The Optimal Share of Variable Renewables: How the Variability of Wind and Solar Power affects their Welfare-optimal Deployment

This paper estimates the welfare-optimal market share of wind and solar power, explicitly taking into account their output variability. We present a theoretical valuation framework that consistently accounts for output variability over time, forecast errors, and the location of generators in the power grid, and evaluate the impact of these three factors on the marginal value of electricity from renewables. Then we estimate the optimal share of wind and solar power in Northwestern Europe from a calibrated numerical power market model. The optimal long-term share of wind power of total electricity consumption is estimated to be 20% at cost levels of 50 €/MWh, about three times the current market share of wind; but this estimate is subject to significant parameter uncertainty. Variability significantly impacts results: if winds were constant, the optimal share would be 60%. In addition, the effect of technological change, price shocks, and policies on the optimal share is assessed. We present and explain several surprising findings, including a negative impact of CO2 prices on optimal wind deployment.

[1]  Ottmar Edenhofer,et al.  Technological Change and International Trade -Insights from REMIND-R , 2010 .

[2]  Aidan Tuohy,et al.  Pumped storage in systems with very high wind penetration , 2011 .

[3]  Nate Blair,et al.  Regional Energy Deployment System (ReEDS) , 2011 .

[4]  Thomas Bruckner,et al.  Mitigation potential and costs , 2011 .

[5]  Rodrigo Rivera-Tinoco,et al.  Cost reductions for offshore wind power: Exploring the balance between scaling, learning and R&D , 2012 .

[6]  Marco Nicolosi,et al.  The Economics of Renewable Electricity Market Integration: An Empirical and Model-Based Analysis of Regulatory Frameworks and their Impacts on the Power Market , 2012 .

[7]  Mark Diesendorf,et al.  The economics of large-scale wind power in the UK A model of an optimally mixed CEGB electricity grid , 1983 .

[8]  J. M. Martínez-Duart,et al.  Analytical model for solar PV and CSP electricity costs: Present LCOE values and their future evolution , 2013 .

[9]  Lion Hirth.  The Market Value of Variable Renewables , 2012 .

[10]  George W. Wilson.  The Theory of Peak-Load Pricing: A Final Note , 1972 .

[11]  James Bushnell,et al.  Building Blocks: Investment in Renewable and Non- Renewable Technologies , 2010 .

[12]  Assessing the Economic Value and Optimal Structure of Large-scale Energy Storage , 2012 .

[13]  Lion Hirth,et al.  Why Wind is Not Coal: On the Economics of Electricity , 2014 .

[14]  Otto Rentz,et al.  Model-based analysis of effects from large-scale wind power production , 2007 .

[15]  M. Bouzguenda,et al.  A model to determine the degree of penetration and energy cost of large scale utility interactive photovoltaic systems , 1994, IEEE Power Engineering Review.

[16]  Marco Nicolosi,et al.  The Importance of High Temporal Resolution in Modeling Renewable Energy Penetration Scenarios , 2011 .

[17]  Gideon Kruseman,et al.  Long-term price and environmental effects in a liberalised electricity market , 2008 .

[18]  Michel G.J. den Elzen,et al.  Meeting radiative forcing targets under delayed participation , 2009 .

[19]  Dolf Gielen,et al.  Re-considering the economics of photovoltaic power , 2013 .

[20]  M. Boiteux.  Peak-Load Pricing , 1960 .

[21]  D. P. van Vuuren,et al.  Transforming the European energy system: member states' prospects within the EU framework. , 2013 .

[22]  Lion Hirth,et al.  Redistribution Effects of Energy and Climate Policy , 2011 .

[23]  Joan M. Ogden,et al.  Integration of Renewable Energy into Present and Future Energy Systems , 2011 .

[24]  Lion Hirth,et al.  The Decreasing Market Value of Variable Renewables: Integration Options and Deadlocks , 2013 .

[25]  Patrik Söderholm,et al.  Wind power learning rates: A conceptual review and meta-analysis☆ , 2012 .

[26]  Chitru S. Fernando,et al.  The theory of peak-load pricing: A survey , 1995 .

[27]  M. O'Malley,et al.  Establishing the role that wind generation may have in future generation portfolios , 2006, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems.

[28]  Fernando Olsina,et al.  Short-term optimal wind power generation capacity in liberalized electricity markets , 2007 .

[29]  Kenichi Wada,et al.  The role of renewable energy in climate stabilization: results from the EMF27 scenarios , 2014, Climatic Change.

[30]  Robert J. Brecha,et al.  Variable Renewable Energy in Modeling Climate Change Mitigation Scenarios , 2011 .

[31]  P. Joskow.  Comparing the Costs of Intermittent and Dispatchable Electricity Generating Technologies , 2011 .

[32]  Andreas Ehrenmann,et al.  Space and Time: Wind in an Investment Planning Model , 2006 .

[33]  Sergey Paltsev,et al.  Marginal Abatement Costs and Marginal Welfare Costs for Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions: Results from the EPPA Model , 2011, Environmental Modeling & Assessment.

[34]  Keywan Riahi,et al.  Impacts of considering electric sector variability and reliability in the MESSAGE model , 2013 .

[35]  E.A. DeMeo,et al.  Utility Wind Integration and Operating Impact State of the Art , 2007, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems.

[36]  Tom Kober,et al.  Implications of different climate protection regimes for the EU-27 and its member states through 2050 , 2012 .

[37]  James Merrick,et al.  A Clean Energy Standard Analysis with the US-REGEN Model , 2014 .

[38]  Ben Hoen,et al.  A Spatial Hedonic Analysis of the Effects of Wind Energy Facilities on Surrounding Property Values in the United States , 2014 .

[39]  Gregory F. Nemet,et al.  Beyond the learning curve: factors influencing cost reductions in photovoltaics , 2006 .

[40]  Michael Milligan,et al.  Integration of Variable Generation, Cost-Causation, and Integration Costs , 2011 .

[41]  S. Borenstein.  The Market Value and Cost of Solar Photovoltaic Electricity Production , 2008 .

[42]  S. Borenstein.  The Private and Public Economics of Renewable Electricity Generation , 2011 .

[43]  Lion Hirth,et al.  Control power and variable renewables , 2013, 2013 10th International Conference on the European Energy Market (EEM).

[45]  Lion Hirth,et al.  Redistribution Effects of Energy and Climate Policy: The Electricity Market , 2012 .

[46]  O. Edenhofer.  Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation , 2011 .

[47]  Martin Greiner,et al.  Seasonal optimal mix of wind and solar power in a future, highly renewable Europe , 2010 .

[48]  Kristin Seyboth,et al.  Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation: Reviewers of the IPCC Special Report , 2011 .

[49]  J. H. Nelson,et al.  High-resolution modeling of the western North American power system demonstrates low-cost and low-carbon futures , 2012 .

[50]  F. Bessière,et al.  The "Investment '85" Model of Electricite de France , 1970 .

[51]  Marc Oliver Bettzüge,et al.  The economic value of storage in renewable power systems - the case of thermal energy storage in concentrating solar plants , 2011 .

[52]  Maryse Labriet,et al.  Deterministic and stochastic analysis of alternative climate targets under differentiated cooperation regimes , 2009 .

[53]  M. Fripp,et al.  Effects of Temporal Wind Patterns on the Value of Wind-Generated Electricity in California and the Northwest , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems.

[54]  Richard Green,et al.  Electricity and Markets , 2005 .

[55]  Dominik Möst,et al.  Renewable energy sources in European energy supply and interactions with emission trading , 2010 .

[56]  E. Baker,et al.  The Economics of Solar Electricity , 2013 .

[57]  Dietmar Lindenberger,et al.  The Costs of Electricity Systems with a High Share of Fluctuating Renewables: A Stochastic Investment and Dispatch Optimization Model for Europe , 2013 .

[58]  M. J. Grubb,et al.  Value of variable sources on power systems , 1991 .

[59]  Liangzhong Yao,et al.  Value of Wind Power at Different Locations in the Grid , 2011, IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery.

[60]  H. Bessembinder,et al.  Equilibrium Pricing and Optimal Hedging in Electricity Forward Markets , 1999 .

[61]  Caroline Elisabeth Hénia Brun,et al.  Economic and technical impacts of wind variability and intermittency on long-term generation expansion planning in the U.S , 2011 .

[62]  A. Lamont.  Assessing the economic value and optimal structure of large-scale electricity storage , 2013, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems.

[63]  Richard Schmalensee.  The Performance of U.S. Wind and Solar Generating Units , 2013 .

[64]  H. Bessembinder,et al.  Equilibrium Pricing and Optimal Hedging in Electricity Forward Markets , 2002 .

[65]  M. O'Malley,et al.  Quantifying the Total Net Benefits of Grid Integrated Wind , 2007, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems.

[66]  Jay Apt,et al.  Regional variations in the health, environmental, and climate benefits of wind and solar generation , 2013, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[67]  H. Zareipour,et al.  The large-scale integration of wind generation: Impacts on price, reliability and dispatchable conventional suppliers , 2010 .

[68]  R. Wiser,et al.  Changes in the Economic Value of Photovoltaic Generation at High Penetration Levels: A Pilot Case Study of California , 2013, IEEE Journal of Photovoltaics.

[69]  M. Haller,et al.  Decarbonization scenarios for the EU and MENA power system: Considering spatial distribution and short term dynamics of renewable generation , 2012 .

[70]  Ana Estanqueiro,et al.  Impacts of large amounts of wind power on design and operation of power systems, results of IEA collaboration , 2008 .

[71]  J. Edmonds,et al.  2.6: Limiting climate change to 450 ppm CO2 equivalent in the 21st century , 2009 .

[72]  William D. Nordhaus,et al.  The Perils of the Learning Model for Modeling Endogenous Technological Change , 2009 .

[73]  P. Steiner.  Peak Loads and Efficient Pricing , 1957 .

[74]  N. Stoughton,et al.  Direct Construction of Optimal Generation Mix , 1980, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems.

[75]  C. Weber,et al.  An electricity market model to estimate the marginal value of wind in an adapting system , 2006, 2006 IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting.

[76]  Keywan Riahi,et al.  Implications of delayed participation and technology failure for the feasibility, costs, and likelihood of staying below temperature targets—Greenhouse gas mitigation scenarios for the 21st century , 2009 .

[77]  G. Luderer,et al.  System LCOE: What are the Costs of Variable Renewables? , 2013 .

[78]  A. J. Padilla,et al.  Harnessing Renewable Energy in Electric Power Systems: Theory, Practice, Policy , 2010 .

[79]  O. Wolfgang,et al.  LIBEMOD - LIBEralisation MODel for the European Energy Markets: A Technical Description , 2001 .

[80]  T. Rutherford,et al.  Feasible climate targets: The roles of economic growth, coalition development and expectations ☆ , 2009 .

[81]  A. Lamont.  Assessing the Long-Term System Value of Intermittent Electric Generation Technologies , 2008 .

[82]  Andrew D. Mills,et al.  Changes in the Economic Value of Variable Generation at High Penetration Levels:A Pilot Case Study of California , 2014 .

[83]  A. Covarrubias,et al.  Expansion Planning for Electric Power Systems , 2008 .

[84]  Danièle Revel,et al.  IPCC Special Report on Renewable Energy Sources and Climate Change Mitigation , 2011 .

[85]  Richard Green,et al.  The long-term impact of wind power on electricity prices and generating capacity , 2011 .

[86]  Lion Hirth.  The Market Value of Variable Renewables The Effect of Solar and Wind Power Variability on their Relative Price , 2013 .

[87]  Joseph F. DeCarolis,et al.  The economics of large-scale wind power in a carbon constrained world , 2006 .