A comparative review of mobile health and electronic health utilization in sub-Saharan African countries.

This study distinguished between the application of e-health and m-health technologies in sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries based on the dimensions of use, targeted diseases or health conditions, locations of use, and beneficiaries (types of patients or health workers) in a country specific context. It further characterized the main opportunities and challenges associated with these dimensions across the sub-region. A systematic review of the literature was conducted on 66 published peer reviewed articles. The review followed the scientific process of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines of identification, selection, assessment, synthesis and interpretation of findings. The results of the study showed that m-health was prevalent in usage for promoting information for treatment and prevention of diseases as well as serving as an effective technology for reminders towards adherence. For e-health, the uniqueness lay in data acquisition and patients' records management; diagnosis; training and recruitment. While m-health was never used for monitoring or training and recruitment, e-health on the other hand could not serve the purpose of reminders or for reporting cases from the field. Both technologies were however useful for adherence, diagnosis, disease control mechanisms, information provision, and decision-making/referrals. HIV/AIDS, malaria, and maternal (postnatal and antenatal) healthcare were important in both m-health and e-health interventions mostly concentrated in the rural settings of South Africa and Kenya. ICT infrastructure, trained personnel, illiteracy, lack of multilingual text and voice messages were major challenges hindering the effective usage of both m-health and e-health technologies.

[1]  G. Darmstadt,et al.  "These are not good things for other people to know": how rural Tanzanian women's experiences of pregnancy loss and early neonatal death may impact survey data quality. , 2010, Social science & medicine.

[2]  M. Jacobs,et al.  Survey of ENT services in Africa: need for a comprehensive intervention , 2009, Global health action.

[3]  Jamie Perin,et al.  Global, regional, and national causes of child mortality: an updated systematic analysis for 2010 with time trends since 2000 , 2012, The Lancet.

[4]  M Mars,et al.  Health Capacity Development Through Telemedicine in Africa , 2010, Yearbook of Medical Informatics.

[5]  Tokunbo Ojo,et al.  Communication Networking: ICTs and health information in Africa , 2006 .

[6]  A. Haines,et al.  The effectiveness of M-health technologies for improving health and health services: a systematic review protocol , 2010, BMC Research Notes.

[7]  Arul Chib,et al.  mHealth Adoption in Low-Resource Environments: A Review of the Use of Mobile Healthcare in Developing Countries , 2015, Journal of health communication.

[8]  Michele L. Ybarra,et al.  Opportunities for technology-based HIV prevention programming among high school students in Cape Town, South Africa , 2014, AIDS care.

[9]  Debbie Bradshaw,et al.  Assessing the quality of routine data for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV: An analytical observational study in two health districts with high HIV prevalence in South Africa , 2016, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[10]  D. Hacking,et al.  Health promotion via SMS improves hypertension knowledge for deaf South Africans , 2017, BMC Public Health.

[11]  W. Jack,et al.  Effects of a mobile phone short message service on antiretroviral treatment adherence in Kenya (WelTel Kenya1): a randomised trial , 2010, The Lancet.

[12]  N. Mbananga,et al.  An e-Health Decision Support System for Improving Compliance of Health Workers to the Maternity Care Protocols in South Africa , 2013, Applied Clinical Informatics.

[13]  N. Nattrass,et al.  Improving the efficiency of monitoring adherence to antiretroviral therapy at primary health care level: a case study of the introduction of electronic technologies in Guguletu, South Africa , 2007 .

[14]  Miguel López-Coronado,et al.  Cost-utility and cost-effectiveness studies of telemedicine, electronic, and mobile health systems in the literature: a systematic review. , 2015, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[15]  E. Bissagnéné,et al.  Field Adherence to Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy in HIV-Infected Adults in Abidjan, Côte d'Ivoire , 2007, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[16]  Gaetano Borriello,et al.  Improving community health worker performance through automated SMS , 2012, ICTD.

[17]  B. Criel,et al.  Effect of Village Health Team Home Visits and Mobile Phone Consultations on Maternal and Newborn Care Practices in Masindi and Kiryandongo, Uganda: A Community-Intervention Trial , 2016, PloS one.

[18]  Clara B. Aranda-Jan,et al.  Systematic review on what works, what does not work and why of implementation of mobile health (mHealth) projects in Africa , 2014, BMC Public Health.

[19]  E. Agaba,et al.  Use of Electronic Health Records in sub-Saharan Africa: Progress and challenges. , 2012, Journal of medicine in the tropics.

[20]  Minki Chatterji,et al.  Can mobile phone messages to drug sellers improve treatment of childhood diarrhoea?--A randomized controlled trial in Ghana. , 2015, Health policy and planning.

[21]  Barbara Castelnuovo,et al.  Implementation of Provider-Based Electronic Medical Records and Improvement of the Quality of Data in a Large HIV Program in Sub-Saharan Africa , 2012, PloS one.

[22]  Paul G. Biondich,et al.  Experience Implementing Electronic Health Records in Three East African Countries , 2010, MedInfo.

[23]  D. Grobbee,et al.  Completeness and accuracy of data transfer of routine maternal health services data in the greater Accra region , 2015, BMC Research Notes.

[24]  Gerald P. Douglas,et al.  Using Touchscreen Electronic Medical Record Systems to Support and Monitor National Scale-Up of Antiretroviral Therapy in Malawi , 2010, PLoS medicine.

[25]  Cristian Pop-Eleches,et al.  Mobile phone technologies improve adherence to antiretroviral treatment in a resource-limited setting: a randomized controlled trial of text message reminders , 2011, AIDS.

[26]  S. Kaaya,et al.  Explaining Adherence Success in Sub-Saharan Africa: An Ethnographic Study , 2009, PLoS medicine.

[27]  Abdullah S Ali,et al.  The use of mobile phone data for the estimation of the travel patterns and imported Plasmodium falciparum rates among Zanzibar residents , 2009, Malaria Journal.

[28]  D. P. Conradie,et al.  ICT Applications as E-Health Solutions in Rural Healthcare in the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa , 2010, Health information management : journal of the Health Information Management Association of Australia.

[29]  Pradeep Kumar Ray,et al.  Electronic Medical Records: A Review Comparing the Challenges in Developed and Developing Countries , 2008, Proceedings of the 41st Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS 2008).

[30]  A. Costello,et al.  How many births in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia will not be attended by a skilled birth attendant between 2011 and 2015? , 2012, BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.

[31]  K. O'Brien,et al.  Mobile phone-delivered reminders and incentives to improve childhood immunisation coverage and timeliness in Kenya (M-SIMU): a cluster randomised controlled trial , 2017, The Lancet. Global health.

[32]  Bassey Ebenso,et al.  Using a mHealth tutorial application to change knowledge and attitude of frontline health workers to Ebola virus disease in Nigeria: a before-and-after study , 2016, Human Resources for Health.

[33]  T. Not,et al.  Digital Radiology to Improve the Quality of Care in Countries with Limited Resources: A Feasibility Study from Angola , 2013, PloS one.

[34]  E. Balas,et al.  Healthcare via cell phones: a systematic review. , 2009, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[35]  Adam Thompson,et al.  Experience Implementing OpenMRS to Support Maternal and Reproductive Health in Northern Nigeria , 2010, MedInfo.

[36]  Audie A Atienza,et al.  Mobile health technology evaluation: the mHealth evidence workshop. , 2013, American journal of preventive medicine.

[37]  A. Kharsany,et al.  HIV Infection and AIDS in Sub-Saharan Africa: Current Status, Challenges and Opportunities , 2016, The open AIDS journal.

[38]  William M. Tierney,et al.  An electronic medical record system for ambulatory care of HIV-infected patients in Kenya , 2005, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[39]  Oladimeji Farri,et al.  Computer use among doctors in Africa: Survey of trainees in a Nigerian teaching hospital , 2008 .

[40]  Aliyah R. Sohani,et al.  Static Digital Telepathology: A Model for Diagnostic and Educational Support to Pathologists in the Developing World , 2012, Analytical cellular pathology.

[41]  K. Maich,et al.  Applied Behavior Analysis , 2018, Reference Module in Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Psychology.

[42]  L. Redman,et al.  The Effectiveness of eHealth Technologies on Weight Management in Pregnant and Postpartum Women: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis , 2017, Journal of medical Internet research.

[43]  Antoine Geissbühler,et al.  E-Health, another mechanism to recruit and retain healthcare professionals in remote areas: lessons learned from EQUI-ResHuS project in Mali , 2014, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[44]  Quentin Eichbaum,et al.  Exploring the patterns of use and the feasibility of using cellular phones for clinic appointment reminders and adherence messages in an antiretroviral treatment clinic, Durban, South Africa. , 2010, AIDS patient care and STDs.

[45]  Maria Zolfo,et al.  The role of information communication technology (ICT) towards universal health coverage: the first steps of a telemedicine project in Ethiopia , 2012, Global health action.

[46]  Emily Gerth-Guyette,et al.  Impact of mHealth Chronic Disease Management on Treatment Adherence and Patient Outcomes: A Systematic Review , 2015, Journal of medical Internet research.

[47]  S. Lund,et al.  Mobile phones improve antenatal care attendance in Zanzibar: a cluster randomized controlled trial , 2014, BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.

[48]  Fabio Pagni,et al.  Virtual surgical pathology in underdeveloped countries: The Zambia Project. , 2011, Archives of pathology & laboratory medicine.

[49]  Edmund Seto,et al.  mSpray: a mobile phone technology to improve malaria control efforts and monitor human exposure to malaria control pesticides in Limpopo, South Africa. , 2014, Environment international.

[50]  D. Wamala,et al.  A meta-analysis of telemedicine success in Africa , 2013, Journal of pathology informatics.

[51]  Doug Brock,et al.  Dermatological diagnostic acumen improves with use of a simple telemedicine system for underserved areas of South Africa. , 2011, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[52]  Jessica E Haberer,et al.  High acceptability for cell phone text messages to improve communication of laboratory results with HIV-infected patients in rural Uganda: a cross-sectional survey study , 2012, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[53]  E. Soliman,et al.  Feasibility of Using Mobile ECG Recording Technology to Detect Atrial Fibrillation in Low-Resource Settings. , 2017, Global heart.

[54]  A. Katamba,et al.  Feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of Internet-based dynamic telepathology between Uganda and Germany , 2011, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[55]  A. Milén,et al.  Improvement of maternal health services through the use of mobile phones , 2011, Tropical medicine & international health : TM & IH.

[56]  T. Coates,et al.  Removing Barriers to Knowing HIV Status: Same-Day Mobile HIV Testing in Zimbabwe , 2006, Journal of acquired immune deficiency syndromes.

[57]  Emmanuelle Daviaud,et al.  Applying a framework for assessing the health system challenges to scaling up mHealth in South Africa , 2012, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[58]  Wilson W. Odero,et al.  Innovative approaches to application of information technology in disease surveillance and prevention in Western Kenya , 2007, J. Biomed. Informatics.

[59]  Gerald P. Douglas,et al.  Experience Implementing a Point-of-Care Electronic Medical Record System for Primary Care in Malawi , 2010, MedInfo.

[60]  Gregory B. Cline,et al.  Information technology systems in public sector health facilities in developing countries: the case of South Africa , 2013, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making.

[61]  Robert W Snow,et al.  The effect of mobile phone text-message reminders on Kenyan health workers' adherence to malaria treatment guidelines: a cluster randomised trial , 2011, The Lancet.

[62]  Christina Synowiec,et al.  E-health in low- and middle-income countries: findings from the Center for Health Market Innovations. , 2012, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[63]  J. Awoonor-Williams,et al.  Evaluation of the integrated disease surveillance and response system for infectious diseases control in northern Ghana , 2015, BMC Public Health.

[64]  R. Scott,et al.  Barriers and opportunities to implementation of sustainable e-Health programmes in Uganda: A literature review , 2017, African journal of primary health care & family medicine.

[65]  Jerome Kabakyenga,et al.  Introduction of mobile phones for use by volunteer community health workers in support of integrated community case management in Bushenyi District, Uganda: development and implementation process , 2014, BMC Health Services Research.

[66]  A. Hulth,et al.  Timelier notification and action with mobile phones–towards malaria elimination in South Africa , 2014, Malaria Journal.

[67]  Christopher Bailey,et al.  Information Systems for Patient Follow-Up and Chronic Management of HIV and Tuberculosis: A Life-Saving Technology in Resource-Poor Areas , 2007, Journal of medical Internet research.

[68]  D. Montagu,et al.  SMS messages increase adherence to rapid diagnostic test results among malaria patients: results from a pilot study in Nigeria , 2014, Malaria Journal.

[69]  Samuel Macharia Were Management of Records in Health Institutions Samuel Macharia , 2015 .

[70]  Kirsty Bobrow,et al.  Improving treatment adherence for blood pressure lowering via mobile phone SMS-messages in South Africa: a qualitative evaluation of the SMS-text Adherence SuppoRt (StAR) trial , 2015, BMC Family Practice.

[71]  T. Cassidy,et al.  Antenatal health promotion via short message service at a Midwife Obstetrics Unit in South Africa: a mixed methods study , 2014, BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth.

[72]  Rolf Wynn,et al.  Giving cell phones to pregnant women and improving services may increase primary health facility utilization: a case–control study of a Nigerian project , 2014, Reproductive Health.

[73]  H. Lucas Information and communications technology for future health systems in developing countries. , 2008, Social science & medicine.

[74]  Marie-Pierre Gagnon,et al.  Striving for evidence in e-health evaluation: Lessons from health technology assessment , 2005, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[75]  Eric-Jan Manders,et al.  Implementing OpenMRS for patient monitoring in an HIV/AIDS care and treatment program in rural Mozambique , 2010, MedInfo.

[76]  J. Walley,et al.  Using no-cost mobile phone reminders to improve attendance for HIV test results: a pilot study in rural Swaziland , 2013, Infectious Diseases of Poverty.

[77]  Lucy W. Kivuti-Bitok,et al.  Self-reported use of internet by cervical cancer clients in two National Referral Hospitals in Kenya , 2012, BMC Research Notes.

[78]  R. Snow,et al.  The feasibility, patterns of use and acceptability of using mobile phone text-messaging to improve treatment adherence and post-treatment review of children with uncomplicated malaria in western Kenya , 2014, Malaria Journal.

[79]  Bart Vinck,et al.  Asynchronous video-otoscopy with a telehealth facilitator. , 2013, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[80]  Ryan Littman-Quinn,et al.  Evaluating the potential impact of a mobile telemedicine system on coordination of specialty care for patients with complicated oral lesions in Botswana , 2016, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[81]  Michele L. Ybarra,et al.  Cell phone usage among adolescents in Uganda: acceptability for relaying health information. , 2011, Health education research.

[82]  Gerald P. Douglas,et al.  The feasibility of automating audit and feedback for ART guideline adherence in Malawi , 2011, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[83]  T. F. Rinke de Wit,et al.  Database-Supported Teleconferencing: An Additional Clinical Mentoring Tool to Assist a Multinational Company HIV/AIDS Treatment Program in Africa , 2006, HIV clinical trials.

[84]  M. Bigdeli,et al.  Addressing access barriers to health services: an analytical framework for selecting appropriate interventions in low-income Asian countries. , 2012, Health policy and planning.

[85]  Martin C. Were,et al.  Leapfrogging Paper-Based Records Using Handheld Technology: Experience from Western Kenya , 2010, MedInfo.

[86]  Paul G. Biondich,et al.  The OpenMRS Implementers Network , 2009, Int. J. Medical Informatics.

[87]  E. Katabira,et al.  Using Mobile Phones to Improve Clinic Attendance Amongst an Antiretroviral Treatment Cohort in Rural Uganda: A Cross-sectional and Prospective Study , 2010, AIDS and Behavior.

[88]  S. Gove,et al.  HIV education for health-care professionals in high prevalence countries: time to integrate a pre-service approach into training , 2008, The Lancet.

[89]  Shirin Madon,et al.  Can mobile phones help control neglected tropical diseases? Experiences from Tanzania. , 2014, Social science & medicine.

[90]  J. Kirigia,et al.  E-health: Determinants, opportunities, challenges and the way forward for countries in the WHO African Region , 2005, BMC public health.

[91]  L. Swartz,et al.  Scaling Up mHealth: Where Is the Evidence? , 2013, PLoS medicine.

[92]  C. Kovarik,et al.  The role of dermatopathology in conjunction with teledermatology in resource‐limited settings: lessons from the African Teledermatology Project , 2011, International journal of dermatology.

[93]  L. Osterberg,et al.  Adherence to medication. , 2005, The New England journal of medicine.

[94]  Susheel Chhabra ICT Influences on Human Development, Interaction, and Collaboration , 2012 .

[95]  Nicolette de Keizer,et al.  Electronic medical record systems are associated with appropriate placement of HIV patients on antiretroviral therapy in rural health facilities in Kenya: a retrospective pre-post study , 2014, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[96]  Hamish S. F. Fraser,et al.  Using Electronic Medical Records for HIV Care in Rural Rwanda , 2010, MedInfo.

[97]  M. Egger,et al.  Developing a point-of-care electronic medical record system for TB/HIV co-infected patients: experiences from Lighthouse Trust, Lilongwe, Malawi , 2016, BMC Research Notes.

[98]  Neeta Kumar,et al.  Telecytology in East Africa: a feasibility study of forty cases using a static imaging system , 2012, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[99]  Michele L. Ybarra,et al.  Acceptability and feasibility of CyberSenga: an Internet-based HIV-prevention program for adolescents in Mbarara, Uganda , 2014, AIDS care.

[100]  Kishwar Azad,et al.  From evidence to action to deliver a healthy start for the next generation , 2014, The Lancet.

[101]  Mark Tomlinson,et al.  Antenatal depression case finding by community health workers in South Africa: feasibility of a mobile phone application , 2014, Archives of Women's Mental Health.

[102]  D. Grobbee,et al.  The effect of a clinical decision-making mHealth support system on maternal and neonatal mortality and morbidity in Ghana: study protocol for a cluster randomized controlled trial , 2017, Trials.

[103]  Terry J. Hannan,et al.  Information, care, HIV/AIDS, and the linking of improved health and social outcomes using electronic information management tools in resource poor nations , 2006 .

[104]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA Statement for Reporting Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Studies That Evaluate Health Care Interventions: Explanation and Elaboration , 2009, Annals of Internal Medicine [serial online].

[105]  M. Maskew,et al.  Treatment outcomes of HIV-infected adolescents attending public-sector HIV clinics across Gauteng and Mpumalanga, South Africa. , 2013, AIDS research and human retroviruses.

[107]  L. Moulton,et al.  Evaluation of a mHealth Data Quality Intervention to Improve Documentation of Pregnancy Outcomes by Health Surveillance Assistants in Malawi: A Cluster Randomized Trial , 2016, PloS one.

[108]  P. Temple,et al.  Limited Access to Care and Home Healthcare , 2008, Clinical obstetrics and gynecology.

[109]  L. Myer,et al.  Assessment of completion of early medical abortion using a text questionnaire on mobile phones compared to a self-administered paper questionnaire among women attending four clinics, Cape Town, South Africa , 2014, Reproductive health matters.

[110]  M. Chopra,et al.  Food insecurity and its association with co-occurring postnatal depression, hazardous drinking, and suicidality among women in peri-urban South Africa. , 2013, Journal of affective disorders.

[111]  Pamela Andreatta,et al.  Using cell phones to collect postpartum hemorrhage outcome data in rural Ghana , 2011, International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics.

[112]  Michael J A Reid,et al.  New models for medical education: Web-based conferencing to support HIV training in Sub-Saharan Africa. , 2012, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.