Influence of the neurological level of spinal cord injury on cardiovascular outcomes in humans: a meta-analysis

Background:Although motor and sensory deficits following spinal cord injury (SCI) are well known, there are still contrasting reports on how SCI affects baseline cardiovascular (CV) parameters and other autonomic functions.Study design:Meta-analysis is performed.Objectives:To examine the effect of injury level on supine and seated CV function in individuals with SCI.Methods:A total of 98 studies representing 1968 individuals were retrieved for analysis. Systolic blood pressure (SBP), diastolic blood pressure (DBP) and heart rate (HR) were abstracted from the studies and compared between four groups according to the neurological lesion level, cervical (C) SCI (C4-C8), high-thoracic (HT) SCI (T1-T6), low-thoracic lumbar (LTL) SCI (below T6) and able-bodied (AB) controls.Results:In the supine position, SBP, DBP and HR were lower in C compared with HT, LTL and AB (all P<0.04). In the seated position, SBP and DBP were significantly lower in C compared with LTL and AB (all P<0.003) and HR was significantly lower in C compared with LTL only (P=0.01). A final finding was that C exhibited a lower resting SBP in the seated compared with the supine position (P<0.001).Conclusion:Individuals with SCI exhibit a lesion-dependent impairment in resting CV function, whereby those with the highest injury had the greatest degree of CV dysfunction. A further finding was that individuals with a C injury exhibited a lower resting SBP in the seated vs supine position. Thus, clinicians and researchers should consider lesion level and body position when measuring and interpreting CV parameters in individuals with SCI.

[1]  H. Ogata,et al.  Static exercise-induced increase in blood pressure in individuals with cervical spinal cord injury. , 1999, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[2]  J. Kameyama,et al.  Altered Mayer wave and baroreflex profiles in high spinal cord injury. , 2001, American journal of hypertension.

[3]  N. Laird,et al.  Meta-analysis in clinical trials. , 1986, Controlled clinical trials.

[4]  R. Teasell,et al.  Autonomic dysreflexia in tetraplegic patients: evidence for alpha-adrenoceptor hyper-responsiveness. , 1995, Clinical autonomic research : official journal of the Clinical Autonomic Research Society.

[5]  Heart rate deflection compared to 4 mmol · l−1 lactate threshold during incremental exercise and to lactate during steady-state exercise on an arm-cranking ergometer in paraplegic athletes , 1998, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[6]  A. Krassioukov,et al.  Autonomic Standards and SCI: Preliminary Considerations , 2006 .

[7]  R. Burnham,et al.  Testosterone, cortisol and catecholamine responses to exercise stress and autonomic dysreflexia in elite quadriplegic athletes , 1994, Paraplegia.

[8]  J. Petrofsky,et al.  The effect of ageing in spinal cord injured humans on the blood pressure and heart rate responses during fatiguing isometric exercise , 2002, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[9]  K. Maeda,et al.  Effects of upper limb exercise on thermoregulatory responses in patients with spinal cord injury. , 1995, Applied human science : journal of physiological anthropology.

[10]  K. Gerrits,et al.  Increased Vascular Resistance in Paralyzed Legs after Spinal Cord Injury Is Reversible By Training. , 2002, Journal of applied physiology.

[11]  Annetine C. Gelijns,et al.  Meta-Analysis: A Quantitative Approach to Research Integration , 1990 .

[12]  J. Steeves,et al.  Orthostatic hypotension following spinal cord injury: understanding clinical pathophysiology , 2006, Spinal Cord.

[13]  S. Lichtman,et al.  Exertional hypotension in spinal cord injury. , 1994, Chest.

[14]  K. Bhamidimarri,et al.  Bedside assessment of sympathetic skin response after spinal cord injury: a brief report comparing inspiratory gasp and visual stimulus , 2006, Spinal Cord.

[15]  Satoshi Muraki,et al.  Cardiovascular and respiratory responses to passive leg cycle exercise in people with spinal cord injuries , 2004, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[16]  M. Yamasaki,et al.  Effect of arm cranking exercise on skin blood flow of lower limb in people with injuries to the spinal cord , 2004, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[17]  B. Wallin,et al.  Assessing the integrity of sympathetic pathways in spinal cord injury , 2007, Autonomic Neuroscience.

[18]  G. Davis,et al.  Cardiovascular responses to an orthostatic challenge and electrical-stimulation-induced leg muscle contractions in individuals with paraplegia , 1999, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[19]  M Akai,et al.  Energy expenditure during walking with weight-bearing control (WBC) orthosis in thoracic level of paraplegic patients , 2003, Spinal Cord.

[20]  T W Janssen,et al.  Coronary heart disease risk indicators, aerobic power, and physical activity in men with spinal cord injuries. , 1997, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[21]  A William Sheel,et al.  Autonomic dysreflexia during sperm retrieval in spinal cord injury: influence of lesion level and sildenafil citrate. , 2005, Journal of applied physiology.

[22]  Antonio Ibarra,et al.  Cardiovascular alterations after spinal cord injury: an overview. , 2004, Current medicinal chemistry. Cardiovascular and hematological agents.

[23]  M. Nash,et al.  The relationship between perceived exertion and physiologic indicators of stress during graded arm exercise in persons with spinal cord injuries. , 2007, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[24]  H. Frankel,et al.  The role of spinal cord transmission in the ventilatory response to exercise in man. , 1984, The Journal of physiology.

[25]  H. Gavras,et al.  Vasopressin response to hyperosmotic stimulus: blood pressure effect in normal subjects and patients with impaired sympathetic system. , 1984, Clinical and experimental hypertension. Part A, Theory and practice.

[26]  M. Hopman,et al.  Does peripheral nerve degeneration affect circulatory responses to head-up tilt in spinal cord-injured individuals? , 2005, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[27]  S C Gupta,et al.  Metabolic and hemodynamic responses to concurrent voluntary arm crank and electrical stimulation leg cycle exercise in quadriplegics. , 1992, Journal of rehabilitation research and development.

[28]  A. Warner,et al.  Heart rate variability is altered following spinal cord injury , 1998, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[29]  Sibrand Houtman M.SC.,et al.  Non-invasive assessment of autonomic nervous system integrity in able-bodied and spinal cord-injured individuals , 2005, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[30]  G. Cheing,et al.  The effects of lower-extremity functional electric stimulation on the orthostatic responses of people with tetraplegia. , 2005, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[31]  N. Secher,et al.  Heart rate during exercise with leg vascular occlusion in spinal cord-injured humans. , 1999, Journal of applied physiology.

[32]  A. Krassioukov,et al.  Descending vasomotor pathways in humans: correlation between axonal preservation and cardiovascular dysfunction after spinal cord injury. , 2003, Journal of neurotrauma.

[33]  C. Mathias,et al.  Hemodynamic and Neurohormonal Effects of Clonidine in Patients With Preganglionic and Postganglionic Sympathetic Lesions: Evidence for a Central Sympatholytic Action , 1991, Circulation.

[34]  A. Krassioukov,et al.  Effect of harness application and postural changes on cardiovascular parameters of individuals with spinal cord injury , 2006, Spinal Cord.

[35]  E. Bárbara-Bataller,et al.  Determination of changes in blood pressure during administration of sildenafil (Viagra®) in patients with spinal cord injury and erectile dysfunction , 2006, Spinal Cord.

[36]  J. Ravits.  Aaem minimonograph #48: Autonomic nervous system testing , 1997, Muscle & nerve.

[37]  D. Han,et al.  Effect of wheelchair ergometer training on spinal cord-injured paraplegics. , 1993, Yonsei medical journal.

[38]  C. Begg,et al.  Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. , 1994, Biometrics.

[39]  Wolfgang Viechtbauer,et al.  Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package , 2010 .

[40]  P. Almenoff,et al.  Baroreceptor sensitivity response to phase IV of the Valsalva maneuver in spinal cord injury , 1998, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[41]  J. Keul,et al.  Catecholamines Response of High Performance Wheelchair Athletes at Rest and During Exercise with Autonomic Dysreflexia , 2001, International journal of sports medicine.

[42]  J. Weir,et al.  Partial Angiotensin–Converting Enzyme Inhibition During Acute Orthostatic Stress in Persons With Tetraplegia , 2005, The journal of spinal cord medicine.

[43]  G. Davis,et al.  Oxygen uptake and heart rate responses during arm vs combined arm/electrically stimulated leg exercise in people with paraplegia , 1997, Spinal Cord.

[44]  P. Jacobs,et al.  Hypokinetic circulation in persons with paraplegia. , 2002, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[45]  A. Cliquet,et al.  Improvement of metabolic and cardiorespiratory responses through treadmill gait training with neuromuscular electrical stimulation in quadriplegic subjects. , 2006, Artificial organs.

[46]  Cardiovascular Responses to Endotracheal Intubation in Patients with Acute and Chronic Spinal Cord Injuries , 2003, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[47]  K. Nair,et al.  Afferent pathways of sympathetic skin response in spinal cord: a clinical and electrophysiological study , 2001, Journal of the Neurological Sciences.

[48]  C. Whittaker.  and Erectile Dysfunction and Erectile Dysfunction and Erectile Dysfunction and Erectile Dysfunction , 2009 .

[49]  C. Mathias,et al.  Haemodynamic actions of clonidine in tetraplegia - Effects at rest and during urinary bladder stimulation , 1988, Paraplegia.

[50]  P. Almenoff,et al.  Sympathovagal balance of the heart in subjects with spinal cord injury. , 1997, The American journal of physiology.

[51]  Kathryn A. Boschen,et al.  Secondary Health Complications in an Aging Canadian Spinal Cord Injury Sample , 2008, American journal of physical medicine & rehabilitation.

[52]  J. Weir,et al.  Blunted heart rate response to vagal withdrawal in persons with tetraplegia , 2006, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[53]  Clyde Williams,et al.  Physiological and metabolic responses of wheelchair athletes in different racing classes to prolonged exercise , 2004, Journal of sports sciences.

[54]  L. C. Anderson,et al.  The Effect of Nifedipine on Cystoscopy-Induced Autonomic Hyperreflexia in Patients with High Spinal Cord Injuries , 1987 .

[55]  I. Olkin,et al.  Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology - A proposal for reporting , 2000 .

[56]  R. Teasell,et al.  Autonomic dysreflexia in tetraplegic patients: Evidence for α-adrenoceptor hyper-responsiveness , 1995, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[57]  Janice K Popp,et al.  Health Problems Associated with International Business Travel , 2000, AAOHN journal : official journal of the American Association of Occupational Health Nurses.

[58]  S C Gupta,et al.  Acute hemodynamic responses of spinal cord injured individuals to functional neuromuscular stimulation-induced knee extension exercise. , 1991, Journal of rehabilitation research and development.

[59]  Adrienne T Hol,et al.  Cardiovascular responses and postexercise hypotension after arm cycling exercise in subjects with spinal cord injury. , 2006, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[60]  D. Eckberg,et al.  Human autonomic rhythms: vagal cardiac mechanisms in tetraplegic subjects. , 1994, The Journal of physiology.

[61]  H J Stam,et al.  Physical capacity in wheelchair-dependent persons with a spinal cord injury: a critical review of the literature , 2006, Spinal Cord.

[62]  C. Mathias,et al.  Renin release during head-up tilt occurs independently of sympathetic nervous activity in tetraplegic man. , 1980, Clinical science.

[63]  SJ Rogers,et al.  Midodrine hydrochloride and the treatment of orthostatic hypotension in tetraplegia: two cases and a review of the literature , 2000, Spinal Cord.

[64]  B Oeseburg,et al.  Systemic circulation and cerebral oxygenation during head-up tilt in spinal cord injured individuals , 2000, Spinal Cord.

[65]  C. Mathias,et al.  Vascular effects of clonidine in patients with tetraplegia and unilateral brachial plexus injury. , 1988, Clinical and experimental hypertension. Part A, Theory and practice.

[66]  J. Weir,et al.  Cardiac autonomic responses to progressive head-up tilt in individuals with paraplegia , 2003, Clinical autonomic research : official journal of the Clinical Autonomic Research Society.

[67]  V. Froelicher,et al.  Altered ventricular repolarization in central sympathetic dysfunction associated with spinal cord injury. , 1989, The American journal of cardiology.

[68]  K. Matsukawa,et al.  Control of heart rate variability by cardiac parasympathetic nerve activity during voluntary static exercise in humans with tetraplegia. , 2007, Journal of applied physiology.

[69]  J. Weir,et al.  The effects of autonomic dysfunction and endurance training on cardiovascular control , 2001, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[70]  V. Convertino,et al.  Enhanced carotid-cardiac baroreflex response and elimination of orthostatic hypotension 24 hours after acute exercise in paraplegics , 1992, Paraplegia.

[71]  C. Mathias,et al.  Haemodynamic, hormonal and urinary responses to postural change in tetraplegic and paraplegic man , 1988, Paraplegia.

[72]  A Cliquet,et al.  Metabolic and cardiorespiratory responses of tetraplegic subjects during treadmill walking using neuromuscular electrical stimulation and partial body weight support , 2005, Spinal Cord.

[73]  R. Matheis,et al.  Blood pressure response to acupuncture in a population at risk for autonomic dysreflexia. , 2000, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[74]  Neil McCartney,et al.  Effects of body weight-supported treadmill training on heart rate variability and blood pressure variability in individuals with spinal cord injury. , 2005, Journal of applied physiology.

[75]  L. C. Anderson,et al.  The effect of nifedipine on cystoscopy-induced autonomic hyperreflexia in patients with high spinal cord injuries. , 1988, The Journal of urology.

[76]  D. Levy,et al.  Hemodynamic patterns of age-related changes in blood pressure. The Framingham Heart Study. , 1997, Circulation.

[77]  C. T. Huang,et al.  Orthostatic hypotension after spinal cord injury: treatment with fludrocortisone and ergotamine. , 1991, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[78]  C J Mathias,et al.  Organisation of the sympathetic skin response in spinal cord injury , 2002, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[79]  H. Gerner,et al.  The effects of sauna on tetraplegic and paraplegic subjects , 1992, Paraplegia.

[80]  Armin Curt,et al.  Sympathetic sudomotor skin activity in human after complete spinal cord injury , 2002, Autonomic Neuroscience.

[81]  S. Thacker,et al.  Characteristics of meta-analyses related to acceptance for publication in a medical journal. , 2001, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[82]  G. W. Hoffler,et al.  Impairment of carotid-cardiac vagal baroreflex in wheelchair-dependent quadriplegics. , 1991, The American journal of physiology.

[83]  Donald A. Schneider,et al.  Excess post-exercise oxygen consumption in spinal cord-injured men , 2004, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[84]  J. Weir,et al.  Autonomic recovery from peak arm exercise in fit and unfit individuals with paraplegia. , 2006, Medicine and science in sports and exercise.

[85]  W. Donovan,et al.  International Standards For Neurological Classification Of Spinal Cord Injury , 2003, The journal of spinal cord medicine.

[86]  G. R. Oliveira,et al.  Cardiovascular control after spinal cord injury. , 2004, Current vascular pharmacology.

[87]  G. Lambert,et al.  Autonomic control of the heart and renal vascular bed during autonomic dysreflexia in high spinal cord injury , 2002, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[88]  L Levi,et al.  Hemodynamic parameters in patients with acute cervical cord trauma: description, intervention, and prediction of outcome. , 1993, Neurosurgery.

[89]  S C Gupta,et al.  Cardiovascular responses to arm cranking and FNS-induced leg exercise in paraplegics. , 1990, Journal of applied physiology.

[90]  K. Pitetti,et al.  Thermoregulatory responses to exercise and warm water immersion in physically trained men with tetraplegia , 2002, Spinal Cord.

[91]  F Iellamo,et al.  Positive and Negative Feedback Mechanisms in the Neural Regulation of Cardiovascular Function in Healthy and Spinal Cord–Injured Humans , 2001, Circulation.

[92]  A. Cliquet,et al.  Response of the arterial blood pressure of quadriplegic patients to treadmill gait training. , 2005, Brazilian journal of medical and biological research = Revista brasileira de pesquisas medicas e biologicas.

[93]  J. Weir,et al.  Normalization of Supine Blood Pressure After Nitric Oxide Synthase Inhibition in Persons With Tetraplegia , 2007, The journal of spinal cord medicine.

[94]  G. Creasey,et al.  Detrusor and blood pressure responses to dorsal penile nerve stimulation during hyperreflexic contraction of the bladder in patients with cervical cord injury. , 2003, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[95]  R. Burnham,et al.  Evidence of autonomic dysreflexia during functional electrical stimulation in individuals with spinal cord injuries , 1993, Paraplegia.

[96]  F. Iellamo,et al.  Spontaneous baroreflex modulation of heart rate and heart rate variability during orthostatic stress in tetraplegics and healthy subjects , 2001, Journal of hypertension.

[97]  R. Burnham,et al.  The effects of surface anaesthesia on the autonomic dysreflexia response during functional electrical stimulation , 1997, Spinal Cord.

[98]  M. Hopman,et al.  Leg vascular resistance increases during head-up tilt in paraplegics , 2005, European Journal of Applied Physiology.

[99]  G. Davis,et al.  Carotid baroreflex control of heart rate and blood pressure during ES leg cycling in paraplegics. , 2000, Journal of applied physiology.

[100]  A. Catz,et al.  Cardiovascular and hormonal responses to food ingestion in humans with spinal cord transection , 1997, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[101]  J. Jeon,et al.  Quadriceps muscle deoxygenation during functional electrical stimulation in adults with spinal cord injury , 2000, Spinal Cord.

[102]  S C Gupta,et al.  Physiologic responses of paraplegics and quadriplegics to passive and active leg cycle ergometry. , 1990, The Journal of the American Paraplegia Society.

[103]  Andrei Krassioukov,et al.  The clinical problems in cardiovascular control following spinal cord injury: an overview. , 2006, Progress in brain research.

[104]  A. Krassioukov,et al.  Cardiovascular consequences of loss of supraspinal control of the sympathetic nervous system after spinal cord injury. , 2000, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[105]  D. Celermajer,et al.  Endothelial function, vascular reactivity and gender differences in the cardiovascular system. , 2002, Cardiovascular research.

[106]  K. Stiller,et al.  The prevalence of orthostatic hypotension during physiotherapy treatment in patients with an acute spinal cord injury , 2000, Spinal Cord.

[107]  R. Binkhorst,et al.  The Effect of an Anti-G Suit on the Maximal Performance of Individuals with Paraplegia , 1993, International journal of sports medicine.

[108]  J Keul,et al.  Catecholamines, heart rate, and oxygen uptake during exercise in persons with spinal cord injury. , 1998, Journal of applied physiology.

[109]  A. Krassioukov,et al.  Orthostatic hypotension and autonomic pathways after spinal cord injury. , 2006, Journal of neurotrauma.

[110]  C. Mathias,et al.  Renin and aldosterone release during sympathetic stimulation in tetraplegia. , 1981, Clinical science.

[111]  V. Dietz,et al.  International standards to document remaining autonomic function after spinal cord injury , 2009, Spinal Cord.

[112]  Arya M. Sharma,et al.  Pressor Effect of Water Drinking in Tetraplegic Patients May Be a Spinal Reflex , 2003, Hypertension.

[113]  H. Houdijk,et al.  The individual relationship between heart rate and oxygen uptake in people with a tetraplegia during exercise , 2007, Spinal Cord.

[114]  A Malliani,et al.  Influences of neural mechanisms on heart period and arterial pressure variabilities in quadriplegic patients. , 1994, The American journal of physiology.

[115]  E. Chartier-Kastler,et al.  Midodrine improves ejaculation in spinal cord injured men. , 2007, The Journal of urology.

[116]  A. Catz,et al.  Hemodynamic effects of liquid food ingestion in mid-thoracic paraplegia: is supine postprandial hypotension related to thoracic spinal cord damage? , 2007, Spinal Cord.

[117]  H. Ogata,et al.  Cardiovascular and endocrine responses during the cold pressor test in subjects with cervical spinal cord injuries. , 2003, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[118]  K. Matsukawa,et al.  Cardiovascular control during voluntary static exercise in humans with tetraplegia. , 2004, Journal of applied physiology.

[119]  M. Hopman,et al.  Non-invasive assessment of autonomic nervous system integrity in able-bodied and spinal cord-injured individuals , 1999, Clinical autonomic research : official journal of the Clinical Autonomic Research Society.

[120]  A. Jackson,et al.  A demographic profile of new traumatic spinal cord injuries: change and stability over 30 years. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[121]  M. Elam,et al.  Regional sympathetic function in high spinal cord injury during mental stress and autonomic dysreflexia. , 1998, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[122]  A. Tokuhiro,et al.  Autonomic dysreflexia during a bowel program in patients with cervical spinal cord injury. , 2007, Acta medica Okayama.

[123]  A. Kerekovska,et al.  Publication bias in clinical research sponsored by pharmaceutical industry , 2014 .

[124]  A. Hicks,et al.  Reproducibility of heart rate variability and blood pressure variability in individuals with spinal cord injury , 2005, Clinical Autonomic Research.

[125]  Influence of Autonomic Impairment on Blood-Pressure and Heart-Rate Scaling Structures , 2006, 2006 International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[126]  E Garshick,et al.  A prospective assessment of mortality in chronic spinal cord injury , 2005, Spinal Cord.

[127]  J. Shi,et al.  The determination of vasoactive substances during autonomic dysreflexia , 1997, Spinal Cord.

[128]  E. Heidbreder,et al.  Circulatory changes during mental stress in tetraplegic and paraplegic man , 1982, Klinische Wochenschrift.

[129]  Effects of graduated compression stockings on cardiovascular and metabolic responses to exercise and exercise recovery in persons with spinal cord injury. , 2007, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[130]  A. Krassioukov.  Autonomic dysreflexia in acute spinal cord injury: incidence, mechanisms, and management. , 2004, SCI nursing : a publication of the American Association of Spinal Cord Injury Nurses.

[131]  J. Steeves,et al.  Orthostatic hypotension in the first month following acute spinal cord injury , 2008, Spinal Cord.

[132]  K. Dickersin,et al.  Publication bias and clinical trials. , 1987, Controlled clinical trials.

[133]  K. D. Donohue,et al.  Blood pressure regulation in neurally intact human vs. acutely injured paraplegic and tetraplegic patients during passive tilt. , 2007, American journal of physiology. Regulatory, integrative and comparative physiology.

[134]  N. Secher,et al.  Leg uptake of calcitonin gene-related peptide during exercise in spinal cord injured humans. , 2001, Clinical physiology.