Comparative net energy analysis of renewable electricity and carbon capture and storage

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) for fossil-fuel power plants is perceived as a critical technology for climate mitigation. Nevertheless, limited installed capacity to date raises concerns about the ability of CCS to scale sufficiently. Conversely, scalable renewable electricity installations—solar and wind—are already deployed at scale and have demonstrated a rapid expansion potential. Here we show that power-sector CO2 emission reductions accomplished by investing in renewable technologies generally provide a better energetic return than CCS. We estimate the electrical energy return on energy invested ratio of CCS projects, accounting for their operational and infrastructural energy penalties, to range between 6.6:1 and 21.3:1 for 90% capture ratio and 85% capacity factor. These values compare unfavourably with dispatchable scalable renewable electricity with storage, which ranges from 9:1 to 30+:1 under realistic configurations. Therefore, renewables plus storage provide a more energetically effective approach to climate mitigation than constructing CCS fossil-fuel power stations.Carbon capture and storage can help reduce fossil-fuel power-plant emissions. Here the authors show that the energy return on input of thermal plants with carbon capture is in general lower than the energy return of most types of renewable energy even when combined with energy storage.

[1]  M. Stefancich,et al.  Evaluating the factors that led to low-priced solar electricity projects in the Middle East , 2018, Nature Energy.

[2]  Vasilis Fthenakis,et al.  The Energy and Environmental Performance of Ground-Mounted Photovoltaic Systems—A Timely Update , 2016 .

[3]  Lisa M. Colosi,et al.  Practical ambiguities during calculation of energy ratios and their impacts on life cycle assessment calculations , 2013 .

[4]  Pericles Pilidis,et al.  A Preliminary Assessment of the Initial Compression Power Requirement in CO2 Pipeline “Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Technologies” , 2016 .

[5]  O. Edenhofer,et al.  Integration costs revisited – An economic framework for wind and solar variability ☆ , 2015 .

[6]  Niall Mac Dowell,et al.  CO2 capture and storage (CCS) cost reduction via infrastructure right-sizing , 2017 .

[7]  J. Matsushima,et al.  Analysis of the Energy Balance of Shale Gas Development , 2014 .

[8]  Sgouris Sgouridis,et al.  The sower's way : quantifying the narrowing net-energy pathways to a global energy transition , 2016 .

[9]  Mark Z. Jacobson,et al.  Flexibility mechanisms and pathways to a highly renewable US electricity future , 2016 .

[10]  Christian Breyer,et al.  On the role of solar photovoltaics in global energy transition scenarios , 2016 .

[11]  David J. Murphy,et al.  Order from Chaos: A Preliminary Protocol for Determining the EROI of Fuels , 2011 .

[12]  Niall Mac Dowell,et al.  The role of CO2 purification and transport networks in carbon capture and storage cost reduction , 2017 .

[13]  P. Kazempoor,et al.  Novel electrical energy storage system based on reversible solid oxide cells: System design and operating conditions , 2015 .

[14]  Jon Freise,et al.  The EROI of Conventional Canadian Natural Gas Production , 2011 .

[15]  André Faaij,et al.  Uncertainty in Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) deployment projections: a cross-model comparison exercise , 2014, Climatic Change.

[16]  Michael Dale,et al.  A Comparative Analysis of Energy Costs of Photovoltaic, Solar Thermal, and Wind Electricity Generation Technologies , 2013 .

[17]  H. Jacobsen,et al.  Curtailment of renewable generation: Economic optimality and incentives , 2012 .

[18]  B. Metz.  IPCC special report on carbon dioxide capture and storage , 2005 .

[19]  Irene Bolea,et al.  Integration of post-combustion capture and storage into a pulverized coal-fired power plant , 2010 .

[20]  Andreas Brekke,et al.  Weighting of environmental trade-offs in CCS—an LCA case study of electricity from a fossil gas power plant with post-combustion CO2 capture, transport and storage , 2012, The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

[21]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  Year in review—EROI or energy return on (energy) invested , 2010, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[22]  M. Raugei.  Net energy analysis must not compare apples and oranges , 2019, Nature Energy.

[23]  Sally M. Benson,et al.  A better currency for investing in a sustainable future , 2014 .

[24]  Pierluigi Mancarella,et al.  UvA-DARE ( Digital Academic Repository ) Energy Return on Energy Invested ( ERoEI ) for photovoltaic solar systems in regions of moderate insolation , 2017 .

[25]  G. Versteeg,et al.  CO2 capture from power plants. Part I: A parametric study of the technical performance based on monoethanolamine , 2007 .

[26]  Alexandre Poisson,et al.  Time Series EROI for Canadian Oil and Gas , 2013 .

[27]  Rembrandt H.E.M. Koppelaar,et al.  Global available wind energy with physical and energy return on investment constraints , 2018 .

[28]  H. S. Matthews,et al.  Extending the Boundaries of Life‐Cycle Assessment through Environmental Economic Input‐Output Models , 2000 .

[29]  Andrea Schreiber,et al.  Meta‐Analysis of Life Cycle Assessment Studies on Electricity Generation with Carbon Capture and Storage , 2012 .

[30]  Analyzing major challenges of wind and solar variability in power systems , 2015 .

[31]  Keywan Riahi,et al.  Carbon budgets and energy transition pathways , 2016 .

[32]  Sally M. Benson,et al.  The energetic implications of curtailing versus storing solar- and wind-generated electricity , 2013 .

[33]  Sally M. Benson,et al.  Hydrogen or batteries for grid storage? A net energy analysis , 2015 .

[34]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  Energy Return on Energy Invested for Tight Gas Wells in the Appalachian Basin, United States of America , 2011 .

[35]  Rembrandt H.E.M. Koppelaar,et al.  Solar-PV energy payback and net energy: Meta-assessment of study quality, reproducibility, and results harmonization , 2017 .

[36]  Remo Guidieri.  Res , 1995, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics.

[37]  A. Faaij,et al.  The influence of uncertainty in the development of a CO2 infrastructure network , 2015 .

[38]  Michael Koller,et al.  Review of grid applications with the Zurich 1 MW battery energy storage system , 2015 .

[39]  Hossein Farahmand,et al.  Transmission expansion planning in Northern Europe in 2030—Methodology and analyses , 2013 .

[40]  J. C. van den Bergh,et al.  Implications of net energy-return-on-investment for a low-carbon energy transition , 2018, Nature Energy.

[41]  Yongqiang Liu,et al.  Contributions of open crop straw burning emissions to PM2.5 concentrations in China , 2016 .

[42]  Defne Apul,et al.  Energy payback time (EPBT) and energy return on energy invested (EROI) of solar photovoltaic systems: A systematic review and meta-analysis , 2015 .

[43]  Eric Masanet,et al.  A Framework for Environmental Assessment of CO2 Capture and Storage Systems , 2012 .

[44]  Andrew Forbes Alexander Hoadley,et al.  Reducing the energy penalty of CO2 capture and compression using pinch analysis , 2010 .

[45]  Andrea Ramírez,et al.  Environmental impact assessment of CCS chains – Lessons learned and limitations from LCA literature , 2013 .

[46]  Manfred Fischedick,et al.  Comparison of carbon capture and storage with renewable energy technologies regarding structural, economic, and ecological aspects in Germany , 2007 .

[47]  Diego Luca de Tena,et al.  Integrated modelling of variable renewable energy-based power supply in Europe , 2017 .

[48]  Cutler J. Cleveland,et al.  Meta-analysis of net energy return for wind power systems , 2010 .

[49]  E. J. Anthony,et al.  Carbon capture and storage update , 2014 .

[50]  André Faaij,et al.  A state-of-the-art review of techno-economic models predicting the costs of CO2 pipeline transport , 2013 .

[51]  Sgouris Sgouridis,et al.  Constant elasticity of substitution functions for energy modeling in general equilibrium integrated assessment models: a critical review and recommendations , 2017, Climatic Change.

[52]  Charles A. S. Hall,et al.  EROI of different fuels and the implications for society , 2014 .

[53]  Christian Breyer,et al.  Energy learning curves of PV systems , 2016 .

[54]  Ali Abbas,et al.  HEN optimization for efficient retrofitting of coal-fired power plants with post-combustion carbon capture , 2011 .

[55]  Jianliang Wang,et al.  Energy Return on Investment (EROI) of China's conventional fossil fuels: Historical and future trends , 2013 .

[56]  D. Kammen,et al.  A commercialization strategy for carbon-negative energy , 2016, Nature Energy.

[57]  Solomon F. Brown,et al.  Carbon capture and storage (CCS): the way forward , 2018 .

[58]  Göran Wall,et al.  A review of life cycle assessments on wind energy systems , 2012, The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment.

[59]  Rui Li,et al.  EROI Analysis for Direct Coal Liquefaction without and with CCS: The Case of the Shenhua DCL Project in China , 2015 .

[60]  Nilay Shah,et al.  Solar-assisted Post-combustion Carbon Capture feasibility study , 2012 .

[61]  Eric Williams,et al.  Potential economies of scale in CO2 transport through use of a trunk pipeline , 2010 .

[62]  Robert J. Brecha,et al.  Analyzing Major Challenges of Wind and Solar Variability in Power Systems , 2014 .

[63]  Grahame Smith,et al.  The way forward , 2018, Reaching Net Zero.

[64]  Charles F. Harvey,et al.  The energy penalty of post-combustion CO2 capture & storage and its implications for retrofitting the U.S. installed base , 2009 .

[65]  Sally M. Benson,et al.  On the importance of reducing the energetic and material demands of electrical energy storage , 2013 .

[66]  André Faaij,et al.  A review at the role of storage in energy systems with a focus on Power to Gas and long-term storage , 2018 .

[67]  David Reiner,et al.  Learning through a portfolio of carbon capture and storage demonstration projects , 2016, Nature Energy.