5G Wireless Communication and Health Effects—A Pragmatic Review Based on Available Studies Regarding 6 to 100 GHz

The introduction of the fifth generation (5G) of wireless communication will increase the number of high-frequency-powered base stations and other devices. The question is if such higher frequencies (in this review, 6–100 GHz, millimeter waves, MMW) can have a health impact. This review analyzed 94 relevant publications performing in vivo or in vitro investigations. Each study was characterized for: study type (in vivo, in vitro), biological material (species, cell type, etc.), biological endpoint, exposure (frequency, exposure duration, power density), results, and certain quality criteria. Eighty percent of the in vivo studies showed responses to exposure, while 58% of the in vitro studies demonstrated effects. The responses affected all biological endpoints studied. There was no consistent relationship between power density, exposure duration, or frequency, and exposure effects. The available studies do not provide adequate and sufficient information for a meaningful safety assessment, or for the question about non-thermal effects. There is a need for research regarding local heat developments on small surfaces, e.g., skin or the eye, and on any environmental impact. Our quality analysis shows that for future studies to be useful for safety assessment, design and implementation need to be significantly improved.

[1]  Fotis Foukalas,et al.  5G: The Convergence of Wireless Communications , 2015, Wirel. Pers. Commun..

[2]  A. Ahlbom Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) , 1998 .

[3]  N. Chemeris,et al.  Anti‐inflammatory effects of low‐intensity extremely high‐frequency electromagnetic radiation: Frequency and power dependence , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[4]  Alexis Agelan,et al.  Effect of millimeter waves on cyclophosphamide induced suppression of the immune system , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[5]  Myrtill Simkó,et al.  Is there a Biological Basis for Therapeutic Applications of Millimetre Waves and THz Waves? , 2018 .

[6]  P. A. Mason,et al.  Protein changes in macrophages induced by plasma from rats exposed to 35 GHz millimeter waves , 2010, Bioelectromagnetics.

[7]  M. Ziskin,et al.  Effect of millimeter waves on cyclophosphamide induced suppression of T cell functions , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[8]  S. Alekseev,et al.  Enhanced absorption of millimeter wave energy in murine subcutaneous blood vessels , 2011, Bioelectromagnetics.

[9]  Marvin C Ziskin Millimeter waves: acoustic and electromagnetic. , 2013, Bioelectromagnetics.

[10]  N. Chemeris,et al.  The role of fatty acids in anti‐inflammatory effects of low‐intensity extremely high‐frequency electromagnetic radiation , 2011, Bioelectromagnetics.

[11]  P. A. Mason,et al.  Lack of effect of 94 GHz radio frequency radiation exposure in an animal model of skin carcinogenesis. , 2001, Carcinogenesis.

[12]  N. Chemeris,et al.  Inhibition of the production of reactive oxygen species in mouse peritoneal neutrophils by millimeter wave radiation in the near and far field zones of the radiator , 1997 .

[13]  Giri N. K. Rangan,et al.  Committee , 2019, 2019 International Conference on Radar, Antenna, Microwave, Electronics, and Telecommunications (ICRAMET).

[14]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter wave‐induced suppression of B16 F10 melanoma growth in mice: Involvement of endogenous opioids , 2004, Bioelectromagnetics.

[15]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  Thermal Response of Human Skin to Microwave Energy: A Critical Review , 2016, Health physics.

[16]  N. A. Volkova,et al.  Effects of Millimeter-Wave Electromagnetic Exposure on the Morphology and Function of Human Cryopreserved Spermatozoa , 2014, Bulletin of Experimental Biology and Medicine.

[17]  K. Schoenbach,et al.  A study on biological effects of low-intensity millimeter waves , 2002 .

[18]  W R Green,et al.  Absence of ocular effects after either single or repeated exposure to 10 mW/cm(2) from a 60 GHz CW source. , 1999, Bioelectromagnetics.

[19]  Zuanfang Li,et al.  Millimeter wave treatment promotes chondrocyte proliferation via G1/S cell cycle transition. , 2012, International journal of molecular medicine.

[20]  M. Yashin,et al.  Exposure to Low-Intensive Superhigh Frequency Electromagnetic Field as a Factor of Carcinogenesis in Experimental Animals , 2005, Bulletin of Experimental Biology and Medicine.

[21]  Ronan Sauleau,et al.  Effect of acute millimeter wave exposure on dopamine metabolism of NGF-treated PC12 cells , 2017, Journal of radiation research.

[22]  Lu Xia,et al.  The effect of different treatment time of millimeter wave on chondrocyte apoptosis, caspase-3, caspase-8, and MMP-13 expression in rabbit surgically induced model of knee osteoarthritis , 2012, Rheumatology International.

[23]  Amerigo Beneduci,et al.  Transmission electron microscopy study of the effects produced by wide-band low-power millimeter waves on MCF-7 human breast cancer cells in culture. , 2005, Anticancer research.

[24]  P. A. Mason,et al.  COMPARISON OF BLOOD PRESSURE AND THERMAL RESPONSES IN RATS EXPOSED TO MILLIMETER WAVE ENERGY OR ENVIRONMENTAL HEAT , 2006, Shock.

[25]  A Cowan,et al.  Peripheral neural system involvement in hypoalgesic effect of electromagnetic millimeter waves. , 2001, Life sciences.

[26]  O. Gandhi,et al.  Effects of millimeter-wave radiation on monolayer cell cultures. I. Design and validation of a novel exposure system. , 1981, Bioelectromagnetics.

[27]  Ronan Sauleau,et al.  Impact of 60‐GHz millimeter waves and corresponding heat effect on endoplasmic reticulum stress sensor gene expression , 2014, Bioelectromagnetics.

[28]  Soichi Watanabe,et al.  ACUTE OCULAR INJURIES CAUSED BY 60-GHZ MILLIMETER-WAVE EXPOSURE , 2009, Health physics.

[29]  Kodo Kawase,et al.  Investigation of the non-thermal effects of exposing cells to 70–300 GHz irradiation using a widely tunable source , 2017, Journal of radiation research.

[30]  Y. Akyel,et al.  Role of field intensity in the biological effectiveness of millimeter waves at a resonance frequency , 1997 .

[31]  S. Alekseev,et al.  Millimeter-wave-induced hypoalgesia in mice: dependence on type of experimental pain , 2004, IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science.

[32]  Akimasa Hirata,et al.  Human exposure to pulsed fields in the frequency range from 6 to 100 GHz , 2017, Physics in medicine and biology.

[33]  Yan Wu,et al.  Millimeter-wave exposure promotes the differentiation of bone marrow stromal cells into cells with a neural phenotype , 2009, Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology. Medical sciences = Hua zhong ke ji da xue xue bao. Yi xue Ying De wen ban = Huazhong keji daxue xuebao. Yixue Yingdewen ban.

[34]  Marvin C Ziskin,et al.  Low power millimeter wave irradiation exerts no harmful effect on human keratinocytes in vitro , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[35]  Luc Martens,et al.  On‐body calibration and measurements using personal radiofrequency exposimeters in indoor diffuse and specular environments , 2016, Bioelectromagnetics.

[36]  J. Varner,et al.  Millimeter wave-induced modulation of calcium dynamics in an engineered skin co-culture model: role of secreted ATP on calcium spiking. , 2012, Journal of radiation research.

[37]  S. Ayrapetyan,et al.  Cell bathing medium as a target for non thermal effect of millimeter waves , 2012, Electromagnetic biology and medicine.

[38]  Frequency dependence of heating of human skin exposed to millimeter waves , 2012, Biofizika.

[39]  G. Gallerano,et al.  Genotoxic Effects in Human Fibroblasts Exposed to Microwave Radiation , 2018, Health physics.

[40]  Opinion on potential health effects of exposure to electromagnetic fields , 2015, Bioelectromagnetics.

[41]  A Cowan,et al.  Hypoalgesic effect of millimeter waves in mice: dependence on the site of exposure. , 2000, Life sciences.

[42]  F. Keilmann,et al.  Nonthermal Effects of Millimeter Microwaves on Yeast Growth , 1978, Zeitschrift fur Naturforschung. Section C, Biosciences.

[43]  S. Ayrapetyan,et al.  Cyclic AMP-dependent signaling system is a primary metabolic target for non-thermal effect of microwaves on heart muscle hydration , 2017, Electromagnetic biology and medicine.

[44]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  RF Energy Absorption by Biological Tissues in Close Proximity to Millimeter-Wave 5G Wireless Equipment , 2018, IEEE Access.

[45]  Marvin C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter wave effects on electrical responses of the sural nerve in vivo. , 2010, Bioelectromagnetics.

[46]  Maria Rosaria Scarfì,et al.  Experimental Requirements for in vitro Studies Aimed to Evaluate the Biological Effects of Radiofrequency Radiation , 2012 .

[47]  T. Walters,et al.  Pathophysiological alterations induced by sustained 35-GHz radio-frequency energy heating , 2016, Journal of basic and clinical physiology and pharmacology.

[48]  A Cowan,et al.  Suppression of pain sensation caused by millimeter waves: a double-blinded, cross-over, prospective human volunteer study. , 1999, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[49]  E. E. Fesenko,et al.  Dual effects of microwaves on single Ca2+‐activated K+ channels in cultured kidney cells Vero , 1995, FEBS letters.

[50]  Guidelines Icnirp Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) , 1998 .

[51]  Marvin C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter wave induced reversible externalization of phosphatidylserine molecules in cells exposed in vitro , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[52]  Ronan Sauleau,et al.  Absence of direct effect of low-power millimeter-wave radiation at 60.4 GHz on endoplasmic reticulum stress , 2009, Cell Biology and Toxicology.

[53]  M. Zhadobov,et al.  Effects of 60-GHz millimeter waves on neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells using high-content screening , 2016, Neuroscience Letters.

[54]  S. Popov,et al.  The effect of a 94 GHz electromagnetic field on neuronal microtubules , 2013, Bioelectromagnetics.

[55]  O. Gandhi,et al.  Effects of millimeter-wave radiation on monolayer cell cultures. III. A search for frequency-specific athermal biological effects on protein synthesis. , 1981, Bioelectromagnetics.

[56]  M. Ziskin,et al.  Single millimeter wave treatment does not impair gastrointestinal transit in mice. , 2002, Life sciences.

[57]  A Cowan,et al.  Electromagnetic millimeter wave induced hypoalgesia: Frequency dependence and involvement of endogenous opioids , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[58]  J R Jauchem,et al.  Does nitric oxide mediate circulatory failure induced by 35-GHz microwave heating? , 1996, Shock.

[59]  Avraham Gover,et al.  Terahertz Radiation Increases Genomic Instability in Human Lymphocytes , 2008, Radiation research.

[60]  E. Mikhalchik,et al.  Extremely high‐frequency electromagnetic radiation enhances neutrophil response to particulate agonists , 2018, Bioelectromagnetics.

[61]  E. Moros,et al.  Altered Calcium Dynamics Mediates P19-Derived Neuron-Like Cell Responses to Millimeter-Wave Radiation , 2009, Radiation research.

[62]  M. Zhadobov,et al.  Whole‐genome expression analysis in primary human keratinocyte cell cultures exposed to 60 GHz radiation , 2012, Bioelectromagnetics.

[63]  G. Dubost,et al.  Biological effects of millimeter wave irradiation on mice-preliminary results , 2000 .

[64]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter wave dosimetry of human skin , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[65]  V. Safronova,et al.  Immunomodulating action of low intensity millimeter waves on primed neutrophils , 2002, Bioelectromagnetics.

[66]  A. Caduff,et al.  Human skin as arrays of helical antennas in the millimeter and submillimeter wave range , 2008, 2008 33rd International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter and Terahertz Waves.

[67]  Effects of millimeter-wave radiation on monolayer cell cultures. II. Scanning and transmission electron microscopy. , 1981, Bioelectromagnetics.

[68]  Youqin Chen,et al.  Millimeter wave treatment inhibits the mitochondrion-dependent apoptosis pathway in chondrocytes. , 2011, Molecular medicine reports.

[69]  Thomas J. Prihoda,et al.  Micronuclei in Peripheral Blood and Bone Marrow Cells of Mice Exposed to 42 GHz Electromagnetic Millimeter Waves , 2004, Radiation research.

[70]  Ronan Sauleau,et al.  Transcriptome Analysis Reveals the Contribution of Thermal and the Specific Effects in Cellular Response to Millimeter Wave Exposure , 2014, PloS one.

[71]  S. Alekseev,et al.  Microscale temperature and SAR measurements in cell monolayer models exposed to millimeter waves , 2017, Bioelectromagnetics.

[72]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter waves thermally alter the firing rate of the Lymnaea pacemaker neuron. , 1997, Bioelectromagnetics.

[73]  P. A. Mason,et al.  Gene Expression Changes in the Skin of Rats Induced by Prolonged 35 GHz Millimeter-Wave Exposure , 2008, Radiation research.

[74]  A Cowan,et al.  Antipruritic effect of millimeter waves in mice: evidence for opioid involvement. , 1998, Life sciences.

[75]  Effects of Millimeter-Wave Electromagnetic Radiation on the Experimental Model of Migraine , 2016, Bulletin of Experimental Biology and Medicine.

[76]  M. Scarfì,et al.  Quality Matters: Systematic Analysis of Endpoints Related to “Cellular Life” in Vitro Data of Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Field Exposure , 2016, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[77]  F. Kremer,et al.  A Non-Thermal Effect of Millimeter Wave Radiation on the Puffing of Giant Chromosomes , 1983, 1983 13th European Microwave Conference.

[78]  M Zhadobov,et al.  Low‐power millimeter wave radiations do not alter stress‐sensitive gene expression of chaperone proteins , 2007, Bioelectromagnetics.

[79]  Microwave irradiation influences on the state of human cell nuclei. , 1998, Bioelectromagnetics.

[80]  Y. Akyel,et al.  Search for frequency-specific effects of millimeter-wave radiation on isolated nerve function. , 1997, Bioelectromagnetics.

[81]  E. Perrotta,et al.  Antiproliferative effect of millimeter radiation on human erythromyeloid leukemia cell line K562 in culture: ultrastructural- and metabolic-induced changes. , 2007, Bioelectrochemistry.

[82]  Francisco Bezanilla,et al.  Thermal mechanisms of millimeter wave stimulation of excitable cells. , 2013, Biophysical Journal.

[83]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Reactions of keratinocytes to in vitro millimeter wave exposure , 2001, Bioelectromagnetics.

[84]  M. Cavagnaro,et al.  Extremely High Frequency Electromagnetic Fields Facilitate Electrical Signal Propagation by Increasing Transmembrane Potassium Efflux in an Artificial Axon Model , 2018, Scientific Reports.

[85]  Ronan Sauleau,et al.  Study of narrow band millimeter‐wave potential interactions with endoplasmic reticulum stress sensor genes , 2009, Bioelectromagnetics.

[86]  H. Chiang,et al.  Millimeter wave exposure reverses TPA suppression of gap junction intercellular communication in HaCaT human keratinocytes , 2004, Bioelectromagnetics.

[87]  M. Ziskin,et al.  Dielectric properties of human skin at an acupuncture point in the 50–75 GHz frequency range: A pilot study , 2011, Bioelectromagnetics.

[88]  Jihwan Yoon,et al.  Millimeter wave bioeffects at 94 GHz on skeletal muscle contraction , 2013, 2013 IEEE Topical Conference on Biomedical Wireless Technologies, Networks, and Sensing Systems.

[89]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Effect of cyclophosphamide and 61.22 GHz millimeter waves on T‐cell, B‐cell, and macrophage functions , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[90]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Effects of millimeter waves on ionic currents of Lymnaea neurons. , 1999, Bioelectromagnetics.

[91]  S. Watanabe,et al.  Measurement of the dielectric properties of the epidermis and dermis at frequencies from 0.5 GHz to 110 GHz , 2014, Physics in medicine and biology.

[92]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Local heating of human skin by millimeter waves: Effect of blood flow , 2005, Bioelectromagnetics.

[93]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Millimeter microwave effect on ion transport across lipid bilayer membranes. , 1995, Bioelectromagnetics.

[94]  Eduardo G Moros,et al.  Modelling millimetre wave propagation and absorption in a high resolution skin model: the effect of sweat glands , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[95]  Amerigo Beneduci,et al.  Frequency and irradiation time-dependant antiproliferative effect of low-power millimeter waves on RPMI 7932 human melanoma cell line. , 2005, Anticancer research.

[96]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  Theoretical and numerical assessment of maximally allowable power-density averaging area for conservative electromagnetic exposure assessment above 6 GHz. , 2018, Bioelectromagnetics.

[97]  M. Zhadobov,et al.  Additive Effects of Millimeter Waves and 2-Deoxyglucose Co-Exposure on the Human Keratinocyte Transcriptome , 2016, PloS one.

[98]  R. Sauleau,et al.  Evaluation of the Potential Biological Effects of the 60-GHz Millimeter Waves Upon Human Cells , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation.

[99]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Effect of millimeter waves on natural killer cell activation , 2005, Bioelectromagnetics.

[100]  Xianghong Arakaki,et al.  Modulation of neuronal activity and plasma membrane properties with low-power millimeter waves in organotypic cortical slices , 2010, Journal of neural engineering.

[101]  M. Zhadobov,et al.  Impact of 60‐GHz millimeter waves on stress and pain‐related protein expression in differentiating neuron‐like cells , 2016, Bioelectromagnetics.

[102]  Guang-wen Wu,et al.  Experimental study of millimeter wave-induced differentiation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells into chondrocytes. , 2009, International journal of molecular medicine.

[103]  M C Ziskin,et al.  Reflection and penetration depth of millimeter waves in murine skin , 2008, Bioelectromagnetics.

[104]  T. Usichenko,et al.  Remote Effects of Electromagnetic Millimeter Waves on Experimentally Induced Cold Pain: A Double-Blinded Crossover Investigation in Healthy Volunteers , 2017, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[105]  Soichi Watanabe,et al.  Ocular Effects of Exposure to 40, 75, and 95 GHz Millimeter Waves , 2018 .

[106]  R. Malekzadeh,et al.  Advisory Group recommendations on priorities for the IARC Monographs. , 2019, The Lancet. Oncology.

[107]  J R Jauchem,et al.  SUSTAINED 35‐GHz RADIOFREQUENCY IRRADIATION INDUCES CIRCULATORY FAILURE , 1995, Shock.

[108]  E. B. Shadrin,et al.  The effect of transcranial electromagnetic brain stimulation on the acquisition of the conditioned response in rats , 2015 .

[109]  D. Wagenaar,et al.  Effects of millimeter wave irradiation and equivalent thermal heating on the activity of individual neurons in the leech ganglion , 2014, Journal of Neurophysiology.

[110]  Naoki Shinohara,et al.  Effects of Long-Term Exposure to 60 GHz Millimeter-Wavelength Radiation on the Genotoxicity and Heat Shock Protein (Hsp) Expression of Cells Derived from Human Eye , 2016, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[111]  A. Beneduci Evaluation of the Potential In Vitro Antiproliferative Effects of Millimeter Waves at Some Therapeutic Frequencies on RPMI 7932 Human Skin Malignant Melanoma Cells , 2009, Cell Biochemistry and Biophysics.

[112]  R. Croft,et al.  The Bioeffects Resulting from Prokaryotic Cells and Yeast Being Exposed to an 18 GHz Electromagnetic Field , 2016, PloS one.

[113]  Kenneth R Foster,et al.  Thermal aspects of exposure to radiofrequency energy: Report of a workshop , 2011, International journal of hyperthermia : the official journal of European Society for Hyperthermic Oncology, North American Hyperthermia Group.

[114]  EEG CHANGES AS HEAT STRESS REACTIONS IN RATS IRRADIATED BY HIGH INTENSITY 35 GHz MILLIMETER WAVES , 2011, Health physics.

[115]  Quirino Balzano,et al.  Thermal Modeling for the Next Generation of Radiofrequency Exposure Limits: Commentary. , 2017, Health physics.

[116]  Zhengang Pan,et al.  5G: rethink mobile communications for 2020+ , 2016, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.