Using patterns of variability to test for multiple community states on rocky intertidal shores

Predictions based on theory of multiple stable states suggest that larger perturbations should lead to more unpredictable patterns of succession. This prediction was tested in the Gulf of Maine using data from 60 intertidal plots of varying size that were experimentally cleared of the rockweed Ascophyllum nodosum and from 14 benchmark sites from throughout the Gulf. Rockweed was removed from the experimental clearings ranging from 1 to 8 m in diameter in 1996 and data collected in 2004 were used to test effects of clearing size and location on divergence and variability in species composition. Benchmark data were collected in 2005, and the 14 sites were from a dataset on 53 sites throughout the Gulf of Maine. The selected sites were randomly chosen from all sites with > 80% canopy cover by A. nodosum and were expected to be similar to uncleared control plots from the experiment. Experimental removal of A. nodosum resulted in clearings at 12 sites within 4 bays. Abundances of gastropods, barnacles, mussels, and fucoid algae and the percentage cover of barnacles, mussels, fucoid algae, bare space, and other species were sampled. CAP and PERMDISP analyses revealed significant differences in multivariate dispersion and variability with both clearing size and location. Variability generally increased with clearing size and location effects were related to the north–south positioning of the sites. Benchmark sites were similar to the experimental control plots but as variable as the largest clearings. Results suggest that succession in larger clearings has been more unpredictable than in small clearings. The pattern of variability in the experimental clearings is consistent with the predictions of multiple stable states. However, the large amount of variation among the benchmark sites was due to mussels and was unexpected. This unexpected variability underscores the importance of sampling benchmark sites as part of experiments.

[1]  P. Petraitis.  Factors organizing rocky intertidal communities of New England: Herbivory and predation in sheltered bays , 1987 .

[2]  P. Fairweather.  Movements of intertidal whelks (Morula marginalba and Thais orbita) in relation to availability of prey and shelter , 1988 .

[3]  J. Connell,et al.  On the Evidence Needed to Judge Ecological Stability or Persistence , 1983, The American Naturalist.

[4]  Marti J. Anderson,et al.  Generalized discriminant analysis based on distances , 2003 .

[5]  M. Bertness,et al.  DO ALTERNATE STABLE COMMUNITY STATES EXIST IN THE GULF OF MAINE ROCKY INTERTIDAL ZONE , 2002 .

[6]  Christian Wissel,et al.  Babel, or the ecological stability discussions: an inventory and analysis of terminology and a guide for avoiding confusion , 1997, Oecologia.

[7]  B. Mapstone.  Scalable Decision Rules for Environmental Impact Studies: Effect Size, Type I, and Type II Errors , 1995 .

[8]  C. Peterson.  Does a Rigorous Criterion for Environmental Identity Preclude the Existence of Multiple Stable Points? , 1984, The American Naturalist.

[9]  M. Chapman,et al.  Inconsistency and variation in the development of rocky intertidal algal assemblages , 1998 .

[10]  P. Petraitis,et al.  Divergent succession and implications for alternative states on rocky intertidal shores , 2005 .

[11]  J. Marshall,et al.  A regression-based equivalence test for model validation: shifting the burden of proof. , 2005, Tree physiology.

[12]  S. Hawkins,et al.  Long term effects of Ascophyllum nodosum canopy removal on mid shore community structure , 2004, Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom.

[13]  Dolph Schluter,et al.  Species diversity in ecological communities: historical and geographical perspectives. , 1993 .

[14]  Kenneth Petren,et al.  Experimental Ecology: Issues and Perspectives , 1999 .

[15]  P. Petraitis,et al.  Experimental evidence for the origin of alternative communities on rocky intertidal shores , 1999 .

[16]  Joseph P. Romano.  Optimal testing of equivalence hypotheses , 2003 .

[17]  M. Foster,et al.  Temporal variation and succession in an algal-dominated high intertidal assemblage , 2003 .

[18]  P. Petraitis,et al.  SCALE-DEPENDENT RECRUITMENT AND DIVERGENCE OF INTERTIDAL COMMUNITIES , 2001 .

[19]  B. Menge,et al.  Organization of the New England Rocky Intertidal Community: Role of Predation, Competition, and Environmental Heterogeneity , 1976 .

[20]  M. Bertness,et al.  CONSUMER‐CONTROLLED COMMUNITY STATES ON GULF OF MAINE ROCKY SHORES , 2004 .

[21]  M. Foster.  Organization of macroalgal assemblages in the Northeast Pacific: the assumption of homogeneity and the illusion of generality , 1990, Hydrobiologia.

[22]  Underwood,et al.  Observations in ecology: you can't make progress on processes without understanding the patterns. , 2000, Journal of experimental marine biology and ecology.

[23]  A. D. Roos,et al.  Direct experimental evidence for alternative stable states: a review , 2005 .

[24]  M. Chapman,et al.  A method for analysing spatial scales of variation in composition of assemblages , 1998, Oecologia.

[25]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems , 2001, Nature.

[26]  A. J. Underwood,et al.  Variability at different spatial scales between a subtidal assemblage exposed to the discharge of sewage and two control assemblages , 1995 .

[27]  J. Sutherland.  Perturbations, Resistance, and Alternative Views of the Existence of Multiple Stable Points in Nature , 1990, The American Naturalist.

[28]  Direct and indirect effects of predation, herbivory and surface rugosity on mussel recruitment , 1990, Oecologia.

[29]  W. Kendall,et al.  HOW SHOULD DETECTION PROBABILITY BE INCORPORATED INTO ESTIMATES OF RELATIVE ABUNDANCE , 2002 .

[30]  A. Underwood,et al.  11. Paradigms, Explanations, and Generalizations in Models for the Structure of Intertidal Communities on Rocky Shores , 1984 .

[31]  David A. Norton,et al.  Are systems with strong underlying abiotic regimes more likely to exhibit alternative stable states , 2005 .

[32]  A. Underwood.  The Logic of Ecological Experiments: A Case History From Studies of the Distribution of Macro-Algae on Rocky Intertidal Shores , 1991, Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom.

[33]  Underwood,et al.  Experimental ecology of rocky intertidal habitats: what are we learning? , 2000, Journal of experimental marine biology and ecology.

[34]  J. Connell,et al.  Further Comments on the Evidence for Multiple Stable Points in Natural Communities , 1985, The American Naturalist.

[35]  K. R. Clarke,et al.  Increased variability as a symptom of stress in marine communities , 1993 .

[36]  R. May.  Thresholds and breakpoints in ecosystems with a multiplicity of stable states , 1977, Nature.

[37]  R. Cole,et al.  Assessing impacts of dredge spoil disposal using equivalence tests: implications of a precautionary (proof of safety) approach , 2004 .

[38]  N. Knowlton.  Thresholds and Multiple Stable States in Coral Reef Community Dynamics , 1992 .

[39]  Leslie Elliott Armijo,et al.  Compared to What? , 2006 .

[40]  M. Lindegarth,et al.  Effects of small-scale disturbances of canopy and grazing on intertidal assemblages on the Swedish west coast , 2004 .

[41]  P. Petraitis,et al.  Detection of alternative stable states in marine communities , 2004 .

[42]  K. Gross,et al.  Alternative states and positive feedbacks in restoration ecology. , 2004, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[43]  Joel E. Cohen,et al.  Communities in Patchy Environments: A Model of Disturbance, Competition, and Heterogeneity , 1991 .

[44]  P. Petraitis,et al.  The importance of scale in testing the origins of alternative community states , 1999 .

[45]  P. Fairweather,et al.  Experimental removals of a rocky intertidal predator : variations within two habitats in the effects on prey , 1991 .

[46]  J. Sutherland,et al.  Multiple Stable Points in Natural Communities , 1974, The American Naturalist.

[47]  Marti J. Anderson,et al.  CANONICAL ANALYSIS OF PRINCIPAL COORDINATES: A USEFUL METHOD OF CONSTRAINED ORDINATION FOR ECOLOGY , 2003 .