A Critical Examination of the Arguments Against Raising the Car Driver Licensing Age in New Zealand

Objectives: In 1987, to address an increasing problem of injury among young drivers, New Zealand chose a graduated driver licensing system (GDLS), in preference to raising the minimum car driver licensing age. Since 1987 the GDLS has contributed to a significant reduction in young driver injury, but a recent spate of high-profile crashes has raised public concern about young drivers and road safety. In response to this concern, a bill has been introduced into the parliament to increase the minimum driver licensing age from 15 to 16 years. In this article we critically examine some of the arguments against raising the licensing age. Our motivation for doing this is that many of the arguments against raising the driver's license age, though they have high face validity, are often presented without any supporting evidence. Method : Our sources for argument include Hansard (New Zealand parliament's official record), various public media, various agencies Web sites, census data, and published papers. The arguments examined against raising the age were the impact on the mobility of 15- and 16-year-olds, disadvantage to the rural sector, alternative transport options, increasing the age shifts the problem, changing the law will not change young driver behaviors, changing the law will not fix the problem, and education is the answer. Results: For each of the topics available, data were examined to quantify the extent to which these factors would affect young drivers if the minimum driver licensing age was raised to 16 years. Conclusion : The evidence demonstrates that young age, independent of experience, is a major determinant of risk; therefore, raising the minimum licensing age would have safety benefits. We also show that many of the arguments against raising the age are based on either no evidence or misinformation. Though raising the licensing age would to some extent disadvantage the rural sector, it may also be in the rural sector where the greatest gains in crash reduction are made.

[1]  J Langley,et al.  Politics can be deadly , 2006, Injury Prevention.

[2]  M Segui-Gomez,et al.  Recognizing the importance of injury in other policy forums: the case of motorcycle licensing policy in Spain , 2007, Injury Prevention.

[3]  Anne T McCartt,et al.  Driving experience, crashes and traffic citations of teenage beginning drivers. , 2003, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[4]  Simon Kingham,et al.  The impact of the minimum driver licensing age on mobility in New Zealand , 2004 .

[5]  R Ian,et al.  School based driver education for the prevention of traffic crashes. , 2001, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[6]  Daniel R Mayhew,et al.  Changes in collision rates among novice drivers during the first months of driving. , 2003, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[7]  A I Reeder,et al.  The New Zealand graduated driver licensing system: teenagers' attitudes towards and experiences with this car driver licensing system. , 1995, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention.

[8]  R Christie,et al.  The effectiveness of driver training as a road safety measure: a review of the literature , 2001 .

[9]  Ben Lewis-Evans,et al.  Crash profile of New Zealand novice drivers , 2007 .

[10]  H M Simpson,et al.  The safety value of driver education an training , 2002, Injury prevention : journal of the International Society for Child and Adolescent Injury Prevention.

[11]  Allan F. Williams,et al.  Effectiveness and Role of Driver Education and Training in a Graduated Licensing System , 1998, Journal of public health policy.

[12]  Colin Stacey,et al.  FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Policy Brief OCTOBER 2006 Young Drivers : The Road to Safety , 2022 .

[13]  C Laberge-Nadeau,et al.  The effects of age and experience on accidents with injuries: should the licensing age be raised? , 1992, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[14]  Dorothy Begg,et al.  Graduated driver licensing: the New Zealand experience. , 2003, Journal of safety research.

[15]  P. Zador,et al.  Variations in minimum licensing age and fatal motor vehicle crashes. , 1983, American Journal of Public Health.