A review of nature-based solutions for urban water management in European circular cities: a critical assessment based on case studies and literature

Nature-based solutions (NBS) can protect, manage and restore natural or modified ecosystems. They are a multidisciplinary, integrated approach to address societal challenges and some natural hazards effectively and adaptively, simultaneously providing human well-being and biodiversity benefits. NBS applications can be easily noticed in circular cities, establishing an urban system that is regenerative and accessible. This paper aims to offer a review on NBS for urban water management from the literature and some relevant projects running within the COST Action ‘Implementing nature-based solutions for creating a resourceful circular city’. The method used in the study is based on a detailed tracking of specific keywords in the literature using Google Scholar, ResearchGate, Academia.edu, ScienceDirect and Scopus. Based on this review, three main applications were identified: (i) flood and drought protection; (ii) the water-food-energy nexus; and (iii) water purification. The paper shows that NBS provide additional benefits, such as improving water quality, increasing biodiversity, obtaining social co-benefits, improving urban microclimate, and the reduction of energy consumption by improving indoor climate. The paper concludes that a systemic change to NBS should be given a higher priority and be preferred over conventional water infrastructure.

[1]  Davide Geneletti,et al.  A framework for assessing and implementing the co-benefits of nature-based solutions in urban areas , 2017 .

[2]  Zhe-ming Tong,et al.  A case study of air quality above an urban roof top vegetable farm. , 2016, Environmental pollution.

[3]  I. Masih,et al.  Intensification of constructed wetlands for land area reduction: a review , 2017, Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

[4]  Timothy O. Randhir,et al.  Managing emerging contaminants in watersheds: Need for comprehensive, systems-based strategies , 2017 .

[5]  Patrizia Piro,et al.  Hydrological Effectiveness of an Extensive Green Roof in Mediterranean Climate , 2019, Water.

[6]  C. Arias,et al.  "WETWALL” : an innovative design concept for the treatment of wastewater at an urban scale , 2018 .

[7]  M. Hekkert,et al.  Conceptualizing the Circular Economy: An Analysis of 114 Definitions , 2017 .

[8]  J. Bayona,et al.  Occurrence and fate of benzothiazoles and benzotriazoles in constructed wetlands. , 2010, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[9]  V. Matamoros,et al.  The ability of biologically based wastewater treatment systems to remove emerging organic contaminants—a review , 2014, Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

[10]  Francesca Nocca,et al.  Moving Towards the Circular Economy/City Model: Which Tools for Operationalizing This Model? , 2019, Sustainability.

[11]  Jakob Magid,et al.  A minimum data set of water quality parameters to assess and compare treatment efficiency of stormwater facilities. , 2011, Journal of environmental quality.

[12]  Patrizia Piro,et al.  A comprehensive numerical analysis of the hydraulic behavior of a permeable pavement , 2016 .

[13]  Connor David,et al.  Mapping and Assessment of Ecosystems and their Services – An analytical framework for ecosystem assessments under Action 5 of the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020. Discussion paper , 2013 .

[14]  Elke S. Reichwaldt,et al.  Giving waterbodies the treatment they need: A critical review of the application of constructed floating wetlands. , 2019, Journal of environmental management.

[15]  J. Spangenberg,et al.  Nature-based solutions: sustainable? , 2017, Nature.

[16]  P. Piro,et al.  Energy and Hydraulic Performance of a Vegetated Roof in Sub-Mediterranean Climate , 2018, Sustainability.

[17]  H. Richnow,et al.  Monitoring and assessing processes of organic chemicals removal in constructed wetlands. , 2009, Chemosphere.

[18]  J. V. Hoof,et al.  Application of Ecological Footprint Accounting as a Part of an Integrated Assessment of Environmental Carrying Capacity: A Case Study of the Footprint of Food of a Large City , 2018, Resources.

[19]  Ghassan Chebbo,et al.  Priority pollutants in urban stormwater: part 2 - case of combined sewers. , 2012, Water research.

[20]  H. Brix,et al.  A review of plant–pharmaceutical interactions: from uptake and effects in crop plants to phytoremediation in constructed wetlands , 2014, Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

[21]  Greening and Cooling the City Using Novel Urban Water Systems , 2019, Approaches to Water Sensitive Urban Design.

[22]  T. Headley,et al.  The taxonomy of treatment wetlands: A proposed classification and nomenclature system , 2013 .

[23]  D. Barceló,et al.  Emerging Contaminants from Industrial and Municipal Waste , 2008 .

[24]  A. Paschke Consideration of the physicochemical properties of sample matrices – an important step in sampling and sample preparation , 2003 .

[25]  R R Brown,et al.  The water sensitive city: principles for practice. , 2009, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[26]  The Internet of Things for Smart Urban Ecosystems , 2019, Internet of Things.

[27]  Salvatore Losco,et al.  Water Sensitive Urban Design - WSUD - Principles and Inspiration for Sustainable Stormwater Management in the City of the Future - AA.VV. , 2014 .

[28]  A. Wüest,et al.  Effects of oligotrophication on primary production in peri‐alpine lakes , 2013 .

[29]  Fabio Masi,et al.  Integrated valuation of a nature-based solution for water pollution control. Highlighting hidden benefits , 2016 .

[30]  Nadja Kabisch,et al.  Nature-Based Solutions to Climate Change Adaptation in Urban Areas: Linkages between Science, Policy and Practice , 2017 .

[31]  Emmanuelle Cohen-Shacham,et al.  Nature-based solutions to address global societal challenges , 2016 .

[32]  Jan Kazak,et al.  Pluvial Flood Risk Assessment Tool (PFRA) for Rainwater Management and Adaptation to Climate Change in Newly Urbanised Areas , 2018 .

[33]  Ü. Mander,et al.  Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment in Cold Climates , 2002 .

[34]  A. Rizzo,et al.  The role of constructed wetlands in a new circular economy, resource oriented, and ecosystem services paradigm. , 2017, Journal of environmental management.

[35]  H. Brix,et al.  Removal of the pharmaceuticals ibuprofen and iohexol by four wetland plant species in hydroponic culture: plant uptake and microbial degradation , 2016, Environmental Science and Pollution Research.

[36]  S. Keesstra,et al.  Connectivity assessment in Mediterranean vineyards using improved stock unearthing method, LiDAR and soil erosion field surveys , 2018 .

[37]  K. Sakadevan,et al.  Stormwater treatment: do constructed wetlands yield improved pollutant management performance over a detention pond system? , 2001, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[38]  Peter Steen Mikkelsen,et al.  SUDS, LID, BMPs, WSUD and more – The evolution and application of terminology surrounding urban drainage , 2015 .

[39]  Soon Keat Tan,et al.  Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in cold climate - A review. , 2017, Journal of environmental sciences.

[40]  F. Müller,et al.  Mapping ecosystem service supply, demand and budgets , 2012 .

[41]  T. McPhearson,et al.  Integrating the Grey, Green, and Blue in Cities: Nature-Based Solutions for Climate Change Adaptation and Risk Reduction , 2017 .

[42]  Georgia Destouni,et al.  Nature-based solutions for flood-drought risk mitigation in vulnerable urbanizing parts of East-Africa , 2018, Current Opinion in Environmental Science & Health.

[43]  P. Bolund,et al.  Ecosystem services in urban areas , 1999 .

[44]  E. Katsou,et al.  Implementing nature-based solutions for creating a resourceful circular city , 2020, Blue-Green Systems.

[45]  Adrián M.T. Silva,et al.  A review on the application of constructed wetlands for the removal of priority substances and contaminants of emerging concern listed in recently launched EU legislation. , 2017, Environmental pollution.

[46]  Kalanithy Vairavamoorthy Managing Water for the City of the Future , 2009 .

[47]  R. Haines-Young,et al.  Nature-Based Solutions , 2016 .

[48]  M. C. Tomei,et al.  Performance of secondary wastewater treatment methods for the removal of contaminants of emerging concern implicated in crop uptake and antibiotic resistance spread: A review. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[49]  Floris Boogaard,et al.  Stormwater characteristics and new testing methods for certain sustainable urban drainage systems in The Netherlands , 2015 .

[50]  F. Escobedo,et al.  Edible green infrastructure: An approach and review of provisioning ecosystem services and disservices in urban environments , 2017 .

[51]  S. J. Stanley,et al.  Urban stormwater quality: Summary of contaminant data , 1995 .

[52]  Robert Costanza,et al.  Ecosystem Appropriation by Cities , 1996 .

[53]  Patrizia Piro,et al.  A Comprehensive Approach to Stormwater Management Problems in the Next Generation Drainage Networks , 2018, The Internet of Things for Smart Urban Ecosystems.

[54]  Małgorzata Świąder,et al.  The implementation of the concept of environmental carrying capacity into spatial management of cities , 2018, Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal.

[55]  P S Mikkelsen,et al.  Selected stormwater priority pollutants: a European perspective. , 2007, The Science of the total environment.

[56]  James M. Gaines Flooding: Water potential , 2016, Nature.

[57]  Sander Jacobs,et al.  Nature‐Based Solutions for Europe's Sustainable Development , 2017 .

[58]  Hanna Obarska-Pempkowiak,et al.  Oczyszczalnie hydrofitowe jako wdrożenie założeń idei gospodarki o obiegu zamkniętym , 2018 .

[59]  Ashok K. Sharma,et al.  Approaches to Water Sensitive Urban Design: Potential, Design, Ecological Health, Urban Greening, Economics, Policies, and Community Perceptions , 2018 .

[60]  J. K. Kazak,et al.  Decision support systems for a sustainable management of the indoor and built environment , 2018, Indoor and Built Environment.

[61]  R R Brown,et al.  Urban water management in cities: historical, current and future regimes. , 2009, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[62]  D. Benson,et al.  Particle tracking and the diffusion‐reaction equation , 2013 .

[63]  W. Gujer,et al.  The concept of sustainable Urban Water Management , 1997 .

[64]  A. Rizzo,et al.  Constructed wetlands for combined sewer overflow treatment: Ecosystem services at Gorla Maggiore, Italy , 2017 .

[65]  H. Golden,et al.  Green infrastructure and its catchment-scale effects: an emerging science , 2018, WIREs. Water.

[66]  J. N. Fernandes,et al.  Key issues for sustainable urban stormwater management. , 2012, Water research.

[67]  Ana Mijic,et al.  Blue Green Solutions. A Systems Approach to Sustainable and Cost-Effective Urban Development , 2017 .

[68]  N. Ursino Dynamic models of socio-ecological systems predict catastrophic shifts following unsustainable development. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[69]  S. Arden,et al.  Constructed wetlands for greywater recycle and reuse: A review. , 2018, The Science of the total environment.

[70]  Ting Fong May Chui,et al.  Linking hydrological and bioecological benefits of green infrastructures across spatial scales - A literature review. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[71]  P. Piro,et al.  Synthetic sustainability index (SSI) based on life cycle assessment approach of low impact development in the Mediterranean area , 2017 .

[72]  Yolanda Madrid,et al.  Water sampling : Traditional methods and new approaches in water sampling strategy , 2007 .

[73]  W. Botzen,et al.  Review of economic valuation of nature based solutions in urban areas , 2017 .

[74]  Soon Keat Tan,et al.  Removal of pharmaceuticals and personal care products in aquatic plant-based systems: a review. , 2014, Environmental pollution.

[75]  Nancey Green Leigh,et al.  Sustainable and Resilient Urban Water Systems: The Role of Decentralization and Planning , 2019, Sustainability.

[76]  Susan A Baldwin,et al.  Vermicomposting toilets, an alternative to latrine style microbial composting toilets, prove far superior in mass reduction, pathogen destruction, compost quality, and operational cost. , 2012, Waste management.

[77]  Guenter Langergraber,et al.  Green walls for greywater treatment and recycling in dense urban areas: a case-study in Pune , 2016 .

[78]  G. Bennett,et al.  Natural infrastructure investment and implications for the nexus: A global overview , 2016 .

[79]  W. Wang,et al.  Water Resources Compound Systems: A Macro Approach to Analysing Water Resource Issues under Changing Situations , 2015 .

[80]  H. Andrieu,et al.  Understanding, management and modelling of urban hydrology and its consequences for receiving waters: A state of the art , 2013 .

[81]  J. Vymazal Is removal of organics and suspended solids in horizontal sub-surface flow constructed wetlands sustainable for twenty and more years? , 2019 .

[82]  Scientific The United Nations World Water Development Report 2018 , 2019, The United Nations World Water Development Report.

[83]  S. Keesstra,et al.  The superior effect of nature based solutions in land management for enhancing ecosystem services. , 2018, The Science of the total environment.

[84]  S. Guner United Nations World Water Assessment Programme , 2011 .

[85]  I. Rodríguez-Roda,et al.  Long term decentralized greywater treatment for water reuse purposes in a tourist facility by vertical ecosystem , 2019, Ecological Engineering.

[86]  J. Kazak,et al.  Spatial Form of Greenery in Strategic Environmental Management in the Context of Urban Adaptation to Climate Change , 2019, Polish Journal of Environmental Studies.

[87]  R. Moilleron,et al.  Priority pollutants in urban stormwater: part 1 - case of separate storm sewers. , 2012, Water research.

[88]  Paola Verlicchi,et al.  How efficient are constructed wetlands in removing pharmaceuticals from untreated and treated urban wastewaters? A review. , 2014, The Science of the total environment.

[89]  P. Piro,et al.  The Influence of Hydrologic Parameters on the Hydraulic Efficiency of an Extensive Green Roof in Mediterranean Area , 2016 .

[90]  Chirjiv K Anand,et al.  Composting toilets as a sustainable alternative to urban sanitation--a review. , 2014, Waste management.

[91]  Maes Joachim,et al.  Mapping and Assessment of Ecosystems and their Services , 2013 .

[92]  Nicolas Faivre,et al.  Nature‐Based Solutions in the EU: Innovating with nature to address social, economic and environmental challenges , 2017, Environmental research.

[93]  P. Bosch,et al.  CITYkeys indicators for smart city projects and smart cities , 2017 .

[94]  A. Singh,et al.  Constructed Wetlands for Management of Urban Stormwater Runoff , 2012 .

[95]  B. Burkhard,et al.  Quantification and Mapping of Flood Regulating Ecosystem Services in Different Watersheds – Case Studies in Bulgaria and Arizona, USA , 2014 .

[96]  Marko P. Hekkert,et al.  Conceptualizing the Circular Economy: An Analysis of 114 Definitions , 2017 .

[97]  N. Frantzeskaki,et al.  The uptake of the ecosystem services concept in planning discourses of European and American cities , 2015 .

[98]  I. Wagner,et al.  From classical water-ecosystem theories to nature-based solutions - Contextualizing nature-based solutions for sustainable city. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[99]  T. Gu,et al.  Microbial fuel cell hybrid systems for wastewater treatment and bioenergy production: Synergistic effects, mechanisms and challenges , 2019, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.

[100]  A. Bawiec Efficiency of nitrogen and phosphorus compounds removal in hydroponic wastewater treatment plant , 2019, Environmental technology.

[101]  R Fragoso,et al.  Overview of the state of the art of constructed wetlands for decentralized wastewater management in Brazil. , 2017, Journal of environmental management.

[102]  L. Bracken,et al.  Introduction to special issue on connectivity in water and sediment dynamics , 2015 .

[103]  L. Ridolfi,et al.  Flood reduction as an ecosystem service of constructed wetlands for combined sewer overflow , 2018 .

[104]  Soon Keat Tan,et al.  Application of constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in developing countries--a review of recent developments (2000-2013). , 2014, Journal of environmental management.

[105]  Niki Frantzeskaki,et al.  Seven lessons for planning nature-based solutions in cities , 2019, Environmental Science & Policy.

[106]  J. Kamińska,et al.  Assessing the impact of wastewater effluent diversion on water quality , 2017 .

[107]  Jiquan Chen,et al.  Nature-based solutions for resilient landscapes and cities. , 2018, Environmental research.

[108]  Davide Geneletti,et al.  An impact evaluation framework to support planning and evaluation of nature-based solutions projects , 2017 .

[109]  Patrizia Piro,et al.  On the use of surrogate-based modeling for the numerical analysis of Low Impact Development techniques , 2017 .

[110]  Soon Keat Tan,et al.  A review on removing pharmaceutical contaminants from wastewater by constructed wetlands: design, performance and mechanism. , 2014, The Science of the total environment.

[111]  Low –Impact Development Design: A New Paradigm for Stormwater Management Mimicking and Restoring the Natural Hydrologic Regime An Alternative Stormwater Management Technology , 2000 .

[112]  Johan Bouma,et al.  The significance of soils and soil science towards realization of the United Nations sustainable development goals , 2016 .

[113]  C. Conoscenti,et al.  A comparison of statistical methods and multi-criteria decision making to map flood hazard susceptibility in Northern Iran. , 2019, The Science of the total environment.

[114]  E. V. van Hullebusch,et al.  Role of Design and Operational Factors in the Removal of Pharmaceuticals by Constructed Wetlands , 2019, Water.

[115]  N. Frantzeskaki,et al.  Nature-based solutions to climate change mitigation and adaptation in urban areas: perspectives on indicators, knowledge gaps, barriers, and opportunities for action , 2016 .