Electron correlation and the self-interaction error of density functional theory

The self-interaction error (SIE) of commonly used DFT functionals has been systematically investigated by comparing the electron density distribution ρ(r) generated by self-interaction corrected DFT (SIC-DFT) with a series of reference densities obtained by DFT or wavefunction theory (WFT) methods that cover typical electron correlation effects. Although the SIE of GGA functionals is considerably smaller than that of LDA functionals, it has significant consequences for the coverage of electron correlation effects at the DFT level of theory. The exchange SIE mimics long range (non-dynamic) pair correlation effects, and is responsible for the fact that the electron density of DFT exchange-only calculations resembles often that of MP4, MP2 or even CCSD(T) calculations. Changes in the electron density caused by SIC-DFT exchange are comparable with those that are associated with HF exchange. Correlation functionals contract the density towards the bond and the valence region, thus taking negative charge out of the van der Waals region where these effects are exaggerated by the influence of the SIE of the correlation functional. Hence, SIC-DFT leads in total to a relatively strong redistribution of negative charge from van der Waals, non-bonding, and valence regions of heavy atoms to the bond regions. These changes, although much stronger, resemble those obtained when comparing the densities of hybrid functionals such as B3LYP with the corresponding GGA functional BLYP. Hence, the balanced mixing of local and non-local exchange and correlation effects as it is achieved by hybrid functionals mimics SIC-DFT and can be considered as an economic way to include some SIC into standard DFT. However, the investigation shows also that the SIC-DFT description of molecules is unreliable because the standard functionals used were optimized for DFT including the SIE.