Combining Experimental Data and Computational Methods for the Non-Computer Specialist

Experimental methods are indispensable for the study of the function of biological macromolecules, not just as static structures, but as dynamic systems that change conformation, bind partners, perform reactions, and respond to different stimulus. However, providing a detailed structural interpretation of the results is often a very challenging task. While experimental and computational methods are often considered as two different and separate approaches, the power and utility of combining both is undeniable. The integration of the experimental data with computational techniques can assist and enrich the interpretation, providing new detailed molecular understanding of the systems. Here, we briefly describe the basic principles of how experimental data can be combined with computational methods to obtain insights into the molecular mechanism and expand the interpretation through the generation of detailed models.

[1]  Chandra S Verma,et al.  Mechanism of Enhanced Immature Dengue Virus Attachment to Endosomal Membrane Induced by prM Antibody. , 2019, Structure.

[2]  A. Bonvin,et al.  Integrative Modeling of Biomolecular Complexes: HADDOCKing with Cryo-Electron Microscopy Data. , 2015, Structure.

[3]  Luca Pinzi,et al.  Molecular Docking: Shifting Paradigms in Drug Discovery , 2019, International journal of molecular sciences.

[4]  Y. Sako,et al.  High-resolution cryo-EM: the nuts and bolts. , 2017, Current opinion in structural biology.

[5]  Emanuele Paci,et al.  Estimating Constraints for Protection Factors from HDX-MS Data , 2019, Biophysical journal.

[6]  Kresten Lindorff-Larsen,et al.  On the Calculation of SAXS Profiles of Folded and Intrinsically Disordered Proteins from Computer Simulations. , 2018, Journal of molecular biology.

[7]  Ad Bax,et al.  Prediction of Sterically Induced Alignment in a Dilute Liquid Crystalline Phase: Aid to Protein Structure Determination by NMR , 2000 .

[8]  Nir Kalisman,et al.  Integrative Structure Modeling: Overview and Assessment. , 2019, Annual review of biochemistry.

[9]  Jane R. Allison Assessing and refining molecular dynamics simulations of proteins with nuclear magnetic resonance data , 2012, Biophysical Reviews.

[10]  Yasuhiro Matsunaga,et al.  Linking time-series of single-molecule experiments with molecular dynamics simulations by machine learning , 2018, eLife.

[11]  Kresten Lindorff-Larsen,et al.  How to learn from inconsistencies: Integrating molecular simulations with experimental data. , 2020, Progress in molecular biology and translational science.

[12]  P. Biggin,et al.  A Refined Open State of the Glycine Receptor Obtained via Molecular Dynamics Simulations , 2019, bioRxiv.

[13]  Hong Liang,et al.  A method for integrative structure determination of protein-protein complexes , 2012, Bioinform..

[14]  Jan H. Jensen,et al.  ProCS15: a DFT-based chemical shift predictor for backbone and Cβ atoms in proteins , 2015, PeerJ.

[15]  P. Callis,et al.  Mechanisms of tryptophan fluorescence shifts in proteins. , 2001, Biophysical journal.

[16]  Stewart A. Adcock,et al.  Molecular dynamics: survey of methods for simulating the activity of proteins. , 2006, Chemical reviews.

[17]  Fabrizio Marinelli,et al.  Structural Characterization of Biomolecules through Atomistic Simulations Guided by DEER Measurements. , 2019, Structure.

[18]  D. Wishart,et al.  Unraveling the meaning of chemical shifts in protein NMR. , 2017, Biochimica et biophysica acta. Proteins and proteomics.

[19]  Sébastien Morin,et al.  Synergistic Applications of MD and NMR for the Study of Biological Systems , 2012, Journal of biomedicine & biotechnology.

[20]  David L. Stokes,et al.  Integrative Structure and Functional Anatomy of a Nuclear Pore Complex , 2018, Nature.

[21]  Determination of Protein Structural Ensembles by Hybrid-Resolution SAXS Restrained Molecular Dynamics , 2020, Journal of chemical theory and computation.

[22]  Yasuhiro Matsunaga,et al.  Use of single-molecule time-series data for refining conformational dynamics in molecular simulations. , 2020, Current opinion in structural biology.

[23]  Fabrizio Marinelli,et al.  Interpretation of HDX Data by Maximum-Entropy Reweighting of Simulated Structural Ensembles , 2020, Biophysical journal.

[24]  J. Prell,et al.  Computational Insights into Compaction of Gas-Phase Protein and Protein Complex Ions in Native Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry. , 2019, Trends in analytical chemistry : TRAC.

[25]  D. Piston,et al.  Fluorescent protein FRET: the good, the bad and the ugly. , 2007, Trends in biochemical sciences.

[26]  Fabrizio Marinelli,et al.  Confidence Analysis of DEER Data and Its Structural Interpretation with Ensemble-Biased Metadynamics. , 2018, Biophysical journal.

[27]  G C P van Zundert,et al.  The HADDOCK2.2 Web Server: User-Friendly Integrative Modeling of Biomolecular Complexes. , 2016, Journal of molecular biology.

[28]  G. Schröder,et al.  Integrating cryo-EM and NMR data. , 2020, Current opinion in structural biology.

[29]  D. Kihara,et al.  Advances in Structure Modeling Methods for Cryo-Electron Microscopy Maps , 2019, Molecules.

[30]  Leandro Martínez,et al.  Parametric models to compute tryptophan fluorescence wavelengths from classical protein simulations , 2018, J. Comput. Chem..

[31]  Holger Gohlke,et al.  Quantitative FRET studies and integrative modeling unravel the structure and dynamics of biomolecular systems. , 2016, Current opinion in structural biology.

[32]  Ben M. Webb,et al.  Integrative structure modeling with the Integrative Modeling Platform , 2017, Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society.

[33]  E. Marklund,et al.  Weighing-up protein dynamics: the combination of native mass spectrometry and molecular dynamics simulations. , 2019, Current opinion in structural biology.

[34]  A. Barth Infrared spectroscopy of proteins. , 2007, Biochimica et biophysica acta.

[35]  D. Svergun,et al.  CRYSOL : a program to evaluate X-ray solution scattering of biological macromolecules from atomic coordinates , 1995 .

[36]  Michal Sharon,et al.  The application of ion-mobility mass spectrometry for structure/function investigation of protein complexes. , 2018, Current opinion in chemical biology.

[37]  Marie Weiel,et al.  Rapid interpretation of small-angle X-ray scattering data , 2019, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[38]  Gunnar Jeschke,et al.  DEER distance measurements on proteins. , 2012, Annual review of physical chemistry.

[39]  Christian Griesinger,et al.  Quantitative determination of the conformational properties of partially folded and intrinsically disordered proteins using NMR dipolar couplings. , 2009, Structure.

[40]  P I Koukos,et al.  Integrative modelling of biomolecular complexes. , 2019, Journal of molecular biology.

[41]  E. Lindahl,et al.  Characterisation of molecular motions in cryo-EM single-particle data by multi-body refinement in RELION , 2018, bioRxiv.

[42]  Jianpeng Ma,et al.  CHARMM: The biomolecular simulation program , 2009, J. Comput. Chem..

[43]  J. Tainer,et al.  Evolving SAXS versatility: solution X-ray scattering for macromolecular architecture, functional landscapes, and integrative structural biology , 2019, Current opinion in structural biology.

[44]  J. Hennig,et al.  Ab Initio Prediction of NMR Spin Relaxation Parameters from Molecular Dynamics Simulations. , 2018, Journal of chemical theory and computation.

[45]  Antonino Ingargiola,et al.  Toward dynamic structural biology: Two decades of single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer , 2018, Science.

[46]  Caitlin M. Davis,et al.  A quantitative connection of experimental and simulated folding landscapes by vibrational spectroscopy , 2018, Chemical science.

[47]  Lauren Boldon,et al.  Review of the fundamental theories behind small angle X-ray scattering, molecular dynamics simulations, and relevant integrated application , 2015, Nano reviews.

[48]  Ron O. Dror,et al.  Molecular Dynamics Simulation for All , 2018, Neuron.

[49]  L. Konermann,et al.  How to run molecular dynamics simulations on electrospray droplets and gas phase proteins: Basic guidelines and selected applications. , 2018, Methods.

[50]  Xavier Salvatella,et al.  Synergistic use of NMR and MD simulations to study the structural heterogeneity of proteins , 2012 .

[51]  Sandro Bottaro,et al.  Integrating Molecular Simulation and Experimental Data: A Bayesian/Maximum Entropy reweighting approach , 2018, bioRxiv.

[52]  Jens Meiler,et al.  Reconstruction of SAXS Profiles from Protein Structures , 2013, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[53]  Toshimichi Fujiwara,et al.  Modern Technologies of Solution Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy for Three-dimensional Structure Determination of Proteins Open Avenues for Life Scientists , 2017, Computational and structural biotechnology journal.

[54]  J. P. Grossman,et al.  Biomolecular simulation: a computational microscope for molecular biology. , 2012, Annual review of biophysics.

[56]  F. Rico,et al.  High-speed force spectroscopy: microsecond force measurements using ultrashort cantilevers , 2019, Biophysical Reviews.

[57]  Helmut Grubmüller,et al.  Automated cryo-EM structure refinement using correlation-driven molecular dynamics , 2019, eLife.

[58]  Ruth Nussinov,et al.  Principles and Overview of Sampling Methods for Modeling Macromolecular Structure and Dynamics , 2016, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[59]  Georgios Skiniotis,et al.  Using enhanced sampling and structural restraints to refine atomic structures into low-resolution electron microscopy maps. , 2012, Structure.

[60]  Tiqing Liu,et al.  Quantitative Prediction of Fluorescence Quantum Yields for Tryptophan in Proteins , 2004 .

[61]  P. Salvador Dependencies of J-Couplings upon Dihedral Angles on Proteins , 2014 .

[62]  T. Ando Directly watching biomolecules in action by high-speed atomic force microscopy , 2017, Biophysical Reviews.

[63]  Kresten Lindorff-Larsen,et al.  Equilibrium simulations of proteins using molecular fragment replacement and NMR chemical shifts , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[64]  J. Díaz,et al.  A step toward the prediction of the fluorescence lifetimes of tryptophan residues in proteins based on structural and spectral data , 2008, Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society.

[65]  Gunnar Jeschke,et al.  The contribution of modern EPR to structural biology , 2018, Emerging topics in life sciences.

[66]  Dmitri I. Svergun,et al.  pyDockSAXS: protein–protein complex structure by SAXS and computational docking , 2015, Nucleic Acids Res..

[67]  Lazaros Mavridis,et al.  PDB2CD: a web-based application for the generation of circular dichroism spectra from protein atomic coordinates , 2017, Bioinform..

[68]  C. Schwieters,et al.  Theory and practice of using solvent paramagnetic relaxation enhancement to characterize protein conformational dynamics. , 2018, Methods.

[69]  Lee Makowski,et al.  Multidomain assembled states of Hck tyrosine kinase in solution , 2010, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[70]  R. Venkatramani,et al.  Near UV-Visible electronic absorption originating from charged amino acids in a monomeric protein , 2017, Chemical science.

[71]  H. Grubmüller,et al.  Heterogeneous and rate-dependent streptavidin–biotin unbinding revealed by high-speed force spectroscopy and atomistic simulations , 2018, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[72]  Holger Gohlke,et al.  Resolving dynamics and function of transient states in single enzyme molecules , 2018, Nature Communications.

[73]  Dominika Elmlund,et al.  Cryogenic electron microscopy and single-particle analysis. , 2015, Annual review of biochemistry.

[74]  R. Kaptein,et al.  Describing Partially Unfolded States of Proteins from Sparse NMR Ddata , 2005, Journal of biomolecular NMR.

[75]  Wei Huang,et al.  Fast-SAXS-pro: a unified approach to computing SAXS profiles of DNA, RNA, protein, and their complexes. , 2013, The Journal of chemical physics.

[76]  Chun Tang,et al.  Integrating non-NMR distance restraints to augment NMR depiction of protein structure and dynamics. , 2020, Journal of molecular biology.

[77]  Massimiliano Bonomi,et al.  Principles of protein structural ensemble determination. , 2017, Current opinion in structural biology.

[78]  S. Takada,et al.  The Particle Filter Method to Integrate High-Speed Atomic Force Microscopy Measurement with Biomolecular Simulations , 2020, bioRxiv.

[79]  E. Salvadori,et al.  Principles and applications of EPR spectroscopy in the chemical sciences. , 2018, Chemical Society reviews.

[80]  Yigong Shi A Glimpse of Structural Biology through X-Ray Crystallography , 2014, Cell.

[81]  Fabrizio Marinelli,et al.  Ensemble-Biased Metadynamics: A Molecular Simulation Method to Sample Experimental Distributions. , 2015, Biophysical journal.

[82]  N. Pastor,et al.  Different Dynamics in 6aJL2 Proteins Associated with AL Amyloidosis, a Conformational Disease , 2019, International journal of molecular sciences.

[83]  David D. Thomas,et al.  Trajectory-Based Simulation of EPR Spectra: Models of Rotational Motion for Spin Labels on Proteins. , 2019, The journal of physical chemistry. B.

[84]  G. Marius Clore,et al.  Using Xplor-NIH for NMR molecular structure determination , 2006 .

[85]  V. Oganesyan EPR spectroscopy and molecular dynamics modelling: a combined approach to study liquid crystals , 2018, Liquid Crystals.

[86]  Yifan Cheng Single-Particle Cryo-EM at Crystallographic Resolution , 2015, Cell.

[87]  Rommie E. Amaro,et al.  Ensemble Docking in Drug Discovery. , 2018, Biophysical journal.

[88]  Stefano Moro,et al.  Bridging Molecular Docking to Molecular Dynamics in Exploring Ligand-Protein Recognition Process: An Overview , 2018, Front. Pharmacol..

[89]  Lan Huang,et al.  Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry: An Emerging Technology for Interactomics and Structural Biology. , 2018, Analytical chemistry.

[90]  Kwong-Sak Leung,et al.  idock: A multithreaded virtual screening tool for flexible ligand docking , 2012, 2012 IEEE Symposium on Computational Intelligence in Bioinformatics and Computational Biology (CIBCB).

[91]  A. Ceulemans,et al.  Protein simulations: The absorption spectrum of barnase point mutants , 2004, Protein science : a publication of the Protein Society.

[92]  Chris Neale,et al.  Characterization of disordered proteins with ENSEMBLE , 2013, Bioinform..

[93]  Vladimir Sarpe,et al.  Mass spec studio for integrative structural biology. , 2014, Structure.

[94]  R. Aebersold,et al.  The Evolving Contribution of Mass Spectrometry to Integrative Structural Biology , 2016, Journal of The American Society for Mass Spectrometry.

[95]  R. Aebersold,et al.  Molecular architecture of the 26S proteasome holocomplex determined by an integrative approach , 2012, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[96]  Giovanni Bussi,et al.  Using the Maximum Entropy Principle to Combine Simulations and Solution Experiments , 2018, Comput..

[97]  A. Sali,et al.  Principles for Integrative Structural Biology Studies , 2019, Cell.

[98]  Martin Blackledge,et al.  Quantitative conformational analysis of partially folded proteins from residual dipolar couplings: application to the molecular recognition element of Sendai virus nucleoprotein. , 2008, Journal of the American Chemical Society.

[99]  Andrej Sali,et al.  FoXS: a web server for rapid computation and fitting of SAXS profiles , 2010, Nucleic Acids Res..

[100]  Ben M. Webb,et al.  Integrative structure modeling with IMP , 2017 .

[101]  Greg L. Hura,et al.  Structure and flexibility within proteins as identified through small angle X-ray scattering. , 2009, General physiology and biophysics.

[102]  M. Sattler,et al.  Current approaches for integrating solution NMR spectroscopy and small angle scattering to study the structure and dynamics of biomolecular complexes. , 2020, Journal of molecular biology.

[103]  N. Dokholyan,et al.  Solving protein structures using short-distance cross-linking constraints as a guide for discrete molecular dynamics simulations , 2017, Science Advances.

[104]  Alvaro J. Lopez,et al.  On the Interpretation of subtilisin Carlsberg Time-Resolved Fluorescence Anisotropy Decays: Modeling with Classical Simulations , 2019, J. Chem. Inf. Model..

[105]  Michele Vendruscolo,et al.  Rare fluctuations of native proteins sampled by equilibrium hydrogen exchange. , 2003, Journal of the American Chemical Society.

[106]  Nina Pastor,et al.  Information flow and protein dynamics: the interplay between nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations , 2015, Front. Plant Sci..

[107]  Yifan Cheng,et al.  Single-particle cryo-EM: beyond the resolution , 2019, National science review.

[108]  Kresten Lindorff-Larsen,et al.  PHAISTOS: A framework for Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation and inference of protein structure , 2013, J. Comput. Chem..

[109]  A. Bax,et al.  SPARTA+: a modest improvement in empirical NMR chemical shift prediction by means of an artificial neural network , 2010, Journal of biomolecular NMR.

[110]  Céline Charavay,et al.  Flexible-meccano: a tool for the generation of explicit ensemble descriptions of intrinsically disordered proteins and their associated experimental observables , 2012, Bioinform..

[111]  John A Tainer,et al.  Super-resolution in solution X-ray scattering and its applications to structural systems biology. , 2013, Annual review of biophysics.

[112]  Barbra Wallace The role of circular dichroism spectroscopy in the era of integrative structural biology. , 2019, Current opinion in structural biology.

[113]  Mark P. Foster,et al.  MESMER: minimal ensemble solutions to multiple experimental restraints , 2015, Bioinform..

[114]  Dmitri I. Svergun,et al.  Advanced ensemble modelling of flexible macromolecules using X-ray solution scattering , 2015, IUCrJ.

[115]  G. Fadda,et al.  Structure of Bolaamphiphile Sophorolipid Micelles Characterized with SAXS, SANS, and MD Simulations. , 2015, The journal of physical chemistry. B.

[116]  E. Paci,et al.  Functional Dynamics of Hexameric Helicase Probed by Hydrogen Exchange and Simulation , 2014, Biophysical journal.

[117]  Jun Huang,et al.  Single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer in molecular biology. , 2016, Nanoscale.

[118]  Massimiliano Bonomi,et al.  Bayesian Weighing of Electron Cryo-Microscopy Data for Integrative Structural Modeling. , 2019, Structure.

[119]  Simon W. Ginzinger,et al.  SHIFTX2: significantly improved protein chemical shift prediction , 2011, Journal of biomolecular NMR.

[120]  Peng Cheng,et al.  SAXS-Oriented Ensemble Refinement of Flexible Biomolecules. , 2017, Biophysical journal.

[121]  Computational Protocol to Evaluate Side-Chain Vicinal Spin-Spin Coupling Constants and Karplus Equation in Amino Acids: Alanine Dipeptide Model. , 2019, Journal of chemical theory and computation.

[122]  Berk Hess,et al.  GROMACS: High performance molecular simulations through multi-level parallelism from laptops to supercomputers , 2015 .

[123]  L. D. Roux,et al.  Applications of NMR and computational methodologies to study protein dynamics. , 2017, Archives of biochemistry and biophysics.

[124]  David Robinson,et al.  Computing infrared spectra of proteins using the exciton model , 2016, J. Comput. Chem..

[125]  Jan H. Jensen,et al.  Protein structure refinement using a quantum mechanics-based chemical shielding predictor , 2016, Chemical science.

[126]  Jonathan D. Hirst,et al.  DichroCalc - circular and linear dichroism online , 2009, Bioinform..

[127]  S. Lenton,et al.  Evaluating Models of Varying Complexity of Crowded Intrinsically Disordered Protein Solutions Against SAXS. , 2019, Journal of chemical theory and computation.

[128]  A. Cavalli,et al.  Structural and Kinetic Characterization of the Intrinsically Disordered Protein SeV NTAIL through Enhanced Sampling Simulations. , 2017, The journal of physical chemistry. B.

[129]  R. Aebersold,et al.  Crosslinking and Mass Spectrometry: An Integrated Technology to Understand the Structure and Function of Molecular Machines. , 2016, Trends in biochemical sciences.

[130]  T. Gräwert Structural Modeling Using Solution Small-Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS). , 2020, Journal of molecular biology.