HYPOTHESIS
Complications are common in hospitalized surgical patients. Provider error contributes to a significant proportion of these complications.
DESIGN
Surgical patients were concurrently observed for the development of explicit complications. All complications were reviewed by the attending surgeon and other members of the service and evaluated for the severity of sequelae (major or minor) and for whether the complication resulted from medical error (avoidable) or not.
SETTING
University teaching hospital with a level I trauma designation.
PATIENTS
All inpatients (operative or nonoperative) from 4 different surgical services: general surgery, combined general surgery and trauma, vascular surgery, and cardiothoracic surgery.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES
Total complication rate (number of complications divided by the number of patients) and the number of patients with complications. Complications were separated into those with major or minor sequelae and the proportion of each type that were due to medical error (avoidable). Rates of complications in a recent Institute of Medicine report were used as a criterion standard.
RESULTS
The data for the respective groups (general surgery, vascular surgery, combined general surgery and trauma, and cardiothoracic surgery) are as follows. The number of patients was 1363, 978, 914, and 1403; number of complications, 413, 409, 295, and 378; total complication rate, 30.3%, 42.4%, 32.3%, and 26.9%; minor complication rate, 13.3%, 19.9%, 13.5%, and 13.0% (percentage of minor complications that were avoidable, 37.4%, 59.0%, 51.2%, and 49.5%); major complication rate, 16.2%, 21.1%, 18.1%, and 12.9% (percentage of major complications that were avoidable, 53.4%, 60.7%, 38.8%, and 38.7%); and mortality rate, 1.83%, 3.33%, 2.28%, and 3.34% (percentage of mortality that was avoidable, 28.0%, 44.1%, 19.0%, and 25.0%).
CONCLUSIONS
Despite mortality rates that compare favorably with national benchmarks, a prospective examination of surgical patients reveals complication rates that are 2 to 4 times higher than those identified in an Institute of Medicine report. Almost half of these adverse events were judged contemporaneously by peers to be due to provider error (avoidable). Errors in care contributed to 38 (30%) of 128 deaths. Recognition that provider error contributes significantly to adverse events presents significant opportunities for improving patient outcomes.
[1]
E. Schimmel.
The hazards of hospitalization*
,
2003,
Annals of internal medicine.
[2]
R. Brook,et al.
Effectiveness of nonemergency care via an emergency room. A study of 116 patients with gastrointestinal symptoms.
,
1973,
Annals of internal medicine.
[3]
P M Gertman,et al.
Iatrogenic illness on a general medical service at a university hospital*
,
1981,
Quality and Safety in Health Care.
[4]
S. Shackford,et al.
Assuring quality in a trauma system--the Medical Audit Committee: composition, cost, and results.
,
1987,
The Journal of trauma.
[5]
T. Brennan,et al.
The nature of adverse events in hospitalized patients. Results of the Harvard Medical Practice Study II.
,
1991,
The New England journal of medicine.
[6]
T. Brennan,et al.
INCIDENCE OF ADVERSE EVENTS AND NEGLIGENCE IN HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS
,
2008
.
[7]
D R Salter,et al.
Measuring and managing quality of surgery. Statistical vs incidental approaches.
,
1992,
Archives of surgery.
[8]
Gerald Doppelt,et al.
The moral limits of Feinberg's liberalism
,
1993
.
[9]
D W Bates,et al.
Evaluation of Screening Criteria for Adverse Events in Medical Patients
,
1995,
Medical care.
[10]
Russell L. Stogsdill,et al.
A regional intervention to improve the hospital mortality associated with coronary artery bypass graft surgery. The Northern New England Cardiovascular Disease Study Group.
,
1996,
JAMA.
[11]
E. Ackermann.
The Quality in Australian Health Care Study.
,
1996,
The Medical journal of Australia.
[12]
L. Andrews,et al.
An alternative strategy for studying adverse events in medical care
,
1997,
The Lancet.
[13]
T. Brennan,et al.
Costs of medical injuries in Utah and Colorado.
,
1999,
Inquiry : a journal of medical care organization, provision and financing.
[14]
C J McDonald,et al.
Deaths due to medical errors are exaggerated in Institute of Medicine report.
,
2000,
JAMA.
[15]
T. Brennan,et al.
Incidence and types of adverse events and negligent care in Utah and Colorado.
,
2000,
Medical care.
[16]
L. Kohn,et al.
To Err Is Human : Building a Safer Health System
,
2007
.
[17]
R. Hayward,et al.
Estimating hospital deaths due to medical errors: preventability is in the eye of the reviewer.
,
2001,
JAMA.