 2019, Simulation Foundations, Methods and Applications.

[44]  Anass Bouchnita,et al.  A hybrid multi-scale model of COVID-19 transmission dynamics to assess the potential of non-pharmaceutical interventions , 2020, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals.

[45]  A Barrat,et al.  Digital proximity tracing on empirical contact networks for pandemic control , 2021, Nature Communications.

[46]  Fred Brauer,et al.  Compartmental Models in Epidemiology , 2008, Mathematical Epidemiology.

[47]  Ben Adlam,et al.  Dynamics of COVID-19 under social distancing measures are driven by transmission network structure , 2021, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[48]  C. Faes,et al.  A data-driven metapopulation model for the Belgian COVID-19 epidemic: assessing the impact of lockdown and exit strategies , 2020, BMC Infectious Diseases.

[49]  A. Fogli,et al.  Pandemic Control in ECON-EPI Networks , 2020, medRxiv.

[50]  Peter Bazan,et al.  Modeling Exit Strategies from COVID-19 Lockdown with a Focus on Antibody Tests , 2020, medRxiv.

[51]  E. Klipp,et al.  Geospatial precision simulations of community confined human interactions during SARS-CoV-2 transmission reveals bimodal intervention outcomes , 2020 .

[52]  M. Lipsitch,et al.  Individual quarantine versus active monitoring of contacts for the mitigation of COVID-19: a modelling study , 2020, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[53]  Rajeev Rastogi,et al.  CRISP: A Probabilistic Model for Individual-Level COVID-19 Infection Risk Estimation Based on Contact Data , 2020, ArXiv.

[54]  Haoyang Sun,et al.  Interventions to mitigate early spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Singapore: a modelling study , 2020, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[55]  G. Giacopelli A full-scale agent-based model of Lombardy COVID-19 dynamics to explore social networks connectivity and vaccine impact on epidemic , 2020, medRxiv.

[56]  Lander Willem,et al.  Intervention strategies against COVID-19 and their estimated impact on Swedish healthcare capacity , 2020, medRxiv.

[57]  Anna Rotkirch,et al.  Universal Masking is Urgent in the COVID-19 Pandemic: SEIR and Agent Based Models, Empirical Validation, Policy Recommendations , 2020, ArXiv.

[58]  Rajnikant Sharma,et al.  Modeling and Simulation of COVID-19 Pandemic for Cincinnati Tri-State Area , 2020, ArXiv.

[59]  Matthieu Nadini,et al.  A multi-agent model to study epidemic spreading and vaccination strategies in an urban-like environment , 2020, Appl. Netw. Sci..

[60]  Leonardo F. S. Scabini,et al.  Social interaction layers in complex networks for the dynamical epidemic modeling of COVID-19 in Brazil , 2020, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications.

[61]  D. Naimark,et al.  Estimation of COVID-19–induced depletion of hospital resources in Ontario, Canada , 2020, Canadian Medical Association Journal.

[62]  Huafeng Li,et al.  A data-driven network model for the emerging COVID-19 epidemics in Wuhan, Toronto and Italy , 2020, Mathematical Biosciences.

[63]  Devabhaktuni Srikrishna,et al.  Modeling layered non-pharmaceutical interventions against SARS-CoV-2 in the United States with Corvid , 2020, medRxiv.

[64]  Mikhail Prokopenko,et al.  Revealing COVID-19 transmission in Australia by SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing and agent-based modeling , 2020, Nature Medicine.

[65]  Vitor M. Marquioni,et al.  Quantifying the effects of quarantine using an IBM SEIR model on scalefree networks , 2020, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals.

[66]  Marco Cremonini,et al.  The Unknown of the Pandemic: An Agent-Based Model of Final Phase Risks , 2020, J. Artif. Soc. Soc. Simul..

[67]  Nilanjan Dey,et al.  Forecasting Models for Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19): A Survey of the State-of-the-Art , 2020, SN Computer Science.

[68]  Radu Marculescu,et al.  Centralized and decentralized isolation strategies and their impact on the COVID-19 pandemic dynamics , 2020, ArXiv.

[69]  Benno Liebchen,et al.  Strategic spatiotemporal vaccine distribution increases the survival rate in an infectious disease like Covid-19 , 2020, Scientific reports.

[70]  Yuan Zhang,et al.  Physical distancing, face masks, and eye protection to prevent person-to-person transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis , 2020, The Lancet.

[71]  Carlo Vercellis,et al.  CoV-ABM: A stochastic discrete-event agent-based framework to simulate spatiotemporal dynamics of COVID-19 , 2020, ArXiv.

[72]  H. Situngkir The Pandemics in Artificial Society: Agent-Based Model to Reflect Strategies on COVID-19 , 2020, medRxiv.

[73]  J.S. Carson,et al.  Model verification and validation , 2002, Proceedings of the Winter Simulation Conference.

[74]  C. Bhattacharyya,et al.  Suppress, and Not Just Flatten: Strategies for Rapid Suppression of COVID19 Transmission in Small World Communities , 2020, Journal of the Indian Institute of Science.

[75]  Juan-Carlos Cano,et al.  Evaluating How Smartphone Contact Tracing Technology Can Reduce the Spread of Infectious Diseases: The Case of COVID-19 , 2020, IEEE Access.

[76]  R. Oidtman,et al.  Impacts of K-12 school reopening on the COVID-19 epidemic in Indiana, USA , 2020, Epidemics.

[77]  Isabel J. Raabe,et al.  Social network-based distancing strategies to flatten the COVID-19 curve in a post-lockdown world , 2020, Nature Human Behaviour.

[78]  Stewart T. Chang,et al.  Covasim: An agent-based model of COVID-19 dynamics and interventions , 2020, medRxiv.

[79]  Christel Faes,et al.  The impact of contact tracing and household bubbles on deconfinement strategies for COVID-19 , 2020, Nature Communications.

[80]  C. Buckee,et al.  Variation in human mobility and its impact on the risk of future COVID-19 outbreaks in Taiwan , 2020, medRxiv.

[81]  A. Vespignani,et al.  Modelling the impact of testing, contact tracing and household quarantine on second waves of COVID-19 , 2020, Nature Human Behaviour.

[82]  D. John,et al.  An Agent Based Model for assessing spread and health systems burden for COVID-19 in Rangareddy district, Telangana state, India , 2020 .

[83]  M. D’Orazio,et al.  A probabilistic model to evaluate the effectiveness of main solutions to COVID-19 spreading in university buildings according to proximity and time-based consolidated criteria , 2020, Building Simulation.

[84]  C. Bancej,et al.  Projected effects of nonpharmaceutical public health interventions to prevent resurgence of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in Canada , 2020, Canadian Medical Association Journal.

[85]  Akio Ishiguro,et al.  An agent-based model of the interrelation between the COVID-19 outbreak and economic activities , 2021, Proceedings of the Royal Society A.

[86]  A. Kucharski,et al.  The effectiveness of social bubbles as part of a Covid-19 lockdown exit strategy, a modelling study , 2020, medRxiv.

[87]  Joel Hellewell,et al.  Using a real-world network to model localized COVID-19 control strategies , 2020, Nature Medicine.

[88]  Woo-Sik Son Individual-based simulation model for COVID-19 transmission in Daegu, Korea , 2020, Epidemiology and health.

[89]  P. Zhao A Social Network Model of the COVID-19 Pandemic , 2020, medRxiv.

[90]  Alexis Akira Toda,et al.  The effect of social distancing on the reach of an epidemic in social networks , 2020, Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination.

[91]  D. Brunmeir,et al.  Agent-Based Simulation for Evaluation of Contact-Tracing Policies Against the Spread of SARS-CoV-2 , 2020, medRxiv.

[92]  Mariza Ferro,et al.  The virus and socioeconomic inequality: An agent-based model to simulate and assess the impact of interventions to reduce the spread of COVID-19 in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil , 2020, Brazilian Journal of Health Review.

[93]  Shahin Jabbari,et al.  Modeling between-population variation in COVID-19 dynamics in Hubei, Lombardy, and New York City , 2020, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[94]  M. Jackson,et al.  Low-impact social distancing interventions to mitigate local epidemics of SARS-CoV-2 , 2020, Microbes and Infection.

[95]  C. Whittaker,et al.  Report 9: Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID19 mortality and healthcare demand , 2020 .

[96]  M. Churpek,et al.  Impact of Timing of and Adherence to Social Distancing Measures on COVID-19 Burden in the US: A Simulation Modeling Approach , 2020, medRxiv.

[97]  Marc Timme,et al.  Limited containment options of COVID-19 outbreak revealed by regional agent-based simulations for South Africa , 2020, F1000Research.

[98]  E. Dong,et al.  An interactive web-based dashboard to track COVID-19 in real time , 2020, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[99]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[100]  J. Alsing,et al.  Containing Covid-19 outbreaks with spatiallytargeted short-term lockdowns and mass-testing , 2020, medRxiv.

[101]  R. Hinch,et al.  OpenABM-Covid19—An agent-based model for non-pharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 including contact tracing , 2020, medRxiv.

[102]  O. Reich,et al.  Modeling COVID-19 on a network: super-spreaders, testing and containment , 2020, medRxiv.

[103]  Benjamin Braun,et al.  Simulating phase transitions and control measures for network epidemics caused by infections with presymptomatic, asymptomatic, and symptomatic stages , 2020, PloS one.

[104]  Kimon Fountoulakis,et al.  Targeted pandemic containment through identifying local contact network bottlenecks , 2020, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[105]  Bruce Edmonds,et al.  The ODD Protocol for Describing Agent-Based and Other Simulation Models: A Second Update to Improve Clarity, Replication, and Structural Realism , 2020, J. Artif. Soc. Soc. Simul..

[106]  C. Bauch,et al.  Model-based projections for COVID-19 outbreak size and student-days lost to closure in Ontario childcare centres and primary schools , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[107]  Erik Cuevas,et al.  An agent-based model to evaluate the COVID-19 transmission risks in facilities , 2020, Computers in Biology and Medicine.

[108]  D. Gurarie,et al.  SARS-CoV-2 transmission and control in a hospital setting: an individual-based modelling study , 2020, Royal Society Open Science.

[109]  Noam Nisan,et al.  On the effectiveness of tracking and testing in SEIR models for improving health vs. economy trade-offs , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[110]  Gudrun Wallentin,et al.  COVID-19 Intervention Scenarios for a Long-term Disease Management , 2020, International journal of health policy and management.

[111]  A. Marzuoli,et al.  Socioeconomic Network Heterogeneity and Pandemic Policy Response , 2020, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[112]  Petrônio C. L. Silva,et al.  COVID-ABS: An agent-based model of COVID-19 epidemic to simulate health and economic effects of social distancing interventions , 2020, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals.

[113]  K. Nagel,et al.  Mobility traces and spreading of COVID-19 , 2020, medRxiv.

[114]  Mikhail Prokopenko,et al.  Modelling transmission and control of the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia , 2020, Nature communications.

[115]  A. Bouchnita,et al.  A hybrid multi-scale model of COVID-19 transmission dynamics to assess the potential of non-pharmaceutical interventions , 2020, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals.

[116]  Bruce Edmonds,et al.  Computational Models That Matter During a Global Pandemic Outbreak: A Call to Action , 2020, J. Artif. Soc. Soc. Simul..

[117]  John W. Fowler,et al.  How simulation modelling can help reduce the impact of COVID-19 , 2020, J. Simulation.

[118]  P. Sen,et al.  Space-time dependence of corona virus (COVID-19) outbreak , 2020, 2003.03149.

[119]  R. Eftimie,et al.  Modelling the transmission of infectious diseases inside hospital bays: implications for Covid-19 , 2020, medRxiv.

[120]  Frank Dignum,et al.  Analysing the Combined Health, Social and Economic Impacts of the Corovanvirus Pandemic Using Agent-Based Social Simulation , 2020, Minds and Machines.

[121]  Impact of intervention methods on COVID-19 transmission in Shenzhen , 2020, Building and Environment.

[122]  C. Kadelka,et al.  A model-based evaluation of the efficacy of COVID-19 social distancing, testing and hospital triage policies , 2020, medRxiv.

[123]  Philip S. Yu,et al.  A Survey on Applications of Artificial Intelligence in Fighting Against COVID-19 , 2020, ACM Comput. Surv..

[124]  E. Resconi,et al.  The impact of digital contact tracing on the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic—a comprehensive modelling study , 2020, medRxiv.

[125]  Eric Bonabeau,et al.  Agent-based modeling: Methods and techniques for simulating human systems , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[126]  M. Stevenson,et al.  Explaining national differences in the mortality of Covid-19: individual patient simulation model to investigate the effects of testing policy and other factors on apparent mortality. , 2020, medRxiv.