Evolution, Population Thinking, and Essentialism

Ernst Mayr has argued that Darwinian theory discredited essentialist modes of thought and replaced them with what he has called "population thinking". In this paper, I characterize essentialism as embodying a certain conception of how variation in nature is to be explained, and show how this conception was undermined by evolutionary theory. The Darwinian doctrine of evolutionary gradualism makes it impossible to say exactly where one species ends and another begins; such line-drawing problems are often taken to be the decisive reason for thinking that essentialism is untenable. However, according to the view of essentialism I suggest, this familiar objection is not fatal to essentialism. It is rather the essentialist's use of what I call the natural state model for explaining variation which clashes with evolutionary theory. This model implemented the essentialist's requirement that properties of populations be defined in terms of properties of member organisms. Requiring such constituent definitions is reductionistic in spirit; additionally, evolutionary theory shows that such definitions are not available, and, moreover, that they are not needed to legitimize population-level concepts. Population thinking involves the thesis that population concepts may be legitimized by showing their connections with each other, even when they are not reducible to concepts applying at lower levels of organization. In the paper, I develop these points by describing Aristotle's ideas on the origins of biological variation; they are a classic formulation of the natural state model. I also describe how the development of statistical ideas in the 19th century involved an abandoning of the natural state model.

[1]  R. Lewontin,et al.  The Genetic Basis of Evolutionary Change , 2022 .

[2]  C. Kirwan,et al.  Aristotle: the growth and structure of his thought , 1968 .

[3]  D. Hull.  A Matter of Individuality , 1978, Philosophy of Science.

[4]  D. Balme.  Development of Biology in Aristotle and Theophrastus: Theory of Spontaneous Generation , 1962 .

[5]  M. Ghiselin.  A Radical Solution to the Species Problem , 1974 .

[6]  F. Marshall.  The Rise of Embryology , 1940, Nature.

[7]  E. Boring.  A History of Experimental Psychology. , 1930 .

[8]  S. Gould,et al.  Punctuated equilibria: an alternative to phyletic gradualism , 1972 .

[9]  E. Sober,et al.  The Principle of Parsimony , 1981, The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science.

[10]  William H. Bossert,et al.  A primer of population biology , 1972 .

[11]  H. M. Walker,et al.  Studies in the history of statistical method , 1930 .

[12]  G. C. Williams.  Sex and evolution. , 1975, Monographs in population biology.

[13]  N. Pierce.  Origin of Species , 1914, Nature.

[14]  Michael T. Ghiselin,et al.  On Psychologism in the Logic of Taxonomic Controversies , 1966 .

[15]  A. Preus.  Science and philosophy in Aristotle's biological works , 1975 .

[16]  J. Altham.  Naming and necessity. , 1981 .

[17]  W. Hardie.  ARISTOTLE: THE GROWTH AND STRUCTURE OF HIS THOUGHT , 1969 .

[18]  Aaron J. Ihde,et al.  The development of modern chemistry , 1964 .

[19]  J. Mulhern,et al.  Science and Philosophy in Aristotle’s Biological Works , 1977 .

[20]  Willard Van Orman Quine,et al.  From a Logical Point of View , 1955 .

[21]  E. S. Robinson.  A History of Experimental Psychology , 1930 .

[22]  Mayr,et al.  Evolution and the diversity of life , 1942 .

[23]  Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet,et al.  A Treatise on Man and the Development of his Faculties: OF THE INFLUENCE OF DISTURBING CAUSES ON MORTALITY , 1968 .

[24]  E. Mayr,et al.  The biological meaning of species , 1969 .

[25]  James F. Crow,et al.  The origins of theoretical population genetics , 1972 .

[26]  Willard Van Orman Quine,et al.  Word and Object , 1960 .

[27]  D. Hull.  Are Species Really Individuals , 1976 .

[28]  F. Ayala.  The mechanisms of evolution. , 1978, Scientific American.

[29]  L. Agassiz.  An Essay on Classification , 2015 .

[30]  unavoidably withheld.  The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication , 1868, The British and foreign medico-chirurgical review.

[31]  J. Felsenstein.  A primer of population biology , 1972 .

[32]  R. Cowan.  Francis Galton's contribution to genetics , 1972, Journal of the history of biology.

[33]  Ron Koppelberger,et al.  Space and Time , 2021, Nature.

[34]  G. A. Horridge,et al.  Animal species and evolution. , 1964 .