Updating Technical Screens for PV Interconnection: Preprint

Solar photovoltaics (PV) is the dominant type of distributed generation (DG) technology interconnected to electric distribution systems in the United States, and deployment of PV systems continues to increase rapidly. Considering the rapid growth and widespread deployment of PV systems in United States electric distribution grids, it is important that interconnection procedures be as streamlined as possible to avoid unnecessary interconnection studies, costs, and delays. Because many PV interconnection applications involve high penetration scenarios, the process needs to allow for a sufficiently rigorous technical evaluation to identify and address possible system impacts. Existing interconnection procedures are designed to balance the need for efficiency and technical rigor for all DG. However, there is an implicit expectation that those procedures will be updated over time in order to remain relevant with respect to evolving standards, technology, and practical experience. Modifications to interconnection screens and procedures must focus on maintaining or improving safety and reliability, as well as accurately allocating costs and improving expediency of the interconnection process. This paper evaluates the origins and usefulness of the capacity penetration screen, offers potential short-term solutions which could effectively allow fast-track interconnection to many PV system applications, and considers longer-term solutions for increasing PV deployment levels in a safe and reliable manner while reducing or eliminating the emphasis on the penetration screen. Index Terms — screens, interconnection, utility, electric utilities, public utility commissions, penetration, high penetration. I. OVERVIEW AND PURPOSE Solar photovoltaics (PV) is the dominant form of distributed generation (DG) technology interconnected to electric distribution systems in the United States, and deployment of PV systems continues to increase rapidly. Considering the rapid growth and widespread deployment of PV systems in the United States today, it is important that interconnection procedures be as efficient as possible to avoid unnecessary interconnection costs and delays. Interconnection procedures vary depending on state or federal jurisdiction, and implementation practices vary by utility system. Most procedures allow for expedited interconnection without additional technical studies if the proposed interconnection passes a series of technical screens. If a proposed interconnection fails one or more of the screens, supplemental interconnection studies may be required before it can proceed to interconnection. Because many PV interconnection applications involve installations on distribution feeders with greater than 15% capacity penetration, the process needs to allow for a sufficiently rigorous technical evaluation to identify and address possible system impacts. There is an implicit expectation that those procedures will be updated over time in order to remain relevant with respect to evolving standards, technology, and practical experience. Modifications to interconnection screens and procedures must focus on maintaining or improving safety and reliability, as well as accurately allocating costs and improving expediency of the interconnection process. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the origins and usefulness of the capacity penetration screen, offer short-term solutions that could effectively allow fast-track interconnection to many PV system applications, and consider longer-term solutions for increasing PV deployment levels in a safe and reliable manner while reducing or eliminating the emphasis on the penetration screen. II. THE 15% PENETRATION THRESHOLD In 1999, before the FERC SGIP was established, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) issued an order instituting a rulemaking to address interconnection standards for devices to the electric grid in California. The order resulted in the reform of CPUC Rule 21, which identified screens that allowed low-impact generators to be interconnected relatively quickly and made the review process more efficient for small, low-impact generation at low penetration levels. During the reformation of CPUC Rule 21, a 15% threshold was established to identify situations in which the amount of DG capacity on a line section exceeds 15% of the line section annual peak load. The 15% threshold was then adopted in the FERC SGIP and is used by most states as a model for developing their interconnection procedures. Under most applicable interconnection screening