Estimating density for species conservation: Comparing camera trap spatial count models to genetic spatial capture-recapture models

Abstract Density estimation is integral to the effective conservation and management of wildlife. Camera traps in conjunction with spatial capture-recapture (SCR) models have been used to accurately and precisely estimate densities of “marked” wildlife populations comprising identifiable individuals. The emergence of spatial count (SC) models holds promise for cost-effective density estimation of “unmarked” wildlife populations when individuals are not identifiable. We evaluated model agreement, precision, and survey costs, between i) a fully marked approach using SCR models fit using non-invasive genetic data, and ii) an unmarked approach using SC models fit using camera trap data, for a recovering population of the mesocarnivore fisher (Pekania pennanti). The SCR density estimates ranged from 2.95 to 3.42 (2.18–5.19 95% BCI) fishers 100 km−2. The SC density estimates were influenced by their priors, ranging from 0.95 (0.65–2.95 95% BCI) fishers 100 km−2 for the uninformative model to 3.60 (2.01–7.55 95% BCI) fishers 100 km−2 for the model informed by prior knowledge of a 16 km2 fisher home range. We caution against using strongly informative priors but instead recommend using a range of unweighted prior knowledge. Thin detection data was problematic for both SCR and SC models, potentially producing biased low estimates. The total cost of the genetic survey ($47 610) was two-thirds of the camera trap survey ($77 080), or comparable ($75 746) if genetic sampling effort was increased to include sex and trap-behaviour covariates in SCR models. Density estimation of unmarked populations continues to be a series of trade-offs but as methods improve and integrate, so will our estimates.

[1]  John Fieberg,et al.  Projecting range-wide sun bear population trends using tree cover and camera-trap bycatch data , 2017, PloS one.

[2]  J. Andrew Royle.  N‐Mixture Models for Estimating Population Size from Spatially Replicated Counts , 2004, Biometrics.

[3]  B. Kendall,et al.  Resetting predator baselines in coral reef ecosystems , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[4]  S. Boutin,et al.  Human disturbance alters the predation rate of moose in the Athabasca oil sands , 2017 .

[5]  John Paczkowski,et al.  Grizzly Bear Noninvasive Genetic Tagging Surveys: Estimating the Magnitude of Missed Detections , 2016, PloS one.

[6]  Steven C. Minta,et al.  DNA-based analysis of hair to identify species and individuals for population research and monitoring , 1997 .

[7]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Spatially explicit models for inference about density in unmarked or partially marked populations , 2011, 1112.3250.

[8]  Richard B. Chandler,et al.  Spatially explicit integrated population models , 2014 .

[9]  Tal Avgar,et al.  Animal movement affects interpretation of occupancy models from camera‐trap surveys of unmarked animals , 2018 .

[10]  Brian D. Gerber,et al.  Evaluating the potential biases in carnivore capture–recapture studies associated with the use of lure and varying density estimation techniques using photographic-sampling data of the Malagasy civet , 2011, Population Ecology.

[11]  Rahel Sollmann,et al.  Comparing capture–recapture, mark–resight, and spatial mark–resight models for estimating puma densities via camera traps , 2014 .

[12]  S. Matthews,et al.  Estimating population size of fishers (Pekania pennanti) using camera stations and auxiliary data on home range size , 2017 .

[13]  M. Conroy,et al.  Analysis and Management of Animal Populations , 2002 .

[14]  C. Traeholt,et al.  Estimating the population density of the Asian tapir (Tapirus indicus) in a selectively logged forest in Peninsular Malaysia. , 2012, Integrative zoology.

[15]  M. Efford.  Density estimation in live‐trapping studies , 2004 .

[16]  Murray G. Efford,et al.  Bird population density estimated from acoustic signals , 2009 .

[17]  D. Diefenbach,et al.  Population and genetic outcomes 20 years after reintroducing bobcats (Lynx rufus) to Cumberland Island, Georgia USA , 2015, Ecology and evolution.

[18]  David A. W. Miller,et al.  Using Spatial Capture–Recapture to Elucidate Population Processes and Space-Use in Herpetological Studies , 2016, Journal of Herpetology.

[19]  J Andrew Royle,et al.  Density estimation in tiger populations: combining information for strong inference. , 2012, Ecology.

[20]  K. Mccarthy,et al.  Investigating the potential impact of trophy hunting of wild ungulates on snow leopard Panthera uncia conservation in Tajikistan , 2016, Oryx.

[21]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Parameter-expanded data augmentation for Bayesian analysis of capture–recapture models , 2010, Journal of Ornithology.

[22]  Brett T McClintock,et al.  A spatial mark--resight model augmented with telemetry data. , 2013, Ecology.

[23]  Erin M. Bayne,et al.  REVIEW: Wildlife camera trapping: a review and recommendations for linking surveys to ecological processes , 2015 .

[24]  Mathias W. Tobler,et al.  Estimating jaguar densities with camera traps: Problems with current designs and recommendations for future studies , 2013 .

[25]  M. Kelly,et al.  Threatened predator on the equator: multi-point abundance estimates of the tiger Panthera tigris in central Sumatra , 2013, Oryx.

[26]  D L Borchers,et al.  Spatially Explicit Maximum Likelihood Methods for Capture–Recapture Studies , 2008, Biometrics.

[27]  K. E. Hodges,et al.  Genetic sampling for estimating density of common species , 2017, Ecology and evolution.

[28]  Alvaro Sanchez-Gonzalez,et al.  Assessing mass trapping efficiency and population density of Cerambyx welensii Küster by mark-recapture in dehesa open woodlands , 2012, European Journal of Forest Research.

[29]  J. Taylor,et al.  Distinguishing reintroduction from recolonization with genetic testing , 2017 .

[30]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Examining the occupancy–density relationship for a low‐density carnivore , 2017 .

[31]  Fehmi Arıkan,et al.  The first density estimation of an isolated Eurasian lynx population in southwest Asia , 2014 .

[32]  M. Plummer,et al.  CODA: convergence diagnosis and output analysis for MCMC , 2006 .

[33]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Estimating Black Bear Density Using DNA Data From Hair Snares , 2010 .

[34]  Dana J. Morin,et al.  Potential for camera-traps and spatial mark-resight models to improve monitoring of the critically endangered West African lion (Panthera leo) , 2015, Biodiversity and Conservation.

[35]  Mark J. Ducey,et al.  Identification and Density Estimation of American Martens (Martes americana) Using a Novel Camera-Trap Method , 2016 .

[36]  C. Packer,et al.  Lion (Panthera leo) populations are declining rapidly across Africa, except in intensively managed areas , 2015, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[37]  Martyn Plummer,et al.  JAGS: A program for analysis of Bayesian graphical models using Gibbs sampling , 2003 .

[38]  J. Fisher,et al.  Species occurrence data reflect the magnitude of animal movements better than the proximity of animal space use , 2018 .

[39]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Trap Configuration and Spacing Influences Parameter Estimates in Spatial Capture-Recapture Models , 2014, PloS one.

[40]  Thomas A. Decker,et al.  An evaluation of territory mapping to estimate fisher density , 2001 .

[41]  D. Macdonald,et al.  To bait or not to bait: A comparison of camera-trapping methods for estimating leopard Panthera pardus density , 2014 .

[42]  Rachel M. Fewster,et al.  Estimating population size by spatially explicit capture–recapture , 2013 .

[43]  C. Findlay,et al.  Home Range and Population Density of Fishers in Eastern Ontario , 2007 .

[44]  Gorry Fairhurst,et al.  Limitations of recreational camera traps for wildlife management and conservation research: A practitioner’s perspective , 2015, Ambio.

[45]  Tavis D. Forrester,et al.  Do occupancy or detection rates from camera traps reflect deer density? , 2017, Journal of Mammalogy.

[46]  D. Macdonald,et al.  Bringing clarity to the clouded leopard Neofelis diardi: first density estimates from Sumatra , 2014, Oryx.

[47]  W. Krohn,et al.  Home Range Characteristics of Adult Fishers , 1989 .

[48]  Andrew Gelman,et al.  General methods for monitoring convergence of iterative simulations , 1998 .

[49]  R. Powell,et al.  The Fisher, Life History, Ecology and Behavior , 1984 .

[50]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Spatial Capture-Recapture with Partial Identity: An Application to Camera Traps , 2016, bioRxiv.

[51]  J. López‐Bao,et al.  Estimating carnivore community structures , 2017, Scientific Reports.

[52]  Jerrold L. Belant,et al.  How Does Spatial Study Design Influence Density Estimates from Spatial Capture-Recapture Models? , 2012, PloS one.

[53]  Sarah Legge,et al.  Density and home range of feral cats in north-western Australia , 2015, Wildlife Research.

[54]  Ben C. Augustine,et al.  Characterizing recolonization by a reintroduced bear population using genetic spatial capture–recapture , 2016 .

[55]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Density Estimation in a Wolverine Population using Spatial Capture-Recapture Models , 2011 .

[56]  J Andrew Royle,et al.  A hierarchical model for spatial capture-recapture data. , 2008, Ecology.

[57]  T. A. Rittenhouse,et al.  Black bear recolonization patterns in a human-dominated landscape vary based on housing: New insights from spatially explicit density models , 2017 .

[58]  John D. J. Clare,et al.  Pairing field methods to improve inference in wildlife surveys while accommodating detection covariance. , 2017, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[59]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Estimating Population Size for Capercaillie (Tetrao urogallus L.) with Spatial Capture-Recapture Models Based on Genotypes from One Field Sample , 2015, PloS one.

[60]  J. Fisher,et al.  Investigating animal activity patterns and temporal niche partitioning using camera‐trap data: challenges and opportunities , 2017 .

[61]  J. Fisher,et al.  A multi-method hierarchical modeling approach to quantifying bias in occupancy from noninvasive genetic tagging studies , 2014 .

[62]  R. Weir,et al.  DENSITY OF FISHERS IN THE SUB-BOREAL SPRUCE BIOGEOCLIMATIC ZONE OF BRITISH COLUMBIA , 2006 .

[63]  J. Andrew Royle,et al.  Scaling-up camera traps: monitoring the planet's biodiversity with networks of remote sensors , 2017 .

[64]  Michael Wood,et al.  A review of camera trapping for conservation behaviour research , 2017 .