The paper presents a theoretical-experimental comparison concerning standard crushing-traction tests of flexible pipe prototypes. The theoretical model for crushing is analytical and based on classic assumptions of equivalent pipes, applying model previously published in OMAE2003, and OMAE2010. Such a model considers the combined action of squeezing, concentrated loads due to the caterpillar shoes as well as the effect of initial ovalization. The experimental measures include a detailed internal geometrical mapping of the deformed carcass, until plastic deformation becomes evident. Discussion is made on the pertinence of modeling hypotheses. Sensitivity analyses, regarding initial ovalization and helical pitch of the pressure armor are also addressed.Copyright © 2011 by ASME