Validating induced seismicity forecast models—Induced Seismicity Test Bench

Induced earthquakes often accompany fluid injection, and the seismic hazard they pose threatens various underground engineering projects. Models to monitor and control induced seismic hazard with traffic light systems should be probabilistic, forward-looking, and updated as new data arrive. In this study, we propose an Induced Seismicity Test Bench to test and rank such models; this test bench can be used for model development, model selection, and ensemble model building. We apply the test bench to data from the Basel 2006 and Soultz-sous-Forets 2004 geothermal stimulation projects, and we assess forecasts from two models: Shapiro and Smoothed Seismicity (SaSS) and Hydraulics and Seismics (HySei). These models incorporate a different mix of physics-based elements and stochastic representation of the induced sequences. Our results show that neither model is fully superior to the other. Generally, HySei forecasts the seismicity rate better after shut-in but is only mediocre at forecasting the spatial distribution. On the other hand, SaSS forecasts the spatial distribution better and gives better seismicity rate estimates before shut-in. The shut-in phase is a difficult moment for both models in both reservoirs: the models tend to underpredict the seismicity rate around, and shortly after, shut-in.

[1]  S. Wiemer,et al.  Validating Models to Forecasting Induced Seismicity Related to Deep Geothermal Energy Projects , 2014 .

[2]  Stefan Wiemer,et al.  Building Robust Models to Forecast the Induced Seismicity Related to Geothermal Reservoir Enhancement , 2012 .

[3]  C. Cauzzi,et al.  Seismic monitoring and analysis of deep geothermal projects in St Gallen and Basel, Switzerland , 2015 .

[4]  Naoshi Hirata,et al.  Overview of the first earthquake forecast testing experiment in Japan , 2011 .

[5]  Philippe Lutz,et al.  The deep EGS (Enhanced Geothermal System) project at Soultz-sous-Forêts (Alsace, France) , 2006 .

[6]  Friedemann Wenzel,et al.  Seismogenic index and magnitude probability of earthquakes induced during reservoir fluid stimulations , 2010 .

[7]  Markus Häring,et al.  Characterisation of the Basel 1 enhanced geothermal system , 2008 .

[8]  P. Segall,et al.  Injection‐induced seismicity: Poroelastic and earthquake nucleation effects , 2015 .

[9]  Y. Kagan,et al.  Probabilistic forecasting of earthquakes , 2000 .

[10]  J. D. Zechar,et al.  Completeness of the Mainland China Earthquake Catalog and Implications for the Setup of the China Earthquake Forecast Testing Center , 2013 .

[11]  C. Dorbath,et al.  Injection tests at the EGS reservoir of Soultz-sous-Forêts. Seismic response of the GPK4 stimulations , 2014 .

[12]  Thomas Kohl,et al.  The role of triggering by static stress transfer during geothermal reservoir stimulation , 2012 .

[13]  J. D. Zechar,et al.  Likelihood-Based Tests for Evaluating Space–Rate–Magnitude Earthquake Forecasts , 2009 .

[14]  Philip J. Maechling,et al.  The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability perspective on computational earthquake science , 2010 .

[15]  Stefan Wiemer,et al.  Potential of ambient seismic noise techniques to monitor the St. Gallen geothermal site (Switzerland) , 2015 .

[16]  J. Douglas Zechar,et al.  Simple smoothed seismicity earthquake forecasts for Italy , 2010 .

[17]  J. D. Zechar,et al.  A prospective earthquake forecast experiment in the western Pacific , 2012 .

[18]  D. Wyborn,et al.  Induced Seismicity during the Stimulation of a Geothermal hfr Reservoir in the Cooper Basin, Australia , 2006 .

[19]  Yan Y. Kagan,et al.  Statistical distributions of earthquake numbers: consequence of branching process , 2009, 0909.2372.

[20]  Gregory C. Beroza,et al.  Ground motion prediction of realistic earthquake sources using the ambient seismic field , 2013 .

[21]  C. Frohlich,et al.  The 17 May 2012 M4.8 earthquake near Timpson, East Texas: An event possibly triggered by fluid injection , 2014 .

[22]  Vladimir Grechka.  This issue of GEOPHYSICS , 2010 .

[23]  Nicholas Deichmann,et al.  Identification of faults activated during the stimulation of the Basel geothermal project from cluster analysis and focal mechanisms of the larger magnitude events , 2014 .

[24]  Paul Segall,et al.  Earthquakes triggered by fluid extraction , 1989 .

[25]  B. Gutenberg,et al.  Frequency of Earthquakes in California , 1944, Nature.

[26]  Valentin Gischig.  Rupture propagation behavior and the largest possible earthquake induced by fluid injection into deep reservoirs , 2015 .

[27]  Albert Genter,et al.  Status of the Soultz geothermal project during exploitation between 2010 and 2012 , 2012 .

[28]  Won-Young Kim,et al.  A Fluid-Injection-Triggered Earthquake Sequence in Ashtabula, Ohio: Implications for Seismogenesis in Stable Continental Regions , 2004 .

[29]  Mia Hubert,et al.  LIBRA: a MATLAB library for robust analysis , 2005 .

[30]  Y. Kagan,et al.  High-resolution Time-independent Grid-based Forecast for M ≥ 5 Earthquakes in California , 2007 .

[31]  Danijel Schorlemmer,et al.  Setting up an earthquake forecast experiment in Italy , 2010 .

[32]  Friedemann Wenzel,et al.  Probability of earthquake occurrence and magnitude estimation in the post shut-in phase of geothermal projects , 2011, Journal of Seismology.

[33]  T. McCuaig,et al.  Banded iron formation to iron ore: A record of the evolution of Earth environments? , 2013 .

[34]  A. Ghassemi,et al.  A 3D Thermal-Poroelastic Model For Naturally Fractured Geothermal Reservoir Stimulation , 2012 .

[35]  Hans-Peter Harjes,et al.  Injection-induced earthquakes and crustal stress at 9 km depth at the KTB deep drilling site, Germany , 1997 .

[36]  G. C. Beroza,et al.  Strong Ground Motion Prediction Using Virtual Earthquakes , 2014, Science.

[37]  G. Abers,et al.  Potentially induced earthquakes in Oklahoma, USA: Links between wastewater injection and the 2011 Mw 5.7 earthquake sequence , 2013 .

[38]  Harsh K. Gupta,et al.  A review of recent studies of triggered earthquakes by artificial water reservoirs with special emphasis on earthquakes in Koyna, India , 2002 .

[39]  Emmanuel Gaucher,et al.  Induced seismicity in geothermal reservoirs: A review of forecasting approaches , 2015 .

[40]  Albert Genter,et al.  Contribution of the exploration of deep crystalline fractured reservoir of Soultz to the knowledge of enhanced geothermal systems (EGS) , 2010 .

[41]  Student,et al.  THE PROBABLE ERROR OF A MEAN , 1908 .

[42]  T. Rikitake.  Probability of earthquake occurrence as estimated from crustal strain , 1974 .

[43]  M. Zoback.  First‐ and second‐order patterns of stress in the lithosphere: The World Stress Map Project , 1992 .

[44]  Julian J. Bommer,et al.  Induced seismicity associated with Enhanced Geothermal Systems , 2007 .

[45]  R. Horne,et al.  Investigation of injection-induced seismicity using a coupled fluid flow and rate/state friction model , 2011 .

[46]  Serge A. Shapiro,et al.  Decay rate of fluid-induced seismicity after termination of reservoir stimulations , 2010 .

[47]  Valentin Gischig,et al.  A stochastic model for induced seismicity based on non-linear pressure diffusion and irreversible permeability enhancement , 2013 .

[48]  T. Spillmann,et al.  Application of microseismic multiplet analysis to the Basel geothermal reservoir stimulation events , 2010 .

[49]  Jacques R. Ernst,et al.  Earthquake focal mechanisms of the induced seismicity in 2006 and 2007 below Basel (Switzerland) , 2009 .

[50]  A. Ryall,et al.  Earthquakes associated with underground nuclear explosions , 1969 .

[51]  Won-Young Kim,et al.  Induced seismicity associated with fluid injection into a deep well in Youngstown, Ohio , 2013 .

[52]  Jonny Rutqvist,et al.  The role of hydromechanical coupling in fractured rock engineering , 2003 .

[53]  B. Orlecka‐Sikora.  The role of static stress transfer in mining induced seismic events occurrence, a case study of the Rudna mine in the Legnica‐Glogow Copper District in Poland , 2010 .

[54]  Warner Marzocchi,et al.  The Assumption of Poisson Seismic-Rate Variability in CSEP/RELM Experiments , 2010 .

[55]  Benjamin Edwards,et al.  Predicting ground motion from induced earthquakes in geothermal areas , 2013 .

[56]  Generation of large postinjection‐induced seismic events by backflow from dead‐end faults and fractures , 2015 .

[57]  Thomas Kohl,et al.  Predictive modeling of reservoir response to hydraulic stimulations at the European EGS site Soultz-sous-Forêts , 2007 .

[58]  J. Bommer,et al.  Control of hazard due to seismicity induced by a hot fractured rock geothermal project , 2006 .

[59]  Jiancang Zhuang,et al.  Basic Models of Seismicity: Temporal Models , 2012 .

[60]  Stefan Wiemer,et al.  The role of Coulomb stress changes for injection‐induced seismicity: The Basel enhanced geothermal system , 2013 .

[61]  Paul Goodwin,et al.  The Holt-Winters Approach to Exponential Smoothing: 50 Years Old and Going Strong , 2010 .

[62]  J. D. Zechar,et al.  Assessing annual global M6+ seismicity forecasts , 2014 .

[63]  Matthew C. Gerstenberger,et al.  New Zealand Earthquake Forecast Testing Centre , 2010 .

[64]  A. Gens,et al.  Nonisothermal multiphase flow of brine and gas through saline media , 1994 .

[65]  M. Cocco,et al.  Introduction to special section: Stress transfer, earthquake triggering, and time‐dependent seismic hazard , 2005 .

[66]  Arnaud Mignan.  Static behaviour of induced seismicity , 2015 .

[67]  S. Ge,et al.  High-rate injection is associated with the increase in U.S. mid-continent seismicity , 2015, Science.

[68]  R. E. Abdel-Aal,et al.  Reservoir property prediction using abductive networks , 2010 .

[69]  Stefan Wiemer,et al.  Statistical analysis of the induced Basel 2006 earthquake sequence: introducing a probability-based monitoring approach for Enhanced Geothermal Systems , 2011 .

[70]  P. Reasenberg,et al.  Earthquake Hazard After a Mainshock in California , 1989, Science.

[71]  Yosihiko Ogata,et al.  Detecting fluid signals in seismicity data through statistical earthquake modeling , 2005 .

[72]  A. McGarr,et al.  Seismic moments and volume changes , 1976 .

[73]  J. D. Zechar,et al.  Regional Earthquake Likelihood Models I: First-Order Results , 2013 .

[74]  David A. Rhoades,et al.  Efficient testing of earthquake forecasting models , 2011 .

[75]  D. Wyborn,et al.  Investigation of Fault Mechanisms during Geothermal Reservoir Stimulation Experiments in the Cooper Basin, Australia , 2009 .

[76]  Reinhard Jung,et al.  A numerical model for fluid injection induced seismicity at Soultz-sous-Forêts , 2010 .

[77]  Fabio Moia,et al.  A survey of the induced seismic responses to fluid injection in geothermal and CO2 reservoirs in Europe , 2012 .

[78]  Stephen P. Horton,et al.  Disposal of Hydrofracking Waste Fluid by Injection into Subsurface Aquifers Triggers Earthquake Swarm in Central Arkansas with Potential for Damaging Earthquake , 2012 .

[79]  Stefan Wiemer,et al.  Geomechanical modeling of induced seismicity source parameters and implications for seismic hazard assessment , 2013 .

[80]  J. Rutqvist,et al.  Fault reactivation during CO2 sequestration: Effects of well orientation on seismicity and leakage , 2015 .

[81]  Dominique Bruel,et al.  Using the migration of the induced seismicity as a constraint for fractured Hot Dry Rock reservoir modelling , 2007 .