Purpose To measure pediatric program directors’ (PDs’) and trainees’ perceptions of and expectations for the balance of service and education in their training programs. Method In fall 2011, an electronic survey was sent to PDs and trainees at Boston Children’s Hospital. Respondents described perceptions and expectations for service and education and rated the education and service inherent to 12 vignettes. Wilcoxon rank sum tests measured the agreement between PD and trainee perceptions and ratings of service and education assigned to each vignette. Results Responses were received from 28/39 PDs (78%) and 223/430 trainees (52%). Seventy-five (34%) trainees responded that their education had been compromised by excessive service obligations; only 1 (4%) PD agreed (P < .0001). Although 132 (59%) trainees reported that service obligations usually/sometimes predominated over clinical education, only 3 (11%) PDs agreed (P < .0001). One hundred trainees (45%) thought rotations never/rarely/sometimes provided a balance between education and clinical demands compared with 2 PDs (7%) (P < .0001). Both groups agreed that service can, without formal teaching, be considered educational. Trainees scored 6 vignettes as having greater educational value (P ⩽ .01) and 10 as having lower service content (P ⩽ .04) than PDs did. Conclusions Trainees and medical educators hold mismatched impressions of their training programs’ balance of service and education. Trainees are more likely to report an overabundance of service. These data may impact the interpretation of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education survey results and should be incorporated into dialogue about future curricular design initiatives.
[1]
C. Cassel,et al.
Service: an essential component of graduate medical education.
,
2013,
The New England journal of medicine.
[2]
S. Galvin,et al.
Resident perceptions of service versus clinical education.
,
2012,
Journal of graduate medical education.
[3]
Dane E. Smith,et al.
Service versus education, what are we talking about?
,
2012,
Journal of surgical education.
[4]
A. Kesselheim,et al.
Residents: workers or students in the eyes of the law?
,
2011,
The New England journal of medicine.
[5]
I. Philibert,et al.
Residents' Perspectives on the Learning Environment: Data From the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Resident Survey
,
2010,
Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.
[6]
P. Brunett,et al.
Service versus education: finding the right balance: a consensus statement from the Council Of Emergency Medicine Residency Directors 2009 Academic Assembly "Question 19" working group.
,
2009,
Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.
[7]
S. Crawford.
Time to Heal: American Medical Education From the Turn of the Century to the Era of Managed Care.
,
1999
.
[8]
A. Nezu,et al.
American College of Physicians.
,
1932,
California and western medicine.