A systematic review of self and observer assessment of pain and related functioning in youth with brain-based developmental disabilities

ABSTRACT Pain experiences of youth with brain-based developmental disabilities are often overlooked and/or misinterpreted, increasing the risk for poor or inadequate pain assessment and management. Ample measures exist to assess acute and chronic pain, yet their utility and frequency of use in youth with brain-based developmental disabilities is unclear and available measures do not have strong measurement properties for this diverse group. This systematic review identified the scope of self-reported and observer-reported pain assessment in studies of youth (aged 3-24 years) with brain-based developmental disabilities (phase 1) and summarized other measures of pain-related functioning for acute and chronic pain (ie, physical, emotional, social, sleep, and quality of life, within the subset of quantitative studies focused primarily on pain, phase 2). A comprehensive search for English-language studies was conducted in August 2022 in Web of Science, CINAHL, MEDLINE, Cochrane CENTRAL, EMBASE, and APA PsychINFO (PROSPERO registration: CRD42021237444). A total of 17,029 unique records were screened. Of the 707 articles included in phase 1, most assessed chronic pain (n = 314; 62.0%) and primarily used observer-report (n = 155; 31%) over self-report (n = 67; 13%). Of the 137 articles included in phase 2, other outcomes assessed alongside pain intensity included motor ability (16.8%), adaptive functioning (11%), quality of life (8%), pain interference (6.6%), mental health (5.8%), and communication ability (2.9%). Cerebral palsy was the most common population in both phase 1 (n = 343; 48.5%) and phase 2 (n = 83; 59.7%). This review provides a foundational understanding of pain assessment in brain-based developmental disabilities and highlights continued inequities in holistic pain assessment for this population.

[1]  Jack M. Fu,et al.  Developmental Variability in Autism Across 17 000 Autistic Individuals and 4000 Siblings Without an Autism Diagnosis , 2022, JAMA pediatrics.

[2]  C. Molster,et al.  The diagnostic odyssey: insights from parents of children living with an undiagnosed condition , 2022, Orphanet Journal of Rare Diseases.

[3]  A. Hervás,et al.  Current state of knowledge on the prevalence of neurodevelopmental disorders in childhood according to the DSM-5: a systematic review in accordance with the PRISMA criteria , 2022, Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health.

[4]  R. Howard,et al.  Pain assessment tools in paediatric palliative care: A systematic review of psychometric properties and recommendations for clinical practice , 2021, Palliative medicine.

[5]  J. Stinson,et al.  Rapid Evidence and Gap Map of virtual care solutions across a stepped care continuum for youth with chronic pain and their families in response to the COVID-19 pandemic , 2021, Pain.

[6]  E. Mayo-Wilson,et al.  The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews , 2021, PLoS medicine.

[7]  G. Crombez,et al.  Core outcome set for pediatric chronic pain clinical trials: results from a Delphi poll and consensus meeting , 2021, Pain.

[8]  B. McGuire,et al.  Challenges in pain assessment and management among individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities , 2020, Pain reports.

[9]  D. Anaby,et al.  Environmental Factors that Impact the Workplace Participation of Transition-Aged Young Adults with Brain-Based Disabilities: A Scoping Review , 2020, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[10]  Mark Tomlinson,et al.  A future for the world's children? A WHO–UNICEF–Lancet Commission , 2020, The Lancet.

[11]  T. Werther,et al.  Pain and Sedation Scales for Neonatal and Pediatric Patients in a Preverbal Stage of Development: A Systematic Review. , 2019, JAMA pediatrics.

[12]  M. King,et al.  Strategies to improve patient-reported outcome completion rates in longitudinal studies , 2019, Quality of Life Research.

[13]  J. Bargh,et al.  Featured Article: Gender Bias in Pediatric Pain Assessment , 2019, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[14]  Pierre Pluye,et al.  Improving the content validity of the mixed methods appraisal tool: a modified e-Delphi study. , 2019, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[15]  Michael B. First,et al.  Chronic pain as a symptom or a disease: the IASP Classification of Chronic Pain for the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11) , 2019, Pain.

[16]  S. Paget,et al.  Management of pain in children and adolescents with cerebral palsy: a systematic review , 2018, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[17]  A. Pollock,et al.  Stakeholder involvement in systematic reviews: a scoping review , 2018, Systematic Reviews.

[18]  T. Voepel-Lewis.  Can pain assessment tools accurately measure pain experience of disabled individuals? , 2018, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[19]  Amos S Hundert,et al.  Recommendations for selection of self-report pain intensity measures in children and adolescents: a systematic review and quality assessment of measurement properties , 2018, Pain.

[20]  D. Reddihough,et al.  Intellectual disability in cerebral palsy: a population‐based retrospective study , 2018, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[21]  T. Oberlander,et al.  Evaluating pain in cerebral palsy: comparing assessment tools using the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health , 2018, Disability and rehabilitation.

[22]  C. Chambers,et al.  Adult judgments of children’s pain and fear during venipuncture: The impact of adult and child sex , 2018, Canadian journal of pain = Revue canadienne de la douleur.

[23]  Stephen P. Lewis,et al.  Pain in Children With Developmental Disabilities: Development and Preliminary Effectiveness of a Pain Training Workshop for Respite Workers , 2017, The Clinical journal of pain.

[24]  G. Champion,et al.  Systematic Review of Self-Report Measures of Pain Intensity in 3- and 4-Year-Old Children: Bridging a Period of Rapid Cognitive Development. , 2017, The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society.

[25]  D. G. Altman,et al.  GRIPP2 reporting checklists: tools to improve reporting of patient and public involvement in research , 2017, Research Involvement and Engagement.

[26]  A. Schwartz,et al.  Reducing Barriers to Patient-Reported Outcome Measures for People With Cognitive Impairments. , 2017, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[27]  A. Houtrow,et al.  Pain Assessment and Treatment in Children With Significant Impairment of the Central Nervous System , 2017, Pediatrics.

[28]  B. Carter,et al.  Developing a Sense of Knowing and Acquiring the Skills to Manage Pain in Children with Profound Cognitive Impairments: Mothers' Perspectives , 2017, Pain research & management.

[29]  C. McMurtry,et al.  Caring for children with intellectual disabilities part 1: Experience with the population, pain-related beliefs, and care decisions. , 2017, Research in developmental disabilities.

[30]  B. Carter,et al.  Navigating Uncertainty: Health Professionals' Knowledge, Skill, and Confidence in Assessing and Managing Pain in Children with Profound Cognitive Impairment , 2016, Pain research & management.

[31]  M. Casanova,et al.  Interoception in Autism Spectrum Disorder: A review , 2016, International Journal of Developmental Neuroscience.

[32]  V. Patel,et al.  Our future: a Lancet commission on adolescent health and wellbeing , 2016, The Lancet.

[33]  J. Stinson,et al.  A comprehensive categorical and bibliometric analysis of published research articles on pediatric pain from 1975 to 2010 , 2016, Pain.

[34]  Mei Lin Chen-Lim,et al.  Pain Assessment of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders , 2016, Journal of developmental and behavioral pediatrics : JDBP.

[35]  C. Provvidenza,et al.  Chronic Pain Assessment Tools for Cerebral Palsy: A Systematic Review , 2015, Pediatrics.

[36]  K. Craig,et al.  Social communication model of pain. , 2015, Pain.

[37]  Sandy Oliver,et al.  Broadening public participation in systematic reviews: a case example involving young people in two configurative reviews , 2015, Research synthesis methods.

[38]  Laura L. Hayman,et al.  Pain Assessment in Children With Special Needs , 2015 .

[39]  Robin A. Paynter,et al.  Defining the benefits and challenges of stakeholder engagement in systematic reviews , 2015 .

[40]  S. Aishwarya,et al.  Behavioral Pattern during Dental Pain in Intellectually Disabled Children: A Comparative Study , 2014, International scholarly research notices.

[41]  M. Offringa,et al.  StaR Child Health: developing evidence-based guidance for the design, conduct and reporting of paediatric trials , 2014, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[42]  B. Beresford,et al.  Key health outcomes for children and young people with neurodisability: qualitative research with young people and parents , 2014, BMJ Open.

[43]  A. Spittle,et al.  Developmental Coordination Disorder and Cerebral Palsy: Is There a Continuum? , 2014, Current Developmental Disorders Reports.

[44]  Jean C. Solodiuk.  Parent described pain responses in nonverbal children with intellectual disability. , 2013, International journal of nursing studies.

[45]  C. Allely,et al.  Pain Sensitivity and Observer Perception of Pain in Individuals with Autistic Spectrum Disorder , 2013, TheScientificWorldJournal.

[46]  Anna Domingo,et al.  The Wong-Baker Pain FACES Scale Measures Pain, Not Fear , 2013, Pediatric emergency care.

[47]  Andrew Booth,et al.  Beyond PICO , 2012, Qualitative health research.

[48]  J. Gorter,et al.  The 'F-words' in childhood disability: I swear this is how we should think! , 2012, Child: care, health and development.

[49]  S. Merkel,et al.  Pain assessment in the patient unable to self-report: position statement with clinical practice recommendations. , 2011, Pain management nursing : official journal of the American Society of Pain Management Nurses.

[50]  Raymond D. Kent,et al.  Developing and validating the Communication Function Classification System for individuals with cerebral palsy , 2011, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[51]  M. Curley,et al.  Validation of the Individualized Numeric Rating Scale (INRS): A pain assessment tool for nonverbal children with intellectual disability , 2010, PAIN.

[52]  KN Parkinson,et al.  Pain in children with cerebral palsy: a cross‐sectional multicentre European study , 2010, Acta paediatrica.

[53]  L. Eker,et al.  Pain prevalence and its impact on the quality of life in a sample of Turkish children with cerebral palsy , 2010, Disability and rehabilitation.

[54]  M. Orlin,et al.  Social and Community Participation of Children and Youth With Cerebral Palsy Is Associated With Age and Gross Motor Function Classification , 2009, Physical Therapy.

[55]  A. La Greca,et al.  Introduction to special issue: Evidence-based assessment in pediatric psychology. , 2008, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[56]  Steven Weisman,et al.  Core outcome domains and measures for pediatric acute and chronic/recurrent pain clinical trials: PedIMMPACT recommendations. , 2008, The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society.

[57]  B. Ghai,et al.  Postoperative pain assessment in preverbal children and children with cognitive impairment , 2008, Paediatric anaesthesia.

[58]  N. Crichton,et al.  Development of the paediatric pain profile: role of video analysis and saliva cortisol in validating a tool to assess pain in children with severe neurological disability. , 2007, Journal of pain and symptom management.

[59]  C. L. Baeyer,et al.  Systematic review of observational (behavioral) measures of pain for children and adolescents aged 3 to 18 years , 2007, Pain.

[60]  Kathryn Drager,et al.  AAC technologies for young children with complex communication needs: State of the science and future research directions , 2007, Augmentative and alternative communication.

[61]  F. Happé,et al.  Time to give up on a single explanation for autism , 2006, Nature Neuroscience.

[62]  A. Martini,et al.  Level of agreement between children, parents, and physicians in rating pain intensity in juvenile idiopathic arthritis. , 2006, Arthritis and rheumatism.

[63]  T. Voepel-Lewis,et al.  The revised FLACC observational pain tool: improved reliability and validity for pain assessment in children with cognitive impairment , 2006, Paediatric anaesthesia.

[64]  C. V. von Baeyer,et al.  Global and Specific Behavioral Measures of Pain in Children With Cerebral Palsy , 2005, The Clinical journal of pain.

[65]  P. McGrath,et al.  The incidence of pain in children with severe cognitive impairments. , 2003, Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine.

[66]  L. Breau.  Non-communicating children’s pain checklist: better pain assessment for severely disabled children , 2003, Expert review of pharmacoeconomics & outcomes research.

[67]  I. Choonara,et al.  Validating the Derbyshire Children's Hospital Pain Tool: a pilot study , 2003, Paediatric anaesthesia.

[68]  K. Seers,et al.  Not knowing--the problem of pain in children with severe neurological impairment. , 2003, International journal of nursing studies.

[69]  B. Carter,et al.  Dealing with uncertainty: parental assessment of pain in their children with profound special needs. , 2002, Journal of advanced nursing.

[70]  P. McGrath,et al.  Brief report: behaviors identified by caregivers to detect pain in noncommunicating children. , 2002, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[71]  R. Velleman,et al.  Pain in cognitively impaired, non-communicating children , 2001, Archives of disease in childhood.

[72]  C. L. Hicks,et al.  The Faces Pain Scale – Revised: toward a common metric in pediatric pain measurement , 2001, Pain.

[73]  C. Cans.  Surveillance of cerebral palsy in Europe: a collaboration of cerebral palsy surveys and registers , 2000 .

[74]  Christine T Chambers,et al.  A comparison of faces scales for the measurement of pediatric pain: children's and parents’ ratings , 1999, PAIN.

[75]  Elizabeth Bredberg.  Writing Disability History: Problems, perspectives and sources , 1999 .

[76]  K. Craig,et al.  Agreement between child and parent reports of pain. , 1998, The Clinical journal of pain.

[77]  P. McGrath,et al.  Behaviours caregivers use to determine pain in non‐verbal, cognitively impaired individuals , 1998, Developmental medicine and child neurology.

[78]  F. Dietz,et al.  Chiari pelvic osteotomy in cerebral palsy. , 1995, Journal of pediatric orthopedics.

[79]  J. U. Baumann,et al.  Clinical benefit of reconstruction of dislocated or subluxated hip joints in patients with spastic cerebral palsy. , 1994, Journal of pediatric orthopedics.

[80]  G. Humphrey,et al.  The occurrence of high levels of acute behavioral distress in children and adolescents undergoing routine venipunctures. , 1992, Pediatrics.

[81]  R. Reeve,et al.  The faces pain scale for the self-assessment of the severity of pain experienced by children: Development, initial validation, and preliminary investigation for ratio scale properties , 1990, Pain.

[82]  J. Beyer,et al.  The assessment of pain in children. , 1989, Pediatric clinics of North America.

[83]  Ronald Melzack,et al.  The short-form McGill pain questionnaire , 1987, Pain.

[84]  Kelly D. Coons,et al.  Conducting Research with Individuals Who Have Intellectual Disabilities : Ethical and Practical Implications for Qualitative Research , 2013 .

[85]  D. Bartlett,et al.  The Prevalence, Distribution, and Effect of Pain Among Adolescents with Cerebral Palsy , 2010, Pediatric physical therapy : the official publication of the Section on Pediatrics of the American Physical Therapy Association.

[86]  M. Law,et al.  The health and quality of life outcomes among youth and young adults with cerebral palsy. , 2010, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[87]  C. L. Baeyer,et al.  Children's self-report of pain intensity: what we know, where we are headed. , 2009 .

[88]  E Guardiola,et al.  An analysis of articles on neonatal pain published from 1965 to 1999. , 2001, Pain research & management.

[89]  L. Koegel,et al.  Autism: Social Communication Difficulties and Related Behaviors , 1994 .

[90]  W. Holzemer,et al.  The word-graphic rating scale as a measure of children's and adolescents' pain intensity. , 1991, Research in nursing & health.

[91]  Longmore Pk.  Uncovering the hidden history of people with disabilities. , 1987 .