Four-Dimensional Printing and Shape Memory Materials in Bone Tissue Engineering

The repair of severe bone defects is still a formidable clinical challenge, requiring the implantation of bone grafts or bone substitute materials. The development of three-dimensional (3D) bioprinting has received considerable attention in bone tissue engineering over the past decade. However, 3D printing has a limitation. It only takes into account the original form of the printed scaffold, which is inanimate and static, and is not suitable for dynamic organisms. With the emergence of stimuli-responsive materials, four-dimensional (4D) printing has become the next-generation solution for biological tissue engineering. It combines the concept of time with three-dimensional printing. Over time, 4D-printed scaffolds change their appearance or function in response to environmental stimuli (physical, chemical, and biological). In conclusion, 4D printing is the change of the fourth dimension (time) in 3D printing, which provides unprecedented potential for bone tissue repair. In this review, we will discuss the latest research on shape memory materials and 4D printing in bone tissue repair.

[1]  L. Ambrosio,et al.  PEEK and Hyaluronan-Based 3D Printed Structures: Promising Combination to Improve Bone Regeneration , 2022, Molecules.

[2]  Y. Yusuf,et al.  Mechanical Characteristics and Bioactivity of Nanocomposite Hydroxyapatite/Collagen Coated Titanium for Bone Tissue Engineering , 2022, Bioengineering.

[3]  Antreas Kantaros 3D Printing in Regenerative Medicine: Technologies and Resources Utilized , 2022, International journal of molecular sciences.

[4]  Takashi Kamio,et al.  Fused Deposition Modeling 3D Printing in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery: Problems and Solutions , 2022, Cureus.

[5]  A. Zolfagharian,et al.  4D printing: a cutting-edge platform for biomedical applications , 2022, Biomedical materials.

[6]  Antreas Kantaros Bio-Inspired Materials: Exhibited Characteristics and Integration Degree in Bio-Printing Operations , 2022, American Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences.

[7]  T. Webster,et al.  A voyage from 3D to 4D printing in nanomedicine and healthcare: part I. , 2022, Nanomedicine.

[8]  E. Alsberg,et al.  Jammed Micro‐Flake Hydrogel for Four‐Dimensional Living Cell Bioprinting , 2022, Advanced materials.

[9]  Y. Açil,et al.  In vivo biocompatibility evaluation of 3D-printed nickel–titanium fabricated by selective laser melting , 2022, Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine.

[10]  N. Zarghami,et al.  Application of decellularized bone matrix as a bioscaffold in bone tissue engineering , 2022, Journal of biological engineering.

[11]  P. Rosendahl,et al.  Additive manufacturing of clay and ceramic building components , 2022, Automation in Construction.

[12]  W. Bai,et al.  Shape-Memory ECM-Mimicking Heparin-Modified Nanofibrous Gelatin Scaffold for Enhanced Bone Regeneration in Sinus Augmentation. , 2021, ACS biomaterials science & engineering.

[13]  Kenan Song,et al.  3D printing for polymer/particle-based processing: A review , 2021 .

[14]  Yingtao Liu,et al.  Three-dimensional printing of cellulose nanofibers reinforced PHB/PCL/Fe3O4 magneto-responsive shape memory polymer composites with excellent mechanical properties , 2021 .

[15]  T. Wong,et al.  Biomimetic scaffolds with programmable pore structures for minimum invasive bone repair. , 2021, Nanoscale.

[16]  S. Hsu,et al.  4D bioprintable self-healing hydrogel with shape memory and cryopreserving properties , 2021, Biofabrication.

[17]  Michaela R. Pfau,et al.  Evaluation of a Self-Fitting, Shape Memory Polymer Scaffold in a Rabbit Calvarial Defect Model. , 2021, Acta biomaterialia.

[18]  Jinah Jang,et al.  Employing Extracellular Matrix-Based Tissue Engineering Strategies for Age-Dependent Tissue Degenerations , 2021, International journal of molecular sciences.

[19]  Y. S. Zhang,et al.  Nanotechnologies and Nanomaterials in 3D (Bio)printing toward Bone Regeneration , 2021, Advanced NanoBiomed Research.

[20]  A. Pourjavadi,et al.  Multi-stimuli-responsive hydrogels and their medical applications , 2021, New Journal of Chemistry.

[21]  N. Al-Dhabi,et al.  Environment friendly, renewable and sustainable poly lactic acid (PLA) based natural fiber reinforced composites – A comprehensive review , 2021 .

[22]  R. Sedghi,et al.  Preparation of chitosan biguanidine/PANI-containing self-healing semi-conductive waterborne scaffolds for bone tissue engineering. , 2021, Carbohydrate polymers.

[23]  L. Velásquez-García,et al.  Biomedical Applications of Metal 3D Printing. , 2021, Annual review of biomedical engineering.

[24]  Huiming Wang,et al.  4D Printing of Multi‐Responsive Membrane for Accelerated In Vivo Bone Healing Via Remote Regulation of Stem Cell Fate , 2021, Advanced Functional Materials.

[25]  F. Senatov,et al.  Polymer Composite Materials Based on Polylactide with a Shape Memory Effect for “Self-Fitting” Bone Implants , 2021, Polymers.

[26]  Siqian Zhang,et al.  Mussel patterned with 4D biodegrading elastomer durably recruits regenerative macrophages to promote regeneration of craniofacial bone. , 2021, Biomaterials.

[27]  Sibel Kaplan,et al.  Production of thermal and water responsive shape memory polyurethane nanocomposite filaments with cellulose nanowhisker incorporation , 2021, Cellulose.

[28]  Weihua Li,et al.  A bionic soft tongue driven by shape memory alloy and pneumatics , 2021, Bioinspiration & biomimetics.

[29]  E. Alsberg,et al.  4D biofabrication via instantly generated graded hydrogel scaffolds , 2021, Bioactive materials.

[30]  K. Fu,et al.  Polymer-based filament feedstock for additive manufacturing , 2021 .

[31]  Pankaj Sahlot,et al.  Application of phase change materials in 4D printing: A review , 2021, Materials Today: Proceedings.

[32]  W. Drossel,et al.  Investigation into the Hybrid Production of a Superelastic Shape Memory Alloy with Additively Manufactured Structures for Medical Implants , 2021, Materials.

[33]  D. Piromalis,et al.  Fabricating Lattice Structures via 3D Printing: The Case of Porous Bio-Engineered Scaffolds , 2021, Applied Mechanics.

[34]  Michaela R. Pfau,et al.  Intrinsic osteoinductivity of PCL-DA/PLLA semi-IPN shape memory polymer scaffolds. , 2021, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A.

[35]  Gerry L. Koons,et al.  3D printed colloidal biomaterials based on photo-reactive gelatin nanoparticles. , 2021, Biomaterials.

[36]  S. Mhaske,et al.  Shape memory polymer nanocomposite: a review on structure–property relationship , 2021, Polymer Bulletin.

[37]  Mohd Javaid,et al.  Significant roles of 4D printing using smart materials in the field of manufacturing , 2021 .

[38]  R. Sedghi,et al.  Self-healable conductive polyurethane with the body temperature‐responsive shape memory for bone tissue engineering , 2021 .

[39]  Tom O. McDonald,et al.  Multi-stimuli-responsive aggregation of nanoparticles driven by the manipulation of colloidal stability. , 2021, Nanoscale.

[40]  A. Khademhosseini,et al.  Multi‐Dimensional Printing for Bone Tissue Engineering , 2021, Advanced healthcare materials.

[41]  Chong Wang,et al.  4D printing of highly printable and shape morphing hydrogels composed of alginate and methylcellulose , 2021, Materials & Design.

[42]  S. Ramakrishna,et al.  Electrospun Shape Memory Polymer Micro-/Nanofibers and Tailoring Their Roles for Biomedical Applications , 2021, Nanomaterials.

[43]  A. Gazzaniga,et al.  Shape memory materials and 4D printing in pharmaceutics. , 2021, Advanced drug delivery reviews.

[44]  H. Alshahrani,et al.  Review of 4D printing materials and reinforced composites: Behaviors, applications and challenges , 2021 .

[45]  Yuming Zhao,et al.  Injectable GelMA Cryogel Microspheres for Modularized Cell Delivery and Potential Vascularized Bone Regeneration. , 2021, Small.

[46]  J. Shibli,et al.  Bioresorbable Polymers: Advanced Materials and 4D Printing for Tissue Engineering , 2021, Polymers.

[47]  Hua Li,et al.  Multiresponse Shape-Memory Nanocomposite with a Reversible Cycle for Powerful Artificial Muscles , 2021 .

[48]  P. Kessler,et al.  Periosteal expansion osteogenesis using an innovative, shape-memory polyethylene terephthalate membrane: An experimental study in rabbits. , 2021, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part B, Applied biomaterials.

[49]  L. Ionov,et al.  4D Biofabrication Using a Combination of 3D Printing and Melt-Electrowriting of Shape-Morphing Polymers. , 2021, ACS applied materials & interfaces.

[50]  K. Essa,et al.  4D Printing of Origami Structures for Minimally Invasive Surgeries Using Functional Scaffold , 2020, Applied Sciences.

[51]  B. Mazzolai,et al.  3D and 4D printing in dentistry and maxillofacial surgery: Printing techniques, materials, and applications. , 2020, Acta biomaterialia.

[52]  Jian Lin,et al.  4D Printing of Shape-memory Polymeric Scaffolds for Adaptive Biomedical Implantation. , 2020, Acta biomaterialia.

[53]  P. Morouco,et al.  Four-Dimensional (Bio-)printing: A Review on Stimuli-Responsive Mechanisms and Their Biomedical Suitability , 2020, Applied Sciences.

[54]  N. Radacsi,et al.  4D Printing: Materials, Technologies, and Future Applications in the Biomedical Field , 2020, Sustainability.

[55]  Sara Shakibania,et al.  Medical application of biomimetic 4D printing , 2020, Drug development and industrial pharmacy.

[56]  M. Meyers,et al.  Hydration-induced reversible deformation of biological materials , 2020, Nature Reviews Materials.

[57]  Namhun Kim,et al.  3D and 4D Printing of Multistable Structures , 2020, Applied Sciences.

[58]  E. Luo,et al.  Smart Porous Scaffold Promotes Peri-Implant Osteogenesis under the Periosteum. , 2020, ACS biomaterials science & engineering.

[59]  Wuyi Zhou,et al.  3D printing of Pickering emulsion inks to construct poly(D,L-lactide-co-trimethylene carbonate)-based porous bioactive scaffolds with shape memory effect , 2020, Journal of Materials Science.

[60]  C. Cherif,et al.  Bio-inspired semi-flexible joint based on fibre-reinforced composites with shape memory alloys , 2020 .

[61]  Ye Been Seo,et al.  4D-bioprinted silk hydrogels for tissue engineering. , 2020, Biomaterials.

[62]  J. Leng,et al.  Light activated shape memory polymers and composites: A review , 2020 .

[63]  Sunpreet Singh,et al.  3D printed biodegradable functional temperature-stimuli shape memory polymer for customized scaffoldings. , 2020, Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials.

[64]  B. Lu,et al.  Advanced reconfigurable scaffolds fabricated by 4D printing for treating critical-size bone defects of irregular shapes , 2020, Biofabrication.

[65]  Nathaniel S. Hwang,et al.  Sequential growth factor releasing double cryogel system for enhanced bone regeneration. , 2020, Biomaterials.

[66]  Balasubramanian Kandasubramanian,et al.  4D printing of shape memory polymers , 2020 .

[67]  C. Xiong,et al.  Biodegradable poly (lactic acid-co-trimethylene carbonate)/chitosan microsphere scaffold with shape-memory effect for bone tissue engineering. , 2020, Colloids and surfaces. B, Biointerfaces.

[68]  S. Ramakrishna,et al.  Characterization of three‐dimensional printed thermal‐stimulus polylactic acid‐hydroxyapatite‐based shape memory scaffolds , 2020 .

[69]  Yanzhong Zhang,et al.  Shape memory and osteogenesis capabilities of the electrospun PHBV modified PLLA fibrous mats. , 2020, Tissue engineering. Part A.

[70]  Matthew L. Becker,et al.  4D Printing of Resorbable Complex Shape Memory Poly(propylene fumarate) Star Scaffolds. , 2020, ACS applied materials & interfaces.

[71]  Juhyuk Park,et al.  Shape memory polymer composites embedded with hybrid ceramic microparticles , 2020, Smart Materials and Structures.

[72]  B. Ni,et al.  Contactless treatment for scoliosis by electromagnetically controlled shape-memory alloy rods: a preliminary study in rabbits , 2020, European Spine Journal.

[73]  Udayan Ghosh,et al.  Nanomaterial Patterning in 3D Printing , 2020, Advanced materials.

[74]  Nam-Trung Nguyen,et al.  Porous scaffolds for bone regeneration , 2020 .

[75]  Krishna Rawat,et al.  4D printing of materials for the future: Opportunities and challenges , 2020, Applied Materials Today.

[76]  A. C. Jayasuriya,et al.  Hydrogel-based 3D bioprinting: A comprehensive review on cell-laden hydrogels, bioink formulations, and future perspectives. , 2020, Applied materials today.

[77]  Juan Liu,et al.  Synthesis and characterization of biodegradable linear shape memory polyurethanes with high mechanical performance by incorporating novel long chain diisocyanates , 2020, New Journal of Chemistry.

[78]  Jianzhong Fu,et al.  4D Printing of High Performance Thermal Responsive Liquid Metal Elastomers Driven by Embedded Micro Liquid Chambers. , 2020, ACS applied materials & interfaces.

[79]  Sung Yun Hann,et al.  4D Self‐Morphing Culture Substrate for Modulating Cell Differentiation , 2020, Advanced science.

[80]  T. Thundat,et al.  Review—Recent Progresses in 4D Printing of Gel Materials , 2020, Journal of The Electrochemical Society.

[81]  S. Hosseini,et al.  Porous shape memory dental implant by reactive sintering of TiH2-Ni-Urea mixture. , 2020, Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications.

[82]  Shichang Zhao,et al.  Biofunctionalized Chondrogenic Shape-Memory Ternary Scaffolds for Efficient Cell-Free Cartilage Regeneration , 2020, Acta biomaterialia.

[83]  L. Ionov,et al.  Microfabrication Using Shape‐Transforming Soft Materials , 2020, Advanced Functional Materials.

[84]  Sung Eun Kim,et al.  Recent Advances of Biphasic Calcium Phosphate Bioceramics for Bone Tissue Regeneration. , 2020, Advances in experimental medicine and biology.

[85]  S. Kasugai,et al.  Introduction of a novel guided bone regeneration memory shape based device. , 2020, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part B, Applied biomaterials.

[86]  Jinlian Hu,et al.  A Programmable, Fast-fixing, Osteo-regenerative, Biomechanically Robust Bone Screw. , 2019, Acta biomaterialia.

[87]  D. Tang,et al.  Electrospun PCL-based polyurethane/HA microfibers as drug carrier of dexamethasone with enhanced biodegradability and shape memory performances , 2019, Colloid and Polymer Science.

[88]  C. Rotsch,et al.  Experimental validation of adaptive pedicle screws—a novel implant concept using shape memory alloys , 2019, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[89]  H. Roghani‐Mamaqani,et al.  The light-controlling of temperature-responsivity in stimuli-responsive polymers , 2019, Polymer Chemistry.

[90]  S. Hoa,et al.  Twisted composite structures made by 4D printing method , 2019, Composite Structures.

[91]  Yufeng Zheng,et al.  In vitro and in vivo studies of Mg-30Sc alloys with different phase structure for potential usage within bone. , 2019, Acta biomaterialia.

[92]  Yongxiang Luo,et al.  Cell-laden four-dimensional bioprinting using near-infrared-triggered shape-morphing alginate/polydopamine bioinks , 2019, Biofabrication.

[93]  A. Perna,et al.  Comparison of Shape Memory Staple and Gelled Platelet-Rich Plasma versus Shape Memory Staple alone for the Treatment of Waist Scaphoid Nonunion: A Single-Center Experience , 2019, Joints.

[94]  S. Bhalla,et al.  Shape memory alloy actuation of non-bonded piezo sensor configuration for bone diagnosis and impedance based analysis , 2019, Biomedical Engineering Letters.

[95]  Paola Sanjuan‐Alberte,et al.  Multifunctional Bioinstructive 3D Architectures to Modulate Cellular Behavior , 2019, Advanced Functional Materials.

[96]  Panyu Zhou,et al.  Nickel–titanium arched shape-memory alloy connector combined with bone grafting in the treatment of scaphoid nonunion , 2019, European Journal of Medical Research.

[97]  A. Retegi,et al.  Hybrid and biocompatible cellulose/polyurethane nanocomposites with water-activated shape memory properties. , 2019, Carbohydrate polymers.

[98]  Sung Young Park,et al.  Light‐Induced Swelling‐Responsive Conductive, Adhesive, and Stretchable Wireless Film Hydrogel as Electronic Artificial Skin , 2019, Advanced Functional Materials.

[99]  N. Lee,et al.  Advancements and frontiers in nano-based 3D and 4D scaffolds for bone and cartilage tissue engineering , 2019, International journal of nanomedicine.

[100]  Hidemitsu Furukawa,et al.  4D Printing of Shape‐Memory Hydrogels for Soft‐Robotic Functions , 2019, Advanced Materials Technologies.

[101]  A. Takale,et al.  Effect of wire electro discharge machining process parameters on surface integrity of Ti49.4Ni50.6 shape memory alloy for orthopedic implant application. , 2019, Materials science & engineering. C, Materials for biological applications.

[102]  P. Coates,et al.  Multiple shape memory behavior of highly oriented long-chain-branched poly(lactic acid) and its recovery mechanism. , 2019, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A.

[103]  Zhizhou Zhang,et al.  Developments in 4D-printing: a review on current smart materials, technologies, and applications , 2019, International Journal of Smart and Nano Materials.

[104]  L. Ionov,et al.  Light‐Responsive Shape‐Changing Polymers , 2019, Advanced Optical Materials.

[105]  Li Shuai,et al.  Biodegradable body temperature-responsive shape memory polyurethanes with self-healing behavior , 2019, Polymer Engineering & Science.

[106]  A. Blencowe,et al.  Thermoresponsive polysaccharides and their thermoreversible physical hydrogel networks. , 2019, Carbohydrate polymers.

[107]  Ali Khademhosseini,et al.  Advancing Frontiers in Bone Bioprinting , 2019, Advanced healthcare materials.

[108]  Jinlian Hu,et al.  Mechanically Robust Shape Memory Polyurethane Nanocomposites for Minimally Invasive Bone Repair. , 2019, ACS applied bio materials.

[109]  Lijie Sun,et al.  A biodegradable functional water-responsive shape memory polymer for biomedical applications. , 2019, Journal of materials chemistry. B.

[110]  J. H. Henderson,et al.  Enzymatically triggered shape memory polymers. , 2019, Acta biomaterialia.

[111]  Geetha Manivasagam,et al.  A review on injectable chitosan/beta glycerophosphate hydrogels for bone tissue regeneration. , 2019, International journal of biological macromolecules.

[112]  A. Chowdhury,et al.  Chitosan/graphene oxide-based multifunctional pH-responsive hydrogel with significant mechanical strength, self-healing property, and shape memory effect , 2018, Advances in Polymer Technology.

[113]  Martin L. Dunn,et al.  Advances in 4D Printing: Materials and Applications , 2018, Advanced Functional Materials.

[114]  A. Villa,et al.  3D Bone Biomimetic Scaffolds for Basic and Translational Studies with Mesenchymal Stem Cells , 2018, International journal of molecular sciences.

[115]  Z. Shao,et al.  Shape-memory collagen scaffold for enhanced cartilage regeneration: native collagen versus denatured collagen. , 2018, Osteoarthritis and cartilage.

[116]  Jae Hyup Lee,et al.  Mesenchymal Stem Cell Therapy for Bone Regeneration , 2018, Clinics in orthopedic surgery.

[117]  Jenna L. Dziki,et al.  Extracellular matrix-based materials for regenerative medicine , 2018, Nature Reviews Materials.

[118]  J. Saul,et al.  Biomaterials for the Delivery of Growth Factors and Other Therapeutic Agents in Tissue Engineering Approaches to Bone Regeneration , 2018, Front. Pharmacol..

[119]  Jinlian Hu,et al.  Self-fitting shape memory polymer foam inducing bone regeneration: A rabbit femoral defect study. , 2018, Biochimica et biophysica acta. General subjects.

[120]  Narges Shayesteh Moghaddam,et al.  Shape memory response of porous NiTi shape memory alloys fabricated by selective laser melting , 2018, Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Medicine.

[121]  S. Hsu,et al.  Biodegradable Water-Based Polyurethane Shape Memory Elastomers for Bone Tissue Engineering. , 2018, ACS biomaterials science & engineering.

[122]  A. Basit,et al.  Powder Bed Fusion: The Working Process, Current Applications and Opportunities , 2018 .

[123]  Q. Ni,et al.  The effect of hydroxyapatite nanoparticles on mechanical behavior and biological performance of porous shape memory polyurethane scaffolds. , 2018, Journal of biomedical materials research. Part A.

[124]  Jason Pui Yin Cheung,et al.  A randomized double-blinded clinical trial to evaluate the safety and efficacy of a novel superelastic nickel–titanium spinal rod in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: 5-year follow-up , 2018, European Spine Journal.

[125]  Nathaniel S. Hwang,et al.  Biomimetic Materials and Fabrication Approaches for Bone Tissue Engineering , 2017, Advanced healthcare materials.

[126]  Lang Xia,et al.  4D printing of polymeric materials for tissue and organ regeneration. , 2017, Materials today.

[127]  Leonid Ionov,et al.  4D Biofabrication Using Shape‐Morphing Hydrogels , 2017, Advanced materials.

[128]  Jun Ni,et al.  A review of 4D printing , 2017 .

[129]  Ali Khademhosseini,et al.  4D bioprinting: the next-generation technology for biofabrication enabled by stimuli-responsive materials , 2016, Biofabrication.

[130]  Robert Langer,et al.  A decade of progress in tissue engineering , 2016, Nature Protocols.

[131]  Wei Zhu,et al.  4D printing smart biomedical scaffolds with novel soybean oil epoxidized acrylate , 2016, Scientific Reports.

[132]  F. Senatov,et al.  Mechanical properties and shape memory effect of 3D-printed PLA-based porous scaffolds. , 2016, Journal of the mechanical behavior of biomedical materials.

[133]  Dany J. Munoz-Pinto,et al.  Evaluation of the Osteoinductive Capacity of Polydopamine-Coated Poly(ε-caprolactone) Diacrylate Shape Memory Foams. , 2015, ACS biomaterials science & engineering.

[134]  Shaobing Zhou,et al.  Delivery of growth factors using a smart porous nanocomposite scaffold to repair a mandibular bone defect. , 2014, Biomacromolecules.

[135]  Skylar Tibbits,et al.  4D Printing: Multi‐Material Shape Change , 2014 .

[136]  D. Vashaee,et al.  Electroconductive Nanocomposite Scaffolds: A New Strategy Into Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine , 2012 .

[137]  S. Chinchalkar,et al.  Dynamic assist splinting for attenuated sagittal bands in the rheumatoid hand. , 2006, Techniques in hand & upper extremity surgery.

[138]  R. V. van Riet,et al.  Three-corner wrist fusion using memory staples. , 2006, Techniques in hand & upper extremity surgery.