Visual and Visuo-tactile Detection of Dental Caries

The objective of this review is to describe and discuss the content validity of a sample of caries detection criteria reported in the literature between January 1, 1966, and May 1, 2000. Using filters to locate randomized or controlled clinical trials on dental caries, fluorides, sealants, and “restorative” care, I identified a total of 171 documents from MEDLINE and the Cochrane Collaboration's Oral Health Group (CC-OHG) special register. These articles met the following inclusion criteria: (1) Data had been collected from samples of patients or populations; and (2) dental caries was assessed clinically, and criteria were either published or described in the paper. From the selected articles, evidence tables were prepared describing each caries detection criterion. Analysis of the content validity of the criteria systems was based on evaluation of the disease process, exclusion of non-caries lesions, subjectivity, use of explorers, and drying of teeth prior to examination. This review included 29 unique criteria systems. Of those, 13 originated from the UK, 3 from the USA, 4 from Denmark, and others from the World Health Organization (WHO), Sweden, Switzerland, Norway, Netherlands, and Canada. Thirteen of the criteria systems either measured active and inactive early and cavitated lesions or defined separate criteria for smooth and occlusal tooth surfaces. Nine systems measured early as well as cavitated stages of the caries process, and 7 measured cavitation only. Eleven of the criteria systems provided explicit descriptions of the disease process measured or information on how to exclude non-caries from caries lesions. The use of explorers and drying and cleaning of teeth varied widely among the criteria. The majority of the newly developed criteria systems originated from Europe. In conclusion, this review of the content validity of the 29 criteria systems found substantial variability in disease processes measured, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and examination conditions.

[1]  S. Cretin,et al.  The reliability of diagnosing root caries using oral examinations. , 1988, Journal of dental education.

[2]  W E van Amerongen,et al.  Prevalence of hidden caries. , 1992, ASDC journal of dentistry for children.

[3]  G. Gibson,et al.  Sticky fissure management. 30-month report. , 1980, Journal.

[4]  J. Abernathy,et al.  Comparative effectiveness of visual/tactile and simplified screening examinations in caries risk assessment. , 1992, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[5]  K. Stephen,et al.  Five years of community preventive dentistry and health education in the county of Sutherland, Scotland. , 1978, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[6]  J. Murray,et al.  A 3-year clinical trial into the effect of fluoride content and toothpaste abrasivity on the caries inhibitory properties of a dentifrice. , 1980, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[7]  Alman Je,et al.  Report of a three-year clinical trial comparing a toothpaste containing sodium monofluorophosphate with two marketed products. , 1968 .

[8]  J. Murray,et al.  Errors in diagnosis of approximal caries on bitewing radiographs. , 1975, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[9]  L. Ranggård,et al.  Dental caries in a group of 15 to 16-year-olds from Göteborg. Part I. , 1992, Swedish dental journal.

[10]  Richardson As,et al.  Sticky fissure management. 30-month report. , 1980 .

[11]  M. Naylor,et al.  A three-year clinical study to determine the separate and combined caries-inhibiting effects of sodium monofluorophosphate toothpaste and an acidulated phosphate-fluoride gel. , 1978, Caries research.

[12]  E. Schwarz,et al.  Prevention of early childhood caries--results of a fluoride toothpaste demonstration trial on Chinese preschool children after three years. , 1998, Journal of public health dentistry.

[13]  N B Pitts,et al.  British Association for the Study of Community Dentistry (BASCD) diagnostic criteria for caries prevalence surveys-1996/97. , 1997, Community dental health.

[14]  T. Modéer,et al.  Caries development in children from 2.5 to 3.5 years of age: a longitudinal study. , 1995, Caries research.

[15]  D. Jackson.  The clinical diagnosis of dental caries. , 1950, British dental journal.

[16]  T. Marthaler.  A standardized system of recording dental conditions. , 1966, Helvetica odontologica acta.

[17]  D. Birkhed,et al.  Reproducibility of clinical caries diagnoses on coronal and root surfaces. , 1996, Caries research.

[18]  N. Pitts,et al.  The Effect of Varying Diagnostic Thresholds upon Clinical Caries Data for a Low Prevalence Group , 1988, Journal of dental research.

[19]  M. Raadal,et al.  Impact of diagnostic criteria on the prevalence of dental caries in Norwegian children aged 5, 12 and 18 years. , 1998, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[20]  C. Pine,et al.  The dental caries experience of 12-year-old children in England and Wales. Surveys coordinated by the British Association for the Study of Community Dentistry in 2000/2001. , 1988, Community dental health.

[21]  K. Ekstrand,et al.  Two and a Half–Year Outcome of Caries– Preventive Programs Offered to Groups of Children in the Solntsevsky District of Moscow , 1999, Caries Research.

[22]  M. A. van 't Hof,et al.  Radiographic versus clinical diagnosis of approximal carious lesions. , 1990, Caries research.

[23]  S. Poulsen,et al.  A standardized system for diagnosing, recording and analyzing dental caries data. , 1973, Scandinavian journal of dental research.

[24]  A. Ismail,et al.  Dental caries in the second millennium. , 2001, Journal of dental education.

[25]  O. Backer Dirks,et al.  The results of 6 1/2 years of artificial fluoridation of drinking water in the Netherlands. The Tiel-Culemborg experiment. , 1961, Archives of oral biology.

[26]  A. Ismail,et al.  A Longitudinal Evaluation of Fissure Sealants Applied in Dental Practices , 1995, Journal of dental research.

[27]  A. D. Hitchin,et al.  Dental disease and related factors in 13-year-old children in Dundee. , 1964 .

[28]  B. Krasse,et al.  Caries incidence, effect of preventive measures, and caries prediction in Uruguayan children. , 1995, Acta odontologica Scandinavica.

[29]  M. Downer.  The British Association for the Study of Community Dentistry , 1998, British Dental Journal.

[30]  F. García-Godoy,et al.  Caries–Preventive Effect of Topical Amine Fluoride in Children with High and Low Salivary Levels of Mutans Streptococci , 1999, Caries Research.

[31]  V. Baelum,et al.  A Comparison of Clinical and Radiographic Caries Diagnoses in Posterior Teeth of 12–Year–Old Lithuanian Children , 1999, Caries Research.

[32]  N. Pitts,et al.  Effect of diagnostic threshold on the validity and reliability of epidemiological caries diagnosis using the Dundee Selectable Threshold Method for caries diagnosis (DSTM). , 2000, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[33]  J. Brodeur,et al.  Restorative treatments received by children covered by a universal, publicly financed, dental insurance plan. , 1997, Journal of public health dentistry.

[34]  M. Heath,et al.  A Microbiological Study of Primary Root-caries Lesions with Different Treatment Needs , 1993, Journal of dental research.

[35]  N. Pitts,et al.  A Randomised Controlled Trial of the Caries– Preventive Efficacy of a Chlorhexidine–Containing Varnish in High–Caries–Risk Adolescents , 2000, Caries Research.

[36]  R. Kent,et al.  Double blind clinical trial of a remineralizing dentifrice in the prevention of caries in a radiation therapy population. , 1999, Gerodontology.

[37]  E. Kidd,et al.  Detection, Diagnosing, Monitoring and Logical Treatment of Occlusal Caries in Relation to Lesion Activity and Severity: An in vivo Examination with Histological Validation , 1998, Caries Research.

[38]  V. Baelum,et al.  Reliability of a New Caries Diagnostic System Differentiating between Active and Inactive Caries Lesions , 1999, Caries Research.

[39]  B. Eastwood,et al.  Prevalence of non-cavitated and cavitated carious lesions in a random sample of 7-9-year-old schoolchildren in Montreal, Quebec. , 1992, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[40]  R. Sognnaes.  The Importance of a Detailed Clinical Examination of Carious Lesions , 1940 .

[41]  S. Creanor,et al.  A 3-year oral health dose-response study of sodium monofluorophosphate dentifrices with and without zinc citrate: anti-caries results. , 1988, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[42]  Marthaler Tm.  A standardized system of recording dental conditions. , 1966 .

[43]  A. Ismail,et al.  Clinical diagnosis of precavitated carious lesions. , 1997, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[44]  P. Holloway,et al.  The effect of diagnostic criteria on the sensitivity of dental epidemiological data. , 1981, Caries research.

[45]  A. Neilson,et al.  The clinical behaviour of free smooth surface carious lesions monitored over 2 years in a group of Scottish children , 1991, British Dental Journal.